Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Short school skirts

282 replies

Kteeb1 · 17/06/2021 16:01

AIBU to think the reason given to me for girls not wearing skirts at school is worrying? So just been called by the school. Apparently all parents have been because girls skirts are very short and it's against school policy. I can only assume the little tyke (13) is rolling her school skirt up because it's not short when she leaves the house and ill sort it when she gets in, but I am concerned with what the female teacher said to me. The reason why the girls skirts shouldn't be short is because male teachers and other boys may feel uncomfortable. Also out of school grounds the girls might be attacked. And young girls must learn to protect their dignity. I have no problem with a uniform and following it, but if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching? And why are we saying what a person wears means they may be attacked. I did ask if any girls had been attacked and I didn't get an answer. I just think it's a really bad message that girls have to change what they wear for those reasons.

OP posts:
AriadnetheSpider · 17/06/2021 19:42

“ Male teachers are uncomfortable seeing girls in short skirts because of the general illogical consensus that all men are out to prey on women. They don't want to put themselves at risk of accidentally coming into contact with the arse cheeks of a young girl who has deliberately broken the rules and has them on show. ”

Agree with this. My DH is a teacher, in a primary not secondary school thank goodness. His colleague was called a paedo (by a parent!) for simply disciplining a student. Technically because it was online and in public view it as illegal (malicious use of communications or some such offence) but he didn’t go to the police. I would have.

Male teachers definitely don’t have an easy time of it. Obviously there are rotten apples in the barrel but the majority just want to do their jobs as best they can.

HarrisMcCoo · 17/06/2021 19:41

@ProfPickles

I'm female and work in a school and the girls in short skirts make me feel uncomfortable.

They're so short I see one of their bums every single day and these are children. I don't want to see the bums of children and girls wearing skirts so short that if you walk behind them up the stairs you can see up.

I feel like the boys uniforms present them as smart preparing for the work place (one argument made for a smart uniform) and the girls does them a disservice because mini skirts so short you can see bum cheeks every day isn't good enough. The women working there wouldn't be allowed to wear them so why are our girls seen as less important?

I'm always a bit confused when people stick up for girls wearing tiny skirts, it just seems like an obvious way girls are sexualised from a young age

I agree with your logic here.
Lulola · 17/06/2021 19:39

I don’t think they phrased it well but I agree with the making others uncomfortable comment. I am a teacher and so many of our girls have their bums hanging out and you can see everything when stood at the front of the room, it’s not a nice conversation to have with a child, but if I don’t then I have to feel uncomfortable because I am being flashed. My colleague in the next room feels more uncomfortable than me so asks me to speak to the girls, he doesn’t feel uncomfortable because he “can’t control” himself but because he worries what the response will be. He has had a girl ask why he was looking before when he has asked her to adjust how she is sitting, he asked because he doesn’t want to see anything....and he is gay. Her mum ended up reporting him for commenting. A blanket ban prevents all of this.

Trytothinkofaname · 17/06/2021 19:39

@DysmalRadius

Surely, if the problem is so endemic, the solution is to change the uniform. Is there not an option to phase out skirts altogether?
Trouble with this is finding girls trousers that fit all girls. In general there is a far, far wide range of bottom shapes for girls than boys....plus add in pre-pubescent and puberty - and you have probably 50% of girls not fitting "standard" school trousers. Boys have far less variation in bum/hip/waist/thigh ratio
faithfulbird20 · 17/06/2021 19:37

Should they really be teaching? No.

But you don't know whose a paedophile and whose not. Some men still have this attitude that if girls wear short skirts they're asking for it. They want it. But how on earth would we find out these men are like that? Once they've committed the crime?

I wouldn't wear all my gold in public either. I've seen school boys take photos of girls arses when they bend down etc and what not. Posting it online etc. When teachers can't do anything coz it's out there. Whose at loss? The poor child whose been exposed and has to deal with the mental trauma.

Puffalicious · 17/06/2021 19:35

@GuyFawkesDay

My DD has the playsuit shorts style "summer dress". So much better for her. Wish they'd been around when I was a kid.

Agree totally the fact that it's the done thing to show off your body to the point of indecency is worrying. Welcome to the world where many girls seem to think they should live up to "Instagram" lifestyles and standards which we know bear no resemblance to reality.

Despite over a century of feminism we appear to be going backwards in some respects.

I regularly espouse this sentiment: it's so depressing.
WestendVBroadway · 17/06/2021 19:35

Wow, this must be a keeping up,with the Jones' type thing in other areas. I work next to a secondary school and the girls roll their skirts up, but only to the length shown in the Aussie pics. I have never seen any girls from any of the 5 secondaries in my town wear their skirts even shorter.

mbosnz · 17/06/2021 19:31

I think different generations have different definitions and ways of expressing 'self respect'.

This generation, as far as I can tell, is saying that it's their choice how to wear their clothes, and if others have a problem with that, that's on them - be it older males, females, or young men.

A bit like the sixties?

I've got to the point where I've pointed out potential issues, and now it's their choices, their consequences. (When it comes to being pinged for uniform, especially after I've tried to reinforce the code, and been undermined by the school, not when it comes to pervy bastards catcalling or worse).

Keepingitreal14 · 17/06/2021 19:28

Our school has solved the battle by removing skirts from the uniform list completely. Both boys and girls have to wear trousers.

Hallyup6 · 17/06/2021 19:25

Male teachers are uncomfortable seeing girls in short skirts because of the general illogical consensus that all men are out to prey on women. They don't want to put themselves at risk of accidentally coming into contact with the arse cheeks of a young girl who has deliberately broken the rules and has them on show.

I regularly see girls walk past while I'm waiting for my daughter outside school, and am subjected to seeing a heck of a lot more than I should have to. I don't understand how some girls have their skirts as short as they do because there's only two skirts that they're allowed to buy and one place that sells them. The lady that works there doesn't even sell shorter length skirts without seeing the child.

Some girls need to learn a little self respect.

GrimDamnFanjo · 17/06/2021 19:21

Our school moved to kilts which makes rolling up harder.

GuyFawkesDay · 17/06/2021 19:21

My DD has the playsuit shorts style "summer dress". So much better for her. Wish they'd been around when I was a kid.

Agree totally the fact that it's the done thing to show off your body to the point of indecency is worrying. Welcome to the world where many girls seem to think they should live up to "Instagram" lifestyles and standards which we know bear no resemblance to reality.

Despite over a century of feminism we appear to be going backwards in some respects.

Ickythefirebobby · 17/06/2021 19:20

@NeverDropYourMoonCup

I don't particularly enjoy seeing teenage girls' inner thighs and gussets when they sit down/their arse cheeks when they go upstairs either. Sometimes I see even more than that, not because I'm looking with malevolent intent but because it's in my line of sight, I can't work blindfolded and frankly, it's all out on display for anybody to see anyhow.

If I chose to deliberately shorten my clothes so that was what everybody saw at work, neither they nor their parents would appreciate it.

Well said.
Mugsen · 17/06/2021 19:20

I support the school in this respect. There are plenty of ways of expressing yourself without having your bits hanging out.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 17/06/2021 19:16

I got my arse handed to me on a plate (no pun intended) on another thread about the amount of bottoms, pants and flashing of vulvas in primary schools and how girls should wear cycling shorts if they insist on doing handstands and cartwheels every 5 minutes.

Boys uniforms are smart. We never see boys pants or penises on display in schools so why is it ok for girls to be dressed inappropriately?

I think the answer is to get rid of skirts in schools. Trousers are far more practical anyway. At primary school girls could play freely. At secondary school girls would look professional, getting ready for work.

ohnothisagain · 17/06/2021 19:12

@WestendVBroadway the girls in your pictures are wearing skirts. The girls at our local secondary have their bumcheeks on display (you can see they are wearing thongs and identify the colour when they walk past).
Most people would feel awkward seeing this - its comparable to boys wearing speedos to school - clearly inappropriate

Frlrlrubert · 17/06/2021 19:11

Those Australian skirts are loooong.

If you google 'stretch black micro mini skirt' you'll see what girls at my school are wearing.

Grellbunt · 17/06/2021 19:10

Ok, so it's for the girls.

Are we not concerned about a prevailing mindset among girls where competition revolves around who can expose as much flesh as possible? Is that not a bit weird, and worrying?

DameAlyson · 17/06/2021 19:07

You will find that schools in warmer climates like Australia, have uniforms that are generally much shorter than in UK.

The skirts the girls in those photos are wearing are nothing like the type of skirt referred to in this thread.

Mymapuddlington · 17/06/2021 19:06

Those skirts are the length we’d roll our skirts to as teens, the skirts now literally flash knickers and bum with every step

GuyFawkesDay · 17/06/2021 19:06

Its absolutely social with other girls. Not for boys. Its the queen bee "alpha female thing". Ditto makeup. Its never for the boys

Same with the lads and play fighting, peacocking behaviour. Top dog determination.

As soon as they hit teens it's a competition as to who's at the top of the social pile all of a sudden. Add hormones, brain "rewiring" and everything else and it's a heady mix.

I'm a big proponent of the plain black loose fitting trousers for all. Polo shirts and sweatshirt. Easy, practical, comfortable.

bonbonours · 17/06/2021 19:06

It's not necessarily to attract attention from boys, it can just be to fit in with the crowd. Girls can be cruel and make fun of someone who is wearing their skirt at an appropriate length.

While I totally agree that girls and boys shouldn't be told that wearing revealing clothes is "asking to be attacked, harrassed or raped" I do think it's acceptable for schools to require decency and nobody (male or female) should be showing underwear or their bum at school.

LoopTheLoops · 17/06/2021 19:05

The skirts I’ve seen are much much shorter than the ones in those pics!

Grellbunt · 17/06/2021 19:04

Skirts in those Australia pics are much longer than what we are talking about here.

WestendVBroadway · 17/06/2021 19:03

You will find that schools in warmer climates like Australia, have uniforms that are generally much shorter than in UK. I assume that our Antipodean male friends have more self control.
Also I went to a girls school in the 80s, we all rolled our waistbands over , and there was not a male anywhere in sight!

Short school skirts
Short school skirts
Short school skirts