Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not sure if I want to buy a house, anyone else decided not to?

179 replies

Drumstick38 · 21/06/2021 22:02

I earn minimum wage, though I am currently applying for higher paid roles.
I have zero debt apart from student loans which is good, and about £1700 in savings.
I can't see how I could ever afford a deposit, as well as all the associated fees. I'm in Greater Manchester and having to look in Bolton, Wigan, Rochdale etc. As everything else is much more expensive.

Aside from this, I think the responsibility of paying a mortgage would be too much for me. I've already lost money this week due to having Covid and having to isolate, I'd be too worried about losing my job or something and not being able to pay.

The repair and maintenance costs are a factor too of buying a house.

I like the flexibility of renting, I don't have any pets and I like that more responsibility falls on the landlord.

The thing that people seem concerned about is in retirement age, and whether people can afford to keep renting, but surely there must be solutions?

Anyone else in a similar situation?

OP posts:
TheLastBeach · 22/06/2021 02:16

@Bythemillpond

The thing that people seem concerned about is in retirement age, and whether people can afford to keep renting, but surely there must be solutions

Dh and I have effectively retired although we both still work odd days here and there.

At the moment we own and we’re planning on going into rented just for a year or so whilst we find a house to buy when our house sale goes through. Possibly a week on Wednesday.

Our problem we are finding is that without full time employment even if we say we will pay the years money upfront it isn’t that easy to rent anything when you are retired. Dd is the one who rental agents have said will have to rent the house as she is the only one who has tax returns for 4 years. Even then what they will allow her to rent is not suitable for all of us
Should add we all have good credit ratings so it isn’t that sort of thing

Add that to the fact we have pets and you might as well be asking for the moon rather than a 3 bed terrace in Walthamstow. The moon would be easier.
Tonight it all imploded. We have given up on renting anything.

I know everyone says rentals are easy and flexible but all we have found is obstacles and snotty rental agents who treat you like you are a piece of dirt on their shoe and rental properties that I have seen for sale on Rightmove that needed renovation that now have cheap carpet laid and being put up for rent with an extortionate monthly price tag.

We have got to the point of thinking that buying something that failed to sell at auction because it is cheap, readily available and the agent isn’t going to make me take a test to see if I am a person of high enough standing because I want to enquire about a property, is going to be so much simpler.

I would save as much as you can and buy the cheapest property you can squeeze into.

Whilst you are younger it can seem that things are easy and renting is the easy route but as you get older problems you didn’t think could exist suddenly crop up and you are left feeling how unfair life is when you are old.

That sounds awful. I am so sorry you have been treated this way.

When I was selling my house to move abroad, and rent in the meantime, the agent who sold my house had a good connection with a local letting agent. I had pets and children, but with him having sold my house he'd seen that it was immaculate regardless of said troublemakers, so his letting agent friend wasn't bothered about the small people/ animals I was taking with me. Is there any option for your agent to help you in that way? Or find one that will?

TheLastBeach · 22/06/2021 01:50

@Confusedaboutlots I answered that poster's question, directed at me, as best I could. I'm not sure what your answer has to do with the question tbh.

Also, the "18 year cycle" is bollocks I'm afraid. In several iterations house prices followed economic cycles, and then they didn't. It doesn't work like that with some magic formula because - as I posted earlier - there are lots of economic, demographic and international factors at play.

Bythemillpond · 22/06/2021 01:45

The thing that people seem concerned about is in retirement age, and whether people can afford to keep renting, but surely there must be solutions

Dh and I have effectively retired although we both still work odd days here and there.

At the moment we own and we’re planning on going into rented just for a year or so whilst we find a house to buy when our house sale goes through. Possibly a week on Wednesday.

Our problem we are finding is that without full time employment even if we say we will pay the years money upfront it isn’t that easy to rent anything when you are retired. Dd is the one who rental agents have said will have to rent the house as she is the only one who has tax returns for 4 years. Even then what they will allow her to rent is not suitable for all of us
Should add we all have good credit ratings so it isn’t that sort of thing

Add that to the fact we have pets and you might as well be asking for the moon rather than a 3 bed terrace in Walthamstow. The moon would be easier.
Tonight it all imploded. We have given up on renting anything.

I know everyone says rentals are easy and flexible but all we have found is obstacles and snotty rental agents who treat you like you are a piece of dirt on their shoe and rental properties that I have seen for sale on Rightmove that needed renovation that now have cheap carpet laid and being put up for rent with an extortionate monthly price tag.

We have got to the point of thinking that buying something that failed to sell at auction because it is cheap, readily available and the agent isn’t going to make me take a test to see if I am a person of high enough standing because I want to enquire about a property, is going to be so much simpler.

I would save as much as you can and buy the cheapest property you can squeeze into.

Whilst you are younger it can seem that things are easy and renting is the easy route but as you get older problems you didn’t think could exist suddenly crop up and you are left feeling how unfair life is when you are old.

Confusedaboutlots · 22/06/2021 01:11

[quote FTEngineerM]@TheLastBeach

  1. is it possible to figure out exactly how much they rise? Or is it just inflation? (Actual question not rhetorical). Re mortgaged: whilst the purchase price is set there certainly aren’t any 25 year fixes so at some point the purchaser will either be on standard or have to refix both would be at the mercy of interest rates, it’s clearly marked now on mortgage applications what the payments would be if they were at 11% (back in 2008 interest rate figures I think). When I took out mine for instance it was paying £88k interest over 25 years, I’ve since remortgaged and it’s down to £49k over 23. I remortgaged because interests rates lowered but I’m fully expecting at the next fix is over for them to rise.

  2. I know those costs are burdened by the renter I’m not sure I’ve written otherwise. Just as a home owner some seem to be saying it’s cheaper in the long run and quote the purchase price only and that’s a tiny snapshot. Legal fees can get complicated and messy depending on the property, which if you had to pay for additional services every time you remortgage it adds up to a few months rent.

My own DP said ‘so we’ve made 20k on the house’ when it was valued and then I wrote down our costs for him to see and we’ve actually just broke even. We haven’t made a penny. We’ve spent the same in relies, interest and fees and we have made in equity. So us personally wouldn’t have been any better off if we’d carried on renting.[/quote]
property does always go up in the long run because it’s in scant supply generally - we only have limited land on which to build.

but that isn’t in a straight line - there’s something called the 18 year cycle which is really interesting

also building high doesn’t always generate the price increase - again supply and demand economics

Confusedaboutlots · 22/06/2021 01:08

other countries like Germany actively encourage long term renting by ensuring there are rent caps and tenant protections.

In the UK landlords are entitled to upwardly rent review every five years which can cause rents to increase in line with inflation - whereas mortgages can be fixed rate and even if not the overall amount is fixed to the initial price paid/loan to value.

But this may change as buying isn’t for everyone. in fact even though private landlords are finding it harder to let, many institutional investors like pension schemes are looking to buy assets and rent to young professionals for the longer term - so called build to rent assets.

so you’re not alone in your views as to the flexibility and lack of hassle of renting- it definitely has a place and should be encouraged for those who would benefit from it

RickiTarr · 22/06/2021 00:59

I think if you won’t be able to afford a small repairs fund and a modest pension, sometimes it’s better to remain renting and have access to full pensioner benefits. The danger being that rents might rise a lot further and make even that quite a meagre safety net.

You’re only young, though. It probably very much hinges on your future carer plans and income expectations.

TheLastBeach · 22/06/2021 00:53

@Watchingyou2sleezes which lender? That is very interesting as it's very common in many other European countries to offer 20-30 years fixed so people know exactly what they'll pay until it is fully paid off. But I'd not heard of it here before on that scale. The longest that existed in the UK market when I last refinanced was a 10 year fix. It would be great if they are now matching the fixes to mortgage terms, it would make buying so much less risky for people.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 22/06/2021 00:49

[quote FTEngineerM]@TheLastBeach

  1. is it possible to figure out exactly how much they rise? Or is it just inflation? (Actual question not rhetorical). Re mortgaged: whilst the purchase price is set there certainly aren’t any 25 year fixes so at some point the purchaser will either be on standard or have to refix both would be at the mercy of interest rates, it’s clearly marked now on mortgage applications what the payments would be if they were at 11% (back in 2008 interest rate figures I think). When I took out mine for instance it was paying £88k interest over 25 years, I’ve since remortgaged and it’s down to £49k over 23. I remortgaged because interests rates lowered but I’m fully expecting at the next fix is over for them to rise.

  2. I know those costs are burdened by the renter I’m not sure I’ve written otherwise. Just as a home owner some seem to be saying it’s cheaper in the long run and quote the purchase price only and that’s a tiny snapshot. Legal fees can get complicated and messy depending on the property, which if you had to pay for additional services every time you remortgage it adds up to a few months rent.

My own DP said ‘so we’ve made 20k on the house’ when it was valued and then I wrote down our costs for him to see and we’ve actually just broke even. We haven’t made a penny. We’ve spent the same in relies, interest and fees and we have made in equity. So us personally wouldn’t have been any better off if we’d carried on renting.[/quote]
Long term fixed rate mortgages are available in the UK, one lender was potentially offering a 40 year fixed rate back in March.

TheLastBeach · 22/06/2021 00:11

@FrownedUpon

I would try to buy if at all possible. By the time I’m fifty, my mortgage will be paid off & I’ll own my house. No more mortgage/rent payments ever again! If I’d rented I would have to find ever increasing rent payments & have no freedom to retire early or perhaps retire ever!
I think that's a huge issue. Many people who are renting for life will never be able to retire at all. Sad
TheLastBeach · 22/06/2021 00:10

@Flawedperfection

You should aim to do what makes you happiest, but you’re so lucky to live somewhere relatively cheap for housing if you do decide to try to buy one day. Where I live, it’s at least £280/300k for a basic 1 bedroom flat- virtually impossible for my partner and me- both on minimum wage in unstable jobs, no real deposit and no family help. Makes me want to cry reading that and we’re not spring chickens either!
I'm so sorry for your situation. I am in the SE and it is hard. I'm a single parents and housing plus nursery fees are killing me atm!

I think though that there will always be public support to help people who couldn't buy a house, so that they can afford a place to live when they retire.

The issue I raised earlier was about people who could do that but said "I'd rather have more free cash now to spend on DC/ fun/ holidays" etc, who then say that's fine because someone else can pick up the bill for their rent when they retire anyway, even though they could have sorted it out themselves either by buying or by putting that extra money they are spending each month into pensions or investments like the rest of us do! That makes me quite cross tbh, it's cheeky fucker behaviour.

Somebody in genuine need who could not afford to put anything aside, I don't think anybody would object to helping through taxpayer funds. Thanks

FrownedUpon · 22/06/2021 00:05

I would try to buy if at all possible. By the time I’m fifty, my mortgage will be paid off & I’ll own my house. No more mortgage/rent payments ever again! If I’d rented I would have to find ever increasing rent payments & have no freedom to retire early or perhaps retire ever!

Flawedperfection · 21/06/2021 23:55

You should aim to do what makes you happiest, but you’re so lucky to live somewhere relatively cheap for housing if you do decide to try to buy one day. Where I live, it’s at least £280/300k for a basic 1 bedroom flat- virtually impossible for my partner and me- both on minimum wage in unstable jobs, no real deposit and no family help. Makes me want to cry reading that and we’re not spring chickens either!

TheLastBeach · 21/06/2021 23:50

@TheLastBeach haha! No chips here (unfortunately, I’m ravenous)

@PassionfruitOrangeGuava aaaargh now I want chips! 😬😣

TheLastBeach · 21/06/2021 23:43

Also @FTEngineerM I had huge issues with one property so I get what you mean about unexpected costs!!! And through life's unexpected swerves, I ended up buying three houses in a 5 year period so paid horrific stamp duty 3 times. 😤🙄 So totally get that in individual circumstances it can end up costing a lot more than expected. But on average people who buy stay for 10 years plus, and most won't find huge structural issues that need to be fixed etc 🤦🏻‍♀️🙈 so I still - despite my personal experiences! - think it's a good decision financially to buy for most people.

And now I intend to live where I am until they carry me out in a box. 🤣🤣

TheLastBeach · 21/06/2021 23:36

[quote FTEngineerM]@TheLastBeach ah fantastic thank you, I will have to read it in the morning now SmileWine[/quote]
No problem! Sleep well! Smile

FTEngineerM · 21/06/2021 23:36

@TheLastBeach ah fantastic thank you, I will have to read it in the morning now SmileWine

TheLastBeach · 21/06/2021 23:33

The graphic is of the Bank of England base interest rate by year. Sorry, should have said that.

TheLastBeach · 21/06/2021 23:30

[quote FTEngineerM]@TheLastBeach

  1. is it possible to figure out exactly how much they rise? Or is it just inflation? (Actual question not rhetorical). Re mortgaged: whilst the purchase price is set there certainly aren’t any 25 year fixes so at some point the purchaser will either be on standard or have to refix both would be at the mercy of interest rates, it’s clearly marked now on mortgage applications what the payments would be if they were at 11% (back in 2008 interest rate figures I think). When I took out mine for instance it was paying £88k interest over 25 years, I’ve since remortgaged and it’s down to £49k over 23. I remortgaged because interests rates lowered but I’m fully expecting at the next fix is over for them to rise.

  2. I know those costs are burdened by the renter I’m not sure I’ve written otherwise. Just as a home owner some seem to be saying it’s cheaper in the long run and quote the purchase price only and that’s a tiny snapshot. Legal fees can get complicated and messy depending on the property, which if you had to pay for additional services every time you remortgage it adds up to a few months rent.

My own DP said ‘so we’ve made 20k on the house’ when it was valued and then I wrote down our costs for him to see and we’ve actually just broke even. We haven’t made a penny. We’ve spent the same in relies, interest and fees and we have made in equity. So us personally wouldn’t have been any better off if we’d carried on renting.[/quote]
Hello @FTEngineerM

No, it's not possible to figure out how much rents rise. All we can do is look at trends and data within the UK market, and also consider externalities that may impact the UK. These are very uncertain times so this is particularly tricky at the moment.

Over the last few decades, rents have risen far above the general rate of inflation. There are a number of factors that have driven that (a higher percentage of people renting, rising population, insufficient house building, smaller households therefore a population the same size would require more properties to live in, concentration of employment in certain areas etc). Few of those factors seem likely to reverse in the medium term, but as always the past can be analysed and the future can only be predicted with the best data and hypotheses we have at the time.

Interest rates were not 11% in 2008. They have not been at that level since the early '90s. It was massively damaging and now with so much of the population highly leveraged on housing (and the Government itself exposed to this through "Help to Buy") plus highly indebted businesses, I cannot imagine that happening again for a long, long time as it would result in economic catastrophe. Interest rates will likely be raised in the coming years to control inflation or in response to foreign influences that are devaluing GBP (not that our Governments have given a shit about that for the last 15 years!!) but not that high, as it simply isn't something our economy can sustain now, as a direct result of what our previous few of Governments have done.

I hope that's helpful and I've answered what you were wanting me to? If not let me know and I'll try again! SmileGrin

Not sure if I want to buy a house, anyone else decided not to?
SchrodingersImmigrant · 21/06/2021 23:29

It's not for everyone at some point. There were times when I wouldn't buy because renting gave me flexibility and no big responsibility for a building. If you are happy with it now (you have great cheap rent), wait. Everyone does things on a different schedule.

PawsQueen · 21/06/2021 23:27

My mortgage is a lot cheaper than rent but I was lucky enough to buy at a decent time and have a small deposit due to family bereavement
Mortgage is about £380, my apartment will rent out for £550 so for me it makes sense
I wouldn't judge anyone differently though if they rented

User135792468 · 21/06/2021 23:24

There is nothing wrong with renting if you can’t afford to buy. Life is for living. There is no point in barely scraping by to afford a mortgage. It’s not the mortgage itself that’s the issue as it would be the same as rent, it is trying to save for a deposit whilst paying rent which is impossible on lower income jobs. Good luck Op.

MediocrePenguin · 21/06/2021 23:24

@FTEngineerM hopefully you should see some big benefits in the longer term though.

They more you pay off the higher loan to value you have, this will translate in smaller payments and better intent rates.

I have about 50% equity now and my mortgage payments are about 1/3 of what I'd be paying in rent.

FTEngineerM · 21/06/2021 23:19

Repairs*

DixonD · 21/06/2021 23:17

@Drumstick38

That's good, as I don't think that people over retirement age should go homeless just because they couldn't afford to buy a house in working age? But people seem to make out that you're screwed if you rent in retirement age.
You may get your rent paid, but what if your landlord decides to sell? And you find it hard financially, and perhaps even physically, to find a new home? Would landlords want to let to someone who’s retired with little income? It’s hard to find somewhere to rent on benefits for someone of working age, let alone someone with no hope of work.

I’m glad I own my home. I will never be forced to move away from all I love, which in old age, I’m sure will become ever more important.

I would do all I could to buy if I were in your position.

FTEngineerM · 21/06/2021 23:17

@TheLastBeach

  1. is it possible to figure out exactly how much they rise? Or is it just inflation? (Actual question not rhetorical). Re mortgaged: whilst the purchase price is set there certainly aren’t any 25 year fixes so at some point the purchaser will either be on standard or have to refix both would be at the mercy of interest rates, it’s clearly marked now on mortgage applications what the payments would be if they were at 11% (back in 2008 interest rate figures I think). When I took out mine for instance it was paying £88k interest over 25 years, I’ve since remortgaged and it’s down to £49k over 23. I remortgaged because interests rates lowered but I’m fully expecting at the next fix is over for them to rise.

  2. I know those costs are burdened by the renter I’m not sure I’ve written otherwise. Just as a home owner some seem to be saying it’s cheaper in the long run and quote the purchase price only and that’s a tiny snapshot. Legal fees can get complicated and messy depending on the property, which if you had to pay for additional services every time you remortgage it adds up to a few months rent.

My own DP said ‘so we’ve made 20k on the house’ when it was valued and then I wrote down our costs for him to see and we’ve actually just broke even. We haven’t made a penny. We’ve spent the same in relies, interest and fees and we have made in equity. So us personally wouldn’t have been any better off if we’d carried on renting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread