Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not sure if I want to buy a house, anyone else decided not to?

179 replies

Drumstick38 · 21/06/2021 22:02

I earn minimum wage, though I am currently applying for higher paid roles.
I have zero debt apart from student loans which is good, and about £1700 in savings.
I can't see how I could ever afford a deposit, as well as all the associated fees. I'm in Greater Manchester and having to look in Bolton, Wigan, Rochdale etc. As everything else is much more expensive.

Aside from this, I think the responsibility of paying a mortgage would be too much for me. I've already lost money this week due to having Covid and having to isolate, I'd be too worried about losing my job or something and not being able to pay.

The repair and maintenance costs are a factor too of buying a house.

I like the flexibility of renting, I don't have any pets and I like that more responsibility falls on the landlord.

The thing that people seem concerned about is in retirement age, and whether people can afford to keep renting, but surely there must be solutions?

Anyone else in a similar situation?

OP posts:
helpmebeanadult · 22/06/2021 11:32

@FTEngineerM

If you own a house you’ll likely be paying tens if not hundreds of thousands in interest to the bank for borrowing the money so whilst it’s an ‘investment’ in reality it’s far more complex.

By the time someone has tallied up mortgage payments, repair costs which can be huge and are often unexpected , legal fees from purchasing and any mortgage fees it’s not actually a great deal.

If you want to rent, just rent, I don’t know why it’s such a hot topic at the minute. I enjoyed renting when I did, totally risk free, I just existed and didn’t worry about the little cracks appearing or the boiler losing pressure for the third time today or the radiator that doesn’t work or the damp gable end wall or the sewage spewing into our garden or party wall dispute. The list is fucking endless when you own the property.

Plus stamp duty from money you've already been taxed on and takes a really long time to save up again if you want to move.
Eggsc1t1ngDay · 22/06/2021 11:32

I've just looked up one of the properties that I used to rent
When I moved out the landlord offered it to me to buy for approx £50k
The approx price is now £200k to buy

So I assume that the rent has increased too over time

LateAtTate · 22/06/2021 11:31

@ShadowsInTheDarkness

I response to posts about getting on the property ladder etc why is that important? I really struggle with this. We rent a 5 bed detached house with an acre of land. If we bought we would have to buy a starter home. Something small with limited outside space and gradually work our way up the ladder over the next few decades. Why do it that way and this emphasis on getting on the ladder when we can continue to rent our lovely house, while slowly saving up over the next 20 years and then go and buy an equally nice house.

Our in-laws sold a 4 bed semi which they had paid the mortgage off on and now rent. They are planning on moving down nearer to us when MIL retires and currently enjoy the flexibility of not being tied to a house sale in order to move. Their fear was that they would end up having to sell up to cover care home fees for themselves in older age or their parents so have used the money from the house sale wisely and invested the bulk of it for their retirement etc. They are very comfortable, certainly aren't struggling as their rent is affordable just the two of them.

Seeing as you’re in a rural area - unlikely to have massive increase in house price that outpace your savings + stable long term rental, it probably makes sense.

Despite everything said on here rent vs buy depends on personal circumstances. If you’re in an area with rising house prices + rent and rent eats up so much of your costs that you can’t save - it’s better to minimise the damage by trying to buy as quickly as possible.

I’m very much in the buy camp - but only because my target area is close to the city (where jobs are in my field are, and not London). If I managed to get a good, well-maintained property with stable rent that enables me to save for longer and properly prices won’t triple in several years then I’d be more comfortable renting for longer. As it stands we’re flooded with London escapees, so there’s a lot of competition and with WFH set to continue it’s unlikely to abate anytime soon.

Judgement depends on individual choice related to circumstances ofc 😂 if people are using ‘benefits’ as their backup plan then you can’t be surprised when people judge but otherwise it’s a personal decision and nobody else’s business ...

ChuckNoWorriesMyWay · 22/06/2021 11:26

I live in London. I do not want to move from London as I was born and raised here.

I rent - a very affordable rent which leaves me a good amount of money to play with. Owning wouldn't give me that. I work and earn a very reasonably wage.

I'm also disabled. If I own a place and become too disabled to work no-one is going to pay my mortgage for me, but benefits would pay my rent.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/06/2021 11:12

Also the mortgage and bills won't be significantly lower than OP's current rent and bills

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/06/2021 11:11

@arithanaggerton absolutely agree on everything you say. I know people on close to nmw who bought few years ago. Admittedly prices of houses are going up due to lockdowns (flats are falling tho), bit it's still doable and it's shame so many people believe it isn't because they are fed London and S prices. Shame.

And yes to the areas. Prices vary massively few miles. I know people who moan they can't afford house because they refuse to change postcode. I did and now I am "oh so luckyyyyy"🙄

And yeah. It may not be right time for OP and that's absolutely fine. We all ahve different nedds at different times.

mumofwildthings · 22/06/2021 11:08

The mortgage repayments on my house are significantly less than market rent. I've been here 10years. As the property has appreciated and rental costs have increased, my mortgage payments have stayed the same andivecreduced the debt. It's a no brainer for me

ShadowsInTheDarkness · 22/06/2021 11:03

I response to posts about getting on the property ladder etc why is that important? I really struggle with this. We rent a 5 bed detached house with an acre of land. If we bought we would have to buy a starter home. Something small with limited outside space and gradually work our way up the ladder over the next few decades. Why do it that way and this emphasis on getting on the ladder when we can continue to rent our lovely house, while slowly saving up over the next 20 years and then go and buy an equally nice house.

Our in-laws sold a 4 bed semi which they had paid the mortgage off on and now rent. They are planning on moving down nearer to us when MIL retires and currently enjoy the flexibility of not being tied to a house sale in order to move. Their fear was that they would end up having to sell up to cover care home fees for themselves in older age or their parents so have used the money from the house sale wisely and invested the bulk of it for their retirement etc. They are very comfortable, certainly aren't struggling as their rent is affordable just the two of them.

ShadowsInTheDarkness · 22/06/2021 10:55

We rent and have no intention currently of buying. We have decided that we will aim to buy when the DCs move out and we are downsizing, that way we can get more land for our money rather than needing lots of inside space. We breed birds and keep goats and sheep. Our landlords are great and we have the bird business here, the sheep and goat are in rented grazing down the road. It works for us as means we are able to afford a much bigger and nice house than we would if we bought and with DC already in the picture I'd hate to spend years saving up and them going without through most of their childhood. Ideally we would have bought a house before having DC but things don't always work out to a plan!!
We are rural and our landlord owns most of the houses in the surrounding villages so if we had to leave this one he would have others available.
I recently went back to uni and I enjoy knowing that even with a reduced income the living costs are fixed - no sudden surprise bills with boilers that need fixing or walls that need repairs. We love it here and will stay as long as we are able.

arithanaggerton · 22/06/2021 10:52

^That isn't my area, I'm West Mids, but I know Lancashire fairly well. People still manage it in my area.

arithanaggerton · 22/06/2021 10:52

@SchrodingersImmigrant

I've done the same, young relatives who I've shown the pricing of certain starter homes in our area and them being stunned that there's a 2 bed terraces going for £90k (which just need new flooring and wallpaper) because they were under the impression it was £200k for a 1 bed flat everywhere in the country. The media doesn't help either. They go on about how impossible it is. I think it may be a consequence of media still being focused on London and the SE, which is obviously a completely different kettle of fish.

OP has said herself there are areas within her own county where she could potentially buy but she has chosen not to go to those areas, which is completely her right. But theoretically, she could. Houses in the towns she mentions are dirt cheap.

In a lot of cases it's not impossible to get on the housing ladder, people just don't want to change areas. Or want a driveway, or won't consider a terrace. I'm not criticising that, I perfectly understand why, but looking at it from an objective point of view, that doesn't make getting on the ladder impossible.

The houses I'm on about aren't necessarily awful either. This house is lovely: www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/109096367#/

worktrip · 22/06/2021 10:48

I also don't get why you say it allows you financial freedom? Paying a mortgage is actually cheaper than renting. It's the deposit which is difficult for most people. Paying rent is paying the landlords mortgage, so why not pay your own and have something to show for it? Repairs and maintenance is not a major issue for most homeowners with a relatively new property.

worktrip · 22/06/2021 10:44

My parents own their own house and are retired on a small pension. They would be crippled financially if they had to pay rent. On their 3 bed detached they would need around £700 pcm in their area. Currently they both own and run cars and enjoy a reasonable standard of living.

LateAtTate · 22/06/2021 10:42

@SchrodingersImmigrant

And yeah. I did calculations with some people who thought they will never buy and it turned out they actually could *@arithanaggerton* I think it's the south centering on these debates with all the news doing "people can't afford to buy because house is 300k".
Yes, it’s very difficult in places like London (although flats have become somewhat cheaper) ... but people mean a house with a reasonable commute etc I suppose. Also with flats you have maintenance fees ...
SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/06/2021 10:36

And yeah. I did calculations with some people who thought they will never buy and it turned out they actually could @arithanaggerton I think it's the south centering on these debates with all the news doing "people can't afford to buy because house is 300k".

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/06/2021 10:34

@arithanaggerton yeah. It is still doable around here. But. I still think OP should wait untill she feels comfortable with the idea and knows she has money for care for the property.
There is no set timeline😁
It may be easier at some point, but that doesn't mean waiting is bad. Just so OP doesn't feel pressured

arithanaggerton · 22/06/2021 10:28

@SchrodingersImmigrant

Very true. Getting on the property ladder is still quite doable in some areas, but I think you have to get on with it in your early 20s. As soon as you're working FT basically. I know a few people in their 20s from very working class backgrounds, never went to uni, who managed to buy terraces buy working full-time in call centre type roles and saving, saving, saving.

I get annoyed by the saying "It's impossible to get on the property ladder". Yes it's much, much harder than it should be. But for some people, it is possible if they really want it. I think some people just write off the idea without ever looking in to it, assuming they can't do it when actually they could pull it off.

Thisnamewasnttaken123 · 22/06/2021 10:25

House prices are continually rising as are rental properties and actually in many areas paying a mortgage monthly is cheaper than if it was rented.
I don't want to be worried about paying my rent in old age and I don't like the thought of not having any control over where I live as with renting if they decide to sell or want their property back you have to move.
I like the security of owning.

Eggsc1t1ngDay · 22/06/2021 10:22

I rented for 10 years & moved more than 10 times

Buying was the right decision for me

I am mortgage free now

Potentially, I could be mortgage free for 40+ more years

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/06/2021 10:18

@arithanaggerton

People who want security but don't care about investment should look into shared ownership. I believe that's what it's for. A few £1000 for a 25% share in some areas.
In some areas you can get whole house for few thousand deposit, which OP can gind around there. Doer upper most likely a bit, but absolutely doable.
LateAtTate · 22/06/2021 10:17

@Auntienumber8

Who knows what the benefit system will be like when you hit retirement age which is almost 40 years away.

Benefits are a last resort for people. It adds a further intrusive layer of control over your life. Have you ever seen the sort of huge probing forms that have to be filled out or dealt with the benefits people? I did once in my life and very short term and the people who helped me were really nice but my goodness the hours on the phone and the questions, it made me feel pretty bad.

The getting ill that people have mentioned, that’s what happened to me. A serious illness leading to a disability at almost 50 meant the end of my career.

I did rent in my twenties and had really decent Landlords but even the really nice ones may at some point need their property back. Renting is stressful. Especially if anyone has dc and you need to find a new house near their school.

At the rate we’re going (ageing population + more SEN needs) counting on benefits isn’t a good idea...
arithanaggerton · 22/06/2021 10:15

A few £1000 for the deposit, obviously. There's the mortgage on that %. I haven't slept.

Auntienumber8 · 22/06/2021 10:09

Who knows what the benefit system will be like when you hit retirement age which is almost 40 years away.

Benefits are a last resort for people. It adds a further intrusive layer of control over your life. Have you ever seen the sort of huge probing forms that have to be filled out or dealt with the benefits people? I did once in my life and very short term and the people who helped me were really nice but my goodness the hours on the phone and the questions, it made me feel pretty bad.

The getting ill that people have mentioned, that’s what happened to me. A serious illness leading to a disability at almost 50 meant the end of my career.

I did rent in my twenties and had really decent Landlords but even the really nice ones may at some point need their property back. Renting is stressful. Especially if anyone has dc and you need to find a new house near their school.

arithanaggerton · 22/06/2021 10:05

People who want security but don't care about investment should look into shared ownership. I believe that's what it's for. A few £1000 for a 25% share in some areas.

Bythemillpond · 22/06/2021 10:02

Many wealthy people do not need to worry about such things. Many poor people cannot contemplate it as it's out ofcreach for them

I will have enough in the bank to actually buy any of the houses we have looked at renting but once you are old and not in f/t employment we might as well be back in the 60s when you had signs saying No Blacks, No Irish, No Dogs except the sign would say No Old People, No Pets.

Meruem

Yes you can get help with your mortgage, or at least the interest part after I think 6 months. I know we were claiming it for a while as we were on UC as we all lost our jobs because of the first lockdown.
That’s another thing you have to watch out for when you get older.
The age of retirement might be late 60s but when you get in your early 60s or even late 50s you can kiss goodbye to any sort of full time employment (unless you happen to know someone in an organisation who can pull a few strings)

I think whilst you are relatively young and in work and everything is going great then renting is also a perfectly good choice to make but as soon as you start to age and something goes wrong then you could end up homeless and on the streets.

It doesn’t matter how much you have saved, if you aren’t in f/t employment then you are looking at a tent or if you can drive, we contemplated a caravan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread