Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Short school skirts

282 replies

Kteeb1 · 17/06/2021 16:01

AIBU to think the reason given to me for girls not wearing skirts at school is worrying? So just been called by the school. Apparently all parents have been because girls skirts are very short and it's against school policy. I can only assume the little tyke (13) is rolling her school skirt up because it's not short when she leaves the house and ill sort it when she gets in, but I am concerned with what the female teacher said to me. The reason why the girls skirts shouldn't be short is because male teachers and other boys may feel uncomfortable. Also out of school grounds the girls might be attacked. And young girls must learn to protect their dignity. I have no problem with a uniform and following it, but if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching? And why are we saying what a person wears means they may be attacked. I did ask if any girls had been attacked and I didn't get an answer. I just think it's a really bad message that girls have to change what they wear for those reasons.

OP posts:
StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind · 19/06/2021 11:05

@Menora I probably shouldn't but that did make me laugh, your DD and her friends sound great 😂

Menora · 19/06/2021 11:01

@Grellbunt

My DD is 16 this is the email we had

We have had some interesting variations in uniform since returning to school and this has mainly been with female students. The main issue is the length of skirt that the girls are wearing, and they are completely inappropriate as well as being very tight fitting. We have also seen a surge of tight- fitting tops that are also not appropriate for a school setting. Other items that are appearing are, leggings, trainers, designer jumpers with large logos across the chest, hoodies and boys not wearing ties. All students have been made fully aware of the correct dress code for Sixth Form, and could I ask you to reinforce the importance of dressing in the correct fashion in a professional setting. If we continue to see flaunting of guidance, which can be found on the link below, then students will be asked to return home to change to the appropriate attire.

In person the teacher was pretty angry and the girls felt upset by how he spoke to them - he didn’t speak to the hoody wearing boys in the same manner. Hence they have started a feminist anti men club 🥴

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind · 19/06/2021 10:58

@Grellbunt

Back to the OP - I am actually stunned that in this day and age any school would mention males rather than just saying inappropriate full stop.
I agree. To say it's inappropriate and not suitable for wearing to school is all that needed to be said.
Grellbunt · 19/06/2021 10:56

Back to the OP - I am actually stunned that in this day and age any school would mention males rather than just saying inappropriate full stop.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind · 19/06/2021 10:54

I agree @Puffalicious that it's really hard to actually come up with the answer. Perhaps at times the lack of dialogue doesn't helps- schools (not just schools but that's what we're discussing here) are very good at setting out rules without giving the reasoning. So if a reasonable uniform could be agreed and a discussion about why it's important to stick to it because of levelling up it may help perhaps?

The polo shirts/sweatshirt with trousers/trainers was the most practical uniform we had and it was cheap. Your school does sound reasonable- I do think blazers/ties look stupid though especially on the younger ones but that's just me 😂

I definitely think schools opening up more of a dialogue with pupils and parents and discussing what would be a uniform that the kids would be happy to wear, that they would stick to wearing and the reasons for this and that is also cheap would help. Allow plain trainers etc- comfy and practical. I think a lot of the time skirts are made shorter partly to rebel against what they see as a horrible uniform so they'll do anything to make it look better (in their eyes of course) or to annoy the school. Give them a bit more say in agreeing a suitable uniform and it might help. They'll always be ones who take the piss but it would be less.

I appreciate its not easy for schools with everything they have to cover though.

Menora · 19/06/2021 10:54

Same discussion with my DD, her skirts too short - she says problem is, you do end up looking ‘dumpy and frumpy’ if you don’t join in so it ends up being a sheep mentality but also MY BODY MY RULES dynamic

What doesn’t help is telling girls it’s because men feel uncomfortable, it honestly enrages them to do it more - girls at DD school have started a feminist group as so outraged at ‘being told what to do by men’ (male HOY) that this pushes them into an angry anti men stance

DD got new skirts - all threatened with suspension otherwise, but all outraged the boys can carry on saying sexualised language and slurs to them now seemingly justified because skirts are short.

Am all for just telling them it’s not the uniform policy - no men need to be cited as the reason

Puffalicious · 19/06/2021 10:32

Strawberrylipstick My school has a plain black policy- trousers/skirt/ v-neck jumper/cardigan / shoes, shirt, tie and a school blazer. However, the blazer is lightweight and is bought from the school for £30-£35. There is then a recycling service- when it gets too small you can wash and swap for a larger one if you wish. Pupils in receipt of school meals get £120 grant towards uniform. PE tshirts are £10 with plain, black shorts.

It's very reasonable. But we still have the issues with disgustingly short skirts. I used to be able to send pupils with such skirts to head of year every day, but it's so endemic it gets impossible to deal with apart from the more outrageous cases and we're now told it affects their 'rights'.

Interestingly, when I started teaching 27 years ago we had a different uniform of polo shirts and sweatshirts with the option of shirt and tie for those who wished. It looked lovely- navy and pale blue- but the joggers were an issue with kids increasingly wearing branded (which is against the whole point of levelling) and this got so bad they changed it to trousers/skirt. We now know where this is going- skirt lengths became the issue!

I don't know the answer.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind · 19/06/2021 07:26

Those stretchy micro skirts are disgusting and have no place in school, the only reasons the school needs to give is that they are breaking uniform rules, and they are making ALL staff feel uncomfortable because it's so difficult for them to challenge this without risking false accusations.

I think issues with uniform work both ways though. Lots of the secondaries round here have adopted blazers, ties, school branded PE kits (and incidentally I noticed on one of their websites that with the schools own PE shorts, the girls shorts were much smaller than the boys which really pissed me off). I'm a big supporter of school uniform because it's a good equaliser and takes away at least one thing that could cause bullying. But the schools themselves are making them ridiculously expensive now and I think it's really unfair on parents- I thought this was meant to be one of the reasons for uniform- that it avoids the competition of wearing expensive brands which leaves the kids from families with less money at a disadvantage. They insist on these expensive school branded uniforms with lots of different items and I don't think it's fair on parents. Schools want the support of parents but they don't make it easy to engage with them when they don't show much consideration for the financial burden they're placing on them with such expensive uniforms.

I think it would be good if schools worked with the pupils and parents and a practical, low cost uniform that the kids were happier to wear would surely be better? One of the secondaries I went to had a good uniform- comfy polo shirts with no tie (I hated ties at my next school), black trousers or skirt (although when I went to secondary in the early 2000s most of the girls wanted to wear trousers), and they also allowed us to wear plain black trainers as well. The only branded thing our parents had to buy was school branded sweatshirts. PE kit was just black shorts/joggers and a white t shirt. So much cheaper and less up its own arse than some of the school uniforms these days.

It was so much more practical and comfy. I don't think kids need to look 'businesslike' in ties ffs, they're schoolkids. They just need to be wearing the same as each other really and not like complete scruffs- it was actually harder to make a polo shirt/sweatshirt combo look as scruffy as creased up shirts that were always coming untucked and ties that were worn in all different styles and that had been modified, usually with crap written all over them. That's what we did at the next secondary I went to and I hated that uniform compared to the first.

Sports and athleisure is a real trend at the moment and I wonder if kids would go for a uniform along those lines and more like the one I had at my first secondary. Schools are right to insist rules are followed and that pupils are dressed appropriately (and decently!) but I don't think they're making life easy for themselves or parents with the uniforms they insist on in the first place.

newtb · 19/06/2021 07:22

Back in the day when Twiggy was a model I had to wear a tunic for school. The skirt length rule was maximum of 3 inches above the knee or, when fashions change - as they did about 1971 - 3 inches below the knee. When kneeling down.

Part of the uniform was a canvas purse belt. It was against the school rules to leave any money in cloakrooms, blazer pockets etc. You put it on just below your diaphragm and then pushed it down to your waist.

Skirt was instantly about 8 inches above the knee. 800 girls of in black mini-skirts. 4 inch heels. We played lacrosse. We looked just like St Trinian's.

The school was direct grant, 20% went to Oxbridge, so it wasn't a question of low aspirations. It was the fashion but thankfully a lot less 'pornified' than today. Knickers were bikini type not thongs, thank God.

Brilliant from a financial pov - I used to make skirts from half a yard of 36-inch wide material, a deep hem and a waistband. About 16 inches in length.

My DM didn't mind, either I was eligible for free school meals so saving money was important.

As many have said, we were expected to judge what was appropriate and stick to it.

Some rebels took great delight once we got to LVth and could wear skirts to delay going into summer uniform and just stop wearing jumper but with a coloured bra so fluorescent that it could be seen from outer space.

Up until about 1969 most bras were white. The Wonderbra only came on the scene in about 1974-5 from memory.

I'm getting old

RoseAndRose · 19/06/2021 06:12

Yes it's sexualisation of girls from a very young age

Yes, telling girls that their skirt lengths are so sexy they bother male teachers and lead to harassment by boys, and that those problems will disappear if only you change) is one of the strongest sexualisation messages there is.

Escapeas · 19/06/2021 00:29

@youvegottenminuteslynn

"Please remind all pupils that skirts more than xx cm above the knee are not appropriate for a school environment and therefore are not accepted within the school's uniform policy." Totally fine .

"Please remind girls that short skirts are distracting and / or uncomfortable to male teachers and pupils therefore are not permitted." Totally not fine.

Surely people can see the difference?

Agree.
DeflatedGinDrinker · 18/06/2021 23:59

Wish our school would say that some of the girls have the tiniest skirts like they are going clubbing.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 18/06/2021 23:54

"Please remind all pupils that skirts more than xx cm above the knee are not appropriate for a school environment and therefore are not accepted within the school's uniform policy." Totally fine .

"Please remind girls that short skirts are distracting and / or uncomfortable to male teachers and pupils therefore are not permitted." Totally not fine.

Surely people can see the difference?

Onlinedilema · 18/06/2021 20:50

Yes it's sexualisation of girls from a very young age.
My dds wore trousers. All the students wore the same PE kit. None of this tight cycling, show your are off, shorts. Baggy proper sports shorts for both boys and girls. School issue track suits were allowed. Again only the standard issue. Loose fitting and practical. It was a very sporty school and both my dds did well at sport. Non of the embarrassment I endure having to wear a PE skirt for PE. I mean for lords sake how could you ever compete seriously whilst wearing a short loose fitting skirt?

HollyGoLoudly1 · 18/06/2021 18:54

@ProfPickles

I'm female and work in a school and the girls in short skirts make me feel uncomfortable.

They're so short I see one of their bums every single day and these are children. I don't want to see the bums of children and girls wearing skirts so short that if you walk behind them up the stairs you can see up.

I feel like the boys uniforms present them as smart preparing for the work place (one argument made for a smart uniform) and the girls does them a disservice because mini skirts so short you can see bum cheeks every day isn't good enough. The women working there wouldn't be allowed to wear them so why are our girls seen as less important?

I'm always a bit confused when people stick up for girls wearing tiny skirts, it just seems like an obvious way girls are sexualised from a young age

I came on to say basically this. I'm a teacher too. I'm all for body confidence and girls wearing what they want, bum cheeks and all. In the appropriate situations.

School is equivalent to their workplace. We're preparing them (apparently) for their future. Boys wear a business casual uniform but the girls uniform can be adapted to something that wouldn't look out of place in a nightclub. It's just not appropriate.

Maireas · 18/06/2021 18:23

It really vexes me, @AriadnetheSpider. These are decent men who just want to do a good job. It troubles me that the clothing is so sexualised. They're young and want to be fashionable. Letters have gone home to parents, to no avail. The head of sixth form is a man and feels anxious about it. The head says if men want to avoid the sixth form area to go round by the other stairs. I would love all girls and women to feel body confident, and would argue strongly about our right to choose and condemn any victim blaming, but it really is a problem.

AriadnetheSpider · 18/06/2021 18:16

“They have stopped 1-2-1 guidance and won't talk to them after class. I don't know a solution.”

This is worrying. Will it get to the stage of all male teachers being chaperoned by a female professional? Will they end up having to wear body cams like the police? It seems like there is already an impact on teaching provision. Also it’s such a shame that your male colleagues @Maireas feel they can’t even look at the girls at all. We had a female teacher who stared over our heads all the time in my high school, and it was really bizarre!

Maireas · 18/06/2021 17:59

I'm in agreement, @sharksarecool.
Even worse, our sixth form don't wear uniform and the hot weather has meant some of them dressing more for the beach than a school. Boob tubes, halter tops, strapless tops, teeny skirts, short shorts. It really is a very sexualised form of dressing and has definitely got worse. Some of my male colleagues say that they don't look at the girls at all, they look above their heads or at the wall behind, so anxious are they not to be accused of perving. They have stopped 1-2-1 guidance and won't talk to them after class. I don't know a solution.

Letclothesbeclothes · 18/06/2021 17:58

@Ozanj

The girls who shorten their skirts do it to get male attention at all or any cost. It is most definitely for the boys so I would punish her by making her wear the trouser option.
Utter rubbish. Many of the girls we spoke to just wanted to look modern, and avoid looking old fashioned. Look at the figures on self-esteem and body positivity amongst teen girls! Girls are saying they don't actually like their bodies, but just want to follow what the high street dictates. They're caught between modesty and marketing. Boys don't come into it.
Letclothesbeclothes · 18/06/2021 17:52

@Kteeb1 any chance you could let me know what school this is?

BarbarianMum · 18/06/2021 17:25

@sharksarecool exactly!

Demortuisnilnisibonum · 18/06/2021 17:21

I hate the fact that some girls do this to make themselves look ‘attractive.’ Most don’t. Most look so much better with knee length skirts. I agree, OP, the wording was insensitive, we must never hold girls accountable for how a man behaves. We must, however, hold them accountable for behaving properly, appropriately and with self-respect. Uniform rules are there for a reason - to prepare them for adult life. It isn’t appropriate in most jobs to flash your knickers, as many PPs have said. I’m a female heterosexual teacher and it makes me uncomfortable to see children’s underwear when they are dressed inappropriately. It makes them look slovenly and as though they have no self-respect. There’s a time and a place for short skirts and school isn’t it. Make her wear trousers.

AriadnetheSpider · 18/06/2021 17:13

@sharksarecool agree with you 1000%.

AriadnetheSpider · 18/06/2021 17:12

With you all the way Prof! My daughter is 3.5, I don’t want this for her. Of course it’s a massive societal issue, but we have to start somewhere.

sharksarecool · 18/06/2021 17:10

Yawn. Im so fed up with this. I'm a straight, female secondary school teacher. The skirt length of some girls makes me feel uncomfortable. Not because it causes me to have uncontrollable sexual urges, but because I just dont want to see someone else's arse hanging out of the bottom of their skirt.

We're all trying to teach boys that its not okay to text random people a picture of their knob or expose themself in public. Why are some people so keen to enshrine girls' rights to expose their underwear to anyone who happens to be walking behind them up the stairs?

When I pull girls up on this, they think I'm being a bitch. But if a male teacher were to pull them up, he'd be branded as a paedo. Please leave male teachers alone. Most of them are doing a bloody good job.