Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Short school skirts

282 replies

Kteeb1 · 17/06/2021 16:01

AIBU to think the reason given to me for girls not wearing skirts at school is worrying? So just been called by the school. Apparently all parents have been because girls skirts are very short and it's against school policy. I can only assume the little tyke (13) is rolling her school skirt up because it's not short when she leaves the house and ill sort it when she gets in, but I am concerned with what the female teacher said to me. The reason why the girls skirts shouldn't be short is because male teachers and other boys may feel uncomfortable. Also out of school grounds the girls might be attacked. And young girls must learn to protect their dignity. I have no problem with a uniform and following it, but if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching? And why are we saying what a person wears means they may be attacked. I did ask if any girls had been attacked and I didn't get an answer. I just think it's a really bad message that girls have to change what they wear for those reasons.

OP posts:
commonsensey · 03/10/2021 17:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Grellbunt · 21/06/2021 16:25

What about just replying

"well why are you showing everyone your bum then?

Hesma · 21/06/2021 15:54

I work in a school and some of the girls roll their skirts ridiculously short. I’ve lost count of the number of times girls have said to me, “ you shouldn’t be looking at my bum” when I’ve asked them to roll them down. That, if anything, may be what makes people feel uncomfortable.

Branleuse · 21/06/2021 12:24

I was discussing it with my dd this morning (who always wears trousers) and she said its usually the other girls who choose to roll them up. The boys dont seem to care or have an opinion, but that most of the girls think the shorter skirts look better than the knee length ones which make them "look like nuns"

Admittedly the schools round here generally have kilt style skirts which are hard to roll up (which is the point of them) and are definitely more along the lines of the pic of the australian school skirts above, or only a bit shorter than that.

LakieLady · 20/06/2021 17:56

*Girls have been hoiking up their skirts since long before the current generation of soft-porn music videos.

Two reasons I'd advance for them doing it:

  1. Conformity - everyone else does it
  2. Teenage rebellion - you know that adults don't like it*

Yes, @DdraigGoch, I rolled up my school skirt when I started secondary in 1966. Almost everyone did, and the girls who didn't were regarded as pretty uncool. It was nothing to do with boys, it was a single-sex school, and had an all-female staff until 1970. It was just a fashion thing.

We had to wear regulation navy-blue cotton knickers though and it was specified that they couldn't be bikini knickers (thongs etc weren't a thing then). Which makes me wonder if schools might do better if they included knickers like this www.marksandspencer.com/anti-chafing-shorts-with-cool-comfort/p/clp60165135?color=ROSEQUARTZ#intid=prodColourId-60500299 in their uniform policy? Girls would probably keep their skirts rolled down rather than have those on display!

For reasons I have never understood, enforcing skirt-length at my school was the responsibility of the PE staff. Every now and then, we'd all have to line up in the gym and kneel on the floor, while the teacher walked along with a yardstick and checked that none of our hems were more than 2" off the ground.

When maxi-skirts became fashionable, they introduced a maximum length as well (at least 9" above the ground iirc), so the PE teachers had to monitor those as well.

Menora · 20/06/2021 16:14

I think as young the ‘my body my rules’ is not quite right, this can be seen across all of celebrity culture and it’s no wonder young girls picking it up too. When’s the last time most female ‘celebs’ had their clothes fully on either, this Kardashian culture is based entirely on their bodies. I could be here all day. Body positivity movement is almost always women scantily clad showing off their bodies, even loose women did it!

Then they are taught that you have the right to wear/do/say whatever you like, freedom of speech and expression… no girl should be sexualised or assaulted just for her outfits - men should be able to control themselves

It’s no wonder it’s confusing, I would rather work on positively educating them and building self confidence and esteem rather than all this slut shaming.

lardylegs123 · 20/06/2021 12:49

YABU.

Grellbunt · 20/06/2021 12:39

So it used to be that the bikini scene with Babs Windsor in Carry On was sexist

Now, objecting to women looking like that is sexist

I'm not sure that's progress for women

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 20/06/2021 12:30

@Menora I know it wasn't your thoughts. Apologies if it came across that way.

Mugsen · 20/06/2021 12:13

The my body my rules mantra has gone askew I think. Saw this in the news recently. Who wants to sit eating their burger next to someone with their boobs hanging out. What happened to self respect or respect for others?

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9696457/Wetherspoon-pub-kicked-two-women-flooded-scathing-TripAdvisor-reviews.html

Grellbunt · 20/06/2021 11:55

We have to question why they think that way though.

Menora · 20/06/2021 11:23

@JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn

I was repeating what a 16 year old thinks. Not what I think

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 20/06/2021 11:10

"...problem is, you do end up looking ‘dumpy and frumpy’ if you don’t join in so it ends up being a sheep mentality but also MY BODY MY RULES dynamic"

I wonder what would happen if the boys decided to expose themselves at school? If they sat with their trousers open and their dicks hanging out? Does that fall into the MY BODY MY RULES dynamic? I think not. The school and parents would be up in arms about how disgusting and inappropriate it was. So girls wearing thongs in plain view with their arse cheeks on show should be clamped down on.

Maireas · 19/06/2021 17:40

Yes, that would be odd, @Branleuse. I don't know, I don't teach in a college but I should think they still have to communicate!
I teach in a school, and some men teachers are not doing the 1-2-1 feedbacks with sixth form girls, but colleagues have stepped in.

Branleuse · 19/06/2021 17:15

thats incredible that male staff are refusing to speak to girls dressing in halter necks or boob tubes at a college. Really odd

Pottedpalm · 19/06/2021 14:16

@Maireas

I'm in agreement, *@sharksarecool*. Even worse, our sixth form don't wear uniform and the hot weather has meant some of them dressing more for the beach than a school. Boob tubes, halter tops, strapless tops, teeny skirts, short shorts. It really is a very sexualised form of dressing and has definitely got worse. Some of my male colleagues say that they don't look at the girls at all, they look above their heads or at the wall behind, so anxious are they not to be accused of perving. They have stopped 1-2-1 guidance and won't talk to them after class. I don't know a solution.
So true! I do some tutoring and am amazed at the clothes the girls turn up in, having come straight from the local independent school. One young lady appeared in calf length dress which looked fine until she sat down, revealing thigh high splits, and I mean very high, pactically knicker high 😏
JeffVaderneedsatray · 19/06/2021 13:35

If there is a uniform or a dress code teenagers will rebel against it, it is hardwired into our genes!
I was at an all girls school in the 70s and early eighties. There were no male staff. Our skirts had to touch the floor while we were kneeling. We ALL rolled the waistband because it was the 'thing' to do.
However as I drive DD to school I do see some very inappropriate length skirts - the micro mini lycra ones are the worst. It makes me uncomfortable - I don't WANT to see people's pants or worse. I feel just as uncomfortable when I see young men with their pants showing.
DD's school introduced a kilt style skirt that was supposedly 'impossible' to roll up........ They gave vouchers from the school for the first skirt and the uniform supplier wasn't allowed to sell them unless they long enough . But the girls found a way and there are many girls with blazers longer than their skirts.
I can see why some schools are opting for trousers only - that would be DD's worst nightmare as she has massive sensory issues and can't cope with trousers - she wears tight cycling shorts under her skirt so she can't feel it moving across her legs - and wears leggings or shorts when not at school.
I really don't know what the answer is.

Branleuse · 19/06/2021 13:22

There are seven secondary schools within walking distance from me and honestly, i do see plenty of rolled up skirts from every school that has girls, but rarely anything thats actually obscene.
Even at the girls granmar they do it. Even my dds girlfriend does it and shes gay. I think that assuming they all do it for male attention is just wrong and this insinuation is part of the bloody problem. Assuming schoolgirls are trying to be sexy when theyre 12. We have posts about how primary school girls shouldnt have to wear modesty shorts, but at secondary school its open season for accusations that theyre asking for it.
Miniskirts are not obscene. I love a minidress in the summer sometimes.
If there is a big issue with girls wearing skirts too short, then its one thing to suggest they wear shorts underneath, but quite another to suggest they are trying to be sexy. I dont think its nice to put adult motives onto adolescents

Puffalicious · 19/06/2021 12:47

A false hem sounds brilliant! I can imagine the faces of my pupils!Grin

Agree should be no mention of males/ dress justifying behaviour but it IS sexualised. I object hugely to 12-18 yo showing me their private parts. I feel the same about certain club/festival wear which shows private parts too. It's not a feminist issue, I'm a proud feminist, I just find it distasteful.

Tanith · 19/06/2021 11:47

They used to make us stitch a false hem on the bottom of the skirt during breaktimes if it was too short in the 80s. I just caught the tail end of the late 70s when skirts were below the knee and girls tried to make them longer.
I see one or two schools have long skirts as part of the uniform: Mount Kelly College has long kilts and Casterton College has ankle length grey skirts.

Grellbunt · 19/06/2021 11:35

Well it is a bit weird to complain about being sexualised when you yourself are choosing to wear sth that you know actually displays your bum and underwear during normal activities.

Menora · 19/06/2021 11:25

It feels that way. Uniform rules being broken is the issue, not that skirts are worse than trainers. Yeah you see less flesh with trainers but that’s not the point. Both are breaking the rules. Otherwise it does come across as sexism. No one needs to know who is the worst offender and so descriptive!

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind · 19/06/2021 11:19

@Menora he sounds quite dim tbh. And probably misogynistic if he's treating the boys differently.

He's right about the skirts being too short and that they should all be sticking to uniform rules but to treat them differently from the boys is poor.

Menora · 19/06/2021 11:16

@StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind

They all so angry! I agree that skirts too short and been not happy about it myself but I think he did not express the school policy in a manner that came across that well directly, he very much was some middle aged dude like an angry dad telling them off. Boys breaking uniform too but girls being told off/called out worse due to it being related to sexuality? Not sure

PixieKitten · 19/06/2021 11:08

At the end of the day the students and the uniform represent the school and it's image

I'm not surprised the school aren't happy with girls walking around with their arse cheeks on display

If you were considering sending your child to said school and you see girls walking around looking trashy would you want to send your child there?