Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I miss the old R4 Woman's Hour. I don't tune in anymore.

185 replies

flashbac · 20/06/2021 22:57

I don't/can't listen to Woman's Hour anymore. It's lost its magic. I miss having it in the background and listening to interesting points of discussion. Now I find it gets on my nerves. It's crap.

OP posts:
skinnyarms · 21/06/2021 07:21

Agree.
I don't think Emma Barnett is a good fit for the position, she doesn't seem natural and free flowing enough.

RickiTarr · 21/06/2021 07:08

@Anycrispsleft

I liked the old programme. I liked listening to women who are older than me. I appreciated their wisdom and insight. Where the hell else can you hear the perspective of older women?
You could talk to some? Smile
Thedogshow · 21/06/2021 07:05

Sorry autocorrect! Not a middle aged woman that should have said!

Thedogshow · 21/06/2021 07:05

I agree. Not a Middle Ages woman, in my 30s, but I find it so aggressive now & really hard to listen to. It used to be calming and interesting. Now it’s just stressful.

Anycrispsleft · 21/06/2021 07:01

I liked the old programme. I liked listening to women who are older than me. I appreciated their wisdom and insight. Where the hell else can you hear the perspective of older women?

PrettyPetalPinkPeony · 21/06/2021 05:49

I found that manchester evening news article interesting, followed by a ridiculous Daily mail self written, self serving piece, followed by brokenbottleboy.substack.com/p/the-sins-of-the-father-the-emails, with just one google search.

TheoMeo · 21/06/2021 05:20

I stopped listening years ago - so many awful stories of trafficking, rapes - just worldwide cruelty to women. Made me angry , v depressing.

garlictwist · 21/06/2021 04:13

IVe also stopped listening. I loved Jane. Couldn't stand Jenni though so never listened on her days. It's a shame as I was quite pleased when they announced Emma would be taking over as I normally like her. But she doesn't bring the same tone as Jane.

BikeRunSki · 21/06/2021 03:32

@chipshopElvis, I’ve been waiting for that top since January!

@sandgrown, I’ve bee listening since my late teens!

NightoftheLivingBread · 21/06/2021 01:48

@YukoandHiro

Agree. And they keep interviewing sodding men on it now. Men are the primary interviewees on every other bloody hour of R4
Oh god, is it supposed to be a hot new take on woman’s hour or something... like when some moronic magazine made Bono woman of the year (woaahh man such fresh vision)
LostInTheColonies · 21/06/2021 01:39

Another vote here for Fortunately! The first part is like sitting in the kitchen with a couple of mates over a bottle of wine, putting the world to rights. Then a great interview.
Also don't like Emma Barnett... but am currently at the other end of the world where radio is pretty pants so I do still listen, gritting my teeth.

YukoandHiro · 21/06/2021 01:31

Agree. And they keep interviewing sodding men on it now. Men are the primary interviewees on every other bloody hour of R4

GetOffThatPhone · 21/06/2021 01:30

I can't take to Emma either, I always think of this when she's on:
www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/school-aide-laundered-brothel-cash-946427

FrankButchersDickieBow · 21/06/2021 01:30

Its not woman's hour anymore.

That's the top and bottom of it

NightoftheLivingBread · 21/06/2021 01:26

Oh no, Jane Garvey’s left as well!? 😭

FlowerArranger · 21/06/2021 01:19

Loved Jane Garvey.
Admired Jenni Murray, though she got on my tits at times.
I switched off shortly after Emma Barnett's horrible interrogation of Zara Mohammed.
Not going back any time soon, though I miss the programme it used to be..

VladmirsPoutine · 21/06/2021 01:06

Emma Barnett is one of the worst 'faces' of feminism they could have found. Honestly just terrible.

AnotherSunrise · 21/06/2021 01:00

Agree... don't like the new presenter

PineappleCakes · 21/06/2021 00:38

Been listening to WH for almost 30 years, but actively avoiding it now. Hate the double loss of brilliant Jenni & Jane, and I don't like how they have approached issues recently - definitely NotWoman's Hour nowadays.

Golightly133 · 21/06/2021 00:26

I hardly listen now Emma is too shouty

chipshopElvis · 21/06/2021 00:14

I remember when Jane Garvey started on Women's hour and I couldn't stand her. Now I could listen to her all day and think she's wonderful. I think Emma's interviews are a bit pants but I'm hoping she will grow on me with time too.

Lovethewater · 21/06/2021 00:12

Thought it was just me. Was a regular listener for over two decades but now I occasionally listen when it's Anita Rani but avoid the rest of the week.

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 21/06/2021 00:09

I find Emma just seems so abrasive and difficult like she is trying to catch people out. Rather than having a good deep discussion. It’s a very poor style.

And it may just be bad luck but several times recently I’ve turned on and it’s been male interviewee after male interviewee. No different to anything else. I never used to turn it off but now I do.

WinterTrees · 21/06/2021 00:07

Yep - either stressfully abrasive when it's an Emma Barnett day, or stressfully saccharine when it's Anita Rani. Either way, it raises my blood pressure.

They also seem to read out listener tweets and emails far more than they used to in the Jane/Jenni days (possibly to fill time now it's an hour long) and often seem to choose blokey bloke messages. I don't want to hear Barry in Croydon's twist on 'well, you girls wanted equality' on Woman's Hour, thank you.

WhereYouLeftIt · 21/06/2021 00:04

I'd thought Emma was OK on Newsnight, but on radio she comes across as totally disinterested. Her tone of voice is often impatient and dismissive and there's not much warmth. It surprised me. Anita, again, I'd liked on Countryfile but find rather simpering when interviewing. Then she got huffy with, presumably, the WH listeners with this tweet -

twitter.com/itsanitarani/status/1398221484779347968
"I’m disgusted by the levels of transphobia on here. @BBCWomansHour is a space to discuss everything including LGBTQ+ issues. Listening to people’s stories helps us understand something and hopefully empathise. Ditch the hate [rainbow emoji]"

She got lots of responses along the lines of 'well call it everything hour then'.

I will give Fortunately a whirl.

Swipe left for the next trending thread