Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I miss the old R4 Woman's Hour. I don't tune in anymore.

185 replies

flashbac · 20/06/2021 22:57

I don't/can't listen to Woman's Hour anymore. It's lost its magic. I miss having it in the background and listening to interesting points of discussion. Now I find it gets on my nerves. It's crap.

OP posts:
Roonerspismed · 21/06/2021 09:15

TBH it reflects my thoughts generally about the BBC.

I was the biggest fan - Radio 2/4, the news and I have binned the lot. I no longer trust the BBC to show impartiality

Howzaboutye · 21/06/2021 09:08

The original presenters didn't talk about sex/gender etc because they were not allowed to by the BBC. Not because they were not interested.
BBC has a scary agenda

WinterTrees · 21/06/2021 09:01

Very much in agreement with Ilovelove and Glencora. I used to really like the gentle pace and wide range of women-centred topics, from craft and cooking to health and body issues and women's history. They were woeful in turning a blind eye to the sex self-id elephant and how it would affect women, but otherwise did good coverage of women in politics and things like the pensions scandal. I can remember a piece they did where they just stopped women out shopping in various towns for a chat, and a wonderful older woman talked about losing her husband and picking up the threads afterwards, and it was so gentle and genuine and moving.

Now it seems like they're trying too hard to be relevant, flogging the news angle, desperately looking for a hot take or a gotcha from Emma, while Anita is smiling manically and doing the One Show/This Morning-style forced attempt to sound as if we're all best mates. 'Now I'm sure we're all looking forward to a barbecue in the garden this weekend...!' sort of thing. If Jane had been given that script she would have delivered it wryly and added something self-deprecating on the end, which would mean I didn't mutter 'oh do fuck off' at the radio, while buttering my toast.

hellosally · 21/06/2021 08:51

totally agree. I find Anita Rani totally bland(even worse on countryfile) and the first time I heard Emma Barnett was with Sinead o'Connor......no empathy or skill whatsoever.I always used to listen when driving and will not tune in any more

Bringmemoonshine · 21/06/2021 08:49

Me too. I tried, but Emma Barnett seems cold and lacking in empathy and seems to prefer the sound of her own voice to that of her interviewees. I miss the warmth, wisdom and honesty of Jane and Jenny. I used to plan my morning around Woman’s Hour and if I had to miss it would listen later. Now I might catch a bit if I’m driving or busy in the kitchen but actually don’t feel comfortable with it anymore. I just can’t be bothered with Emma’s approach which manages simultaneously to be confrontational and disinterested.

AesopsMables · 21/06/2021 08:40

I agree. It's not the same and now I have unsubscribed.
I miss Jane and Jenny. plus the content is no longer interesting.

Let's hope the production read this thread and take action.

reprehensibleme · 21/06/2021 08:38

I don't 'listen' any more - R4 is on in the background most of the day, but I used to actively listen to WH. I find Emma Barnett scathing and Anita Rani a bit damp. I loved Jenni Murray - her interview style was so far removed from Emma Barnett's somewhat hectoring style - I think often, young female interviewers seem to think they need to harry and bully their interviewees i.e. 'be more like a man' Hmm.

I've been listening to WH since I was a teenager - I think most people have either listened all their lives or come to it a bit later in life. I do get a bit miffed with all the talk of trying to attract a younger audience - you never hear about R1's efforts to appeal to an older audience.....

There was a segment on R4's Feedback programme a few months ago - there is a segment where people listen to a programme outside their normal comfort zone. There were a couple of students studying politics who never listened to 'Today' and had never heard of the 08.10 'big interview', which left me slightly gobsmacked - so I suppose from that perspective attracting a younger audience is no bad thing, but they do need to be careful that they don't alienate their core audience at the same time.

toffeebutterpopcorn · 21/06/2021 08:36

Occasionally I wander in - but more often than not I end up ‘bah - not listening to this mince!’

GlencoraP · 21/06/2021 08:35

What I miss is the lack of reflection. The old WH was like a magazine . The articles were longer and more in depth, the interviewees were often more relaxed because they weren’t looking every moment for the ‘gotcha’ .

I have never got the EB worship, she seems to me to be constantly looking for the headline, you always get the sense that she isn’t listening to the interviewee she is just thinking about her own next line. This was also the case on 5live but is much more evident in the slower pace of WH where you can almost hear her brain looking for her next line and ignoring her guests replies.

LakieLady · 21/06/2021 08:29

I can't bear Emma Barnett on Newsnight and was gutted when they gave her WH. I only listen on Fridays now, and I like Anita Rani but she can't hold a candle to Jane Garvey.

I can't believe they couldn't find anyone better.

Ilovelove · 21/06/2021 08:17

Agree

I found Jenny and Jane - wise, truthful, safe, searching, professional journalists who were themselves and representative of an intelligent, thoughtful, curious, edgy woman.
The guests and topics were always interesting.

I used to listen every day I was able to and now I do not bother/switch over to another channel.

Missed the mark with this current set up in my opinion.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/06/2021 08:13

I was thinking the other day it had improved a bit - buy reading through, I realised I really only hear it on Fridays when it's Anita Rani.

MayIDestroyYou · 21/06/2021 08:13

I like radio drama - but I have hated the R4 move to a snippet of this and a bit of that. All these little 15 minute 'programmes' are utterly useless. So frustratingly superficial and difficult to keep track of. They're very clearly just throwing anything they can find at our ears, in the hope that something will appeal to their ideal teen listener. HmmHmmHmm

I'm an adult, I want serious in depth attention paid to whatever subject they're covering.

Iwantacampervan · 21/06/2021 08:01

I miss the drama - I didn't always listen to all of them but many were excellent.

BikeRunSki · 21/06/2021 08:00

Tbh I credit R4 with at least half my education, over a lifetime Totally! At least as much as the late departed Inner London Education Authority.

CroydianSlip · 21/06/2021 07:53

I don't really 'do' Twitter, but am really shocked by that AR one? And some of the comments too...

To know that the presenters of WH have no understanding or empathy for their listeners, and no interest in finding out what their core audience feel is just so so arrogant and rude. When else would it be OK for a presenter of a programme to behave like that with impunity?

I'm really shocked, but it all makes a lot of sense now. Quite cathartic deleting any downloaded episodes from my Sounds app and making sure I've unsubscribed properly.

borntobequiet · 21/06/2021 07:52

It’s been awful for ages, either covering completely trite topics or attempting difficult ones but eroding the listeners’ ability to draw meaningful conclusions by going for “balance”. I stopped listening years ago.

MayIDestroyYou · 21/06/2021 07:47

@sandgrown

I am in my sixties and was waiting to be old enough to start listening to Radio 4 and Women’s Hour. I guess I have missed the boat !
Grin I was listening in the womb! And spent my earliest childhood Listen[ing] With Mother. Listened to The Archers at home, at boarding school, at university ... HmmBlush Woman's Hour always seemed unavoidable.

Tbh I credit R4 with at least half my education, over a lifetime.

BirdsandBeesmakinghay · 21/06/2021 07:46

I agree. Women in their twenties don’t listen to R4 in general so I think they’re missing their demo graphic and losing listeners fast.
I can’t stand Lauren Laverne on Desert Island Discs either.

GU24Mum · 21/06/2021 07:45

Another one who switches it on rarely now. I used to catch up with the podcasts too but don't bother any more. Different is fine (though sad that Team J&J both left more or less the same time) but Emma Barnett just isn't the right person.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/06/2021 07:42

I occasionally listen to the Anita Rani version but can’t stand Emma Barnett. I caught one episode where they were interviewing a MP who was trying to bring in more help for Domestic Abuse victims (guidance for employers who were concerned, IIRC) and Emma’s treatment of him was just appalling. So rude and dismissive, and very quick to use any counter argument (one employer said it was unreasonable as he had 40,000 staff and he couldn’t keep an eye on them all - unlikely they’re all a direct report though, isn’t it sunshine?) as a stick with which to beat someone who was a) taking DA seriously and b) trying to help.

She’s bloody awful.

Smoothyloopy · 21/06/2021 07:37

Absolutely agree with you, I've stopped listening aswell

Onelittlepiglet · 21/06/2021 07:34

That should be ‘who think that…’ -
Eg women like me who who knows that women’s hour should be about and for women.

Onelittlepiglet · 21/06/2021 07:32

Can’t stand either of the new presenters. They clearly hate women like me (who have an opinion that differs from theirs…) and think feminism and women’s hour should be for actual women!

It’s irrelevant to me now, so I don’t listen any more.

GlorianaCervixia · 21/06/2021 07:22

I wonder how WH can cover stories about human trafficking and prostitution - both important issues affecting women - when one of its presenters allegedly financially benefited from her parents doing both those things and allegedly exchanged emails with her father about his “whores”. I just can’t see how they could have any credibility there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread