Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I miss the old R4 Woman's Hour. I don't tune in anymore.

185 replies

flashbac · 20/06/2021 22:57

I don't/can't listen to Woman's Hour anymore. It's lost its magic. I miss having it in the background and listening to interesting points of discussion. Now I find it gets on my nerves. It's crap.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FlowerArranger · 21/07/2021 11:05

Just caught Chloe Tilley today. Definitely much more relatable.

TheOrigRights · 21/07/2021 10:17

Chloe Tilley has been hosting Woman's Hour this week and I'm enjoying it far more.

Watchingreruns · 25/06/2021 22:39

Yep

Leah2005 · 25/06/2021 22:38

I've never listened to it but do enjoy 'Fortunately' with Fi and Jane Garvey. (sorry not read tft if anyone has already mentioned this Smile)

vincettenoir · 25/06/2021 22:15

I like Anita Rani on it. I like Emma Barnett and think she’s talented but she’s the wrong fit for the show. But I miss Jane Garvey sooooo much.

GlencoraP · 25/06/2021 21:39

Emma Barnett does sneer at people it’s one of the things I don’t like .

Lurcherloves · 25/06/2021 21:21

I don’t like Emma Barnet’s voice. I’m not sure it’s her real voice she uses which is perhaps why it is irritating.
I’ve found myself disappointed with most of the topics

Tacono1 · 25/06/2021 21:17

Haha

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/06/2021 21:15

@bridgetreilly 😂.

I shall have to find that on catch up!

Tacono1 · 25/06/2021 21:15

I guess it was good there was a place where issues such as infertility were discussed without being sneered and laughed at. It was a genuine female space.

bridgetreilly · 25/06/2021 20:42

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER there was an utterly brilliant R4 comedy by the late Linda Smith called A Brief History of Timewasting. One of the recurring jokes was that whenever she turned on the radio it would be Jeni Murray saying, “…misery of infertility.”

C8H10N4O2 · 25/06/2021 12:51

Jenni Murray proceeded to ask her nothing but if she had a body double during her sex scenes

At the time that was one of the issues Michaela Coel was focused on - the situation of actors filming intimate scenes in the era of #MeToo and raising awareness of the importance of the role. Should more time have been spent on the wider issues? Possibly. Were the wider issues regularly discussed on WH under J&J - yes.

Or maybe it was just a duff interview. I wouldn't pretend for a moment that every item was perfect or even good, what feels different to me is that in that time the programme always felt as if it were by women for women focused on women's interests and issues.

There have been other presenters - Martha Kearney springs to mind, plus ocasionals such as Bidisha and Ritula Shah - and the feel has always been of a woman centred programme. That is what has changed. Why does woman's hour have to become more inclusive of men? There have been various attempts at Men's Hours with varying success (Tom Robinson's was good I thought) - why not continue those rather than making WH into Everything Hour?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/06/2021 09:59

I stopped listening ages ago anyway, because it seemed that every time I did, they were talking about breast cancer. Yes, I know it’s important, but I didn’t want cancer rammed down my throat non stop, esp. when family members were suffering from it.
And TBH I never liked Jenni Murray.

I once bought a Joanna Trollope novel after browsing the first few pages, purely because I identified with the central character, who switched off her car radio because it was WH banging on about breast cancer yet again.

reprehensibleme · 25/06/2021 09:45

Well, considering Michaela Coel dedicated her Bafta to Ita O'Brien, the intimacy coach on 'I May Destroy You', the body double question was quite possibly very relevant.

Demelza82 · 25/06/2021 09:21

Ah yes, the old Woman's Hour where they got one of the actors from I May Destroy You on as part of a discussion about the many, many issues raised by the groundbreaking series and Jenni Murray proceeded to ask her nothing but if she had a body double during her sex scenes. So deep, so insightful.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/06/2021 09:17

It used to feel like a meaty discussion with good female friends. It’s a bit ordinary and just like everything else now

Yes this may well be it. Its a bit dumbed down pale imitation of R4 at its best. No clear purpose, just a "be nice to everyone, especially the poor men" schtick. The edge isn't there.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/06/2021 09:14

I'm not sure about working class though because Jenni M has said herself that she exaggerated her 'humble origins'

Yes maybe what the old acorn groups called C rather than D/E in origin but certainly made very good. I'm possibly over focusing on that trying to pin down the actual problem. Or maybe it overlaps with a frustration that I meet so many young professional women who think equality is a done deal and don't raise their eyes to see less fortunate women around them, let alone look ahead to when they may have children and the lack of equality bites.

I doubt most twenty somethings are even aware of WH

Possibly but I was a twenty something new mother when I started listening regularly. I had certainly listened before but then it seemed to be one of the more relevant R4 programmes to me and I acquired the habit. (Didn't it used to be repeated in the evening before replays were a thing?). I may be wrong but at one time I thought the WH serial specifically showcased women writers and dramas centering women's lives.

Agree on some of the mediocre occasionally from the arts. I generally put that down to budgets and cronyism resulting in using what agents into producers rather than going out to seek. Even with the mediocre though Jenny and Jane manage to bring a story out of the person rather than do the "oh how interesting whatever you just said" routine.

Tacono1 · 24/06/2021 21:52

It used to feel like a meaty discussion with good female friends. It’s a bit ordinary and just like everything else now. At first I was finding it annoying and now I’ve just forgotten about it and only hear it in passing. I used to love the Saturday recap show as I was cooking dinner.

campion · 24/06/2021 21:26

C8H10N4O2 Thanks for the confirmation.

I'm not sure about working class though because Jenni M has said herself that she exaggerated her 'humble origins'.
I'd say she and Jane G are pretty firmly middle class even though their parents might have been working class originally. Social mobility etc. But in this case, I don't think it matters anyway.

I doubt most twenty somethings are even aware of WH. Radio 4 is hardly on their radar at the best of times but the BBC are a bit obsessed with 'reaching a younger demographic' at the expense of those who actually listen!

I do think that the programme was tired and needed a reset and I was hoping for eg that they'd, finally, have fewer mediocre female musicians but that seems to be continuing. There are plenty of serious, successful, innovative female musicians around so they need to be braver. Just a personal gripe there.
I suppose it very much depends on who is actually editing and steering programme content, not just the presenter.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/06/2021 20:04

Do WC and MC mean working and middle class in your post? I'm assuming yes?

Yes sorry.

It shouldn't matter than Jane and Jenny were both grammar school girls made good (although Jane's was under the old direct grant model and subsequently went independent I think) but I think it did. Or maybe its just that they had more of a focus on the most fundamental issues women face, which affect us all before you add in other factors.

I'm not really sure but there is a shift away from women and the magazine format in the programme (EB really struggles to feign interest in many of the less newsworthy items) and it stopped being a regular listen for me. It feels like EB would really prefer to be on Today/Newsnight and is trying to turn WH into a more newsy everything hour with far more men in focus. OTOH maybe I'm just not their target demographic and teh 20 somethings are all lapping it up.

Butteredtoast55 · 24/06/2021 19:06

Agree with so many other posters. Anita Rani is better than the terrible Emma Barnett, but the gravitas, wit, intelligence and humanity have generally fallen off a cliff since Jenny and Jane left.

campion · 24/06/2021 15:16

C8H10N4O2

Do WC and MC mean working and middle class in your post? I'm assuming yes?

Feckingirritated · 24/06/2021 14:12

I’m another one who grew up listening to R4 with my mum, and from the point that I started to take notice of WH, I always found it lacking. Every other article seemed to be about breastfeeding or the menopause or caring for elderly parents; the articles that were relevant to me (exams, university, health) massively missed the mark, were often dismissive. Even if younger women weren’t the target demographic, there is still value to presenting their stories with their own voices - it creates a talking point for listeners within their own families if nothing else. I also remember always being irritated by the assumption that listeners had children, even when there was scope within a story to look at it from both angles.

It was definitely due a shake up, and although I’ve yet to listen to the new format, I’d definitely be willing to give it a go now.

RickiTarr · 24/06/2021 13:01

The other change I feel (and this is very subjective I know) is that we have gone from two white WC presenters to two ethnic minority MC presenters and yet the show feels less diverse and whiter. I can't put my finger on exactly why, its not overt, but I find less to identify with. Maybe its because its just lost that heart of being woman centred to a wishy washy "lets all be nice and men will magically be lovely" type feminism.

TBF that’s not change along the more diverse/whiter axis. It’s shifted further down the more feminism/less feminism axis.

Which is saying something as the feminism had been muzzled anyway in recent years, as PPs have observed.

It gives it an overall feeling of greater conformity and credulity, I think.

GlencoraP · 24/06/2021 12:25

I think the PP is referring to the fact that she is Jewish

Swipe left for the next trending thread