Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you let your child be a model?

84 replies

Strawberriesonasummersevening · 18/06/2021 15:00

This week I was approached at the local
supermarket by a lady and asked if I wanted to put dd, almost 3 through for some modelling projects in the the capital (we live abroad)
She gave me her details and all is legitimate, and are well known and reputable, they had an advert scouting for child models for this campaign.
Spoke to friends and some of them have done similar or would be happy to, given the opportunity.
Aibu to feel weird about it? I’m not sure it makes me 100% comfortable or am I being too uptight and it’s just a bit of fun?
I don’t want DD’s worth to be based on looks, have to say, she is beautiful to me inside and out, for many different reasons, but she has quite a unique look (reddish hair and blue eyes) and I’m quite surprised they asked, as looking at their work, the child models have a different look.
She’s contacted me twice since, would you do it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MaryShelley1818 · 03/02/2024 15:56

Absolutely never in a million years. Children should be spending their spare time playing and going on adventures. Not learning their value lies in their looks.

imaginationhasfailedme · 03/02/2024 15:51

If the scout even mentioned that they'd be doing a portfolio of pictures, run away. However, if they're an actual agency scouting for looks like your daughter to fill a gap in their books, then fine.

However (again!), if you're not happy with your daughter's image being out there, then 100% no way. If she successfully books jobs (it's the casting team who decides that anyway, not the agent) then those images will be out there forever somewhere.

People can be vicious. You'll need skin like teflon.

Octipus · 03/02/2024 15:41

May i ask which agency you worked with?

Skysblue · 21/06/2021 13:15

No I wouldn’t. Because you don’t own the finished photo which can be used in any way and may follow them around for years

For example, I know book cover designers who buy a stock photo of a model, modify it to make them a sexy demonic wolf or whatever then make advertising campaigns using the image. Those models are adults and knew what they were selling. Let your family keep the rights to your daughters face until she’s an adult and can choose.

Also the pay is crap, models mix with unhealthy body image types and it leads to unhealthy obsession with appearance that I wouldn’t want for my child.

ChunkyKitKat123 · 19/06/2021 20:45

I've always been quite suspicious of this "scouting" business. Surely if an agency is looking for models they'd put a call out or advert of some kind...I'm sure there wouldn't be a shortage of applicants as modelling is very popular. Or they'd at least be scouting at showbiz-type events, like the PP whose child was scouted at a dance event. But randomly approaching someone at a supermarket...it just doesn't seem like something a reputable business would do.

Regarding the paedophile "hysteria"...it's really not "hysteria". I don't want to disclose my exact job but I've worked in the criminal justice system and it's disturbingly common for these types of people to take perfectly innocent photos of kids from the Internet (e.g. photogenic kids from blogs and Instagram) then doctor them to make them dodgy. One guy had superimposed a child's face and his own face onto images of child abuse, so that it looked like he was abusing this particular child. It's horrific.
The thing is, even if the agency is legit and the photo shoots are done in the safest way possible, you still have no control over what random people do with the images once they're in the public domain. It's something every parent needs to consider when making photos of their child public, even if it's just on Facebook or whatever.

LushHeaven · 19/06/2021 14:45

My kids did it for a while. Made a bit of money. The travel up to London was too much in the end. Very last minute and not workable around work.

I would be concerned at being 'scouted' - which company does she work for? I'd be more concerned it's a scam tbh. Lots of scam companies say they have big campaigns then get people to go to portfolio shoots (which are not necessary for children - the model agencies do their own), and then charge ££££ without an actual job at the end.

TheFnozwhowasmirage · 19/06/2021 13:17

Money wise,mine earned £10 an hour for fitting work,£40 an hour for photographic. But this was 15 years ago.They worked almost every week,but don't remember any of it as they were so young. Dd2 was headhunted by one company before she was born,and I did say that she/he might not have the temperament for modelling,but turns out that she did. Jobs were assigned with short notice,but I was self employed and on maternity leave,so it wasn't a problem for us. They were earning more per hour than I was. The only times it felt remotely weird was when Dd1 was a fitting model for baby bikinis. I did make my opinion on the idea known. Also,when she was in a fashion shoot for prams and there was a model mother cooing over my baby,that felt a bit odd. Other than that it was fine.
I did some modelling as an adult,and it isn't glamorous or exciting,but not many jobs are.

Annehedonia · 18/06/2021 20:19

@CthulhuInDisguise

I might do, but I would make sure that any money made from it was put aside for the child when they are older. But I do know someone who has had all four of her children modelling, almost from birth, and has used their earnings to finance new cars, house renovations and holidays (with and without children). I can't get my head around that. It seems a bit exploitative. She works herself, as does her DP, but she is open about the money being from the modelling, posting stuff on Insta like "new kitchen tiles thanks to Megan's shoot with Next" and so on.
That's disgusting. Hugely exploitative.
CthulhuInDisguise · 18/06/2021 20:14

I might do, but I would make sure that any money made from it was put aside for the child when they are older. But I do know someone who has had all four of her children modelling, almost from birth, and has used their earnings to finance new cars, house renovations and holidays (with and without children). I can't get my head around that. It seems a bit exploitative. She works herself, as does her DP, but she is open about the money being from the modelling, posting stuff on Insta like "new kitchen tiles thanks to Megan's shoot with Next" and so on.

blahblahblah321 · 18/06/2021 19:47

No I wouldn't

I was approached when DS was about 3 asking if I'd be interesting in him doing some modelling. I looked into it briefly, but decided to hold off and see if he was interested as a teen - he wasn't.

HelpingJane · 18/06/2021 19:45

My children do, 6 & 8yo.
Not modelling, but they've done TV commercials etc. All good fun. Nothing about their looks have ever been mentioned by anyone.

To clear a few things up...

-No you don't get much notice and it can be a bit 'we say jump and you do it'.

  • It's extremely well regulated. You have to stay with your child at all times, plus have a chaperone to ensure the correct working conditions (not on set too long etc.) Children have their own areas away from adult cast/ crew members.
  • Yes there's waiting around, but this is usually my kids' favourite part 😂 They get to make friends and play with other kids. Their other favourite part is the food!
  • Both children have a nice little nest egg, but I do worry about one getting more than the other.
  • if you're not happy with the job/ role than you don't have to do it. There's lots we wouldn't allow. (swimwear, shows involving crime etc or anything that showed the kids in a bad light.) We avoid adult TV shows completely.
  • I've never met any bratty/ badly behaved kids on shoots. Part of what makes a child a good prospect is being able to listen and follow instructions.
-some roles you don't even see them, voice over jobs and so on.

Neither of my DH are big headed about it, it's just another hobby to them. It's really not the big deal people make it out to be. We've had nothing but brilliant and fun experiences.

HonestlyFuckThis · 18/06/2021 17:38

I considered it for my baby. I wouldn’t for an older child, but for a baby / toddler I think I could have made peace with it. But I think if it gives you an uneasy feeling, that’s your heart telling you something.

IdblowJonSnow · 18/06/2021 17:37

No I don't think I would.
If i did i would never leave their side.

Pengwyn · 18/06/2021 17:35

My cousin did a European campaign for Tampax when she was a pre-teen.

She regrets it now and the money wasn't that great to make it worthwhile.

Very young children are too young to consent and I think it is exploitative.

AmyDudley · 18/06/2021 17:30

A friend of mine's DD was scouted and did some modelling as a teenager, she didn't really enjoy it - she's a very beautiful girl, but quite shy and I think it just wasn't for her.

I don't think I'd want a child as young as 3 doing it - I imagine it is very boring with a lot of sitting around doing nothing and children getting fractious and tired.

NcagainNC · 18/06/2021 17:09

Never

HelloMissus · 18/06/2021 17:07

GreenCrayon you may well be right.
Mine did some huge campaigns so the money was great. I don’t know if we’d have bothered otherwise, except for an initial let’s-see-what-this-is-like try out.

All of mine enjoyed it too. And DD went on to do some acting.

Beamur · 18/06/2021 17:00

I'd try it for a day and see if your DD likes it
Whilst not a model, there are a few pics if DD that were taken professionally and have been sold on(I signed a waiver) and it's been quite interesting seeing them 'in the wild'. They've been used a few times in journals and reports. She's quite striking looking but is quite a few years older now and she might not be automatically recognised from that image. She's amused by seeing it from time to time.

Livebythecoast · 18/06/2021 17:00

I had a similar scenario when my daughter was a little bit older than yours. My DD was very outgoing and photogenic and probably would have enjoyed it. However, it just didn't sit right with me for some reason and I decided against it. I wouldn't judge anyone else though. It's entirely up to the individual.

eurochick · 18/06/2021 16:58

I went to school with someone who was a child model. She was unbearable😄. So on that basis, no.

EdithWeston · 18/06/2021 16:57

One of my DC was scouted, aged about 8, in a perfectly respectable way at a dance event. But as DC was totally uninterested in the idea, we didn't take it forwards.

The main embuggeration, from a friend who did it briefly, is that you have to drop everything to get them to shoots because if you decline even once, it's curtains.

duffeldaisy · 18/06/2021 16:54

(I don't think the paedophilia thing is such an issue (eg. with paedophiles looking at the photos) and you'd be there or have a chaperone at all times. It's more the emphasis on appearance, on compliance, on basically being a child in an adult environment of work. I think unless your child is extremely chilled, it could give them all sorts of psychological problems in the future.

Tobermorie · 18/06/2021 16:53

If it’s legit I’d go for it. The money could be life changing later on.

duffeldaisy · 18/06/2021 16:51

I wouldn't judge anyone who did (and do know a couple of people who have done this with their children (not close friends, so it's never come up but I've heard it on the grape vine)) because I can see how tempting it would be in building up a nest egg.

But I wouldn't personally because I know enough about aspects of the entertainment industry, through friends, to know that it really can be a toxic environment which attracts some quite nasty characters, and I wouldn't want to normalise that whole thing of auditioning, being judged on appearance, being rejected for jobs etc. at such a young age.

Because of that, my kids can do what they want when they're adults (or ideally in their mid-twenties and have properly developed their sense of self and so have the confidence not to deal with any crap), but before 18 I wouldn't allow them to do any kind of professional modelling/acting/singing etc, especially nothing on tv or in media.

Einszwei · 18/06/2021 16:50

As a red headed child I was also scouted. Thankfully my parents said no. I am glad photos of me as a child are not in the public domain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread