Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think table manners are on the decline

114 replies

RankManners · 24/06/2021 11:09

inspired by current thread on table manners...
I work in a primary school and am shocked by the lack of table manners. Thinking that year 3 or 4 (age 8/9) is a suitable age to be able to use cutlery properly, I'd say about 2 children in each class do this. I'm talking eating sweetcorn (and pretty much everything) with fingers, putting a chicken breast on a fork and eating it like a lolly, eating a jacket potato by scraping the insides off on bottom teeth etc.

Similarly in a restaurant, you'll see parents with decent table manners and then kids eating like animals - how can parents not notice this??

(I'm your average WC parent, nothing posh here, but was bought up with standards!)
So AIBU it's the way things are going
YANBU manners separate us from animals

OP posts:
LadyJaye · 24/06/2021 19:42

I was brought up in the West and have lived in both East and South Asia.

I can use chopsticks, and a spoon and chopsticks (Korean-style) very well - not so good at using my right hand without cutlery, but I can pass tolerably well without embarrassing myself in company!

Interestingly, it's very rare to see EA/SA children above a certain age (three-ish) be unable to use the eating implements common to their respective cultures, in the way that Western children seem unable to use a knife and fork at 10.

Elphame · 24/06/2021 19:35

This is one of the "softer" reasons we elected for private education - sloppy manners were not tolerated by the school which backed up the "at home" training.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 19:25

I think she meant take it over towards the sink/dishwasher area.

You are correct!

But I still wouldn't expect young primary school children to bring back their plates and everything back to the kitchen when they are visiting my kids, find the bin, scrap the food, open the dishwasher...
They can take back one item and go back and play!

Grellbunt · 24/06/2021 19:22

@kindaclassy

mine have always been taught to clear it

mine are taught not to pile their plate up with ridiculous amounts of food, and to finish what they put when they help themselves,

but if someone else is plating up for them, they absolutely do not have to finish.

I think she meant take it over towards the sink/dishwasher area.
kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 19:19

I've never met an adult who can't passably use a knife and fork

Oh gosh, I have! Not even talking about right or left hand, but some people have shocking habits.

It looks so much more difficult to eat anyway, it really does not make sense but there are some extreme.

butwhatcanwedo · 24/06/2021 19:18

Children’s hands are still growing. Adult cutlery is too big for them.
Using cutlery actually involves quite a lot of dexterity and different skills. Cutting requires strength. These things take time.
Chairs are often too big too especially in restaurants so their bodies aren’t supported in a normal seated position. Once teetering on knees they become more manic with eating
Also as well as having fewer opportunities to eat with family because of work, During the last year or so children haven’t had the chance at school. My own children can’t eat in the hall so eat in their classrooms and the tv is on - we never eat in front of the tv but I know they are doing their best.
I think it doesn’t matter that much tbh. They will get there in the end.

mbosnz · 24/06/2021 18:47

I've always thought that the important part of development that is enjoying and appreciating food is the province of the parents and home.

Possibly that's because we didn't have school dinners in NZ, we sent them with a packed lunch, they ate them cross legged outside, and then buggered off as fast as possible to play.

solittletime · 24/06/2021 18:45

Problem is that meal times at school are just a feeding frenzy. There are not enough adults to supervise. Most schools have limited space so children often get 20 minutes for lunch, and that includes queuing up.
All my dcs left nursery with wonderful table manners. It all started to go downhill once they started school dinners. Even just slowing them down to not wolf down their food is a battle.
Such an important part of development, enjoying and appreciating food, and completely disregarded in most schools.
And don’t even get me started on the unbelievable quantities of food thrown away at each sitting. Most children take a few bites then shove it all in a big bin so they can get more playtime outside.
I avoid the canteen as much as possible

CaptainBarbossa · 24/06/2021 18:38

I've never met an adult who can't passably use a knife and fork (like maybe in the right hands or not posh table manners, but good enough). I've met many adults who can't read and write, but none who hadn't picked up basic table manners.

13579db · 24/06/2021 18:33

Sometimes my kids do this just to wind me up - because when they're at grandparents they turn into Victorian diners using all the cutlery impeccably and sitting straight, waiting their turn to speak etc

So I try to remember that they DO know

But try and ignore it sometimes or react less and just tell them that there's a new checkpoint in town for police to check homes where kids are using cutlery properly or not.

Usually works

Hardchoices · 24/06/2021 18:27

I absolutely agree. All my fiends could be described as professional middle class people and the majority of them cannot hold cutlery properly.

cocoloco987 · 24/06/2021 18:07

I would be interested to hear from teachers how much leeway you have these days to correct children's table manners or whether this is a big no-no.

I'm a TA and do the lunch supervision. The teachers are on their lunch break. Mine are primary 1 so 4-5-6 moving through the year. I have 1 full class to supervise on my own (and the the 2 other classes often ask me for things) hand out meals, fruit course, treat course and drinks (covid means they need to have them served while the dc sit). Some have school lunches and others a variety of packed lunches. I have a 1:1 who is a runner and a dc in one of the other classes who's food intake I need to monitor closely and sometimes do calculations for. I don't allow the dc to get up and walk or run around. I do not allow shouting and they always tidy up after themselves. Any major silliness like food throwing would be spotted and corrected but I honestly could not tell you who is eating sweetcorn with their hands or like a lollipop, if they are chewing with their mouths open etc as I only have one set of eyes

womaninatightspot · 24/06/2021 18:06

My children know how to eat properly but if I don't keep an eye on them their table manners slide at the dinner table. I wonder how many kids eat properly at home under their parents beady eyes and like they've been dragged up at school.

HiHoSylvie · 24/06/2021 17:57

Like most things, there's a balance to be had. Eating with your mouth open or with fingers is obviously to be discouraged. Holding your fork the right way up, meh. So many people get this 'wrong', even adults. If I got worked up about it, I would be worked up a lot.

My 3yo prefers cutlery as he hates touching food. My 6yo preferred to eat with her fingers. We did baby led weaning with her, so think that might be what did it!

5foot5 · 24/06/2021 17:49

I would be interested to hear from teachers how much leeway you have these days to correct children's table manners or whether this is a big no-no.

Back in the 60s/early-70s at my primary school proper behaviour at the table was very much expected. We didn't have a separate dining hall so the classroom had to be turned in to a dining space with desks pushed together and then the tables were set by the children. We had table cloths (I kid you not) and the cutlery, glasses and water jug had to be put in their correct place. It was one of the very first things we learnt to do at 5 or less. Then there was grace and we all sat down together to eat.

We were expected to eat properly and behave at the table but the teachers were not so strict as to make it stressful. You could talk to the people on your table and anyone struggling to use knife and fork properly would be helped to cut things up at first. However, shouting, running around or eating with your fingers would NOT be tolerated.

I think that this was probably a good thing especially for children who didn't have this sort of behaviour instilled at home. We always sat and ate together as a family so it wasn't anything new to me, but presumably for some of the children it was their first introduction to polite behaviour at the table.

Ironically the only time I can remember anybody behaving badly or making a fuss it was a little boy from one of the more well off middle-class families in the village who was being sent to the village school until he was old enough to be packed off to prep. I think Mummy used to pander a bit to his fads and didn't try to insist on him sitting still and trying his vegetables. As a 5 year old I was suitably shocked to hear him tell the (very gentle) headmaster that he "bloody well wasn't going to eat it" Shock

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 17:46

I cannot ignore him spitting food pieces he has chewed onto my son's food.

THAT would not be tolerated in most schools either, and the child would get a telling off, even pre-Covid.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 17:45

@undermycatsthumb

Speak for yourself *@kindaclassy*... I love that I have friends that pitch in and that I do the same at theirs. We are all at home in each other’s homes and that is extremely precious to me. And I love children helping out, even if they ultimately cause more work... how else do they learn?! Horses for courses.
kids practice at home, not in somebody else's house.

We are all at home in each other’s homes yeah... and we end up reading so many threads about people being overly "at home" and not respecting any boundaries 😂

It might work with some very close friends, but it won't apply to every single one of your friends anyway. I have heard that comment so many times, of guests being overly "helpful" and making a nuisance of themselves instead.

Librariesmakeshhhhappen · 24/06/2021 17:43

@Hardbackwriter

He was spitting for onto my own children's plates from his mouth. My kitchen table isnt huge. Supposed to just let that carry on with every mouthful?
Children are not adults. We dont need to sit there meekly ignoring their bad behaviour. If his parent's actually bloody patented then he wouldn't be such a state at other people's homes.

I ignored the food throwing after one telling off. I ignored the eating with his hands. I ignored him putting his messy hands all over my son's t-shirt. I cannot ignore him spitting food pieces he has chewed onto my son's food.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 17:40

@LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus

I honestly don't think it matters!
It does.

And having good table manners means you are comfortable everywhere. You can eat at school, with friends, in a pub or very nice restaurant, with your boss, with your boyfriend parents for the first time, the same rules still apply and you don't think about it.

It's no effort to check what the rules are when you have to adapt to an unfamiliar culture, but at least you should know your own.

Hardbackwriter · 24/06/2021 17:35

@Librariesmakeshhhhappen

A friend of my son's was round for dinner the other night and jesus fucking christ, I had to get up and walk away from him or I was going to shout. Chewing with his mouth wide open whilst continuing to talk. Food spitting everywhere. Every forkfull I was telling him to close his mouth and he gave me this most horrible look (he's properly spoilt by his parent's. They do not tell him off so he doesnt react well). He didnt like the herbs on the potatoes so sat throwing his potatoes at me/onto my plate. Kept putting his fingers all over the food sitting in the serving dishes. Eating with his hands and then touching my son on the arm with his messy fingers. Never again is he coming over for dinner. It happens every time and I've lost all patience.

It's not his fault. He gets his dinner alone, on his knee, infront of the TV. So he has never learned. He's 8. His parents have fucked up really.

I think the correct thing to do here is exactly what you'd do with an adult with bad table manners - perfectly reasonable to not invite them back, it's your house, and one discreet and gentle reminder that they've got their mouth full is fine, but repeatedly and ostentatiously correcting their manners, especially in front of other people is - ironically - very rude.
undermycatsthumb · 24/06/2021 17:33

Speak for yourself @kindaclassy... I love that I have friends that pitch in and that I do the same at theirs. We are all at home in each other’s homes and that is extremely precious to me.
And I love children helping out, even if they ultimately cause more work... how else do they learn?! Horses for courses.

kindaclassy · 24/06/2021 17:31

frankly, I cut my food and put down the knife, then swap my fork to the right hand. I don't see how that means I have poor manners.

even if it wasn't bad manner, what a lot of unnecessary fuss.

MooseBreath · 24/06/2021 16:34

I genuinely don't understand why people are expected to eat with a fork in the left hand and a knife in the right throughout the entire meal. I know how to do it, but frankly, I cut my food and put down the knife, then swap my fork to the right hand. I don't see how that means I have poor manners.

I am teaching 1yo DS to use a spoon and once he's got that, I will teach him to use a knife and fork. But I certainly won't expect aristocratic eating from him.

I see "please", "thank you", "excuse me", and basic kindness as good manners. That is what I will expect from my child!

Bagelsandbrie · 24/06/2021 16:32

@MedusasBadHairDay

I've never understood why elbows on the table was considered bad manners? Most of the others make sense, eg. Not talking with your mouth full.
www.rd.com/article/elbows-on-the-table-why-is-it-considered-rude/
Carbara · 24/06/2021 16:22

@newnortherner111

Not surprised. Also those who might intervene such as restaurant staff will get abuse and not be supported by their managers.
This is the most ludicrous thing I’ve read here this week. You think that poverty wage labourers should step in and perform basic parenting on strangers kids? Seriously? 🤣