Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop breastfeeding

120 replies

ohthestruggles · 23/06/2021 21:13

Posted here for traffic really, this may well be moved to a more relevant topic but I'm getting desperate.

Two week old has been 'cluster feeding' for 6 hours today, he and I are absolutely exhausted. He's getting on and falling asleep I just don't think he has the energy to get what he needs when it goes on for so long. He has slept for 10-20 min spells but thats it. I have given him a formula top up (40ml) and he's gone straight to sleep and is content Confused I feel awful, I've persevered as that's what ever HV and midwife tells you to do but have I gone too far and just made him tired and hungry? Having a serious mum guilt battle of wether to continue this, stress both me and my baby boy out or just give him formula which will ensure he is definitely fedSad I feel like I've starved him but I've just persevered as I was advised to do and let him 'feed on demand'.

He doesn't have tongue tie and these 6 hour bouts of feeding on and off have been for the last 5 days or so. It's exhausting but I ultimately want what's best for him.

Please be gentle, he's my first baba and I didn't realise how strongly you feel for them and just want the absolute best for them.

OP posts:
User0ne · 23/06/2021 21:53

It sounds like little one building up your supply. Headbutting your breast? Fussing? Fighting when trying to latch on? On and off breast quickly and crying in between? All normal and a sign that they're getting enough to encourage your supply to increase for the next day. Formula takes longer to digest so they might seem more settled afterwards but you're not comparing like with like.

The first couple of months ebf are hard. It can feel relentless with constant feeding. It does ease off and if you can stick it out its really convenient (and cheap).

At night have you tried bf on your side? I found this a real breakthrough in terms of getting enough sleep.

It sounds like you're doing great. Definitely see if you can join a bf support group (in person is best if you can). Hope you're ok whatever you decide

ohthestruggles · 23/06/2021 21:51

@Horehound

I persevered BF and hated it for almost two years!

Why don't you try combi feeding? Then it's best of both worlds

I've thought about it but because his feeding is all over the place I wouldn't be able to pin point a replacement feeding time if that makes sense? His cluster feeding can be morning, noon, night or both or all three. I don't know when to say enoughs enough and give him the bottle. I think because everyone and the HCP's have advised me to let him cluster feed I didn't want to interfere too much with it. But it did become too much tonight after 6 hours and I could see his wee eyes getting heavy but he was still so upset.
OP posts:
MamaEs · 23/06/2021 21:51

I stopped after 2 weeks and moved to formula and it was the best decision I ever made. I now have a very healthy 7 year old.

Do what works best for you and don't beat yourself up.

Fed is best.

Twizbe · 23/06/2021 21:51

[quote ohthestruggles]@DinosaurDiana I feel like I literally am just feeding him. I had to wait til DP came back this morning for my food as I hadn't been able to put DS down. This does worry me as he does have to work and I will have to semi-function as something other than a milk machine at some point! [/quote]
And at some point you will. It won't be like this forever.

One thing your partner can do to help is make you some food when he gets up. Pop a sandwich in the fridge for example. Get him to fill a bottle of water for you as well.

shouldistop · 23/06/2021 21:50

Hypnobirthing should come with a warning, it can make women feel inadequate when it doesn't go 'right'. I'm sorry you had a tough experience.

Horehound · 23/06/2021 21:49

I persevered BF and hated it for almost two years!

Why don't you try combi feeding? Then it's best of both worlds

shouldistop · 23/06/2021 21:49

I never had a problem with supply. Giving that bottle made no difference whatsoever.

Yeah the odd bottle wouldn't matter, I mean a regular bottle. Say every day for a week then there's the risk that your supply changes to match the smaller demand from your baby. Which is obviously totally fine if you're choosing to combi feed.

ohthestruggles · 23/06/2021 21:48

My partner does think I am a bit hard on myself. I feel a lot more strongly about wanting BF to work out because we didn't have the birth I wanted/thought would be possible. I had an antepartum haemorrhage and things were taken completely out of my hands which I had never even considered may happen. Hypnobirthing should come with a warning and I realise now my expectations were perhaps too high.

OP posts:
shouldistop · 23/06/2021 21:47

@mayblossominapril 🤣🤣 my 6mo growls and punches my boobs at his 7pm bedtime feed as my milk is slower at that time and he's tired.

DinosaurDiana · 23/06/2021 21:46

@shouldistop

Cluster feeding absolutely does not mean your baby is starving. As long as nappies are good you don't need to worry about that. Giving formula during cluster feeding isn't great actually as it can affect future supply if given too much. I don't say that to make you feel bad and indeed combination feeding is a perfectly good way of feeding but just make an informed decision. If you give a regular bottle then you might have to keep giving that regular bottle unless you want to do a lot of hard work with a pump.
I never had a problem with supply. Giving that bottle made no difference whatsoever.
PassionfruitOrangeGuava · 23/06/2021 21:45

Of course yanbu!

You’ll get lots of people saying they kept going and are glad, so I wanted to share my own perspective too. Often people don’t feel able to share if their bf journey didn’t work out so well. I persevered and really regret having done so. Bf exclusively was never physically possible for us and I deeply regret the stress I put myself through trying to force it for nine long months. There are lots of benefits to bf and formula and neither one is best for everyone. It depends totally on you and your baby. I loved breastfeeding itself and wished I could have done it forever, but on balance it was the wrong decision for us to keep going and it would have been far better for me, baby, my mental health, and our family as a whole to switch to formula much, much sooner.

If you want to stop bf then that’s the right decision for you. For some it gets easier, for others it doesn’t, so you can only go by how you feel in the here and now. Whichever way you feed your baby they will thrive, and if bf isn’t or doesn’t feel doable for you that’s no reflection on you in any way. Fed is best and we are so lucky to have options, good luck.

Please don’t feel discouraged if you get lots of encouragement to carry on but it isn’t right for you: people are quick to try and encourage breastfeeding but I think it’s important too to highlight that what’s best for you as a family might not be that and to empower you to make the decision for yourself. Combo feeding is a great option, exclusive bf is a great option, exclusive formula feeding is a great option. Whatever way you go from here have the confidence that you know what’s best for you and your baby, nobody else here does Flowers

shouldistop · 23/06/2021 21:45

Cluster feeding absolutely does not mean your baby is starving. As long as nappies are good you don't need to worry about that.
Giving formula during cluster feeding isn't great actually as it can affect future supply if given too much. I don't say that to make you feel bad and indeed combination feeding is a perfectly good way of feeding but just make an informed decision. If you give a regular bottle then you might have to keep giving that regular bottle unless you want to do a lot of hard work with a pump.

ComDummings · 23/06/2021 21:44

You’re doing great. If you want to persevere then go for it, you can always try giving formula if you need a break at night or something. But if you want to give up completely then it’s fine. Don’t make yourself ill over it.

ohthestruggles · 23/06/2021 21:44

@DinosaurDiana I feel like I literally am just feeding him. I had to wait til DP came back this morning for my food as I hadn't been able to put DS down. This does worry me as he does have to work and I will have to semi-function as something other than a milk machine at some point!

OP posts:
Twizbe · 23/06/2021 21:44

[quote ohthestruggles]@Twizbe this is the thing, on a good day/morning whatever it is, I don't want to stop. In the middle of a feeding marathon/frenzy I could totally reach for the formula and make up a full bottle but something tells me not to pack it in completely. However, seeing him fed and content tonight I felt horrendously guilty like I'd starved him for hours and made a very selfish decision to persevere for so long. [/quote]
Then likely you would regret stopping.

Don't feel guilty though. I remember one night after a major cluster feed just giving baby to dad and rolling over to sleep. I'm sure baby was fine (or if they weren't dad was clever enough to not tell me) I needed that sleep at that time

110APiccadilly · 23/06/2021 21:43

I persevered but I found it quite hard. What helped me was thinking of milestones where I would take stock and stop if I wanted to - so I told myself I'd do it for the first three weeks, then when I got there I decided I could carry on to 6 weeks, and so on. She's 7 months now and still breast feeding, so that worked for me.

The other thing which helped me practically in the cluster feed stage was feeding lying down so my arms and back got a break. Just make sure you're either not going to fall asleep or you're set up for safe co-sleeping, or both!

However, do stop if you need to and don't feel guilty. Your baby needs you happy and functioning well more than your milk.

mayblossominapril · 23/06/2021 21:42

Yes they can definitely smell the milk. DD head butted me during cluster feeding to get the milk to let down faster.
I found eating calorie dense food and drinking more than I thought I needed helped.
IF you want to switch do but you are at the most exhausting stage and in a few weeks it will be easier and by 12 weeks it will be a doddle
During the night feeds I used to play games on my phone, then I switched to online surveys. I average about £50 a month from doing a surveys whilst feeding. It just gave me something else to focus on. You might want to watch Netflix for example.

DinosaurDiana · 23/06/2021 21:42

Do whatever you need to do.
You need to shower, eat, shop, housework etc
Mine were all BF but they all had a bottle at night to hopefully get them to sleep slightly longer. I also think it’s a good idea for a baby to be able to take a bottle in case there’s ever a situation where you can’t BF your baby.

ohthestruggles · 23/06/2021 21:41

@Twizbe this is the thing, on a good day/morning whatever it is, I don't want to stop. In the middle of a feeding marathon/frenzy I could totally reach for the formula and make up a full bottle but something tells me not to pack it in completely. However, seeing him fed and content tonight I felt horrendously guilty like I'd starved him for hours and made a very selfish decision to persevere for so long.

OP posts:
shouldistop · 23/06/2021 21:41

Ahh the early days are hard. You're adjusting to being a parent and the responsibilities that brings plus all of the physical and hormonal difficulties and changes.
I promise it gets easier.

Twizbe · 23/06/2021 21:39

Best advice I got was not to stop on a bad day.

If you're having a good breastfeeding day and you still want to stop then it's the right choice for you.

Also, I remember during cluster feeds just thinking through the steps of making up formula.... putting baby on the boob just seemed so much easier

ohthestruggles · 23/06/2021 21:39

@shouldistop thank you! I tried a dummy yesterday, it upset me to see him with that shoved in his mouth. He spat it out anyway. And I have never ever judged anyone for giving a dummy, they don't bother me in the slightest but seeing my own with one in his mouth freaked me out for some reason Confused fully ready for people to say I'm odd for that but it just gave me a strange feeling.

He has had it a few times since then but isn't keen so far.

Being a new mum brings about a lot of feelings I didn't know I would ever have for some reason and I was utterly unprepared for it.

OP posts:
cindarellasbelly · 23/06/2021 21:36

Honestly OP, the first three weeks were really really hard, the next few weeks were different but had their struggles, from about 2 months on I never had a moment's difficulty and fed till she was 2. It was so easy a way to comfort her, I enjoyed it so much.

So I struggle with these a bit - the non-negotiable is your mental health, and if breastfeeding is stopping you enjoying your child then its better to stop. But its all a bit hard at the start, so if its manageable to push through, often people find its worth it. Only you can decide exactly where you fall. But yes, I cried in the evenings, I thought something was wrong, sometimes it went well, sometimes she screamed and couldn't latch. I would recommend advise from La leche League and maybe even a lactation consultant, but it eventually fell into place for us and was really lovely. Equally: I wasn't breastfed, I have a great relationship with my mum, its a nice thing to do but it will seem less critical as time goes on. My gut always says to advise people so early on to push through because I know so many people its worked out for but is not the best path for everyone.

SBAM · 23/06/2021 21:35

Formula top ups don’t mean you have to stop breastfeeding, combo-feeding is a valid choice. My son had reflux and was a bad sleeper so until weaning he had at least one bottle of formula a day, in the evening so I could get to bed early and get a few uninterrupted hours sleep while he was with his dad. If it’s working for you then carry on.

shouldistop · 23/06/2021 21:35

Does the baby have a dummy? I know some people don't like them but if weight gain is good then I don't see the problem with giving one at this stage.