Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think table manners are on the decline

114 replies

RankManners · 24/06/2021 11:09

inspired by current thread on table manners...
I work in a primary school and am shocked by the lack of table manners. Thinking that year 3 or 4 (age 8/9) is a suitable age to be able to use cutlery properly, I'd say about 2 children in each class do this. I'm talking eating sweetcorn (and pretty much everything) with fingers, putting a chicken breast on a fork and eating it like a lolly, eating a jacket potato by scraping the insides off on bottom teeth etc.

Similarly in a restaurant, you'll see parents with decent table manners and then kids eating like animals - how can parents not notice this??

(I'm your average WC parent, nothing posh here, but was bought up with standards!)
So AIBU it's the way things are going
YANBU manners separate us from animals

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
adam7485 · 08/09/2021 08:18

ok i know this thread is couple of months old but came across it and didn't want to just read and run. the poster who said that her ds's friend was spitting food everywhere including onto ds plate shouting, etc absolutely no way i would have that child back certainly not for a meal. and most of the other things mentioned in this thread i would certainly not be encouraging such as food fighting and generally pissing about at the table but to get worked up over which way to hold a knife and fork? is it really that big a deal? there is a fine line between letting dc get into disgusting table habits and going all ott and victorian. i don't see what's wrong with asking to help clear things away but obviously i wouldn't get up and just do it without asking if i could.

Triffid1 · 26/06/2021 11:58

@letsgotrilobite I agree with this. My children are being taught the kind of table manners that mean they can eat politely in company. DS is a leftie, so I'm certainly not going to insist that he eats in a manner that is "wrong" for him - any more than I'd insist he writes with his right hand. I have an extremely mild "disability" (it's not a disability but it does mean I have reduced movement on one side of my body) so my parents never forced me to use the fork consistently in that hand because if I do have to do that, my manners deteriorate because it means I practically have to drop my face into my plate to reach my mouth.

I don't care if people have their index finger in exactly the right place etc.

But I DO care if my children can't cut food, eat with their mouths open or generally behave in a way that is unpleasant for anyone else to watch. They aren't allowed to grab food etc.

letsgotrilobite · 26/06/2021 11:23

@Sillyduckseverywhere

People saying "does it matter?" Did you read the story about the junior solicitor being sent home because she was embarrassing the senior partner? Good social skills are part and parcel of being an adult. That will have affected her career, it's fine for a toddler, not for an adult.
It depends on the table manners being discussed doesn't it? There are different levels of table manners.

Throwing food, chewing with your mouth open so everyone can see, spitting things out, being messy and unnecessarily noisy are obviously going to put other people off eating with you and children should be taught not to do those things.

Whereas eating with the knife and fork the wrong way round, using the fork the wrong way up, putting your knife down and only using a fork, using a spoon instead of a fork etc are all "bad manners" that make no logical sense and I fail to see how doing those things is embarrassing or impolite.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 26/06/2021 10:48

I’d be more inclined to vote if the OP’s phrasing of the choices weren’t so loaded.

Sillyduckseverywhere · 26/06/2021 10:03

People saying "does it matter?"
Did you read the story about the junior solicitor being sent home because she was embarrassing the senior partner? Good social skills are part and parcel of being an adult.
That will have affected her career, it's fine for a toddler, not for an adult.

MedusasBadHairDay · 26/06/2021 07:28

@Pigeonpocket

He insists on having his knife and fork the wrong way round, we make his swap them

Why?? It's adding completely unnecessary stress. It's like forcing left handed people to use their right hand to write. If he's comfier with them in the other hands then how is it affecting anybody else?

This. Why does it matter which way around they hold the knife and fork??
Pigeonpocket · 26/06/2021 00:00

He insists on having his knife and fork the wrong way round, we make his swap them

Why?? It's adding completely unnecessary stress. It's like forcing left handed people to use their right hand to write. If he's comfier with them in the other hands then how is it affecting anybody else?

SofiaMichelle · 25/06/2021 22:57

@choli

And yet that awful American behavior is about more sensible manners. Perhaps you're the sad one.
Err... que?
OkOkWhatsNext · 25/06/2021 14:20

Every mealtime ends up in an argument with my 10 year old. He insists on having his knife and fork the wrong way round, we make his swap them
And then he’ll swap them back the wrong way when we’re not watching. All 3 of them do the chicken lollipop thing. Am fed up of hearing myself tell them to chop pieces off, not hold up the whole thing and nibble it. Eating with their hands…it’s hard to know how much to push it, and with just trying to get them to actually eat what’s on their plate, mealtimes can get quite stressful. We try and eat with them at weekends to set an example but frankly I much prefer eating separately so I can actually enjoy my food!

choli · 25/06/2021 13:48

And yet that awful American behavior is about more sensible manners. Perhaps you're the sad one.

SofiaMichelle · 25/06/2021 10:09

@Heneage

It's how the Americans are shown as eating especially in cartoons
I was about to post something similar.

It's another encroachment of American behaviour, picked up from TV and cartoons, sadly.

mbosnz · 25/06/2021 10:05

Re chopsticks, my girls wanted to learn how to use them from around five, which was great. I'd only learned in adulthood (my uncle sent me to eat in the kitchen once, because I didn't know how to eat with chopsticks!) Very few of their friends, and an awful lot of adults don't know how to eat with them - which is absolutely fine, but I find it tedious when some adults seem to think it's a virtue not to be able to do so - weird!)

We had a friend of our daughter's come to a sleepover, and she'd never eaten with a knife and fork - it was wonderful how the kids were absolutely fine with that, and they all pitched in to show her how, when she decided she wanted to give it the old college try. (We were absolutely fine with her eating whatever she wanted, how she wanted.)

sbfptw · 25/06/2021 10:02

@RankManners

inspired by current thread on table manners... I work in a primary school and am shocked by the lack of table manners. Thinking that year 3 or 4 (age 8/9) is a suitable age to be able to use cutlery properly, I'd say about 2 children in each class do this. I'm talking eating sweetcorn (and pretty much everything) with fingers, putting a chicken breast on a fork and eating it like a lolly, eating a jacket potato by scraping the insides off on bottom teeth etc. Similarly in a restaurant, you'll see parents with decent table manners and then kids eating like animals - how can parents not notice this?? (I'm your average WC parent, nothing posh here, but was bought up with standards!) So AIBU it's the way things are going YANBU manners separate us from animals
To be honest, the way some adults hold their cutlery and then use is beyond me. Kids don't stand a chance
SecondCityShark · 24/06/2021 23:54

This drives me nuts. My partner's 8 year old has horrendous table manners to the extent that I have to leave the room when she's eating certain things. Like meat for example. She chews the meat, pulls it out of her mouth, takes a good look and puts it back in Envy

He seems oblivious. What's wrong with people's standards?

SisterMonicaJoansHabit · 24/06/2021 23:23

I've yanbued despite my youngest eating like this. She has special needs but it's not that she doesn't know how to eat things properly but sometimes it's the lesser of whatever evils. Makes me cringe.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 24/06/2021 23:20

@memberofthewedding

When I was a child of 9 I was expected to use a knife and fork properly and to use proper manners at the table. There were no smart phones then but TV was turned off, and no reading at the table. No elbows on the table and no talking with a full mouth. When we had finished my sister and I had to ask permission to leave the table. By that age I automatically took my own plate and that of my parents into the kitchen to begin the washing up. It was one of my "jobs" to earn my pocket money.
Sis is that you? If you had mentioned trying a little bit of everything offered You’d have described it perfectly. This was meals in my house growing up too. Table manners was one of my mum’s hot buttons. That’s not to say I was always perfect, but let’s just say I was never allowed to use my fingers inappropriately, not use a napkin, and hold and use my cutlery correctly*

I’m sure at 9 I was still being corrected by her, but only occasionally. I have faith in this as she was not especially patient or tolerant, and I grew up in the time when corporal punishment was the norm. So I’m pretty sure I would remember the consequences of not having good table manners.

*I did win the battle of the fork though. Hard to describe but I found one way more comfortable than the ‘correct’ way and it’s only slightly different than the ‘correct’ way so she gave up and let me have that one.

waterrat · 24/06/2021 22:11

God sorry to say but my 9 year old has appalling table manners despite my best efforts he would absolutely eat food on his fork with no attempt to cut with a knife.

Susannahmoody · 24/06/2021 22:10

It's tough teaching kids table manners. A necessary part of their upbringing though.

shdodnbek · 24/06/2021 22:08

Meh... I couldn't get worked up about this 🤷‍♀️ they'll learn soon enough through being a human in this world. No adult I know eats sweetcorn with their hands.

ethelredonagoodday · 24/06/2021 21:58

My husband is an absolute stickler for table manners, no elbows on the table, etc and cannot abide poor table behaviour from our kids. What they're like at school though is anybody's guess!

DolphinFC · 24/06/2021 21:29

I think fewer children sit around the table for a family meal.

They very often sit on their own with tray in front of the TV.

I teach in a primary school in a middle class area; the table manners of our children are appalling.

junebirthdaygirl · 24/06/2021 21:22

I am old. I never remember my parents teaching me table manners or even mentioning it. We ate every meal, breakfast, lunch ( when not in school) and dinner at the table. We just copied our parents. The table was set properly each time and we lingered over evening meals. But my dm was a SAHP with time for all this.
Same here as my kids were growing. We ate every meal together and l genuinely don't ever remember speaking about manners. They just did it right from the start. No school dinners in lreland so all eating was with family.
Now parents are running in, everyone is hungry and it's not as easy. A lot of families don't eat together. Or eat in front of TV. If they eat out it's children's meals that lend themselves to finger food. It's an extra strain in busy lives fussing over table manners

MumBowJumBow · 24/06/2021 20:25

I really value good table manners and I agree with you OP it's shocking how many children cannot eat properly. I always feel for the pupils that can and do but have to sit opposite pupils who can't
I couldn't do it but we expect them to

KingdomScrolls · 24/06/2021 19:52

DS always eats at the table, we always do when we're eating with him (Tuesday football was on he'd had dinner at nursery so we had pizza in the living room when he was in bed).
A farm park local ish to us posted this that with a request for families to clear away after themselves, if children learn this is acceptable it's no wonder they won't eat nicely at a table.

To think table manners are on the decline
To think table manners are on the decline
To think table manners are on the decline