Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Considering a 5 hours per day school run

263 replies

Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 15:18

My son has been offered a place at a lovely school which is around an hour away. It’s an independent SEN school and will suit him so much better than his current mainstream.
We are taking our council to a tribunal in the hope they will name the school on my sons EHCP and therefore pay the fees/taxi. The court date isn’t set until October. I have the option to pay for the school myself so he can start in September, I will have to drive him myself for a minimum of half a term or max 3 years if we lose our appeal.

Has anyone done a long school run like this? Was it manageable and did it get any easier? AIBU to even consider this journey is sustainable?

OP posts:
Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 16:11

@canigooutyet I am lucky to have a fantastic solicitor and my expert witness are all tribunal experienced.

@Nettleskeins currently if he does a full day at school he needs hours of recovery afterwards (which is why he’s on a reduced timetable), the new school would mean he’s more able to cope after school and at weekends meaning we would probably have more time for extra activities.

OP posts:
Backthewaywecame · 21/06/2021 16:11

My dc normally has a taxi to school but during lockdown, the school was open and pupils could attend if transported by a parent. It was probably 2 1/2 hours for me in the car (no rush hour traffic as other schools were closed) but I found it hard. I don’t think I would do it in your position.

danni0509 · 21/06/2021 16:10

@danni0509

Ds special school is 35 mins away, I did it for 2 weeks - had no choice, transport couldn’t start immediately (i wasn’t even coming home it was dropping him off, waiting in the town for the time he was at school then driving him back!)

Personally I wouldn’t commit to that, you would have no life... if I drove ds now I would be driving nearly 2 and a half hours a day.

That drove me mad ^^

Waiting about and it cost me a fair amount in fuel for the 2 weeks there and back, so there back there back would be a nightmare for me.

Think carefully OP. It’s a big commitment.

HopeForTheBestExpectTheWorst · 21/06/2021 16:07

So it might be well over an hour each way, depending on traffic etc?
What about family life? Do you have other kids or pets or relatives who would be impacted by this? How is your ds with early mornings? One of mine could get up and be ready to go, the other absolutely not.
There’s so much to think about.
Is there any way you could do a trial week?

LIZS · 21/06/2021 16:07

Unless you can plan to spend your days there rather than to and fro twice a day do not commit yourselves to this. It will be exhausting, costly and get you down unless things are going really well, which with SEN is not realistic 100% of the time.

danni0509 · 21/06/2021 16:07

Ds special school is 35 mins away, I did it for 2 weeks - had no choice, transport couldn’t start immediately (i wasn’t even coming home it was dropping him off, waiting in the town for the time he was at school then driving him back!)

Personally I wouldn’t commit to that, you would have no life... if I drove ds now I would be driving nearly 2 and a half hours a day.

Bryonyshcmyony · 21/06/2021 16:06

I did a 45 minute there and back twice a day and that was soul destroying after a while. Thank god I met a mum who lived near ish and we did one week on one week off.

Nettleskeins · 21/06/2021 16:04

The time you spend dealing with a school so far away is time you cannot spend supporting your son in many other ways, holistic extras, downtime, support with homework. And his friends will also be an hour or two hours away, have you considered that aspect???

NumberTheory · 21/06/2021 16:04

If it was the difference between a positive school experience and misery for my kids (and I was fortunate enough to be able to afford it etc.) I would certainly consider it. I had a 3 - 4 hr school commute for a couple of years (45+ mins each way plus waiting time and frequent traffic snarls). It was doable, I didn’t get to the stage where I was dreading the drive but it did mean I didn’t get nearly as much done in the day. If you have other kids as well I think it’s much less feasible.

I frequently planned my day to be out all day near my kids’ school which made things more enjoyable (my gym had a place there, I signed up for a class or two and there was a great library and nice lunch/coffee places - so could get pricey!) but chore wise mainly just covered household shopping.

.

CatherineMorland · 21/06/2021 16:04

I was doing 3 hours a day school run and found it unbearable. We have moved 15 mins away, and it has made such a positive difference to my life.

Ellie56 · 21/06/2021 16:04

Yes If I had the money to pay for the school I absolutely would do this.

With regard to the Tribunal have you asked for an expedited hearing?

And if your child is on a reduced timetable is the LA providing education some other way to ensure he gets F/T education?

Eddielzzard · 21/06/2021 16:04

My SEN child goes to a specialist school which is 1.5 hours on the school bus each way. It is so worth the awful journey. In your case since you're driving, it would depend on how you can cope with that much driving. If you can manage, do it, because the transformation of my DC in a much better suited school was way worth the horrible journey.

Nettleskeins · 21/06/2021 16:02

No
I would move to be nearer school for the next few years.
DS has SEN; his EHCP named a school on our doorstep and part of the reason was we wanted him to have the independence of getting himself to and from school. He absolutely thrived there (it was a comprehensive with good SEN dept) and his now at uni...a brilliant independent traveller, from that seed. A boy who needed driving to school when he was 13 due to his anxiety

People suggested a specialist school and taxi, I am so so glad we considered a different tack.

canigooutyet · 21/06/2021 15:59

Good luck with the tribunal. LEA's can be incredibly stubborn and dig their heels in. Hope you are getting some help with this

AlwaysLatte · 21/06/2021 15:57

I wouldn't! Going for parents eves etc would be a real pain, and they're so tired at the end of the day - my two would hate an hour journey, including the early starts!

canigooutyet · 21/06/2021 15:56

For those saying it's too long for the child.
If he was getting the council provided school bus daily he would be travelling a lot more. They get picked up anytime from 6:30 am to arrive at school on time depending on where else transport had to go. I would very occasionally do it if short staffed as the last pupil wouldn't get dropped off home until nearly 6. Long day.

As for the suggestion op gets a job nearby.
What about the school holidays? Finding childcare for someone with SN can be incredibly impossible. Never mind all the time off because of various medical appointments, avoidance and general health.

I would do it and ensure there's a back up in case anything happens to the car. Weather if it's really bad no doubt the school would be closed anyway and that's assuming the area is rural.

When I was working in a SN school, some of the TA's would also be a carer for a child outside of school so they would take them home. There was also times that TA's did the drop off and pick up as they lived local enough for it to work, even on ad hoc basis when the family were stuck and couldn't get in. And homework I cannot remember any being set tbh.

FindMeInTheSunshine · 21/06/2021 15:55

If it's a good school, I think I'd absolutely go for it. It's hard on you, but hopefully the council will come up with the taxi.

Ozanj · 21/06/2021 15:52

For a SEN pupil the right school can change their lives. I know SEN kids who went to uni and are in good jobs because they went to the right school. In your position I would probably try and hire a nanny to do this as it could work out cheaper (and on holidays they could support you with childcare). I know many nannies whose main job is to drive children to and from school and then make dinner and entertain them for a bit until parents come home, so def work approaching people

cupsofcoffee · 21/06/2021 15:52

@QueenBee52

So where does the 5 hours come from then ... Im confused 😩
OP says each journey could take over an hour if the traffic is bad.

Multiply that by four (there and back in the AM, and again in the PM) and that could easily add up to five hours per day in the car.

Oldpeoplesprinting · 21/06/2021 15:51

Lots to think about - do you work? Do you have other children who this would impact? If the answer is no & no, then yes I would do it. However you have to weigh up the cons (mostly your time, & the fuel cost) & see if they’re worth it.

For those saying find a gym nearby, it’s a long gym session..! It would be really annoying having to hang around killing time for 6 hours a day… Is moving closer a possibility? (Possibly not worth it for 3 years but depends if you liked the area/fancied a change anyway)

Hard one but on balance, if it’s not too disruptive to family life, I would do it.

Akire · 21/06/2021 15:51

It’s not straight hour door to door. If school starts at 9 you may have to leave 745 to give yourself 15min time just case for traffic or parking. So each leg would be between 1h and 1.15 so up to max of 5hours a day all in all “bum in car time”.

Clickbait · 21/06/2021 15:51

I'd do it (if you can fit it in with your work situation).

My DC get the bus to school in the nearest town, and it's still nearly an hour door-to-door (the school is only 20 mins away by car, but you need to include getting to/from the bus stop at each end, waiting time, bus slower than car).

So I think that's fine / normal for him. Although a pain in the arse for you obviously!

CommanderBurnham · 21/06/2021 15:51

It's one of those where you won't know until you do it.

Are you able to try it out somehow???

What is the plan if it doesn't work out?

cupsofcoffee · 21/06/2021 15:50

It's such a long time to spend driving though - if you don't get any help from the council, it's a huge, long-term commitment to make.

I assume you don't work and can afford all the fuel and wear and tear that all those miles will put on your vehicle?

QueenBee52 · 21/06/2021 15:50

So where does the 5 hours come from then ... Im confused 😩

Swipe left for the next trending thread