Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Considering a 5 hours per day school run

263 replies

Cactusowl · 21/06/2021 15:18

My son has been offered a place at a lovely school which is around an hour away. It’s an independent SEN school and will suit him so much better than his current mainstream.
We are taking our council to a tribunal in the hope they will name the school on my sons EHCP and therefore pay the fees/taxi. The court date isn’t set until October. I have the option to pay for the school myself so he can start in September, I will have to drive him myself for a minimum of half a term or max 3 years if we lose our appeal.

Has anyone done a long school run like this? Was it manageable and did it get any easier? AIBU to even consider this journey is sustainable?

OP posts:
Polkadots2021 · 26/06/2021 17:19

OP I don't blame you for considering this but I think you and your son would be extremely miserable very quickly. Could you move?

Polkadots2021 · 26/06/2021 17:18

We do a half hour commute to school and half hour back, twice a day. My husband does the morning and me the afternoons, and even then it's a shag & we are looking forward to the holidays! There's little traffic and it's actually a very scenic drive and it's still tiresome sometimes. You have to also realistically add 20 mins for waiting for your kiddo, faffing around, parking and what have you.

Sockwomble · 26/06/2021 17:04

We have done this quite a few times over the last couple of years because the school transport is unreliable and it has either been take him ourselves or him miss school. It is an absolute killer.

ByeClare · 26/06/2021 16:55

I'll put it another way for you @Zzelda to ensure you understand my point, because I think it's important for people reading to know the correct information.

You said that with regard to the the LA providing the OP's child with transport to "this" school, "the child is unquestionably eligible". Agreed, that's correct. But the LA's duty is determined by this school being the nearest suitable one AND suitably far from the OP"s home as to require LA provided transport. The duty is NOT just determined by the first part, i.e. a school being the nearest suitable one.

What you wrote:
If the tribunal decides that this is the only suitable school, then the LA will have no choice but to arrange transport because its duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school.

What you should have written:
If the tribunal decides that this is the only suitable school, then the LA will have no choice but to arrange transport because its duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school if that school is X distance away or the child's SEND means they can't walk or get public transport to school.

Calvinlookingforhobbes · 26/06/2021 16:47

YABVU to think your son should do this. Couldn’t you move?

Majorfluff · 26/06/2021 16:46

You won't have time for house chores if you spend those hours travelling.

ByeClare · 26/06/2021 16:37

@Zeelda, I can see why think I cherry-picked what you wrote but even with it your statement isn't correct. The part I "cherry picked" stands alone, and even if you don't think it did, it's not affected by the 'this'. The LA does not have a duty to provide transport to the nearest suitable school ... unless the child is eligible. It would therefore only have a duty to provide transport to this school because it is over X metres away or because the OP's child's SN means they can't take public transport (which the OP hasn't told us, but is probably irrelevant in this scenario due to distance). At the very best, your statement was unclear and could reasonably be read to mean that the LA has this duty unconditionally, when that is not the case.

I didn't assume you don't have a SN child, I thought it likely you may not, I was 50/50 actually.

When I wrote about the 75 minute maximum, I was correcting someone who said it was an hour, and I specifically used the word "technically"

Untrue. You corrected someone who wrote: "I think that’s way too far for a child and you if you are driving." That poster didn't mention the journey being an hour. However yes, they were going by the OP saying it was an hour each way but that's irrelevant. The OP asked whether that length of school run was sustainable, she didn't specify that she meant for her specifically and not for her child. She asked people if she was BU to "even consider that this journey is sustainable". The poster you quoted was responding to the OP's question with their opinion. It's not your right to "correct" that. The poster could be well aware about the 75 min govt maximum; in fact the poster probably is, as you'll see from their post that their own child is at a special school and other children travel in from far away.

Zzelda · 24/06/2021 09:03

I was contesting your very early on statement that "because its [the LA's] duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school"; I think it's important for clarity to add the qualifier "if eligible"

You cherry-picked only part of what I wrote, @ByeClare, which was " If the tribunal decides that this is the only suitable school, then the LA will have no choice but to arrange transport because its duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school." The important word is "this" - i.e. the one OP wants, for which the child is unquestionably eligible.

You made incorrect assumptions about whether I had had to deal with the practicalities involved with an SEN child, and seem to be perpetuating that. When I wrote about the 75 minute maximum, I was correcting someone who said it was an hour, and I specifically used the word "technically"; life is really too short to write an essay on all the exceptions and ifs and buts when offering information on this site. If OP's child were unable to cope with a 75 minute journey I'm sure she could work that out for herself without needing us to tell her, and she's happy that her child is OK with that.

Diamondnights · 23/06/2021 12:52

It's utterly doable OP (as your dc is fine in a car/ taxi). Won't be much fun for you maybe but hopefully your dc will absolutely flourish and then it will certainly have been worth it.

ByeClare · 22/06/2021 19:55

The practicalities of what that length of journey is like for both the child and mother is relevant because that is what the OP is asking. She's not asking whether it's allowed by law. She's asking whether she's BU to consider the journey sustainable. Therefore people's opinions, feelings and experiences of that are relevant, regardless of what the tribunal may order.

ByeClare · 22/06/2021 19:52

@Zzelda I was contesting your very early on statement that "because its [the LA's] duty is to provide transport to the nearest suitable school"; I think it's important for clarity to add the qualifier "if eligible", even if taken in context with what the OP had written it may have been obvious. Because the duty is contingent on a child's eligibility. I've seen a certain SEN charity get this wrong on by missing out the eligibility qualifier (as I'm calling it here) and saying if a school is named on an EHCP then an LA has to provide transport there.

You said "unless you actually have a child with SEND and had to provide for their needs as well as actually fight for them, you may not be so hot on the actual ground-level practicalities." I've had to do all of that. What was the point of posting it if you accepted that I might have a child with SEND?

Because I got the impression you may not have had to deal with the practicalities I was talking about. I can accept that you may have a child with SEND and still think that you may not have had to organise these practicalities for your SEND child, as not all SEND children require LA-provided transport. It's not all black and white.

Your comments are very much about the technicalities, and not the practice. e.g. technically yes, the government may say that a child can travel up to 1hr 15 mins, but that doesn't mean that in practice that length of journey would not be viable for some children with SEND, or their parents who also have to do the return legs.

zingally · 22/06/2021 19:12

I'd say it depends on the child as much as you. 2 hours in the car a day is a LOT, especially for a kid with additional needs. But that is 4+ hours a day driving for you. You'll be dead on your feet within a week.

Skysblue · 22/06/2021 18:13

As I read it, the commute for your child would be one hour there and one hour back? If so AND you can find somewhere there to work or do what you do then yanbu.

Five hours daily drive commute doesn’t work. It would wear you out and is unsustainable. If this school matters that much - and you know your child - then I’d probably move house or find something near the school (or at the school?!) to do while child is at school.

Sorry you’re in this situation 😔

Zzelda · 22/06/2021 18:10

Children must have non-stressful transport to school and journey times of more than about an hour are usually considered to be too long

Official government guidance is that, for a child of secondary school age, 75 minutes each way is generally the maximum. However, it recognises that there are circumstances where it may be necessary to go above that, notably because there may not be a suitable school any closer.

Zzelda · 22/06/2021 18:06

But taking your example of a situation where the OP's child can't cope with sharing - It would be very rare for that to be written into the EHCP. For a start, it would need to be known. More likely, should this be the case, it won't be found out until the OP's child is in a taxi with others and then it's discovered that sharing is not suitable. The OP would then have to go to the time and effort of demonstrating that and getting the LA to arrange a solo taxi, rather than instead provide money for mileage and making her drive him. Not insurmountable, and obviously not something to put the OP off the whole process, but hugely draining and often difficult when you're in that situation.

It may or may not be known: it depends on the evidence - often for a child with an EHCP that sort of difficulty has become clear in school or through something like an occupational therapy assessment. Sure, the parent would need to get the evidence if it did not already exist. But again the fact that it might be difficult to get an LA to comply with its legal duty doesn't change that duty.

One thing is clear, it is not open to any LA to refuse to arrange transport and insist that the parent drives their child, even on the basis that they pay mileage. It has no power whatsoever to do so. It may be that in practical terms OP would have to do that whilst gathering the evidence, but that's a different point.

lardylegs123 · 22/06/2021 17:58

Is moving home out of the question?
Sadly I don't think you can have it all ways Sad

Zzelda · 22/06/2021 17:57

The point I was making @Zzelda is that the blanket statement you made about an LA having to provide home to school transport to a child with an EHCP is not correct

If I had said that it would indeed be incorrect, @ByeClare. However, I didn't. I said the LA would have to provide transport if the tribunal decided that OP's choice was the only suitable school. Given the distance of the school from OP's home, none of the scenarios you refer to apply.

I didn't assume you don't have a child with SEN, I wondered if you have had to navigate the tribunal and directly navigate with the LA about transport regarding your own child.

You said "unless you actually have a child with SEND and had to provide for their needs as well as actually fight for them, you may not be so hot on the actual ground-level practicalities." I've had to do all of that. What was the point of posting it if you accepted that I might have a child with SEND?

You seem to think that because the law states X, then that will happen immediately and simply

Where did I say that? I said that the LA would have no choice but to provide transport if the school was named as the only suitable school, which is correct. Of course no-one can guarantee that the LA won't try to evade the law, but ultimately it can be forced to comply relatively easily. Transport doesn't go into the EHCP unless it's educational provision, but it is a statutory duty imposed on the LA.

spongedog · 22/06/2021 17:18

"@independentfriend

The journey isn't sustainable. It's a barely acceptable travel time for your child - 1h15 mins each way. Children must have non-stressful transport to school and journey times of more than about an hour are usually considered to be too long."

It really isnt considered too long for a secondary school special needs placement. My DC were placed at their prior school through a private court order and we argued the journey time as a con vs moving to a location closer to a different school. The judge wouldnt hear that evidence with any serious consideration. People are always quoting the "guidance " on travel times - it is meaningless.

independentfriend · 22/06/2021 12:19

The journey isn't sustainable.

It's a barely acceptable travel time for your child - 1h15 mins each way. Children must have non-stressful transport to school and journey times of more than about an hour are usually considered to be too long. Can the journey reliably be done in that time or are there days when it takes much longer? If it can't be, you're better off thinking about moving closer to the school (not without its complications if you're moving to a different LA area) / considering a residential placement there if available / looking at similar schools closer to home (if any exist).

It's generally a bad idea to enable a child to start at your preferred school prior to a Tribunal hearing - it can give the impression to the Tribunal that you can afford the placement (when often that's really not the case) and in these times of austerity/LAs having limited funds, can set them against your case. That wouldn't be said openly and would never appear in a decision, but it's worth bearing in mind. From the perspective of success in the case, it's better your child attends either his current school or is at home until after the case has been decided.

ByeClare · 22/06/2021 11:57

The point I was making @Zzelda is that the blanket statement you made about an LA having to provide home to school transport to a child with an EHCP is not correct - it depends on eligibility. It depends on the individual needs of the child and it also depends on distance. Many children with EHCPs don't receive assistance with transport. Some children with EHCPs will walk to school if their school is near enough. Some are able to take the bus or other forms of public transport, and the LA may provide them with a bus pass but will not have a duty to provide taxi services or pay for mileage. It depends on the LA's policy.

With children with ASD and ADHD for example, there's a huge range. My child with both is able to take public transport and wants to, so does. There was a time when for time-specific reasons they were unable, and then I was given money to pay for a cab.

I didn't assume you don't have a child with SEN, I wondered if you have had to navigate the tribunal and directly navigate with the LA about transport regarding your own child. You seem to think that because the law states X, then that will happen immediately and simply. In practice, this is not the case; transport issues are much more complicated than that. As you no doubt know, transport provisions rarely get added into an EHCP. So it's something that the parent then has to arrange with the LA directly.

Case in point about issues in practice:

If OP's child is entitled to transport but can't be added to the existing taxi route (including because he can't cope with sharing), then the LA will have to organise another taxi or means of transport. Again, transport can't be refused for that reason.

No transport can't be refused for that reason. But taking your example of a situation where the OP's child can't cope with sharing -
It would be very rare for that to be written into the EHCP. For a start, it would need to be known. More likely, should this be the case, it won't be found out until the OP's child is in a taxi with others and then it's discovered that sharing is not suitable. The OP would then have to go to the time and effort of demonstrating that and getting the LA to arrange a solo taxi, rather than instead provide money for mileage and making her drive him. Not insurmountable, and obviously not something to put the OP off the whole process, but hugely draining and often difficult when you're in that situation.

ArianaDumbledore · 22/06/2021 10:15

In my LA If there's an existing route the pupil can go on you would be offered a much lower mileage allowance, I think 11p.

There isn't an existing one for my son and the LA wanted to pay me mileage, but I couldn't do it.

My LA named a mainstream (not our nearest) but tribunal concluded they couldn't meet needs despite them saying they could. The evidence I got from a SAR to his old school was very significant

danni0509 · 22/06/2021 09:30

My ds has autism / adhd & has to have a separate taxi with escort despite the same taxi company doing several other children to the same school all with same diagnosis’s, the driver on the first day couldn’t understand why ds was on his own and not sharing another taxi until he dropped him off at the end of that first day Grin

Dithercats · 22/06/2021 09:21

[quote Cactusowl]@ByeClaire I’m very grateful to everyone who has posted. DS does indeed have ASD/ADHD and other needs too as do some of the other children at the school - the school is specific to another learning need. I’m not so worried about how DS will be in a taxi as I know he will just put his headphones to listen to his phone. There may be a chance that the children in the taxi clash meaning that they can’t travel together but I’m optimistic knowing DS and the general profile of the children that go to that school.[/quote]
My DC has similar needs. Their statement specifically states they are not to travel with another pupil.
You simply cannot assume.
That said, the LEA must provide you transport if that is your DS named school, so that isn't a worry really. Though if you establish from day 1 you can drive him they may push you to continue with a milage allowance - which with other children in other schools I would not accept for obvious reasons.

blissfulllife · 22/06/2021 08:57

[quote Cactusowl]@ByeClaire I’m very grateful to everyone who has posted. DS does indeed have ASD/ADHD and other needs too as do some of the other children at the school - the school is specific to another learning need. I’m not so worried about how DS will be in a taxi as I know he will just put his headphones to listen to his phone. There may be a chance that the children in the taxi clash meaning that they can’t travel together but I’m optimistic knowing DS and the general profile of the children that go to that school.[/quote]
My girl is ASD. Gets in a taxi with 2 other children from her SEN school. They enjoy the ride and support each other if ones having a tough morning/afternoon. It's nice to see her with other children who just get it x

BlackeyedSusan · 22/06/2021 08:53

Though the actual route would factor in. Mine was town centre traffic, lots of roundabouts and slip roads and traffic lights and scissor junctions, congested secondary school traffic in narrow double parked streets for part of it with lots of idiot drivers. The bit out towards the primary school was less bad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread