Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this house is worth it and London won't crash?

466 replies

Yazhi · 18/06/2021 19:20

After searching for a long time we have found a house in an area that both DH and I like. DH thinks we should wait and see if the prices drop in London. Flats seem to have dropped and he's hoping houses follow. Who do you think is right?

OP posts:
BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 18/06/2021 22:29

It’s really dated and the kitchen’s a joke. You’d have to spend a fortune to get that to the standard of the first house OP posted.

Just looked at it, and... too true. I don't actually want to pretend I'm a Bennet sister, thanks. I want a modern family house in the city.

TatianaBis · 18/06/2021 22:29

@Camdenish

You won’t “need” to go down the private Ed route in MH.

Plenty of children will be in bigger houses and some in smaller. Some in flats, some in private rented, some in social housing but plenty in that sort of house. Some families may well have that Hitchin or Scottish house as their holiday home.
I think I prefer house 2 just because the futility room is in the basement. The washing machine is likely to be on floorboards in the other house which makes more noise. Concrete floor and out of the way would be my preference.

The side return is not done though and that’s a lot of money/mess. Plus the kitchen needs replacing.

OP can always put the futility in the basement in the other house and use the current one as a pantry/storage.

Blossomtoes · 18/06/2021 22:26

[quote slippersandprosecco]Example of what you could get in a pretty market town with super fast and regular trains into London and a much better change at getting into outstanding schools. If this isn't to your taste then are also plenty of Edwardian style houses akin to the ones you listed, but bigger for the same price.

People spending that many £££ in London outskirts are fools! Especially for a house that doesn't even have its own parking!

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/80403462#/[/quote]
It’s really dated and the kitchen’s a joke. You’d have to spend a fortune to get that to the standard of the first house OP posted.

notgoodenoug · 18/06/2021 22:26

As pp have pointed out your DC would not be out of place in state school because classmates will be from your street or the one over.
I'd recommend figuring out what house to want to purchase ASAP so you can go and assess the local school - I don't think you can get a feel for them unless you visit. You'll either get a good or bad vibe which can then guide you as to whether you go private.

Twattergy · 18/06/2021 22:24

A good test for how much you love a house is 'would I care if I lived here for 10 years and at the end it was worth the same or less than when I bought it?' If the answer is no I wouldn't mind, and you can afford it without a risky amount of borrowing, then do it. A house is a home. If it goes up in value that nice extra, not the reason for buying it. My DH said we should wait last summer and rent rather than buy because of his predicted Covid house price cash. We saw a house we liked and I pushed to buy not rent. Now I'm feeling smug because prices have risen c 10% in this area since then, and we'd be stuck in a dingy rental whilst prices rise steply around us if we'd followed his advice. I said I was willing to buy and to accept that its value could fall, as we'd made a lot of money on our own sale and it's greedy to expect to make money on every house transaction.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 18/06/2021 22:23

Kids know the difference. I would say from as early as 10 years' old. I have teenagers. Trust me, they know.

The majority of houses in the catchment will be pretty similar to this one. It's London. The rest of the houses on this street are worth in the same range, and in the next street too, and the one after that. It's likely to be mid range in value, not way higher than most. There will be a mix, yes. There will be some flats in catchment, and some social housing, probably, and maybe some detached 6-beds. For many people, that is a plus of London state schooling. There are no state schools in areas of London where a family house costs £1.6m where a child, or teen, is going to stand out for living in a family house.

DroopyClematis · 18/06/2021 22:23

The trouble is, so many have predicted a London crash .
Economics will suggest that profiteers will be crawling around london now and will be stocking up to sell on, later , at a massive profit.
Just an opinion.

Camdenish · 18/06/2021 22:22

You won’t “need” to go down the private Ed route in MH.

Plenty of children will be in bigger houses and some in smaller. Some in flats, some in private rented, some in social housing but plenty in that sort of house. Some families may well have that Hitchin or Scottish house as their holiday home.
I think I prefer house 2 just because the futility room is in the basement. The washing machine is likely to be on floorboards in the other house which makes more noise. Concrete floor and out of the way would be my preference.

Rhinothunder · 18/06/2021 22:19

Lovely house. Go for it. Where we are in London the property market for houses is going crazy last few weeks. Prices had dipped a bit and i think now people realise it's probably at a low and going to Go back up/ getting called back to office etc etc. Now things are going to sealed bids before they've even hit righmove.

TatianaBis · 18/06/2021 22:19

My house is worth £300k now grin. It's much bigger than those houses with 1/4 acre garden. But then it's not in London.

Where is it? I’d love to know.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 18/06/2021 22:18

What's with the focus on persuading OP to pay for private school instead?

London state schools will be full of kids in similar houses and similar situations. Many/most London state schools already have good wraparound. Or OP can pay for an after-school and holiday nanny if she wants. Many people prefer to have kids in state for primary and focus on private for secondary instead. Some people actively want their kids in a state environment for primary for political or emotional reasons.

OP can choose private or state if she wants, but a lot of the reasons being put forward for private are... Let's politely say, making a distorted representation of reality.

Jangle33 · 18/06/2021 22:18

Completely disagree @Diverseopinions there are a lot of kids in London in houses like the one the OP might buy who are at state school. There are also a lot who aren’t. That’s a plus point, a amhe of society.

Frankly in this part of London you’d be looked down at private school at a £1.6m house. Certainly one of he smaller ones.

One of the many reasons supporting the state sector is a positive thing in my opinion.

TatianaBis · 18/06/2021 22:18

I'm trying to sell my London flat and have dropped the price by almost a fifth. Agents tell me houses are also dipping now

It’s not true, they’re just cheering you up.

Thecazelets · 18/06/2021 22:18

I love these threads. Everyone pointing out that you could buy a castle in Royston Vasey for a fraction of the price. And yet we stupid Londoners will keep on buying these massively overpriced houses and then selling them on to even stupider people for even more money...why won't we listen?!

UrbanRambler · 18/06/2021 22:18

@MiloAndEddie

Well that’s a stealth brag if ever I saw one Grin
Yep. Like the people on Location, Location, who are struggling to find what they want for £1m or more... usually youngish couples, with high salaries and/or huge deposit/inheritance money, who can't find what they're looking for, despite being internet savvy. Hmm
BareGrylls · 18/06/2021 22:17

@Grellbunt

Look at what house 2 sold for in 1997

300k

Shit

My house is worth £300k now Grin. It's much bigger than those houses with 1/4 acre garden. But then it's not in London. I
littlejalapeno · 18/06/2021 22:16

Both houses have north east gardens though. Means they won’t get much sunlight at the back except from May to august. Either house would be lovely, on the other side of the street! However if you don’t care about garden orientation, ignore this comment.

califragalistico · 18/06/2021 22:16

@Diverseopinions I lived in that area. Everyone I knew sent their kids to state schools cos they're excellent. They spent the cash on the house not private schooling. It's the norm there.

blueshoes · 18/06/2021 22:16

@BuffySummersReportingforSanity

Your kids are going to be living in a massively more expensive home than many of their friends. I wonder how that will play out. Will it be awkward for them?

As PP say... It's just a normal house. Most kids don't have a clue what a 4bed in a popular London area costs, and don't care anyway. Why should they? Most of the state school primary kids in the tiny catchment will live in similar - some smaller, some bigger. The Scottish castle or commuter pile some people are keen for OP to buy instead would be much more of an issue.

Kids know the difference. I would say from as early as 10 years' old. I have teenagers. Trust me, they know.
Motnight · 18/06/2021 22:15

That is a lovely house!

Grellbunt · 18/06/2021 22:15

@SunglassesSeventy

Gorgeous house, go for it!

I've always been curious about people who can afford to spend that much on a house. Where does the money come from? Inheritance? Bought somewhere expensive years ago then sold?

I can't wrap my brain around being able to afford a house of that price yet still needing to go to work. You could buy a house for £650k elsewhere in the UK and then have 1 million left over to spend on whatever you like!

Sorry, know this isn't what the thread's about, I'm just incredibly curious re how people afford this level of house.

But obviously the money is just borrowed? You pay off the debt .... you wouldn't get that money as an unsecured loan. Or am I missing sth?
Squirrelblanket · 18/06/2021 22:15

For the millionth time, I think I'm so glad I don't live in London. Grin

blueshoes · 18/06/2021 22:14

[quote Yazhi]@highlighteryellow No, we are first time buyers in the U.K. We've been here 5 years on a work contract that's just been made local. Up until now work has paid our rent. We now have two little kids one of whom will need a reception place next year. I'm really not sure how true it is but a lot of the other mums say getting a reception place at a great school in London is very tricky. DH reckons we could send them private but that seems like more of a waste of money to me than just paying for a house now in a good catchment. [/quote]
If both of you are working ft, it makes sense to pay for private school with wrap around facilities and great clubs on site, so that you do not have to ferry. Smaller class sizes means problems are spotted earlier. Private schools (but that is not always the case) also understand working parents better and don't operate on the basis that you can drop everything to turn up at their doorstep any time of the day.

Complaints are dealt with because you are the paying parent. If not, you can vote with your feet. The culture of interaction between the school and the parents is completely different from state schools.

If anything, you are paying for convenience when you send the children to private schools and also great all rounded education of course, which is one of the UK's best exports.

TatianaBis · 18/06/2021 22:13

@Yazhi

We don't have a car so parking not really an issue.

@SunglassesSeventy We aren't anything special! We both have science degrees. We were offered the opportunity to move here as part of a secondment package that included our living costs. I've been ploughing away our salaries for the years we've been on secondment. We gambled and took jobs with a start-up that was venture capital funding. In lieu of higher salaries we got lots of stock. The company sold and we make quite a lot off the stock. The U.K. can't hold onto its young science talent and we cashed in on that. Our roles were empty for a year before we took them.

Good thinking Yazhi,

But don’t listen to your DH or anyone who tells you houses in London will go down in the near future they will not.

Flats in central London fell because lockdown drove people to buy houses in leafy roads like this. Houses will continue to rise as people are still trying to move and there is not much inventory.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 18/06/2021 22:13

Your kids are going to be living in a massively more expensive home than many of their friends. I wonder how that will play out. Will it be awkward for them?

As PP say... It's just a normal house. Most kids don't have a clue what a 4bed in a popular London area costs, and don't care anyway. Why should they? Most of the state school primary kids in the tiny catchment will live in similar - some smaller, some bigger. The Scottish castle or commuter pile some people are keen for OP to buy instead would be much more of an issue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread