Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Considering a 5 hours per day school run

263 replies

Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 15:18

My son has been offered a place at a lovely school which is around an hour away. It’s an independent SEN school and will suit him so much better than his current mainstream.
We are taking our council to a tribunal in the hope they will name the school on my sons EHCP and therefore pay the fees/taxi. The court date isn’t set until October. I have the option to pay for the school myself so he can start in September, I will have to drive him myself for a minimum of half a term or max 3 years if we lose our appeal.

Has anyone done a long school run like this? Was it manageable and did it get any easier? AIBU to even consider this journey is sustainable?

OP posts:
BlackeyedSusan · 22/06/2021 08:48

It's exhausting. I did two schools so left at 7.50 and got home earliest 9.20 then evening worse as used free sports clubs/ library to enable the pick up so left at three back at 4.30 or left at 2.50 and back at 5.

A three hour a day school run was really hard.

Zzelda · 22/06/2021 08:17

@ByeClare, you claimed that the statement "If the tribunal decides that this is the only suitable school, then the LA will have no choice but to arrange transport because its duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school" wasn't "the full truth", but you were mistaken. It's a simple fact that local authorities have to provide transport to the nearest suitable school, and if the tribunal has decided that X independent school must be named in the EHCP then that is a finding that that is the nearest suitable school.

In talking about points made about the length of the journey, you are shifting the discussion to something I didn't contest. I was simply correcting some misconceptions put forward about the relevant legal duties and the tribunal. And what on earth makes you assume I don't have a child with SEN? You're mistaken.

If OP's child is entitled to transport but can't be added to the existing taxi route (including because he can't cope with sharing), then the LA will have to organise another taxi or means of transport. Again, transport can't be refused for that reason.

Cactusowl · 22/06/2021 07:57

@ByeClaire I’m very grateful to everyone who has posted. DS does indeed have ASD/ADHD and other needs too as do some of the other children at the school - the school is specific to another learning need. I’m not so worried about how DS will be in a taxi as I know he will just put his headphones to listen to his phone. There may be a chance that the children in the taxi clash meaning that they can’t travel together but I’m optimistic knowing DS and the general profile of the children that go to that school.

OP posts:
ByeClaire · 22/06/2021 00:37

[quote Zzelda]@ByeClare, I've helped with several appeals and have also attended conferences at which the lead Tribunal Judge has spoken. What I said about transport was absolutely correct. If a school can't meet needs, the tribunal is simply not going to name it no matter how expensive the alternative may be. Very, very occasionally they will decide not to name either the LA's or the parent's choice of school because they decide the parent's school is overprovision, but that is vanishingly rare. If the LA doesn't bother to tell the current school to up its game, that's all the better in terms of OP's chances.

As OP realistically acknowledges, nothing is guaranteed. However it is near-inevitable that if she loses in terms of the school place the EHCP will be improved. If that means the mainstream school becomes even more useless, she may indeed achieve what she wants when they give up.[/quote]
I wasn't denying that what you last said about transport was absolutely correct. I was quite clearly referring to an earlier comment you made that wasn't correct.

Yes the hearing will likely result in an improvement of some sort for the OP's DS, which is obviously A Good Thing. Did anyone suggest it wasn't? You - and the OP for that matter - seem to be taking the view as if I and others are arguing about the quality of the hearing, and ignoring all the useful points others and I made in response to the OP's actual questions about the journey. You may have helped with appeals and been to conferences, but unless you actually have a child with SEND and had to provide for their needs as well as actually fight for them, you may not be so hot on the actual ground-level practicalities. Neither the OP nor you have responded to comments that the OP's hope/plan/suggestion that her DS be added to the LA's current taxi route may not be feasible. She has not said how he may be affected by having other kids in the cabs or delays in traffic or going a particularly long route to drop others off. These are reasonable concerns when you have a child with ASD and ADHD, as I do and the OP does, so it's very useful for the OP that these are raised for her to consider, even if she chooses not to acknowledge them or thank those posters.

The LA may have a duty to provide transport, but the type of transport is dependent on needs and distance. It may be in the form in a taxi to himself that goes straight there and straight back, but it equally may not.

Zzelda · 22/06/2021 00:04

There is an organisation that helps with travel claims - is it SENDIASS?

I think it's called SENTAS.

Zzelda · 22/06/2021 00:03

@ByeClare, I've helped with several appeals and have also attended conferences at which the lead Tribunal Judge has spoken. What I said about transport was absolutely correct. If a school can't meet needs, the tribunal is simply not going to name it no matter how expensive the alternative may be. Very, very occasionally they will decide not to name either the LA's or the parent's choice of school because they decide the parent's school is overprovision, but that is vanishingly rare. If the LA doesn't bother to tell the current school to up its game, that's all the better in terms of OP's chances.

As OP realistically acknowledges, nothing is guaranteed. However it is near-inevitable that if she loses in terms of the school place the EHCP will be improved. If that means the mainstream school becomes even more useless, she may indeed achieve what she wants when they give up.

spongedog · 21/06/2021 22:44

Hi Op,

I have read your posts but not the whole thread so apologies if this has already been covered.

My DC is perhaps a similar age to yours. They moved schools last year to an independent school which, whilst not SEN specific, supports students with a range of SEN. The change in them is extraordinary. They like learning, mostly engaged, have a full curriculum including several GCSEs and most of all are happy. So a good school makes all the difference.

They moved from an independent specialist SEN school which failed them miserably but that is not the point of my post.

Children from Year 4 to 6th form traveled for hours to go to that school from several counties around. Most parents knew the school wasnt perfect but it was the best available. Approx 70% EHCPs - rest funded privately. I knew families who fought for funding for taxis, others used the school's minibuses, others boarded and one family I knew employed a nanny - her only job was to take the charge to school daily and collect - that was 5 hrs per day driving. I am not sure what other work she did back at home. My journey to take DC on a Monday and collect on a Friday was a round trip each time of 2 1/2 - 3 hours. When I returned to work some days I would drive over 120 miles for school run then to work and then back home again.

It is doable in the short-term - perhaps 1-2 years, providing you dont have other commitments. My employer actually wrote into my T&Cs that I would be late into the office every other Monday and then how the time would be made up. #stressful You mention 3 years maximum - I think that is OK. The travel time of 60-75 mins is OK for that age group - single trip. My DC used to fall asleep on the way home - they were so stressed and relieved to be out of the place.

There is an organisation that helps with travel claims - is it SENDIASS?

Hope it works out for you all.

TableFlowerss · 21/06/2021 21:40

There back, there back

I forgot about the drive back 😂

ByeClare · 21/06/2021 21:11

@Zzelda I hadn’t conflated two issues. I was pointing out that your statement about transport wasn’t fully correct, and then I went on to make a separate point. Of course it doesn’t just come down to the cheapest school, but it does come down to effective use of expenses.

I know how EHCPs and tribunals work, I won our appeal and my child is at an independent school. I can assure you that my LA have a reputation for not doing the sensible thing, even if it’s in their own best interests. So on that basis it wouldn’t surprise me if the OP’s LA hadn’t tried (hard enough) to get the current school to put existing provisions in place. The OP basically implied in a post that it was difficult to get the LA to do this.

It sounds like the OP’s son isn’t making sufficient progress at his current school, which is one of the reasons a tribunal would regard as necessitating a new school named. I sincerely hope she gets what her son needs. I think though that it would probably be unwise to move her son until the appeal has been and won, unless the OP is fully prepared to pay the fees and do the journey for however many years.

Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 21:03

@Zzelda, thank you for taking the time to post - you’re being really helpful.

We are appealing sections B and F as well as I. Even if the tribunal don’t agree to our specialist placement DS will at least have a very clear, specific and quantified EHCP (which will be too time consuming and expensive for mainstream to follow).

OP posts:
secular39 · 21/06/2021 20:50

Some posters on here don't understand that it is extremely, extremely difficult to find SEN school for children who have SEN. There's hardly any around as it is and the good ones a very few and far between. Society has low expectation of special needs and some state special needs school and a few private ones too have low expectation and children come out no worse than they were and very very low academic attainment.

FYI, you don't get those years back and a school can make the difference to a child. You would not like the journey but you will get used to it. The posters on here who are telling you to forget the school all together would not be holding your hand when your child is 16. Do what's best for you and your child. Also, if you move boroughs, you would run the risk of the new LA not paying for the school.

EversoDelighted · 21/06/2021 20:45

Mine goes to a specialist SEN school and many families do make this sort of commitment and find it worthwhile such is the benefit of going to the right school. Many get SEN transport from more than an hour away and cope too. It is so worth it for the right school. Parents evenings are likely to stay virtual now, in any case we've always had them straight after pickup time so no one has to come back in the evening as the school is fully aware of the distances for many families. Many families move to be near the school too. We are fortunate enough to already live fairly close but I would do that journey if I had to.

Zzelda · 21/06/2021 20:43

I know of at least two SENDist hearing that were rescheduled at short notice during lockdown

@ByeClare, that's not what the tribunal says. I suspect those hearings were rescheduled for reasons other than the tribunal being too busy, e.g. non-availability of witnesses, the cases not being ready for a hearing.

By October we should possibly be out of lockdown, which may mean that in-person hearings get postponed again.

The tribunal has made it clear that online hearings will still be the norm after lockdown unless there is a particular reason for wanting an in-person hearing. If OP's hearing has been listed as a remote hearing that won't be changed without a very good reason. They have done a lot of judge recruitment since the period before lockdown when late postponements were a particular problem, so the likelihood of a recurrence is pretty small.

If the tribunal decides that this is the only suitable school, then the LA will have no choice but to arrange transport because its duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school

This is not the full truth as an absolute statement. The child’s SEND and the distance are relevant; yes in this case they will have to provide it going by what the OP has said, but it’s not a sure fire bet for all. Part id the issue here is that the considerable cost of the transport will be a factor in whether it’s considered suitable, as it may cost an awful lot more than the school the LA considered suitable. Which presumably is his current one. Which again begs my earlier point, whether the LA has tried to get the school currently named in the EHCP to provide what they’re supposed to

You have conflated two different issues. The tribunal takes into account two things - cost, and whether the school is able to meet needs. If it were to decide that both the current school and OP's school can meet needs, then certainly OP is highly unlikely to win because a mainstream school will be cheaper even before you take transport into account. However, if they decide that the current school (or any alternative the LA might nominate) cannot meet needs, then it is very likely indeed to name OP's school. What the tribunal absolutely cannot do is to decide that a school which cannot meet needs must nevertheless be named because the alternative is expensive. Being cheap can't in itself make a school suitable.

We don't know whether the LA has tried to make the current school comply with the EHCP - I suspect they have, not least because they've got an appeal to deal with. They wouldn't have decided to ignore the issue knowing that it would destroy their case.

But equally we don't know whether the current EHCP is adequate and properly sets out the provision OP's child needs. Generally speaking, LAs draft EHCPs very badly and don't get adequate advice and information when assessing what is needed. If, for instance, OP's evidence demonstrates to the tribunal's satisfaction that her child needs specialist provision of a type which the current school cannot provide under any circumstances - e.g. smaller classes, specialist teachers, on-site therapies etc - then again the tribunal will not be able to name the current school.

Lovemusic33 · 21/06/2021 20:33

My dd travels out of our county to school, she goes by taxi and it takes a hour or longer some days as she shares a taxi with two others, she’s the first to be collected. I am looking at a 16+ placement for her which if further away but has the possibility or residential .

Luckily my dd loves being in the car so doesn’t mind the journey but I do find it hard to fit everything thing into the day as she leaves at 7.30am and gets home at 4.30-5pm (depending on traffic), evenings are a bit of a rush with cooking dinner, bathing, homework and then bed so there’s not much time for after school activities.

It is really hard to find the right school for a sn child so many have to travel a fair distance,

Tanith · 21/06/2021 20:30

I would think very carefully about that journey at all, and I certainly wouldn't recommend you do it yourself every day.

We cared for a boy with a similar journey attending an independent SEN school. It was on his statement so he had a council-paid taxi to take him to school and back.
At first, the taxi also had a chaperone, who was responsible for looking after the children so they didn't distract the driver. After a few years, they cut back and only the driver was employed. It was utter hell on earth! The poor driver resigned after a term. They soon switched back to using a driver and chaperone.

The journey was long enough anyway. Coupled with the traffic jams, accidents and rush hour traffic that made delays a regular occurrence, it became intolerable with the children kicking off in the car and really needing that chaperone to calm them down and distract them.
They were once stuck on the motorway for over 4 hours, hot, hungry and overtired. He was beside himself when he arrived at our house.
Eventually, he boarded weekly, and that was much better.

It's really tough to do a journey like this every day and I wouldn't do it alone.

DoubleTweenQueen · 21/06/2021 20:30

I have a three hour daily run. It’s fine. We go through nice countryside, we listen to music, we have a laugh, practice spellings. It’s fine for us. I don’t mind it. I do shopping on the way back which I would need to do anyway. Sometimes I take the dog and we go for a lovely walk somewhere along the route after drop-off.

5hrs though? But for a particular school you are certain will be beneficial for your son? That’s probably more important to you. Only you can decide if it’s worth the commute.

Backthewaywecame · 21/06/2021 20:23

Re the journey for the child, each child is different. I have two dc in separate special schools who have a taxi and they have always found it hard, especially if they have to travel with other children. We have also had times when they have refused to get in the taxi or it has not been deemed safe for them to travel and I have been called to collect them from school.

Cheesypea · 21/06/2021 20:21

If you can afford to pay the fees on an ongoing basis and can hack the commute then do it op. If not wait for the tribunal outcome.

Hawkins001 · 21/06/2021 20:09

Which is more important, a hours 4 hours a day traveling or a better school ?

undertheblue · 21/06/2021 20:08

It's interesting that people think it's too far / too long for a child to travel. I wonder how much people realise that education is so limited for SEN children and that there are very few if none door step opportunities for our children. We don't get the luxury of living in the community where our child goes to school.

My son travels by taxi for 50 mins each way. There are 5 year olds at his school that have to travel over an hour. Some primary age have to weekly board so they can access education as it's the only one of its type in the county.

Op, if I were you, I would self fund the taxi service that the LEA would probably pay after the tribunal. Start as you mean to go on.

BlankTimes · 21/06/2021 20:03

An hour journey an help a child with AN have some processing and downtime between leaving school and coming home. It worked well for us.

Living rurally, lots of parents of NT kids did the same type of journey time daily.

ElfDragon · 21/06/2021 20:03

I do slightly more than that, due to 2 dc out of county.

I’m in the car (on a good day) from 7.30-10.15am, and 2.30-5.5.15pm.

It is absolutely shattering, if I’m honest. I do a lot of miles too, given the locations of each school (about 170 miles a day). It is expensive fuel wise, and I need to service my car every 6 months instead of annually, due to mileage and wear and tear.

If I had any other choice, I wouldn’t do it, but both dds are at the school they need to be at for their respective needs (and both progressing well), so there is that consolation. I would say do consider very carefully what it will mean, both time wise and cost wise. It does have a big impact on everything.

Fieldsofstars · 21/06/2021 19:52

No don’t it, it’s not sustainable.
I used to do a slightly smaller journey in secondary and oh my goodness, the tiredness.

TheOtherTrees · 21/06/2021 19:52

It’s do-able I reckon and I’d consider it if I didn’t work I guess... a woman I know does similar - only 2-3 days a week she goes to a private health club near the school. Saves petrol cash and maximises her daytimes, she takes calls and does admin from the club lounge...

olivethegreat · 21/06/2021 19:52

It did exhaust dd though and affected her at school, probably had more impact on her than me

Swipe left for the next trending thread