Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I miss the old R4 Woman's Hour. I don't tune in anymore.

185 replies

flashbac · 20/06/2021 22:57

I don't/can't listen to Woman's Hour anymore. It's lost its magic. I miss having it in the background and listening to interesting points of discussion. Now I find it gets on my nerves. It's crap.

OP posts:
Sammysquiz · 21/06/2021 18:24

Totally agree, it’s such a shame.

I very much join in with those praising the Fortunately podcast. Its consistently brilliant.

Backtodeep · 21/06/2021 17:20

Abrasive!!! Yes that’s the word. We need better programming for women. There isn’t any left...

Still love Evan Davies. Yes Eddie Mair’s Steven Hewlett interviews were radio gold. Really moving.

The Today programme... too easy on the government and I often feel like the presenters miss the chuffing point and then I’m screaming at the radio... !

But partly I have switched off from Today because it’s just too bloody miserable.

Backtodeep · 21/06/2021 17:05

Ugh me either. So disappointing. Woman’s hour used to be reliably quality listening. And entertaining! Now it’s just pants, waffly and sounds a bit amateurish to me.

The new presenter who I’ve not warmed to much just hasn’t got the right VOICE/ approach... Everything is a bit pointy, the points kind of nakedly made and sometimes plain superficial rather than being an intelligent discussion where Jane Garvey can gently draw the interviewees out to reveal their true intentions, point out where things are still shit for women, and shoehorns in a laugh wherever she can to lighten the mood.

Never really loved Jenni Murray- but she was credible, intelligent and well just better than the current presenter.

The Friday presenter - Anita Rani. Better voice and seems more credible. Can’t say I’ve listened so much recently.

None of the WH programmes really grab me like they did before!

I don’t feel part of the new radio 4. I’m a middle class, early 40s, self employed, married professional with 2.4 children. Maybe that’s why??

The Fortunately Podcast OTOH ... I switch it on and cook and know I’m in for a total treat... Grin It rocks!

I feel really mean sayibg my opinion on an individual but the new presenter is just in the wrong slot!! She sounds like she’s be better on a money programme or something with far fewer emotional connections... Although I love that programme as it is too!

BikeRunSki · 21/06/2021 16:48

Oh yes, of course it is!

StiffyByng · 21/06/2021 16:30

It's Feedback for radio, and I'm pretty sure they've heard all this already.

BikeRunSki · 21/06/2021 15:57

Do the BBC still do “Points of View” in some format? We should send them this thread.

SorryAuntLydia · 21/06/2021 15:38

Was a regular.
I have tried.
But
Lots of light subjects.
Too many men.
Ignoring the real feminist issues of the day.

And
Every interview… ‘but how did/does that make you feeeeeeeel?’
Every. Single. One.

Plus Emma Barnett’s interview technique seems to consist of lecturing her interviewees about themselves and what she thinks they think, at great length, and then tacking a short question on the end. That’s when she’s not petulantly berating them. To be fair it did produce one of my favourite radio interviews in a while - with Sinead O’Connor. I suspect Emma won’t be putting it on her showreel though Grin

JSL52 · 21/06/2021 15:36

Same , Emma is so combative and rude.

Chickpeasorchips · 21/06/2021 15:29

I'm not a fan of Emma Barnett and have to switch Newsnight off if she's doing it - she's too abrasive and doesn't listen properly. Not the right fit for women's hour. YANBU

campion · 21/06/2021 15:21

I gave up on Jenni Murray years ago but I think she probably wasn't allowed free rein at times.
Jane Garvey is an excellent broadcaster but never quite seemed to suit Woman's Hour. She's at her best when she's sparking off another broadcaster imo.

I do like Emma Barnett, unlike most pp. Her interview with 2 women with opposing views /experiences of Judaism last week allowed them to express themselves without it becoming a slanging match. It was sensitively handled.
Likewise, I found her interview with Clemency Burton Hill (after her brain haemorrhage), moving.

She can be as hard as she likes on politicians, for me. They need holding to account.

Howzaboutye · 21/06/2021 15:21

Evan Davis is great. No wool over his eyes. Tall lanky bloke, funny how he doesn't get any grief eh.

I do miss Eddie Mair he was fab

cansu · 21/06/2021 14:53

Agree. I used to really like the style of it before. It doesn't have any warmth anymore.

MayIDestroyYou · 21/06/2021 14:31

Yes ... I'm not keen on all AR's jollying us on. I'm not her mate. Hmm

purplesequins · 21/06/2021 14:12

I'm starting to warm to emma barnett but anita rani is too soft spoken and nicey nicey for my liking

MayIDestroyYou · 21/06/2021 14:05

I've forgotten to miss Eddie Mair! As a pp said - Evan Davis is really beginning to carve out his own style on PM. I know it's the producers / editors / researchers who perhaps control the content - but it really lights up when they feature a topic in which he has some personal or long-standing professional interest. And often, particularly on subjects that centre women, I almost gasp in amazement at the slant taken, and feel the broadcast would have been very different with another presenter. So, amidst all the R4 dross, thumbs up for that man.

SausageCrush · 21/06/2021 13:58

Another vote for the Fortunately podcast for those missing Jane Garvey.

KateTheEighth · 21/06/2021 13:45

And I absolutely agree re Today. Listened to it every day for about 30 years but can't listen now.

newnortherner111 · 21/06/2021 13:44

Some people are a programme and really no-one can replace them. Could this be the case with Jenni Murray?

PandorasMailbox · 21/06/2021 13:43

I've gone off Anita Rani since she fawned all over Paris Lees.

It's not Woman's Hour any more, it's an hour for basically anyone and no-one.

KateTheEighth · 21/06/2021 13:42

I love Emma Barnett but I don't think she's the right fit for WH

I stopped listening a while ago (I found Jane Garvery quite sneering towards some people she interviewed) but I gave it a go when EB joined.

It's not working for me at all so I'm listening to Times radio instead

GoingGently · 21/06/2021 13:38

@CardinalLolzy

Such a shame. They'll see people switching off and say "see, we no longer need content just for women! Equality achieved!"
Ugh! Yes, this.... sadly
StiffyByng · 21/06/2021 13:28

With the presenters I do suspect there's an element of we longer-term listeners being a bit Luddite, and not liking New Things. Who else remembers the absolute uproar when the schedule was changed in the 90s? Mixing it up to appeal to new listeners has to be part of the approach. Dramatic changes do have a habit of settling down and we may see something similar with WH.

BUT the Today programme has eaten itself, no question.

Blossomtoes · 21/06/2021 13:11

@RickiTarr

I still miss Eddie Mair on PM too!

I know. I did try to follow him at first but no, that new format was very commercial radio.

Oh God, me too. His series of interviews with Steve Hewlett was the most sensitive, moving radio ever.
RickiTarr · 21/06/2021 13:08

@CardinalLolzy

Such a shame. They'll see people switching off and say "see, we no longer need content just for women! Equality achieved!"
It’ll have to be podcasting and it will have to be word of mouth. Women’s issues are fast being forced back to underground organisation, almost.

I still want radio to survive, though.

RickiTarr · 21/06/2021 13:06

I still miss Eddie Mair on PM too!

I know. I did try to follow him at first but no, that new format was very commercial radio.

Swipe left for the next trending thread