Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think table manners are on the decline

114 replies

RankManners · 24/06/2021 11:09

inspired by current thread on table manners...
I work in a primary school and am shocked by the lack of table manners. Thinking that year 3 or 4 (age 8/9) is a suitable age to be able to use cutlery properly, I'd say about 2 children in each class do this. I'm talking eating sweetcorn (and pretty much everything) with fingers, putting a chicken breast on a fork and eating it like a lolly, eating a jacket potato by scraping the insides off on bottom teeth etc.

Similarly in a restaurant, you'll see parents with decent table manners and then kids eating like animals - how can parents not notice this??

(I'm your average WC parent, nothing posh here, but was bought up with standards!)
So AIBU it's the way things are going
YANBU manners separate us from animals

OP posts:
Librariesmakeshhhhappen · 24/06/2021 16:22

A friend of my son's was round for dinner the other night and jesus fucking christ, I had to get up and walk away from him or I was going to shout. Chewing with his mouth wide open whilst continuing to talk. Food spitting everywhere. Every forkfull I was telling him to close his mouth and he gave me this most horrible look (he's properly spoilt by his parent's. They do not tell him off so he doesnt react well). He didnt like the herbs on the potatoes so sat throwing his potatoes at me/onto my plate. Kept putting his fingers all over the food sitting in the serving dishes. Eating with his hands and then touching my son on the arm with his messy fingers. Never again is he coming over for dinner. It happens every time and I've lost all patience.

It's not his fault. He gets his dinner alone, on his knee, infront of the TV. So he has never learned. He's 8. His parents have fucked up really.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 24/06/2021 16:20

I honestly don't think it matters!

mbosnz · 24/06/2021 16:19

A friend and mine were lamenting table manners of today recently. She told me of a dinner she was present at, where a junior solicitor was pulled aside by a senior partner, told to make her excuses and leave, because she wasn't going to continue at the table with clients with table manners like that. Poor girl, she must have been mortified. And I imagine, it was somewhat career limiting.

MedusasBadHairDay · 24/06/2021 16:16

I've never understood why elbows on the table was considered bad manners? Most of the others make sense, eg. Not talking with your mouth full.

MereDintofPandiculation · 24/06/2021 16:13

Things are changing. "No elbows on table" is no longer a rule. It's no longer normal to insist that children ask permission before getting down from the table when they've finished eating. There's always a messy stage while "bad manners" morphs into "accepted norm".

RonObvious · 24/06/2021 15:51

I don't know. Meal times were never comfortable for us, when I was a child. My Dad had a tendency to go off into rants, and could be a tad violent. Table manners were held as being extremely important - no elbows on the table, hold the knife properly, not allowed to turn the fork over, even for sodding peas. We encourage table manners, but overall I want meals to be relaxed, sociable times. I think there's a balance in everything!

cocoloco987 · 24/06/2021 15:46

My dc would probably eat chicken breast like a lollipop at home in front of the tv or in the dinner hall laughing and joking with friends. They wouldn't in a restaurant or at the table at a family meal. I think it's important to know when things like that matter more or matter less.

Triffid1 · 24/06/2021 15:38

THere's a lot of infantilising of children so that a 10 year old who can't do the most basic of things is considered normal, this includes table manners and there's an attitude of, "he can learn this later". But "later" is probably too late.

Having said that, I think as a society we are less rigid, which is a good thing. So eating neatly and politely is still v important, but it's less and less important whether you hold your knife exactly the "right" way. I'm sure there are still people who notice if this isn't right, but the bulk of us notice whether the people sitting with us eat in a way that makes it unpleasant for the rest of us or not.

Having said that, it IS important, and parents are doing their DC a disservice by not working on the basics. I regularly tell my DC, when they complain, that I owe my career at least in part to being able to behave and eat appropriately in a restaurant - my second job interview was over lunch and it was pretty clear it was partly to ensure that I could be trusted to behave in a way that would work for their rich, poncey clients! Grin

Also, please and thank you. I spend my life reminding children to say this. My own seem to have it largely automatically (at least at home or when I am within hearing distance) but I can't remember the last time one of their friends used a "please" and thank yous, while more common, are still rare.

Bagelsandbrie · 24/06/2021 15:28

I think there’s less opportunity for kids to learn table manners now. People don’t eat round a table so much (we don’t even have a table, for us it’s just because we don’t like eating at one but I’d imagine a lot of people don’t have one due to lack of space). A lot of the restaurants people eat out now are the type where you can get away with using your hands - pizzas, burgers, street food type Mexican places, Nando’s etc. Unless you’re quite well off and eat at a lot of smaller independent type places you can get away with not even using cutlery.

My son is 9 and has autism and dyspraxia and can’t use a knife. He can use a fork. But I don’t make an issue of it because being honest until he was 4 all he would ever eat was tuna sandwiches (breakfast, lunch and dinner) and the last thing I want to do is create issues around food again- he was under a dietician for restricted eating. We were told to just make food as positive an experience as possible and not to add any judgement or negativity. He will now eat most things but it’s a long road. We do eat out a lot as a family but never anywhere he’d stand out as having bad manners.

I was brought up by a very strict middle class mum and dad who always told me elbows off the table, sit up straight etc etc. We used to eat out at fancy places all the time (my dad was the chief executive of a large international company, he was always meeting clients etc). I remember being absolutely embarrassed once at a very posh place where I tried to eat a Brussel sprout and it rolled down the long table where a waiter used a silver dustpan and brush to sweep it up….!

Budapestdreams · 24/06/2021 15:17

I couldn't go on a second date with someone who spoke with their mouth full of food.

Ridiculousradish · 24/06/2021 14:33

Yeah same Pigeonpocket.
Oh God the fucking pea fork debacle ls we used to have! Meal times were just so stressful. I don't want the same for my son. It's an opportunity for us to get together at the end of the day and connect, not a time for stress.
I had to spend hours sat at the table til I ate the meat put in front of me. I didn't like it. I've never liked it. My poor Mum, she couldn't understand how I could be so bloody cheeky. She came from a massive family and there was bugger all money. You'd never turn down food.
My parents were very worried about what others thought. We weren't allowed to eat in the street as it was "common."

Sillyduckseverywhere · 24/06/2021 14:19

I never have a second meal with people that eat open mouthed.
I've even turned down invitations to family events because I knew I'd be sat with chompers and slurpers Hmm

Pigeonpocket · 24/06/2021 14:06

@Ridiculousradish yes I found mealtimes stressful. We had to use our fork the correct way up for peas. I got nagged at that my elbows must remain by my sides at all times, even if that made actually eating more difficult. I used to eat slowly so I could stay at the table on my own to eat in peace.

Ridiculousradish · 24/06/2021 14:04

kindaclassy you sound fun.

Manners and reading are not comparable. It's very hard to get through life without being able to read. Plenty of people manage just fine getting through life with poor manners. Obviously manners are important, but bloody hell some people need to chill out.

BarbarianMum · 24/06/2021 13:57

No @Pigeonpocket table manners are also beneficial for the person involved. Grossing other people out when you eat is not a ticket to social success. I dont care which hand people hold their knife and fork but even in (especially in actually) cultures where eating with your fingers is common there are rules.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 13:53

It never take long before we get a post explaining why manners are wrong Grin

Pigeonpocket · 24/06/2021 13:52

I see manners the same way as I see reading. It's a skill you master, it should be basic, it doesn't have any effect on your personality or anything.

They're not remotely the same. Reading is beneficial to the person doing it. Table manners are for the people around you. And most of them are completely arbitrary.

Not talking with your mouth full, not making a mess and not making loud noises are probably the only rules I really agree with - it's good to learn so you don't disgust other people, spray food everywhere, etc.

Having the knife and fork in the "correct" hand, no elbows on the table, using the "correct" implement for things, not using your fingers for non-messy foods etc. have no reason to exist other than that's how people in the past have decided that things should be done. They are culturally specific as well. People only get annoyed by them because they can't stand people who don't follow "rules" or because they like to exert control.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 13:39

but to be honest as long as he's not a twat I'll be happy.

I never understand how that is remotely relevant. It's 2 completely different and unrelated things.

It sounds like some people (speaking in general, not a specific poster) are either trying to find excuse or reason to smirk at the concept of manners.

I see manners the same way as I see reading. It's a skill you master, it should be basic, it doesn't have any effect on your personality or anything.

Ridiculousradish · 24/06/2021 13:33

I hope my son uses the table manners that he's been taught throughout his life, but to be honest as long as he's not a twat I'll be happy. Being a decent person with questionable table manners is better than the other way around. Hoping for both, but as Skral said, "nobody's perfect."

percheron67 · 24/06/2021 13:31

Many people have appalling table manners. On TV people are shown talking with mouths full, irons used as spears etc.. In a diet food ad yesterday the woman held her irons halfway down, pointed with them and didn't put them down at all. Revolting.

Ridiculousradish · 24/06/2021 13:31

Pigeonpocket my parents were the same. It was beyond stressful. A hell of a lot of anxiety was created around mealtimes and I ended up with an eating disorder. It wasn't all down to their rules, but it was a contributing factor.

Ridiculousradish · 24/06/2021 13:27

Skral Grin

Skral · 24/06/2021 13:20

My friend at university was always banging on about table manners and criticising everyone else about them. Her mother did a wonderful job on her table manners. Unfortunately, she had bad personal hygiene and stole stuff. Nobody’s perfect.

Feedingthebirds1 · 24/06/2021 13:20

We were in a cafe. At the table next to us two men, mid twenties, were already eating. When they'd finished they started a fairly loud conversation, and one of them was bemoaning the fact that he'd take a girl out for a meal and then she never wanted to see him again and he didn't know why. I soooo much wanted to lean over and say 'Mate, I've just seen you eating. I know why there's no second date.'

Pigeonpocket · 24/06/2021 13:04

Perhaps the parents do realise and the children are rebelling against strict rules at home when they're able to at school?
A lot of child nutritionists say not to make table manners a big deal, just model what's appropriate and they will follow.

My parents were really strict with me and I hated eating with them, they were constantly moaning at me for things I couldn't really help or didn't really care about - how is it bad manners to have your knife and fork in the "wrong" hands, or to eat off a (not sharp) knife? It's just a way for parents to exert control.

My 2yo uses a fork and spoon when she feels like it which is more often than not at the moment and she's started trying to copy us with a knife. But I'm not going to force it.