Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to do controlled crying with my 3.5 year old?

59 replies

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 03:03

Controlled crying as in I go in after 5 min, then 10, then 15 and so on.
At my wits end, have tried everything and it’s having a detrimental affect on my already poor mental health now.

Has anyone had any success with this with over 3’s?

OP posts:
coffeeandjuice · 24/06/2021 15:46

There's a section on this in "siblings without rivalry" on how to get your youngest child to sleep when they can see the elder is up... dunno if it might help? (It's a good book anyway!)

But 3 years of what your going through is tough! Hope you manage to sort it soon- good luck!!

ChaBishkoot · 24/06/2021 15:41

You shut the door, and walk away. Let him scream. You come in at 5/10/15 and say ‘time to sleep.’ You don’t explain, you don’t engage in long conversation(or any conversation), you don’t negotiate. You pick him up, give him a hug and say good night and walk out. Rinse and repeat till he gets the message.
And repeat for as many nights as needed.

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 15:38

@coffeeandjuice his sister is 9 so she is usually just on her phone, he wants her to give him a hug sometimes in the middle of the night. Which I say no she’s asleep so he will just keep saying it over and over again and getting more worked up

@idontlikealdi what kind of structure ?

OP posts:
idontlikealdi · 24/06/2021 15:36

It's not controlled crying at 3.5, you need to instil some more structure. Look at rapid return or anything else you want to call it but at that age, quite frankly I'd ignore it.

coffeeandjuice · 24/06/2021 15:32

Is his sister older than him and does he want to be out playing with her instead of in bed?

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 15:26

@JackieTheFart I think his cries/whines trigger me

@letsgotrilobite I couldn’t spend more quality time with him if I tried. He’s extremely clingy with me, always has being but more so when me and his dad split up. I’ve tried staying with him but the duration gets longer and longer so it’s not working.

@Fitforforty
His bedtime was 7pm but when he started messing I pushed it back to 730/745. He wakes up anytime after 7

OP posts:
Fitforforty · 24/06/2021 15:18

@Sleepdeprive

He spends mon to Thur with a childminder 9-430 and Friday with me. He has a small light on outside his room and his door is left ajar Last night at one point during his tantrum he kept asking for his sister so I said no, but it’s like he’s just not listening he just keeps repeating it louder and louder. It’s like I can’t through to him when he is like that

@PassionfruitOrangeGuava I tried searching for that group on Facebook but nothing came up ?

What time does he get up and what time are you putting him to bed?
letsgotrilobite · 24/06/2021 15:16

Have you tried making him feel secure so that he's happy to stay in bed alone?
My dd pushes back if I say I'm going to leave her in bed now because I have to go and do something. Whereas if I say don't worry, I'll stay if you need me, sometimes she'll happily ask me to leave and go to sleep alone.

Kids who feel rejected can become more clingy, and that includes being told to go to sleep alone. It's really hard when you feel like it's a battle every night. I learnt to let go of the battle and help my dd feel secure and it's working much better for us.

JackieTheFart · 24/06/2021 15:01

I don’t even understand why you’re hesitating tbh. You deserve a proper nights sleep too!

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 15:01

I tried reward system but he’s being with his speech so I’m not sure he really understands

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 24/06/2021 14:51

Does he come out of his room? If so you need the Super Nanny back to bed routine. Basically he is returned to bed with absolutely no interaction form you, a silent return no matter what he is saying or doing. It will take quite a few returns and probably a few nights.

If it's just shouting / crying then ignore, ignore, ignore. Also use a gro clock.

notasillysausage · 24/06/2021 14:38

Have you tried a reward system? So sit him down during the day way before it’s time for bed and explain why sleep is important, to keep our bodies strong etc and what you want him to do at bedtime and sort of casually reinforce expectations throughout the day. Sort of set the scene I guess. Then explain if he does that then you can do “x fun thing” eg toy from shop or trip somewhere fun. If he does it, lots of praise and reward. If he doesn’t do it, oh sorry sweetie mummy is too tired today to go to fun place because we didn’t get good sleep. My children seem to react a lot better to things they don’t want to do if they understand why it’s important and the consequences of doing it or not doing it.

Liverpoolgirl52 · 24/06/2021 14:29

Perhaps say to him that you will leave his gate open as long as he doesn’t come out of his room? If he comes out then shut the gate or keep taking him back to bed.

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 14:25

I know that tonight if I close his gate he will kick off as he hates it being closed and if I do go in his room he will try everything to keep me in there and will just repeat over and over what he wants.
What do I do?

OP posts:
Mabelface · 24/06/2021 11:22

I successfully did the same as @Lilyminilli when my eldest son was 3. It's more gentle and less screaming.

beingsunny · 24/06/2021 10:45

I did this with my son at a similar age, whe he came out of the cot to a toddler bed.

It's worth looking up the timing as it's bit 5/10/15 mins it's hotter than that.

It too maybe 3 nights and mostly involved my husband managing it and me sobbing in the kitchen, DS was also found asleep on the floor in front of the gate a couple of night but plain sailing after.

Lilyminilli · 24/06/2021 10:02

I had this with my dd. I did the method where you move further out of the bedroom each night. (We went from hand holding to go to sleep). I sat on the floor and moved a foot away then in the doorway. Then in my bedroom doorway, top of the stairs etc. Any crying just said “shh” and “it’s bedtime now”. It was the only thing that seemed to work. We still have faffing around eg need a wee, have something really important to tell me etc but it’s much better than up and down all night!!

BrownEyedGirl80 · 24/06/2021 10:00

I mean if he made himself scared "I can see a monster" etc I don't mean there were things to fear in his upbringing

BrownEyedGirl80 · 24/06/2021 09:59

Don't know if we were harsh but after 2 yrs unless ds was poorly or scared we made it clear he was in bed to sleep and we wouldn't be coming in.Hes 7 now and it's kiss,cuddle sleep time and hes used to it.

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 09:49

@Stompythedinosaur I tried that but each night he took longer and longer to settle and go to sleep

OP posts:
TheGumption · 24/06/2021 09:43

At 3.5 I wouldn't even consider it controlled crying. It's ignoring a tantrum.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/06/2021 09:35

In honesty, I sat with my dc at that age for 15 mins while they went to sleep. It was less stressful for both of us. Various people on here lredicted I would set up a bad pattern I wouldn't be able to get out of, but by the time they were 4 both dc just seemed ready to settle on their own and did it without a fight.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 24/06/2021 09:29

Could you try some sort of sticker/reward chart? A gro clock? Nightlight? Story playing? As PPs have said it isn't really CC at that age more establishing firm boundaries. If he comes out the room calmly take him back over ane over until he stays where he is.

SoloMotherofFour · 24/06/2021 09:25

I don't think it's controlled crying with a 3 year old. Don't feel guilty! They aren't even a toddler anymore. They understand they aren't being abandoned, it's just bedtime and you are going to sleep. Best thing for both of you to get a proper nights sleep. YANBU. Best of luck. :)

Sleepdeprive · 24/06/2021 09:19

He spends mon to Thur with a childminder 9-430 and Friday with me.
He has a small light on outside his room and his door is left ajar
Last night at one point during his tantrum he kept asking for his sister so I said no, but it’s like he’s just not listening he just keeps repeating it louder and louder. It’s like I can’t through to him when he is like that

@PassionfruitOrangeGuava I tried searching for that group on Facebook but nothing came up ?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread