Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Short school skirts

282 replies

Kteeb1 · 17/06/2021 16:01

AIBU to think the reason given to me for girls not wearing skirts at school is worrying? So just been called by the school. Apparently all parents have been because girls skirts are very short and it's against school policy. I can only assume the little tyke (13) is rolling her school skirt up because it's not short when she leaves the house and ill sort it when she gets in, but I am concerned with what the female teacher said to me. The reason why the girls skirts shouldn't be short is because male teachers and other boys may feel uncomfortable. Also out of school grounds the girls might be attacked. And young girls must learn to protect their dignity. I have no problem with a uniform and following it, but if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching? And why are we saying what a person wears means they may be attacked. I did ask if any girls had been attacked and I didn't get an answer. I just think it's a really bad message that girls have to change what they wear for those reasons.

OP posts:
Miljea · 17/06/2021 22:38

I'm a HCP. A bit long in the tooth, granted! (57).

At times during my long career I have been occasionally faced with/confronted with (90-95% male) patients who pretty much refuse to wear appropriate covering for their imaging examinations.

It's always 'Okay, could you pop on this gown?'- him 'Nah, love, I'm easy!' (Strips off).

Well, guess what? I'm not and nor should the patient following you. Put the gown on, mate. It's not all about how you want to project.

Why is that any different to requiring female pupils to dress in a way that doesn't make others feel uncomfortable? You can wear a really quite short skirt without being gynaecological, miss.

PolkadotSloth · 17/06/2021 22:31

That's horrendous. I am genuinely shocked any parent would allow that. Shock

StoneofDestiny · 17/06/2021 22:29

Polkadot
Many hundreds of parents!
It can be eye popping driving passed schools - no way if that skirt suitable for work, but it will also ride up even further when walking, climbing stairs and sitting at a desk.

Grellbunt · 17/06/2021 22:27

Erm loads of folk???!!!

We are the nation of Love Island and Naked Attraction, remember?

PolkadotSloth · 17/06/2021 22:26

@StoneofDestiny

It’s these skirts that are not rolled up / they are bought too short.
Who is letting their daughter go to school dressed like that though? ShockConfused
StoneofDestiny · 17/06/2021 22:24

It’s these skirts that are not rolled up / they are bought too short.

Short school skirts
PolkadotSloth · 17/06/2021 21:56

@Kteeb1

I think my problem is by saying short skirts make male teachers uncomfortable, rather than all teachers, it is sexulising them. Saying that a girl may be attacked because her skirt is short is both untrue and dangerous. As I said I have no issues with a uniform policy being enforced. I have just had a discussion with said child and confirmed this, and confirmed that I wouldn't be able to wear what I am wearing (an off the shoulder top) at work. But not because my male colleagues wouldn't be able to control themselves or I may get raped on the tube, but because its not professional. If I get raped on the tube its nothing to do with what I was wearing. Sarah Everard was wearing a coat and hat and gloves. It's a bad message to give our young people, boys and girls.
I agree completely. The way the issue is framed matters in terms of forming young people's view of why something is appropriate or not, and therefore how they will assess acceptable behaviour in future situations.

Saying this to young girls may makes them believe they are to blame if harrassed or assaulted while wearing "skimpy" clothes. Saying this to young boys may make them think it's more acceptable to harrass or assault girls wearing such clothing, outside school.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/06/2021 21:27

The reason is wrong but there are 14 years old at my local high school literally with their arses hanging out. No tights. Its absolutely ridiculous.

I just think wtf are their parents thinking.

ProfPickles · 17/06/2021 21:11

Is anyone else interested in putting together some points and writing a letter that we can send out to our local schools?

I've always been the type to be upset about this sort of thing but never the type to act upon it. Working in a school has made this a real issue because I'm seeing up so many girls' skirts and I think it's a really important issue to tackle.

I've been considering this for around 6 months now and any support would be fantastic. I've been put off due to being a member of staff and not wanting to have my name mentioned but now I'm thinking sod it let's actually get out there and try to make a change.

I feel like there's a good chance that a well written argument will be listened to and I'd love it if others got on board and sent it out in their local area instead of my trust alone

cocoloco987 · 17/06/2021 21:04

Dd wore shorts all throughout primary, mostly 'boy shorts' the longer cargo type with pockets on the side. Unfortunately at high school these are not allowed so instead she wears gym skorts. These have none of the issues mentioned as you can't see pants or bum walking upstairs thanks to the built in cycle shorts but the entire thing is incredibly short unlike her original shorts of choice that she isn't allowed. If they want modesty they should allow shorts IMO

iwishiwasonhol · 17/06/2021 20:32

ahh i remember getting a phone call from the head of year, that my dd 's skirt was too short ,me" what a shame as it was bought from your school recommended stockist and that was the length it came in for her waist size" not my fault shes tall and a bigger waist size would have fell down to her ankles

HarrisMcCoo · 17/06/2021 20:27

@DameAlyson

You will find that schools in warmer climates like Australia, have uniforms that are generally much shorter than in UK.

The skirts the girls in those photos are wearing are nothing like the type of skirt referred to in this thread.

Exactly. We are talking micro micro short.
Pottedpalm · 17/06/2021 20:24

Those Australian uniforms are modest! We are talking about skirts made of a tube of elastic fabric barely skimming the bum cheeks.

MadeOfStarStuff · 17/06/2021 20:07

YANBU to be concerned at the wording. Skirts should be the correct length because it’s the uniform policy and because nobody wants to see anyone else’s private parts in public.

Not because it’s distracting for males (funny how lesbians generally manage to control themselves but nobody expects boys/men to do so).

Saying girls shouldn’t wear short skirts because it distracts boys or theyre putting themselves at risk is victim blaming.

Beannag · 17/06/2021 20:06

I think saying it's distracting for male teachers is an unfair rationale, as demonstrated by this thread it makes many teachers uncomfortable, and going to assume the overwhelming majority isn't because of anything sexual.

Pottedpalm · 17/06/2021 20:04

@NeverDropYourMoonCup

I don't particularly enjoy seeing teenage girls' inner thighs and gussets when they sit down/their arse cheeks when they go upstairs either. Sometimes I see even more than that, not because I'm looking with malevolent intent but because it's in my line of sight, I can't work blindfolded and frankly, it's all out on display for anybody to see anyhow.

If I chose to deliberately shorten my clothes so that was what everybody saw at work, neither they nor their parents would appreciate it.

Spot on! But we are not allowed to say ‘I prefer not to see your pants when you are sitting in class!’, because then we are accused of being a pervert.
HarrisMcCoo · 17/06/2021 20:02

[quote ProfPickles]@Branleuse of course it's a battle that can be won, there'll be plenty of backlash from the girls but that doesn't mean we give up on them and allow them to continue flashing their bums and underwear in public. We have a responsibility as adults to do what is best for children, women and girls have always been on a back foot to men and this is just one small part of it we have the power to change [/quote]
Bloody hell, give this woman a 🏅 she is talking a ridiculous amount of common sense.

I agree it's to do with dress code only, flashing parts of the body wouldn't be acceptable in the work place. Teaching staff shouldn't feel uncomfortable doing their job (male or female).

I have seen them at lunch time when I have been getting shopping at the supermarket, skirts so short surely completely unnecessary. Fair enough in their private time but not in school hours.

Christmasfairy2020 · 17/06/2021 20:01

Tbh some men like the sexy school uniform etc so the girls wearing skirts so short and a tie and blazer etc is effectively the one sold in Ann summers. Our school skirt has to be a specific skirt and to the knee

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 17/06/2021 20:00

"Trouble with this is finding girls trousers that fit all girls. In general there is a far, far wide range of bottom shapes for girls than boys....plus add in pre-pubescent and puberty - and you have probably 50% of girls not fitting "standard" school trousers. Boys have far less variation in bum/hip/waist/thigh ratio"

As long as schools don't insist that the trousers are bought from a school supplier, which always provide woefully inadequately shaped garments, it's easy to get a pair of black trousers that fit the child and are suitable for school.

Soontobe60 · 17/06/2021 20:00

@HarryBlackberry1

My daughter is in sixth form, and was telling me yesterday that they get repeatedly told not to wear short skirts, because the male teachers see it as a distraction. Like a previous poster said, should they be in the profession then? I'm a teacher myself, and think this is bizarre. Mind, I hate to see horrendously short skirts. It does make me feel uneasy.
So by your own admission, if you saw someone in an extremely short skirt you’d feel uneasy - and most likely be distracted. Therefore, should you also be in the teaching profession? Male teachers being distracted doesn’t mean they suddenly find themselves aroused at the sight. It means they may lose concentration momentarily, may find it awkward to walk up the school stairs if there’s a girl in front of him in a short skirt so choose to turn round and go back down.
Beannag · 17/06/2021 19:58

When I was at school I was so relived when they became stricter with skirt length. Peer pressure made me roll mine up far shorter than I was comfortable with, but being 13 I didn't have the fight in me to stand up for myself, it just made life easier to conform. I do fail to see why it's something worth fighting for, is there any benefit for short skirts in school?

faithfulbird20 · 17/06/2021 19:55

As a female teacher, I feel uncomfortable around girls who wear short skirts where I can see their arse. Not needed.

GertietheGherkin · 17/06/2021 19:45

My daughter's never had the opportunity to even think of doing this... Their schools uniform policy was the skirt had to be 6 inches from the ankle. They were pleated too. Never saw a buttock or anything on show ever on the school run.

DolphinFC · 17/06/2021 19:44

" I assume that our Antipodean male friends have more self control."

Or better mothers.

Minezatea · 17/06/2021 19:43

I think it is indeed odd tp focus on males feeling uncomfortable when the reality is that most people are uncomfortable when they see girls bums or pants as their skirts are so short - I know I am.