Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not sure if I want to buy a house, anyone else decided not to?

179 replies

Drumstick38 · 21/06/2021 22:02

I earn minimum wage, though I am currently applying for higher paid roles.
I have zero debt apart from student loans which is good, and about £1700 in savings.
I can't see how I could ever afford a deposit, as well as all the associated fees. I'm in Greater Manchester and having to look in Bolton, Wigan, Rochdale etc. As everything else is much more expensive.

Aside from this, I think the responsibility of paying a mortgage would be too much for me. I've already lost money this week due to having Covid and having to isolate, I'd be too worried about losing my job or something and not being able to pay.

The repair and maintenance costs are a factor too of buying a house.

I like the flexibility of renting, I don't have any pets and I like that more responsibility falls on the landlord.

The thing that people seem concerned about is in retirement age, and whether people can afford to keep renting, but surely there must be solutions?

Anyone else in a similar situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ladyofclass · 24/12/2021 23:27

I would recommend to buy, my parents always rented and now coming up to retirement and struggle I would say compared to people I know who are mortgage free. I plan to buy and not be having to struggle.

Newmumatlast · 22/06/2021 23:16

To be honest I do think too much emphasis is placed on buying however, if in the position to buy rather than rent, I would pretty much always choose to buy unless I had a secure local authority tenancy on low rent. My mortgage, even when I first bought my house when I was paying back the most interest, has never been more than renting the same property wouldve been. I have overpaid almost the entire time as I figured we should pay more so that if we ever had to rent or upsize it would be more achievable. By doing that and paying any bonuses/money saved from wage increases onto the mortgage my 30 year mortgage will be finished in about half the time. Now it is about a third per month (if I didnt overpay) what it would rent for. There is no way the cost of any improvements I have done have amounted to the difference between renting and paying the mortgage so I am not out of pocket in comparison plus the house has gone up in price by about 90k in 10 years. Even if it hadn't, I would still have equity in an asset to release on retirement or whenever. And if times got hard we could sell and release the equity and rent (if rents were low enough but tbh we would still need to live somewhere and cannot even rent a studio flat here cheaper than our mortgage for our house. I've looked).

To be fair though I have been looking at houses incase we need to upsize and someone buying now in my area would find prices much closer to renting.

Bythemillpond · 22/06/2021 21:37

Embracelife

£60 rent per month for 42 years is £30,240. The flats were about £7500 for a 2 bedder in about 1978. If he had bought 3 at the time he would have spent £22500. Which leaves nearly £8000 for interest payments etc

Does that make sense to you.

Plus he doesn’t even live in a 2 bed flat he lives in one room with a toilet and bathroom he has to cross the landing to get to.

SchrodingersImmigrant not everyone’s jobs survived the first lockdown and as most of our jobs were in the hospitality sector which was decimated, what people expect and the reality is something completely different.
Dh has applied to so many jobs and companies to find work at age 64 and the only time they invite him for an interview is when he doesn’t put his age and he cuts out some of his cv.
If he puts his real age then he just doesn’t get anything back. Even applied to the local job centre and didn’t even get a no thank you.
I haven’t worked as an employee for years (possibly due to having ADHD which I am now being tested for)
Dc and I applied for every supermarket job every fruit picking job that was in our neighbourhood and beyond and never heard a thing back.
Dd is the only one who has 4 years self employed tax returns and she doesn’t earn enough to be able to rent anything more than a one bed flat. Ds is too young to have enough tax returns

ChuckNoWorriesMyWay
I still have teenagers

As Thisnamewasnttaken123 says rents have climbed hugely this year. As I said we were looking at 4 bed detached at the beginning of the year and now are looking at 3 bed terraces for the same money.
Not that we even get to view any

ChuckNoWorriesMyWay · 22/06/2021 18:08

I wouldn't need a 4 bed house aged 60. My kids will be 43 and 30 years old by then.

I'm already 50 and in no position to buy even if I wanted to.

I know housing benefit pays the interest (after a substantial wait) but if I'm never able to work again, what is the point in that ?

Jellyfishnchips · 22/06/2021 18:01

There are pros and cons to both. I loved renting and the freedom/ flexibility it affords until I had a rotten landlord who failed to do any repairs and left us with no heating or hot water over winter, water leaks and unsafe gas appliances. Some agents were awful to deal with too and charged unnecessary fees annually for ‘admin’ for tenancy renewals and this cost went up year on year. I once worked with a family in who had been given notice to vacate 6 times over 2 years and we’re very distressed from having to move so many times and the upheaval of it ( no fault of their own, landlords just wanted property back for their own use or selling it, renovation works to re-market etc) I worked with so many people experiencing being made homeless through no fault of their own due to tenancies being terminated. So insecurity of tenure put me off renting long term ( and bad landlord / issues with agents) however get a good landlord who plans to rent out long term and it’s much better ( though plans can and do change, our nice long term landlords who lived abroad had to evict our lovely next door neighbours as they had to move back to UK due to health). would advise to consider insecurity risk as Assured Shorthold tenancies ( standard UK tenancies) after the initial 6 month period has expired landlord can serve 2 months notice to vacate at any time, without needing to cite a reason. Renting culture is better in Europe, much more widely accepted as secure long term housing as Assured (protected) tenancies are more the norm ( this is where a tenant can only be evicted on certain grounds , eg rent arrears or damage, so ‘good’ tenants are v secure). Rents are increasing generally but mortgages also cost ££. I agree with what others have said that it is your choice, but personally prefer owning and you gain an asset that increases in value and more security. Rents tend to keep going up but paying down a mortgage over time means monthly payments reduce over time. Also not having to deal with bad or unpredictable landlords, your home is your own and if something goes wrong yes it costs money but you can get it fixed without frustrating back and forths through an agent and the delays this often involves. The rental market is very competitive, especially for good properties and landlords can increase their rents whenever they want really (ours went up 3 times in 3 years).

Willowtree999 · 22/06/2021 17:57

I am renting following a relationship breakdown and have only just reached the point where I am able to save anything towards a deposit. However, I can't save huge amounts and with 2 DC buying somewhere big enough is a long way off. I think the only reason buying would be good would be the security of not having to move but once the kids are grown up I don't think I'll care about that.

I'm just making sure my pension is good and will just carry on renting if needs be, life's too short to worry about it. A million things could happen between now and then.

Ylvamoon · 22/06/2021 17:55

Our mortgage is paid off. We put about half of what we used to pay into savings.

... Financially we are a lot better of than if we didn't bother and just kept on renting. Our home belongs to us, nobody can force us to move or increase monthly payments.

Definitely something to think about.

Thisnamewasnttaken123 · 22/06/2021 17:53

Someone I know is trying to find a place to rent at the moment and there are so many people going for the same property, the rents are at least twice the price of any mortgage monthly and there are a real lack of any rented houses when they do come up they are extremely overpriced for the location and condition.

They can't find anywhere to live.
This person never wanted to own and have never even looked into it.
Some people live life for now and don't think too much about the future, unfortunately with property with the rate it's going up many people are being pushed out of areas because the increases in rents are just far too high.

hibbledibble · 22/06/2021 17:49

What about help to buy/shared ownership/social housing?

The problem with private renting is that you have no security,and can be moved on multiple times with minimal notice through no fault of your own. If you had a secure tenancy, or partial ownership, then you would have security.

Embracelife · 22/06/2021 17:48

@Bythemillpond

Embracelife

We need 4 bedrooms because we need 4 bedrooms. I can’t see adult children sharing especially when boy/girl friends stay over.

No I do mean £60 per month and this was since the 70s so 40+ years and these particular flats were less than £10,000 at the time. I know because I used to live in the neighbourhood at that time which was quite grotty.

So he paid 60 a month. How does 60 a month x xx years equate to three flats? 60 a month is 720 a year x 40 years is 28 k which is two or three flats but only if they still 10 k each...

Makes no sense.
Or do you mean if he got 10 k loan and paid 60 a month to pay it back?
Plus all the repairs and maintenance.
I don't understand the calculations at all sorry!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/06/2021 17:44

Tbh I would expect 4 adults in the house to be in ft employment, at least 2 of them, if I were renting property out, and the ft ones pass affordability.

I had issues when self employed so we had to pay in advance

Bythemillpond · 22/06/2021 17:41

Also I am not allowed to view because you have to get through the questions first and we always fail on the question about being in f/t employment.

Bythemillpond · 22/06/2021 17:38

Embracelife

We need 4 bedrooms because we need 4 bedrooms. I can’t see adult children sharing especially when boy/girl friends stay over.

No I do mean £60 per month and this was since the 70s so 40+ years and these particular flats were less than £10,000 at the time. I know because I used to live in the neighbourhood at that time which was quite grotty.

LateAtTate · 22/06/2021 17:36

@Bythemillpond

I'm also disabled. If I own a place and become too disabled to work no-one is going to pay my mortgage for me, but benefits would pay my rent

Actually you can get your interest payments made through Housing Benefits. Yes they pay this at the moment but I would be worried about things changing and the amount you can claim going down and rents staying the same or going up.

All of you who rent have you ever tried to rent a 4 bed house when you are in your 60s and don’t have a regular income?

Then you will realise it isn’t quite so flexible or easy.

Also has anyone looked at rent lately. We started looking earlier on the year and we thought for our budget we could get a 4 bed detached with a double garage.
Atm for our same budget we are now looking at 3 bed terraces and when we do enquire we are being turned down because we are too old.

Someone I know rented a room in a shared house for £60 per month in a very nice area of London.
He could have bought 3 flats (and he could have afforded 3 flats at the time) for the amount he has paid on rent even with stamp duty and mortgage interest added in.
And he continues to pay.

Your strange flat calculation aside (as mentioned by pp) you’re right - in popular areas of the country there are several people competing for desirable properties. You search on Rightmove and see lots, go to view and then never get called back ...
entropynow · 22/06/2021 17:34

@TheLastBeach

overall true, but there are still places where even over 10-15 years you don't make much back after sale costs and ownership costs. The average gains are heavily weighted by the South East/London bubble. And you never know if/when you will have to move.

Embracelife · 22/06/2021 17:30

Why do you need four bedxhouse ?

"Someone I know rented a room in a shared house for £60 per month in a very nice area of London.
He could have bought 3 flats (and he could have afforded 3 flats at the time) for the amount he has paid on rent even with stamp duty and mortgage interest added in.
And he continues to pay."

I guess you mean 600?

That's 7200 a year.

Not sure how you calculate 600 a month = three flats in London? even over 20 years that s 144 k paid out which won't buy you anything in London except a parking space. Where do you get three flats from??

Bythemillpond · 22/06/2021 17:19

I'm also disabled. If I own a place and become too disabled to work no-one is going to pay my mortgage for me, but benefits would pay my rent

Actually you can get your interest payments made through Housing Benefits. Yes they pay this at the moment but I would be worried about things changing and the amount you can claim going down and rents staying the same or going up.

All of you who rent have you ever tried to rent a 4 bed house when you are in your 60s and don’t have a regular income?

Then you will realise it isn’t quite so flexible or easy.

Also has anyone looked at rent lately. We started looking earlier on the year and we thought for our budget we could get a 4 bed detached with a double garage.
Atm for our same budget we are now looking at 3 bed terraces and when we do enquire we are being turned down because we are too old.

Someone I know rented a room in a shared house for £60 per month in a very nice area of London.
He could have bought 3 flats (and he could have afforded 3 flats at the time) for the amount he has paid on rent even with stamp duty and mortgage interest added in.
And he continues to pay.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 22/06/2021 15:42

[quote TheLastBeach]@Watchingyou2sleezes which lender? That is very interesting as it's very common in many other European countries to offer 20-30 years fixed so people know exactly what they'll pay until it is fully paid off. But I'd not heard of it here before on that scale. The longest that existed in the UK market when I last refinanced was a 10 year fix. It would be great if they are now matching the fixes to mortgage terms, it would make buying so much less risky for people.[/quote]
Habito

Sweetchocolatecandy · 22/06/2021 15:15

I live in one of the few places in the country where it’s cheaper to buy than rent (the NE), so it makes more sense to own a property. I think you’ve obviously had a positive experience of renting and your rent is very low but if you were living in a small, damp, shabby house with a rubbish landlord and paying extortionate rent then you’d probably think a lot differently and perhaps want more security. I know people from uni in these sort of situations who are desperate to buy.

FastFood · 22/06/2021 13:21

I've been a very happy tenant for years, but have decided to buy my first flat last year.
Beyond securing my living situation for retirement, a big motivation for me was to be able to decorate and "own" my space as I wanted.
I've been loving it so far, although I've made some serious tradeoffs, I live in London and went from zone 1 to zone 3, and overall, I need to be way more deliberate with my money, I can't be as carefree as I was before, I need an emergency fund for the flat, and in case I'm out of employement.
I live a very frugal life and can't even consider trying keeping up with the joneses, my flat is now my priority.
This said, I really love that, gives me purpose, but for me, home ownership goes beyond just having a mortgage, it requires a certain mindset shift that I wasn't ready for a few years ago.

I've been in my flat for 9 months and I'm starting to relax money-wise, I've been able to save loads since I moved in, so now I'm not scared anymore something may need urgent repair.
Next step will be overpaying the mortgage but I'm not there yet, I first want to really make that place exactly as I want.

SpaceRaiders · 22/06/2021 12:31

We choose to rent, we live in an area where houses rarely come up for sale and when they do they are 800k+. So I rent a lovely house on a country estate, I have a secure tenancy as the estate has been in the same ownership for about 400 years, the last tenant who lived in this house was here for 15 years, I expect we’ll continue renting for a good few years as dc don’t want to move. I do own other property, just not the one I live in.

The risk of long term renting is the financial it leaves you in retirement. Also if you have a family, it gives you the ability to leave assets to them. There all manner of pros and cons, as long as you’re aware of the risks of your choices, it’s really down to you.

RitaFires · 22/06/2021 12:30

Renting is a perfectly valid choice but your experience of renting is much more reliant on other people than if you buy.

The last landlord I had was fantastic, repairs done ASAP, always gave notice before visiting, gave us a card and bottle of wine before visiting, the apartment was beautiful and done to a higher standard than average for the area. But most of my other experiences were not so good, I lived in places that had just been painted when we viewed to hide the damp, places where the agency wrote the wrong date on our contract and then rang us to complain that rent was due on a completely different date, agents who let themselves in while we were asleep, a landlord who was trying to dodge tax by claiming we were only renting a room and living with them while they actually lived in another country, that one turned out to be damp as well. I never had the stress of the landlord selling the property and needing vacant possession but it has happened to friends of mine. I don't regret renting as I needed flexibility when I initially moved out and that last apartment was fantastic but I own now as I wanted more stability.

MsJinks · 22/06/2021 11:59

I have a cat - it’s not a car that makes renting difficult 🙈

MsJinks · 22/06/2021 11:58

My parents bought their home many moons ago, own it outright but my dad passed away and my mum needs massive care package- plus the house needs a lot of work some ideally some essential as it was too much for them to keep up in latter years. Owning the house makes no odds really in terms of costs now as she could have rented a more suitable place instead of paying a lot for adaptations and ultimately it will be sold to see her through care homes I expect. I’m trying to say that mortgage free retirement is not without its own costs and problems.
Personally I dislike owning in my 50s as it’s too much hassle and energy required and the only downside to renting, imo, is possibilities of having to move unexpectedly and all deposits etc plus I have a car. Unless I win the lottery I plan to sell and rent again when mortgage is paid off, as responsibilities of house upkeep as i age is very unappealing to me.
I will say my parents always adored their home and my mum is happy she can at least be there, even if she literally can’t leave the front room. I think sometimes it is about feelings rather than costs.
It is a shame rental is considered just a stop gap and not managed better and respected more.

LateAtTate · 22/06/2021 11:40

Also @ChuckNoWorriesMyWay I didn’t mean you - if people become too disabled to work etc then it’s perfectly fine.
Was referring to arrangements for the age where people who have bought a house have paid off a house, but those who still rent are continuing to rent. If rents have risen and incomes drop benefits cant be counted on to maintain the same standard of living.