Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I miss the old R4 Woman's Hour. I don't tune in anymore.

185 replies

flashbac · 20/06/2021 22:57

I don't/can't listen to Woman's Hour anymore. It's lost its magic. I miss having it in the background and listening to interesting points of discussion. Now I find it gets on my nerves. It's crap.

OP posts:
CardinalLolzy · 21/06/2021 13:06

Such a shame. They'll see people switching off and say "see, we no longer need content just for women! Equality achieved!"

IAmQuitePutOut · 21/06/2021 13:05

I miss it so much - felt a profound sense of loss when Jenni Murray and then Jane Garvey left but was prepared to give Emma Barnett the benefit of the doubt. Her style is so abrasive though and I cannot stand the way she tries to turn everything into an argument. I have unsubscribed on BBCSounds.

I listen to Fortunately and Newscast now to try and fill the 10am void but I will always feel sad about what became of Woman's Hour. Like previous posters it was a fixture in my life from listening as a child when my mum had it on in the background - and later when I had small children became a comforting daily ritual.

I still miss Eddie Mair on PM too!

RickiTarr · 21/06/2021 13:04

Well the students should be the last ones left being made to do the basics. In any subject. Smile

I know DS still listens (not live, though, and he skips through) but he’s early career and keen and all that stuff still. As it should be. They need some listeners or it will just be the press officers or journalists listening!

Do we think radio is actually going to die and melt entirely into podcasting?

pigglepot · 21/06/2021 13:01

Agree with this. Jenny and Jane were so fantastic- funny, warm and insightful. The new lot really aren't and I agree I can't get on board with Emma's style.

Blossomtoes · 21/06/2021 12:57

I can’t believe it’s no longer mentioned on Politics courses

It’s because it’s become irrelevant. If addicts with professional reasons for listening to it like @StiffyByng and me have given up on it, it’s beyond hope.

StiffyByng · 21/06/2021 12:56

The specific point about Politics Students is a good one, though. The Today programme is essential listening in Westminster and for lobbyists. My Politics Professors referenced it constantly. I can’t believe it’s no longer mentioned on Politics courses.

But we ARE Westminster and we have abandoned it. We're not the only ones I know who just couldn't put ourselves through it. Fair enough for politics students to be using it as part of their learning but now I would say there's a lot more about there that is interesting/useful - podcasts, Substacks, etc. It had got to the point of offering no insight or education. The traditional use of the Today programme to break news has also hugely diminished now we have Twitter and other instant media.

RickiTarr · 21/06/2021 12:49

Quite honestly it had never occurred to me until that moment that anyone in England could claim to be interested in politics and yet not listen to 'Today', every day.

We abandoned Today entirely in our house as we could no longer bear the stress of it every morning. Balance was out of the window and we were living enough in our daily lives with the constant round and round of politics without starting the day with it.

The specific point about Politics Students is a good one, though. The Today programme is essential listening in Westminster and for lobbyists. My Politics Professors referenced it constantly. I can’t believe it’s no longer mentioned on Politics courses.

StiffyByng · 21/06/2021 12:46

Quite honestly it had never occurred to me until that moment that anyone in England could claim to be interested in politics and yet not listen to 'Today', every day.

We abandoned Today entirely in our house as we could no longer bear the stress of it every morning. Balance was out of the window and we were living enough in our daily lives with the constant round and round of politics without starting the day with it. So we have both gone from news junkies who had listened to Today since our student days to total non-listeners, and feel much the better for it. And we have both been in roles before in which we were so connected to this stuff that we were sometimes involved in negotiating with the producers on bagging spots for the people we worked with.

I haven't listened to the new Woman's Hour. Jenni Murray was my surrogate feminist compassionate and intelligent mum. I haven't heard the new presenters but I feel I'm too old to start again. It was comfort listening (even if the comfort was in hearing debate on uncomfortable issues but knowing I could depend on the presenters) and now it won't be. That's my fault and not theirs, as they are untested. My only material reason for being wary was the comment from Emma Barnett on wanting the programme to be more inclusive - I am a bit sick of women seeking to be more inclusive while so much of the world continues to exclude them.

YouSetTheTone · 21/06/2021 12:24

I was angered by that tweet from Anita Rani too. Extremely patronising, and not to mention tone deaf at the moment with the Maya Forstater verdict and the Jess de Wahl situation at the RA.

If WH can't accurately define a woman and engage in any meaningful discussion about the biggest issues currently facing women today - ie the conflict between gender identity and sex based rights then why would I bother listening? There's being respectful to other viewpoints and then there's centering them at the expense of meaningful discussion about issues that directly affect biological women.

It's perfectly valid to point out to WH that some women find it a bit offensive that they (fawningly) promoted Paris Lees's book 'What it feels like for a girl'? when Paris Lees might identify as a woman but Paris Lees has definitely never been a girl. And yet they refuse to engage with the important work being done by Maya Forstater, Sex Matters, Fair Play for Women or even Jess De Wahls - the artist at the centre of the de-platforming storm by the Royal Academy. Whether WH agree with these individuals/ groups or not they should have the courage to actually engage with them. So Rani's tweet was rudely dismissive of what large numbers of women are telling her they think.

There's just so much cognitive dissonance - for example discussions about VAWG and yet bowing and scraping at the altar of gender identity - an ideology that directly impacts on how women and girls seeking safety and treatment from violence are able to be helped.

If WH don't have the Big Swinging Ovaries to state that they are a programme for women then what's the point? Just call it 'Current Affairs Hour' and be done with it.

ragged · 21/06/2021 12:12

The soporific pace & dull topics had put me off for years. Maybe I'll try to listen again if all that has changed!

Chicchicchicchiclana · 21/06/2021 12:11

Me too OP Sad.

Takeittotheboss · 21/06/2021 12:02

I have also stopped listening after tuning in most days throughout my adult life. If they wanted a programme for "young/other's hour" , why not just make one instead of cuckooing "Women's Hour"?

AliceSprings123 · 21/06/2021 11:49

@Anordinarymum

Maybe it is just me but I could not stand listening to Jenny Murray's voice. I listen more now than before
Same here!
Blossomtoes · 21/06/2021 11:46

I was a huge fan of the Today programme. I used to listen to it on my way to work every morning, I arrived soggy and tear stained when Brian Redhead died! I haven’t listened for two or three years now because it fell off a cliff. It lost all authority when the government decided to boycott it.

ginghamstarfish · 21/06/2021 11:03

Agree, it's awful now, and the presenter has poor use of grammar which doesn't help. Maybe it's deliberate though, trying to fit in with the 'yoof'.

NeonStones · 21/06/2021 10:56

@MayIDestroyYou

There were a couple of students studying politics who never listened to 'Today' and had never heard of the 08.10 'big interview', which left me slightly gobsmacked

'Gobsmacked' is exactly how I felt listening to that, too. It was completely incredible. Quite honestly it had never occurred to me until that moment that anyone in England could claim to be interested in politics and yet not listen to 'Today', every day.

I definitely miss Jane on WH. I don't think I heard her, even once, exoticise a not-white interviewee - which is a thing that erm ... other WH presenters were repeatedly guilty of. And I loved her deadpan, raised eyebrow voice whenever she was forced to introduce a drama segment that she clearly thought was a waste of time. Gudrun, iirc. Grin

But the Today programme is awful, I honestly can't bear to listen to it. I'll listen to The World At One and PM (not as good since Eddie Mair left but I couldn't follow him to LBC as I hate the format) but I cannot take Today. It's hectoring for the sake of it.

I have also gone off Woman's Hour. I wasn't very keen on Jenni Murray by the end, but I always liked Jane Garvey. Loved her deadpan delivery and cynicism as discussed by PP. I also always felt that she was really interested in her 'ordinary' guests when she had them on. Listening to what they say and trying to make them comfortable. As well as Fortunately I would recommend her newer podcast Life Changing. Really interesting stories.

GlencoraP · 21/06/2021 10:41

does more not ‘dies more’Blush

GlencoraP · 21/06/2021 10:39

They should take a leaf from Emily Maitlis’ book, her interview with the Duke of York was a masterclass in the art of the killer interview.

Very true. On the plus side I am enjoying hearing Jane Garvey do news and current affairs on the Newscast podcast, I hope she dies more .

I am another who has pretty much ditched the Today programme as well , it used to be compulsory listening but it’s lost it’s edge. Now I mix and match with Times radio and various news podcasts. I do enjoy Sarah Montague at 1pm on R4 though and Evan Davis often has an interesting slant on the PM programme .

Blossomtoes · 21/06/2021 10:25

I think often, young female interviewers seem to think they need to harry and bully their interviewees i.e. 'be more like a man'

There’s a lot in this. They should take a leaf from Emily Maitlis’ book, her interview with the Duke of York was a masterclass in the art of the killer interview.

Clymene · 21/06/2021 10:25

I like Emma Barnett as a journalist but I don't like her voice and I don't think she gets the best out of her interviewees. Anita Rani is just wet.

I also agree that LL is bloody awful on DID.

I listen to Fortunately instead.

waltzingparrot · 21/06/2021 10:17

R4, if you're listening - you should have just developed a new programme for the under 30s.

Lunificent · 21/06/2021 10:06

It makes me anxious when I see it’s Emma Barnett doing Newsnight and I really think she’s the wrong fit for Women’s Hour.
In her favour, I get the impression she does her homework before an interview. I imagine as she ages she’ll mellow and people will take to her more.

Hazelnut5 · 21/06/2021 09:55

What I miss is the lack of reflection. The old WH was like a magazine . The articles were longer and more in depth, the interviewees were often more relaxed because they weren’t looking every moment for the ‘gotcha’

^Yes, this. I’ve given up on it now.

MayIDestroyYou · 21/06/2021 09:28

There were a couple of students studying politics who never listened to 'Today' and had never heard of the 08.10 'big interview', which left me slightly gobsmacked

'Gobsmacked' is exactly how I felt listening to that, too. It was completely incredible. Quite honestly it had never occurred to me until that moment that anyone in England could claim to be interested in politics and yet not listen to 'Today', every day.

I definitely miss Jane on WH. I don't think I heard her, even once, exoticise a not-white interviewee - which is a thing that erm ... other WH presenters were repeatedly guilty of. And I loved her deadpan, raised eyebrow voice whenever she was forced to introduce a drama segment that she clearly thought was a waste of time. Gudrun, iirc. Grin

TrojaninTroy · 21/06/2021 09:16

I agree with what previous posters have said, especially Howzaboutye. It is now less 'Woman's Hour' and more 'Marginalised Groups' hour. Not that a marginalised group having their issues & views should be covered. It's just that is all there seems to be. Now I'm the marginalised one. Maybe I'm supposed to feel that way?

Swipe left for the next trending thread