Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I miss the old R4 Woman's Hour. I don't tune in anymore.

185 replies

flashbac · 20/06/2021 22:57

I don't/can't listen to Woman's Hour anymore. It's lost its magic. I miss having it in the background and listening to interesting points of discussion. Now I find it gets on my nerves. It's crap.

OP posts:
GoingGently · 24/06/2021 12:12

I thought EB was white?

C8H10N4O2 · 24/06/2021 10:04

However, she is quite good on issues which affect her- endometriosis, to name just one. I think her sharing her own experiences brings something.

I do like Emma Barnett, unlike most pp. Her interview with 2 women with opposing views /experiences of Judaism last week allowed them to express themselves without it becoming a slanging match. It was sensitively handled

These comments illustrate the problem to me. Where EB has personal insight or interest in the topic the interviews are much better. Where its just a "job" she does the research but her style often overtakes the interview and it becomes the EB show.

The combative style is old fashioned and dated, interviewees with any experience are prepared for it. The slightly quieter, more interrogative style of a Jane Garvey or Emily Maitlis or Mishal Hussein actually gets more answers. I miss Jenny Murray but she was plainly muzzled for the last few years and it showed.

I have liked Anita Rani in the past but her focus on making it "everything hour" just makes it irrelevant.

Overall the show seems to have lost its woman centred focus. I wasn't always interested in Delilah who started a company painting mushrooms but I really appreciated the whole as a forum for a wide range of women's interests - that magazine format.

The other change I feel (and this is very subjective I know) is that we have gone from two white WC presenters to two ethnic minority MC presenters and yet the show feels less diverse and whiter. I can't put my finger on exactly why, its not overt, but I find less to identify with. Maybe its because its just lost that heart of being woman centred to a wishy washy "lets all be nice and men will magically be lovely" type feminism.

yeOldeTrout · 23/06/2021 21:58

I listened to about 3 minutes of Woman's Hour this morning.
Dancing was the topic.
"How much do you love dancing, how much do you miss dancing!"

I have zero interest in dancing.

Yup, just as boring as ever.

bridgetreilly · 23/06/2021 19:52

@MayIDestroyYou, I'm pretty sure there would have been outcry from the listeners to the 7.45pm drama if it had indeed been by women/about women/for women. And since it was a repeat of the Woman's Hour Drama....

MayIDestroyYou · 23/06/2021 16:56

Hmm ... 'done some research' is what I meant.

MayIDestroyYou · 23/06/2021 16:55

You mean the dramas largely written by men, about men?

What an interesting point! In half a century I've never stopped to think about the relationship of those 15 minute serialised dramas to Woman's Hour itself.

But actually, the things that spring to mind did quite often have women as the main character: Gudrun, the thing about a detective (?), the thing with an emergency services telephone responder ... It's appalling that so few have stuck in my mind.

Surely someone's fine done research on this?

bridgetreilly · 23/06/2021 16:22

Yeah, that's right. The dramas that also appeared elsewhere in the regular schedule without any Woman's Hour label attached that we were supposed to be too stupid to realise were the same.

GoingGently · 23/06/2021 15:04

You mean the dramas largely written by men, about men?

bridgetreilly · 23/06/2021 13:40

I like Anita Rani and I REALLY like that it is an actual hour now without the insult of the so-called Woman's Hour Drama.

JohnSteinbeck · 23/06/2021 12:46

I’ve resorted to listening to the R4 podcasts. Very soothing World Routes music series presented by Lucy Duran who has a more calm and informative manner...

Howzaboutye · 23/06/2021 11:14

Is there anything on the times radio?

PensionsYes · 23/06/2021 10:27

So apart from Fortunately which of course isn’t daily - is there an alternative woman’s radio our there?

We can’t be alone in all broadly speaking - thinking similarly about this!

JohnSteinbeck · 23/06/2021 10:21

Trying to listen to it now and the voices just hurt my ears. The style is abrasive and unnecessarily litigious. It’s not a comforting space any more.

HareofEasttown · 22/06/2021 20:50

Agree

TheFnozwhowasmirage · 22/06/2021 20:50

I used to listen to R4 all day at work. I stopped about 3 years ago. It was utterly miserable, worthy crap all the time. WH in particular had absolutely no relevance to me or my life at all,and from what I've read since,it's gone even more downhill and is plain insulting and gaslighting women,by centering men if they possibly can.

headpillow · 22/06/2021 20:27

I used to enjoy listening regularly and came away feeling like it was time well spent and it enriched my life. I would learn a bit more about something I'd never have considered deeply before. Now it's like being on shouty social media where the loudest voice and lowest common denominator wins and everything is dumbed down. It is such a loss.

What killed it completely for me was when they had a man interviewing. It is 'woman's' hour. The whole word is run by men for men and WH used to be a special space for women - by women.

flashbac · 22/06/2021 19:13

Glad to know it's not just me then!

OP posts:
tactum · 22/06/2021 11:13

I can't bear it any more - Emma is soooo abrasive and agressive and it's just not an enjoyable noise to subject my ears to. It makes me cross rather than informs me.
Jenni's voice was wonderful.....wistful

DoingItMyself · 21/06/2021 20:05

To be fair, I don't listen to radio four now. Seven years clean.

Retrievemysanity · 21/06/2021 19:59

@campion yes, I found that interview with Clemency really moving too (totally blubbed like a baby in fact!).

Wasn’t an EB fan initially but I do think she’s settling into the role now. I think she was a bit aggressive to try and make her mark at first but has toned it down a bit recently.

StiffyByng · 21/06/2021 19:56

@mrpenny

totally agree. It’s of no relevance to me at all. Younger people have other channels to listen to . Leave Radio 4 alone!!!!!
But many of us posting on here have listened to Radio 4 since we were young ourselves. There need to be ways of engaging a broad audience.
Draineddraineddrained · 21/06/2021 19:56

Btw I'm 36 so hardly a crone, but I grew up on Radio 4, my mum always had it on in the background growing up and it made me interested in so many things very young. Such a shame they're chasing the whims of a generation that will never give them the loyalty their core audience would have.

mrpenny · 21/06/2021 19:51

totally agree. It’s of no relevance to me at all. Younger people have other channels to listen to . Leave Radio 4 alone!!!!!

Draineddraineddrained · 21/06/2021 19:47

Hadn't listened for a while and had no idea how much it had changed. Caught it by accident today down the allotment and the very young presenter seemed to be perpetually fielding responses fr social media and via text about whether one should wear pants under one's pyjamas Hmm no offence but if I want a hundred randoms' opinions on some trivial shite I know where AIBU is Grin - when I tune into Radio 4 I expect more frankly. Also the way it kept going,popping up in the middle of her other pieces, asking the guests who were there to talk about something sensible this facile question - the women, anyway, didn't notice her asking the MAN who they'd got on to opine about the issue of harassment of women in the workplace (!!! Sample remark " let's not make people feel guilty about this, we're all subject to cultural conditioning" 😡).

Seriously I was shocked how shit it was.

CriticalCondition · 21/06/2021 19:08

Completely agree. The new presenters are at the extreme ends of interviewing approach. Emma Barnett is abrasive and her guests get defensive and double down . Anita Rani is feeble and sycophantic and comes across as shallow and a bit dim. Her guests spout whatever they want to. And her shockingly rude and biased tweet calling listeners transphobic after her cringe inducing Paris Lees 'interview' was the final straw for me. Neither gets the best out of their guests.
Both Jenni Murray and Jane Garvey asked difficult questions and had warmth and humour. I miss them both. I listened to Woman's Hour every day for decades. I can't bear it now and will actively turn it off.
The Fortunately podcast is consistently brilliant though and something I look forward to and savour every week. A couple of wise, witty women I wish I could welcome into my kitchen more often.

Swipe left for the next trending thread