Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this house is worth it and London won't crash?

466 replies

Yazhi · 18/06/2021 19:20

After searching for a long time we have found a house in an area that both DH and I like. DH thinks we should wait and see if the prices drop in London. Flats seem to have dropped and he's hoping houses follow. Who do you think is right?

OP posts:
Diverseopinions · 18/06/2021 22:12

I think you need to find out more about education and philosophies because, although private schools are part of a divisive narrative about how we live as a society, they really do nurture - the very good ones - and develop your child's confidence and independent thinking. The small class sizes enable that. And before and after-school homework and sport clubs make childcare easier. I hope I'm not being out of turn giving unsolicited advice on schools, but it isn't as simple, I don't think, as 'great state schools versus wasting your money' . State schools are great for a free of charge provision, but not as magnificent as what can be achieved with the most attention to individualised teaching. A lot of work may need to go into to helping children from what will seem to most peers as a very well-off, privileged family, manage not to stand out as very lucky and out of touch with the experience of the others.

YukoandHiro · 18/06/2021 22:12

I'm trying to sell my London flat and have dropped the price by almost a fifth. Agents tell me houses are also dipping now. This was reassuring to us as we're not moving areas so it was the widening gap that was stressing us out most

Thecazelets · 18/06/2021 22:11

@BuffySummersReportingforSanity Me too!

Maggiesfarm · 18/06/2021 22:09

[quote Yazhi]This one is 100k more which is my evidence to DH that the one I like is worth it! The second houses photos are nicer but the house itself isn't I don't think.

Rosebery Road, Muswell Hill N10
www.rightmove.co.uk/property/108637082[/quote]
I like the other one better.

There's one near me quite similar for under £900k, however Muswell Hill and nearby is a more vibrant area, especially for a young family.

TatianaBis · 18/06/2021 22:09

In Muswell Hill there will be loads of middle class kids in similarly priced houses in state schools.

Yazhi · 18/06/2021 22:09

We don't have a car so parking not really an issue.

@SunglassesSeventy We aren't anything special! We both have science degrees. We were offered the opportunity to move here as part of a secondment package that included our living costs. I've been ploughing away our salaries for the years we've been on secondment. We gambled and took jobs with a start-up that was venture capital funding. In lieu of higher salaries we got lots of stock. The company sold and we make quite a lot off the stock. The U.K. can't hold onto its young science talent and we cashed in on that. Our roles were empty for a year before we took them.

OP posts:
NeedToKnow101 · 18/06/2021 22:08

@Diverseopinions - tbh most of the kids in that actual area live in houses like that; it's the norm.

And as the state schools are so good, lots of people don't go private.

The prices are just what they are in that part of London. Crazy, but it's just how it is. Most people would buy that as a starter home though, they'd work their way up.

Ostara212 · 18/06/2021 22:06

I don't know anything about london prices

But I have taken a real shine to the second one. I could live there on my own!

BakeOffRewatch · 18/06/2021 22:06

Oh just read all the comments, I didn’t realise such a bed would be a huge hazard!

@SunglassesSeventy it’s not cash in pocket though, you don’t have 1mil left over, it’s just 1mil you didn’t borrow. London salaries are bigger. Say 10% deposit, so borrowing £1,440,000, needs combined salaries of £260k. Two execs can earn that.

Maggiesfarm · 18/06/2021 22:04

I think it's a lovely house in a charming area, Yazhi. I hope you go for it.

Diverseopinions · 18/06/2021 22:02

I think your DH is right about the private schools. I think I do, anyway. It definitely needs thought.

Your kids are going to be living in a massively more expensive home than many of their friends. I wonder how that will play out. Will it be awkward for them?

If you decide you don't like aspects of the state school and you don't have time to micromanage and improve the experience by liaising with school or becoming a school governor - then will you be able to afford private schools after all if you decide you want to later, and you've purchased this costly house? . The older children get, the more issues can impact their school experience.

I believe in state education, but I do accept it is hard going through a school and being different to the others. Easier if your family is middle class and socialist, as are many families in SE London. Especially if your parents are seriously well off and live in a house that you could buy maybe three small houses or nice flats for in nearby areas, it could be a bit tricky. . Think of the kids' potential experience.

You say you have not been in London long, perhaps you will not be offended by me commenting this way, as I wouldn't like you not to know about the relative pros and cons of schools.

It strikes me that the house you post, at that price, is ostentatious and grand. Do you really need that? Why not save on your mortgage, because who knows what might happen in the job market.

I even think your DH is right about watching prices, as to fall by 5 - 10% would be a massive life- impacting saving for your future.

Look for s cheaper area and save on your mortgage. Aim for 800 or 900k . And research the ethos of different schools and even the emphasis in the teaching and how certain issues are dealt with, say in 'An Inspector Calls' , the GCSE English Lit text

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 18/06/2021 22:01

As lovely as Muswell Hill is, people are completely deluding themselves if they think that there aren't just as nice and better value places to live which have equal commute times into central London

I don't want to live in a commuter town. Not even slightly. Most places in the Home Counties are priced equivalently to London on top of being deeply suburban and blah. Fuck no.

I want to be in London. Because I love London.

Atla · 18/06/2021 22:01

As an aside, my mum sold a garden flat in muswell hill in 1992 for 96k..... same flat was recently on the market for 660k!

I moved away from London over 20 years ago and I can't get over the property prices. How on earth does anyone on a normal wage afford to buy?!

Its a lovely house OP - go for it. MH property wont be going down in value imo.

SunglassesSeventy · 18/06/2021 21:55

Gorgeous house, go for it!

I've always been curious about people who can afford to spend that much on a house. Where does the money come from? Inheritance? Bought somewhere expensive years ago then sold?

I can't wrap my brain around being able to afford a house of that price yet still needing to go to work. You could buy a house for £650k elsewhere in the UK and then have 1 million left over to spend on whatever you like!

Sorry, know this isn't what the thread's about, I'm just incredibly curious re how people afford this level of house.

Camdenish · 18/06/2021 21:54

Street parking in these parts of London is the norm. People aren’t as wedded to their cars as they are in the ‘burbs. You get to chat to your neighbours when you’re wandering round the block in your slippers wondering where you’re partner may have parked the car this time.

Turmerictolly · 18/06/2021 21:53

[quote slippersandprosecco]Example of what you could get in a pretty market town with super fast and regular trains into London and a much better change at getting into outstanding schools. If this isn't to your taste then are also plenty of Edwardian style houses akin to the ones you listed, but bigger for the same price.

People spending that many £££ in London outskirts are fools! Especially for a house that doesn't even have its own parking!

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/80403462#/[/quote]

It's beautiful but Hitchin is a world away from Muswell Hill!

PattyPan · 18/06/2021 21:52

No one has a crystal ball. No one can predict what markets will do. If you like the house and are comfortable that you can afford it (including if interest rates rise) then by all means go for it. It’s a lovely house. Inflation rose more than was predicted this month so just don’t rely on the rock-bottom interest rates we have got used to.

CustardySergeant · 18/06/2021 21:50

@Ickythefirebobby

Gorgeous house. Who the heck has a hanging rope in a children’s bedroom though😮
When I read that I thought you meant a noose!
blueshoes · 18/06/2021 21:49

To be safe, and I assume from the prices of those properties you are not short of a few bob, budget on the basis you have to pay for private school if in London. Most Londoners who live in houses that size do not bat an eyelid at using the independent sector.

Other posters talking about the catchments being so small you practically having to live on the doorstep of your local school to get in are not kidding. If you are in a high birth rate year particularly for your first child, that is 100,000s of pounds in school fees for one child from reception to sixth form. Which is kinda the difference (plus some) in cost between the 2 houses.

BakeOffRewatch · 18/06/2021 21:46

@Peoniesandpeaches

I really love the lampshade in the child’s room with the birds… so cheers for sending me down a rabbit hole trying to find where it’s from Grin
I love the bed in the kids room! Anyone know what brand it might be or what search terms I should try in google?
NeedToKnow101 · 18/06/2021 21:44

I wouldn't call Muswell Hill 'cut-off.'

User657849 · 18/06/2021 21:44

Lived in Mussell Hill for a year when I was much younger.
I have such fond memories, it’s a beautiful place to live.
I like the second house better, other than the kitchen.

Grellbunt · 18/06/2021 21:43

A lot of what is nice here is the furniture....

slippersandprosecco · 18/06/2021 21:41

Example of what you could get in a pretty market town with super fast and regular trains into London and a much better change at getting into outstanding schools. If this isn't to your taste then are also plenty of Edwardian style houses akin to the ones you listed, but bigger for the same price.

People spending that many £££ in London outskirts are fools! Especially for a house that doesn't even have its own parking!

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/80403462#/

Serin · 18/06/2021 21:37

Ooh, both lovely. Difficult decision.
House one seems to have more potential to add value.
I'd park up outside both of them for a good long time and get a feel for the immediate neighbourhood.
I'd also ring the local schools and check out what are the chances of admission.