Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Considering a 5 hours per day school run

263 replies

Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 15:18

My son has been offered a place at a lovely school which is around an hour away. It’s an independent SEN school and will suit him so much better than his current mainstream.
We are taking our council to a tribunal in the hope they will name the school on my sons EHCP and therefore pay the fees/taxi. The court date isn’t set until October. I have the option to pay for the school myself so he can start in September, I will have to drive him myself for a minimum of half a term or max 3 years if we lose our appeal.

Has anyone done a long school run like this? Was it manageable and did it get any easier? AIBU to even consider this journey is sustainable?

OP posts:
Mamanyt · 21/06/2021 18:52

I lived in a very rural area when my boys were growing up. There was no possibility of private schooling, and the lower schools that served our area were a 2-hour school bus ride away, only an hour by car. I ferried my boys to and from school for 5 years to keep them from a 4-hour bus journey each day. It was not particularly fun, but I also didn't find it overly difficult. We spent the rides talking, playing word games and such, and the half-trip I spent alone was a glorious bit of privacy that I came to treasure.

At the end of that time, we moved to an area that offered them a very easy school bus trip, or even walking. I found that I missed those rides very much.

BearOfEasttown · 21/06/2021 18:51

@Cactusowl No way in HELL would I do this.

Zzelda · 21/06/2021 18:42

@singleagain22

It's totally not practical and you sound entitled expecting the council to foot the bill.
Not in the least entitled. It's what is required by law.
Zzelda · 21/06/2021 18:41

The LEA can say at tribunal oh you have withdrawn from state provision, are paying for private, and are transporting your child to school.....why do you need us involved as your child is no longer under LEA.
Rightly or wrongly they can (and prob will) say that. Use caution

No, they can't say that in the tribunal context. You may be thinking of the situation where parents withdraw their child from a mainstream school and choose to home educate or to pay for a private school placement, in which case, yes, they become responsible for arranging special educational provision.

However, LAs continue to be responsible for children in their area irrespective of whether they are in state or independent schools. Parents are perfectly free to argue that only the independent school can meet their child's needs and therefore should be named in the EHCP. It's an argument that's accepted frequently both by LAs and the tribunal.

danni0509 · 21/06/2021 18:41

@TableFlowerss

I’m confused? You say 5 hours per day school run, but the school is only 1 hour away? So that’s 2 hours, not 5?
There back, there back.
TableFlowerss · 21/06/2021 18:40

I’m confused? You say 5 hours per day school run, but the school is only 1 hour away? So that’s 2 hours, not 5?

YouLookSoCool · 21/06/2021 18:38

It's a long way but there are often posts on here about DC travelling an hour each way to private or grammar schools, especially in and around London. Seems as if you've exhausted other options and this school seems like a great fit for your DS. Absolute worst case scenario it's for 3 school years/9 terms so maybe you just have to decide if it's worth the sacrifice for that period of time.

singleagain22 · 21/06/2021 18:38

It's totally not practical and you sound entitled expecting the council to foot the bill.

itsgettingwierd · 21/06/2021 18:35

If you can and are willing I'd say do it.

I'd look though for things to do whilst there.

Perhaps even some volunteering, library one day, nice walks, leisure centre for gym or swimming etc.

Add into it opportunities for you too. (I have an autistic ds so I get it).
It's a big commitment and as long as you factor in your own MH I think it could work wonderfully for you both.

Zzelda · 21/06/2021 18:35

@ByeClare

Another thing to bear in mind is that there's currently a big backlog plus a huge demand for SEND tribunal appeal hearings, so a lot of hearings have had to be rescheduled, often with short notice.

This means there's a fairly good chance yours may be pushed back. This means that even if you end up winning, you may not have your hearing in October, then it's at least another two weeks or so for the decision to come out. So regardless of whether you ultimately win, you may end up having to do the journey for longer than to October anyway.

This isn't the case any more. Paradoxically, lockdown has helped in scheduling SEND tribunal cases because everything is done online and judges don't have to travel around the country. They haven't had to reschedule any hearings at short notice due to the tribunal being too busy since around April last year. They may adjourn for other reasons, notably the case not being ready for a hearing, but I would expect OP's solicitor to take steps to ensure that that won't happen.
hiredandsqueak · 21/06/2021 18:34

I do 45mins each way to get dd to independent specialist. Unfortunately when the traffic is heavy it's nearer an hour each way. LA pay mileage because dd really wouldn't be comfortable in a taxi and to me it's more important that she is in the right frame of mind when she gets there. I play audiobooks when dd isn't in the car so as it doesn't feel like the day is wasted tbh.

Zzelda · 21/06/2021 18:32

Most importantly, you don't have the school named on his EHCP yet or the LA agreeing to pay his travel. You'd have to have both of these decisions in your favour, and your LA is likely to argue strongly against both because of money.

It doesn't quite work like that. If the tribunal decides that this is the only suitable school, then the LA will have no choice but to arrange transport because its duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school. The LA will no doubt argue against this, but if OP can prove that the current school is unable to meet the child's needs then the very strong likelihood is that the school of her choice will be named.

CatkinToadflax · 21/06/2021 18:31

Two of my friends do a similar length journey and have been doing it for years. It’s incredibly hard work. Their DC both qualify for LA funded taxis but for specific reasons the parents drive their children themselves.

My DS goes in a taxi - he’s the first pick up in the morning and last drop off in the evening, so a journey that would take a very minimum of an hour straight from our house to school, with added pickups and traffic can take up to 1hr 45m. It’s a very long day. He has got used to it and he does his homework in school. Sticks his headphones in in the taxi and zones out. When he first joined the school he weekly boarded, to avoid the long journeys. This isn’t right for every child (and I’m sure many SEN schools don’t have boarding houses anyway) but it worked for him for a couple of years.

Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 18:31

@Zzelda there is a backlog for tribunal hearings, the date we got seems in line with others who entered paperwork at the same time - even those who have no school places for September. There is an option to request an August hearing but I would struggle to get all my witnesses available at the same time that month.

OP posts:
doubleshotespresso · 21/06/2021 18:31

Fellow SEN parent here. We have accepted a place for September that necessitates a journey which takes an hour and a half door to door, despite only being a couple of miles away (damned Khan and his LTN /Cycle lane nonsense). We have no choice but o accept as this is literally the only setting that can meet needs within the borough. It sucks as I am committing to basically spending all my daylight hours being stuck in the car.
However, the alternative is to continue home schooling as we have in excess of two years. It sucks it really does, but for the right place I am prepared to do the distance.

Blurp · 21/06/2021 18:29

Obviously you don't want to move, but is there any possibility that you could rent somewhere a bit closer for a couple of years and rent your own house out to cover the cost?

Or if you can afford it, get an Air BnB for at least a couple of nights each week, so you could drive to school, go to the Air BnB to work/relax, stay over there, and then drive home on the second evening? Obviously an expensive option, but if you found a good place you might be able to negotiate a long-term discount or something?

Twoforthree · 21/06/2021 18:25

Isn’t there a closer school?

Beautiful3 · 21/06/2021 18:22

No I wouldn't do this. My nephew attends a sens unit at a school 45 minutes away. However he has to share the taxi with two others, so it takes 1.5 hours to get there. He's always tired and hungry, as a result.

Zzelda · 21/06/2021 18:22

I think that’s way too far for a child and you if you are driving.

Technically it isn't too far for the child as he's at secondary level. Official government guidance says that the recommended maximum for children of this age is 1 hour 15 minutes each way.

Zzelda · 21/06/2021 18:19

@ThePlantsitter

I wouldn't start doing anything that you can't continue tbh. I'm my experience councils love saying 'well you're doing it now, surely you can continue'. I'm not an expert though.
They wouldn't have that option if OP wins the appeal.

OP, any chance of applying to bring the appeal hearing forward?

bonfireheart · 21/06/2021 18:19

OP, my nephew has SEN and EHCP and went to a mainstream secondary school which the council chose for him (over the independent school my sister wanted him to go to) the council then sorted out the transport for him (a free minibus with other SEN children). Might be worth finding out if your council does similar.

SeeSection · 21/06/2021 18:17

Maybe house swap during term time?

Dithercats · 21/06/2021 18:15

Yes don't assume he can just be added to the taxi run 10 mins away.....no other children could be added to my DC for example due to their needs - it's simply not that easy to assume your child can fit into the LEA arrangements EST in Sep 2021.

The LEA can say at tribunal oh you have withdrawn from state provision, are paying for private, and are transporting your child to school.....why do you need us involved as your child is no longer under LEA.
Rightly or wrongly they can (and prob will) say that. Use caution.
Like PP said they aren't seeing DS as a priority if the tribunal isn't till October....we all know term starts September after all.

Good luck. It's hideous that we fight so hard.

ByeClare · 21/06/2021 18:12

I should have said that if it were me, I wouldn't do it. I'd move if there were no nearer suitable provisions. That amount of travelling, particularly if having to share with others on a long round-the-houses-route would really not suit my child with SEN. Nor me, although that is a secondary concern, when you have a child with SEN, you really need all the energy and mental sharpness you can get.

cansu · 21/06/2021 18:11

Personally I would wait for the court date. If you don't win the case, you can then reassess and think about whether the drive is doable. I would also be wary of paying for the school yourself as that gives the signal to both the LA and the tribunal panel that you can and will fund yourself. I have been through three tribunals successfully and the key is proving that only this provision can meet need. If you can get them to accept this, you will get the taxi funded and the school. If they think it's a preference and that you can afford it yourself, then you won't get it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread