Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this house is worth it and London won't crash?

466 replies

Yazhi · 18/06/2021 19:20

After searching for a long time we have found a house in an area that both DH and I like. DH thinks we should wait and see if the prices drop in London. Flats seem to have dropped and he's hoping houses follow. Who do you think is right?

OP posts:
GappyValley · 20/06/2021 10:25

@TatianaBis

I’m perplexed by the posters trying to get OP to move south of the river.

Very similar to MH, why not leave her to it?

Personally, I like North and South London equally.

The state schools around here in SW London are not particularly good, other than Tiffins which is quite far out. Post primary all the middle class kids are in private school. Round here most primary age are in private too.

Because she asked if posters had suggestions of other areas which had similar quantities to MH - good schools, green space, nice high street and good transport

Why is it perplexing that some of those areas might be south..?

TatianaBis · 20/06/2021 10:18

I’m perplexed by the posters trying to get OP to move south of the river.

Very similar to MH, why not leave her to it?

Personally, I like North and South London equally.

The state schools around here in SW London are not particularly good, other than Tiffins which is quite far out. Post primary all the middle class kids are in private school. Round here most primary age are in private too.

LivingLaVidaCovid · 20/06/2021 10:14

Check the catchment but honestly I think that's a great house and not a bad price, I def prefer 1 vs 2.

I used to live nearish and it's a lovely area.

GappyValley · 20/06/2021 10:01

@Yazhi

Our friends in South London have mostly opted for private school at secondary. Where would be the comparable Rhodes Avenue/APS schools? For a similar house I think we priced out of places like Barnes.
For Barnes, it would be Barnes Primary All saints in Putney East sheen primary in east sheen Beatrix potter for Earlsfiend Honeywell and Belleville for between the commons

You’d be able to get a 4 bed/roughly 1800-2000 sq ft house in all of those areas except Barnes
But those schools all have pretty tiny catchments so I wouldn’t fancy your chances for many in catchment schools being on the market at any one time

SoupDragon · 20/06/2021 09:57

Wild deer and bright green parakeets

Croydon has both those 🤣🤣

womble2017 · 20/06/2021 09:55

A slightly different tangent... Muswell Hill is awesome and that road is a great spot (I’m just around the corner!). Be careful with ‘catchments’ though, as it’s all on distance and some parts of that road might too far depending which school you’d target (e.g. Muswell Hill Primary was 0.23 miles this year I think). Check out the Haringey website for precise distance of the house to the schools and last ten years admissions distance. The prices in MH are heavily impacted by distance from the schools. Gorgeous house though. Good luck!

CreamOrange · 20/06/2021 09:55

It's because London is a different world and psychology to the rest of society. You have to have lived outside and inside to understand. Sounds trite but cannot summarise it simpler.

DynamoKev · 20/06/2021 09:52

I don’t buy into British exceptionalism at all, but I do with London.
What a ridiculous statement.

Yazhi · 20/06/2021 09:51

Our friends in South London have mostly opted for private school at secondary. Where would be the comparable Rhodes Avenue/APS schools? For a similar house I think we priced out of places like Barnes.

OP posts:
GappyValley · 20/06/2021 09:48

@TatianaBis

Once you take out theft of range rovers (which is irrelevant to OP because she doesn’t drive) SW11 has a very low crime rate

Battersea crime rate is double that of my area in the borough of Wandsworth including violent crime.

When ‘Battersea’ includes all the estates in SW8..?

The between the commons crime rate isn’t indicative of the drug dealing in the estates several miles away

Charley50 · 20/06/2021 09:46

Walking up hills is good for the health.

Charley50 · 20/06/2021 09:45

😂😂 loving all this North South competitiveness. It's true, South has the Thames, but parakeets are all over London. Lots in Ally Pally.

GappyValley · 20/06/2021 09:43

[quote HaveringWavering]@GappyValley have you never seen kids roll down hills? 😀[/quote]
Have you never had a scooting or cycling preschooler who expects to be pulled or carried up hills?!

When I was pushing a pram long walks around parks, I thought about a lot of things but ‘I wish this was more hilly’ was definitely not one of them!

Lulalu · 20/06/2021 09:33

Richmond Park isn’t flat and it’s huge. Wild deer and bright green parakeets. It merges with Wimbledon Common too. But the best thing about the SW London area is the river because of the towpath runs for miles and miles and there’s something about being near the water that makes everything seem less enclosed. OP, venture this side and come and visit!

Though I do remember Highgate has lovely views. Probably MH is the same. Hampstead is lovely character-wise, but for some reason, it feels more intense to me than say, Putney or Barnes or Fulham because there’s no water..

For that style of house she is looking at, the OP may also like Chiswick.

TatianaBis · 20/06/2021 09:26

Once you take out theft of range rovers (which is irrelevant to OP because she doesn’t drive) SW11 has a very low crime rate

Battersea crime rate is double that of my area in the borough of Wandsworth including violent crime.

Marriedatfirstyear · 20/06/2021 09:25

@YukoandHiro

I'm trying to sell my London flat and have dropped the price by almost a fifth. Agents tell me houses are also dipping now. This was reassuring to us as we're not moving areas so it was the widening gap that was stressing us out most
Where are you, we are trying to sell a flat too which isn't shifting. We're in SE London. No cladding issue as it's below cladding height regulations.
Charley50 · 20/06/2021 09:25

[quote HaveringWavering]@GappyValley have you never seen kids roll down hills? 😀[/quote]

😂😂 I used to spend lots of time rolling down the hill of Ally Pally as a child.
MH has Ally Pally. It also has Highgate and Queens Woods nearby and the Parkland Walk and is generally a lovely area with beautiful architecture in the houses.

HaveringWavering · 20/06/2021 09:20

@GappyValley have you never seen kids roll down hills? 😀

GappyValley · 20/06/2021 09:16

@TatianaBis

Battersea is near me, I really dislike it. Yes it’s got a couple of commons but they’re flat and surrounded by very busy roads. It’s urban and polluted, The crime is quite high comparative to the rest of Wandsworth.

I would choose MH over that any day. The nicer bits of SW -

  • W London that are like MH but with better transport (Barnes, Putney, Chiswick, Richmond etc) would be more expensive than OP’s house.
Once you take out theft of range rovers (which is irrelevant to OP because she doesn’t drive) SW11 has a very low crime rate

Clapham Common is surrounded by busy roads but Wandsworth common is a total oasis in parts. The tree dens in the Woodland trust area are absolutely lovely

Not sure what the great appeal of a hill is for a young family Confused

HaveringWavering · 20/06/2021 09:10

@TatianaBis

Battersea is near me, I really dislike it. Yes it’s got a couple of commons but they’re flat and surrounded by very busy roads. It’s urban and polluted, The crime is quite high comparative to the rest of Wandsworth.

I would choose MH over that any day. The nicer bits of SW -

  • W London that are like MH but with better transport (Barnes, Putney, Chiswick, Richmond etc) would be more expensive than OP’s house.
I was on a bus last week went past Clapham Common for the first time in a million years and I thought “God, it’s so flat!”. Give me Hampstead Heath or Ally Pally park any day!
TatianaBis · 20/06/2021 09:08

Battersea is near me, I really dislike it. Yes it’s got a couple of commons but they’re flat and surrounded by very busy roads. It’s urban and polluted, The crime is quite high comparative to the rest of Wandsworth.

I would choose MH over that any day. The nicer bits of SW -

  • W London that are like MH but with better transport (Barnes, Putney, Chiswick, Richmond etc) would be more expensive than OP’s house.
urkidding · 20/06/2021 08:25

I think house prices are ridiculously high at present. And interest rates are low, and we also had the stamp duty holiday. Personally, I would wait. Also I would look at other areas, further away from central London for more space.

NiceGerbil · 20/06/2021 02:25

Yeesss do we have to do the North South thing?

I love it here!

North and South are very different. I can appreciate that South London is very nice. Definitely arguably nicer.

But. I love North.

They're just different.

I heard diggs on the radio years ago saying South London was nice and everything but as soon as he went over the river it felt 'wrong'. I can understand that!

Horses for courses really.

greenwichvillage · 20/06/2021 02:16

How about living South of the river in Battersea in an area nicknamed Between the Commons. There are 2 fantastic state primary schools in the area, in between 2 huge green commons, lots of independent don't shops, restaurants and cafes. The transports links are fantastic, with the Overground,underground and Rail all within walking distance and the house prices are similar for some beautiful vitoria and Edwardian properties. Plus it's only 15 mins to central London by bus, tube or train. I have lived here 25 years and absolutely love it, would not wish to live anywhere else. You have the best of both worlds, lots of green space with a villagy feel and close to central London.

NiceGerbil · 20/06/2021 01:54

It's not for me even if I could afford it.

Went to school nearby-ish and used to have loads of muswell hill friends. And used to drink in the green Man a lot (is that still there?).

There's a definite muswell hill 'type' that isn't everyone's cup of tea! And the transport links are crap. No tube station.

Highgate woods are lovely and near though and of course the grounds of ally pally (don't know how to spell only said it!).

I prefer something a bit.. grittier? Less fancy?

That's just me though. It is very sought after for a reason.

There is a certain cache as it were to saying I live in muswell hill.