Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this harsh or AIBU?

85 replies

Anonymouse21 · 22/06/2021 18:50

My child is in Y3 at school (aged 7) they are autistic and have ADHD. DS came home from school yesterday very upset as he had been kept inside at break times and lunch. This was because he made an inappropriate comment towards another child at after school club LAST Wednesday!

He did not attend school last Thursday and Friday as when we picked him from after school club last Wednesday he was clearly unwell (high temperature, sore throat). We were not told about the incident at the time or what the consequence would be. Of course by the time DS went back to school yesterday it had been almost 5 days since he made the inappropriate comment. AIBU to think that’s too long for a 7 year old with autism and ADHD to make the connection to his behaviour so as to be a meaningful consequence.

I asked him about his behaviour and he said he lost control as all the children were annoying him (I expect his tolerance towards others was further reduced because he wasn’t very well). He knows what he said wasn’t appropriate but from his perspective other children annoy him and make comments towards him - he tells the teacher, he then gets told to stop being a tattletale. He then loses control, the other children tell on him and he gets into trouble. He can’t see a difference between his behaviour and theirs only that he gets into trouble and they don’t.

I also think that missing all his breaks for the day is too much - he needs movement breaks, it’s his chance to blow off steam. He was most upset at being kept in because it was hot and stuffy inside. He needs lots of outside time each day so I think it was overly harsh to keep him in all day.

He was extremely upset and we had a very difficult evening with him, then this morning he made me late for work as he was screaming he hates school and wouldn’t get dressed. I’m very frustrated as he was just starting to settle and I feel the situation has been very badly handled. Not sure where to go from here though.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Conspiracyornotr · 07/01/2022 19:55

I would be fuming about it poor child and they didn't inform you about this incident . My child 5 been excluded 3 times things are out of control school just ring me and send him.home daily basic beacuse they can't cope 😑 then he gets excluded from assembly and the other children makes me sad. I would be having a word with the school and find out why they didn't haven't informed you about thus incident. X

SaltAndVinegarSandwiches · 24/06/2021 20:42

It sounds like the school are inadaquately supporting him. Similiar happened to a friend's child. The other kids knew he was explosive and would wind him up until he'd shout and scream. Then he'd be in trouble for not controlling his emotions. He couldn't control his emotions because he had ADHD and had terrible emotional regulation but the other kids were capable of not winding him up though.

Anonymouse21 · 24/06/2021 20:34

The teacher I spoke with is part of the school leadership team and he’s brilliant with DS and children like him. He knows what should’ve been done and suggested how things could be done in future. But I need to talk to them again as it’s becoming clear from other things DS has told me this evening that the teacher (who is very inexperienced and not a fully qualified teacher) is not managing him correctly at all. Nothing is being done to support him and he’s spiralling downward. I’m not sure she is even aware of his difficulties as she’s making zero allowances.

OP posts:
BlatantlyNameChanged · 24/06/2021 20:20

That's good, OP. Have they said how they'll better support him moving forwards?

Anonymouse21 · 24/06/2021 20:17

After talking to the school it was decided that the situation had not been handled appropriately and I was offered an apology.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 23/06/2021 15:13

@Anonymouse21

I would not assume the ‘teacher’ is best placed to make an appropriate judgment. It’s very easy to always blame the child who is known to make inappropriate comments. He feels he always gets into trouble and the other children do the same and don’t get into trouble
I said, that as you have not yet found out what specifically happened, it would be reasonable to make the presumption that the teacher, who did know what happened, acted appropriately.

If you genuinely think your starting assumption should be that the teacher is always in the wrong, then there are big problems at your school

Diamondnights · 23/06/2021 11:54

I am so sorry OP. I hope you get to the bottom of things and that your son can get back to being happy to go to school.

Flowers500 · 23/06/2021 10:35

@Rosebel

I also think you need to address him "telling tales" especially as it's okay for the other children to do this. Ask his teachers what he should do and when they say he should tell them you can raise the "telling tales". Make sure you also ask why it's okay for the other kids to tell tales. I'm sad but not surprised. It always seems to be kids with SEN who get the blame.
This was what I was going to say—it sounds like the teachers have given him a process to raise the issue when it starts, go to the teacher for help, let them help resolve before it escalates. But then they are totally betraying that by responding negatively to him following what he was supposed to do, leaving him confused, not resolving the issue and causing the flare up. He’s not currently ina a place to manage these emotions himself, the processes and the teachers are meant to assist with that. They’re making it worse by failing to follow the nice clear path of how to deal with the issue.
Rosebel · 23/06/2021 08:43

I also think you need to address him "telling tales" especially as it's okay for the other children to do this.
Ask his teachers what he should do and when they say he should tell them you can raise the "telling tales". Make sure you also ask why it's okay for the other kids to tell tales.
I'm sad but not surprised. It always seems to be kids with SEN who get the blame.

Sydendad · 22/06/2021 23:08

@SamanthaJayne4

I have an adult DC who is autistic, not diagnosed as a child. They need an escape for when they get overwhelmed and at risk of a meltdown. My DC has permission to leave any environment at uni for a break and time to cool off if they need to. For any family occasions I make sure there is an escape. School should make allowances for autistic children, very unkind not to. My DC has ADHD as well.
I'd like to add as well that in stead of only talking about consequences you should also ask your school to help your DS to learn coping mechanisms, which are very important for children with mental challenges as frustration and anger are often the cause of behavioral problems. They need to learn to cope with those feelings and find other outlets and methods of breaking their frustration /anger cycle. It also seems to me the other children ought to be taught about the emotional difficulties your DS is facing and teach them to be more sensitive and accepting towards your DS.
BlatantlyNameChanged · 22/06/2021 23:07

his disability doesn't mean he doesn't have consequences

No one has said he shouldn't have consequences but removing his break time should not be one of those consequences and the school should be more proactive in intervening before he reaches breaking point as this would have prevented the incident occurring in the first place.

Sydendad · 22/06/2021 23:00

I don't think your being unreasonable here. It is clear that the approach to your child's social interaction and his learningnof social skills and social rules needs a more guided and personal approach that accounts for his autism and ADHD. Your story sounds to me that this is not adequately addressed by his teachers. I think you should discuss the wider strategy here as this shouldn't only be about his reactions and your teacher reaction to this situation but about a strategy that helps your DS to feel part of school life, without judgement, bullying and alienation but also with a clear framework of what is and isn't acceptable and what are and aren't appropriate consequences. Also I do think this is a sensitive situation that if managed well can enable your DS to grow socially or if badly managed can really damage his social skills and further school life. You should keep pushing for dialogue here and as your son seems to have a good understanding and perspective of his own position, I wouldnt be afraid to make him part of this conversation and ask him what clarity / help/ support he needs.

SamanthaJayne4 · 22/06/2021 22:59

I have an adult DC who is autistic, not diagnosed as a child. They need an escape for when they get overwhelmed and at risk of a meltdown. My DC has permission to leave any environment at uni for a break and time to cool off if they need to. For any family occasions I make sure there is an escape. School should make allowances for autistic children, very unkind not to. My DC has ADHD as well.

RoomOfRequirement · 22/06/2021 22:49

I don't really see that they had another choice to punish him when they did, if he was off school Thursday and Friday? When else could they have done it?

Obviously I'm sure they'd have preferred to deal with it Thursday like they did the other child, but they didn't have that option, and his disability doesn't mean he doesn't have consequences.

Sycamor · 22/06/2021 22:32

My 6yr old has ASD and we went thro a period of frequent break and lunchtime detentions. He struggles with his behaviour and tho improving I agree with the need for a consequence (even if I doubt the sanity of this consequence for a boy who can't sit still).
However this was being reported back to me by his brother and like you I felt we weren't getting a reliable account of what happened.
I asked for a communication diary (now online) which was sent home every Friday or more frequently if anything needed. Gave the teacher a chance to accurately report issues, let's me flag issues, if for example he was having a period of difficulty with his clothes which might cause distress, and serves as a record of issues if further support is gonna be requested.
I've found it very helpful, and even acts a a slight deterent when he knows the book is coming home to me with an issue in it.

Anonymouse21 · 22/06/2021 22:15

The teacher confirmed via message that he had missed his break and lunch for making an inappropriate comment but didn’t want to discuss further in a message so I have to arrange a time to speak to her.

OP posts:
Oneandanotherone · 22/06/2021 22:15

My son wouldn’t remember what was said today nevermind last Wednesday. The teacher has a lot to learn.

Anonymouse21 · 22/06/2021 22:13

Removal of break time and lunch time for one day is the top step of the behaviour policy - but the behaviour policy also a states a letter will be sent home to inform parents and I have not received a letter. Usually the behaviour policy is applied step wise but for serious issues like bullying which is zero tolerance you go straight to the top.

OP posts:
toocold54 · 22/06/2021 22:08

He should definitely have consequences but I think break and lunch is too much. Usually for a small offence it’s break and then a bigger offence it’s lunch. I would rather it was spread over a couple of days as everyone needs to get fresh air and exercise. I would be tempted to double check this is what actually happened and clarify what was said. You can say it in a way that you are concerned about his language and will speak to him at home etc.

You say the teacher isn’t qualified yet. If they are a trainee they should have a qualified teacher with them.

BlatantlyNameChanged · 22/06/2021 22:07

Ha! Wait until you get an EHCP and (depending on what it includes) get to hear about how "unfair" it is that your DC gets a TA, no homework, and daily circuit training during registration because "all the children should be allowed that".

Marmalady75 · 22/06/2021 22:05

A lot of this discussion seems to have missed what I think is the main point (so maybe I’m off), but no child should have their playtime withdrawn unless there has been a violent incident that necessitates them staying in for the safety of others.
I’m a teacher and on the very few occasions I’ve kept children in (usually because I am told to by management) I ensure that they still get time outside with a classroom assistant after the other children return. Everyone needs a chance to blow off steam and get fresh air.

Anonymouse21 · 22/06/2021 22:03

Yes, I forgot how judgemental some people are. It’s a bit like water off a ducks back now I find. In that sadly I’m used to it.

OP posts:
BlatantlyNameChanged · 22/06/2021 21:57

The EHCP formalises matters by setting out exactly what support is needed, who is responsible for providing it, and who it will be funded by. It has both short term and long term outcomes built into it and includes regular reviews to track progress and amend as necessary (and it also sets out how progress will be measured/checked). If a school is dicking about with support then applying for an EHCP can help sharpen their focus by giving them a clear breakdown of what they need to be doing.

Namechangecosguilty · 22/06/2021 21:56

@BrilliantBetty

He doesn’t have an EHCP. At the moment I don’t think he would qualify.

Well, this seems the problem. You're expecting special treatment / adjustments without having an EHCP.

Why are people being so hostile, 'special treatment', seriously??

OP maybe AIBU isn't the best place to post this what with all the lack of empathy and bitchery going on.

I get where you're coming from, YANBU at all.

annieannietomjoe · 22/06/2021 21:56

@BrilliantBetty

He doesn’t have an EHCP. At the moment I don’t think he would qualify.

Well, this seems the problem. You're expecting special treatment / adjustments without having an EHCP.

You are incorrect

A school has a duty to provide support and provision and support for kids with SEN, they have budget for this...a diagnosis proves SEN. An EHCP is for a kid with SEN and needs specialist provision - the fact a kid has SEN and may need specialist provision should get him assessed (per the law) but in practice that is not the case.