Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Short school skirts

282 replies

Kteeb1 · 17/06/2021 16:01

AIBU to think the reason given to me for girls not wearing skirts at school is worrying? So just been called by the school. Apparently all parents have been because girls skirts are very short and it's against school policy. I can only assume the little tyke (13) is rolling her school skirt up because it's not short when she leaves the house and ill sort it when she gets in, but I am concerned with what the female teacher said to me. The reason why the girls skirts shouldn't be short is because male teachers and other boys may feel uncomfortable. Also out of school grounds the girls might be attacked. And young girls must learn to protect their dignity. I have no problem with a uniform and following it, but if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching? And why are we saying what a person wears means they may be attacked. I did ask if any girls had been attacked and I didn't get an answer. I just think it's a really bad message that girls have to change what they wear for those reasons.

OP posts:
Frlrlrubert · 17/06/2021 18:15

I think the reasons given are a bit off.

It shouldn't be about male gaze, or victim blaming.

But, skirts at my school are indecently short. No-one, male or female, needs to see a 13 year olds arse cheeks in their place of employment or learning (certain medical or caring professionals maybe).

Male staff and pupils may be more uncomfortable than female because of it being a body different to their own, in the same way female staff and pupils might be more uncomfortable than male if Mr Jones went about shirtless. But flashing your arse is just plain unacceptable in school really.

I'd ban stretch fabric skirts for starters, they are our main culprit. The PE skorts are awful too. I don't know why they make them so short, if they wear them with a hoodie it looks like they have nothing in their bottom half.

I promise I'm not an old moaner, but when I went into teaching I did not expect to be seeing so much arse.

Branleuse · 17/06/2021 18:13

id rather they got rid of uniform altogether than waste time and energy policing how much they try desperatly to personalise it or make it cool.

Make them all just wear jeans and tshrts like on the continent

HavelockVetinari · 17/06/2021 18:12

@ProfPickles

I'm female and work in a school and the girls in short skirts make me feel uncomfortable.

They're so short I see one of their bums every single day and these are children. I don't want to see the bums of children and girls wearing skirts so short that if you walk behind them up the stairs you can see up.

I feel like the boys uniforms present them as smart preparing for the work place (one argument made for a smart uniform) and the girls does them a disservice because mini skirts so short you can see bum cheeks every day isn't good enough. The women working there wouldn't be allowed to wear them so why are our girls seen as less important?

I'm always a bit confused when people stick up for girls wearing tiny skirts, it just seems like an obvious way girls are sexualised from a young age

This. I HATED the pressure to wear a short skirt as a teenager, so much so that I got a petition together, signed by most of the girls in my year and the years below/above. The headmistress was pretty annoyed, but eventually (with some parents roped in, including a solicitor) it prevailed.

It's not good for young girls to feel pressured to wear revealing clothing (fine if it's genuinely their choice, but society pressures young girls to fit a prematurely sexualised profile - it's rarely a real "choice" IYSWIM).

GuyFawkesDay · 17/06/2021 18:11

It's worse this time of year, definitely. No tights. I'd say trousers for all. Shorts in summer.

I'll give an example. Walking towards stairs in school today. Ahead of me, going upstairs a girl in a very rolled up skirt. I got a total eyeful of bare cheeks. I can only assume she was in a thong... I was mortified as I definitely wasn't looking, it was just....there and I averted gaze immediately.

I can totally understand why it can cause issues because a male teacher just can't tackle that without accusations flying.

Viviennemary · 17/06/2021 18:08

I agree with saying skirts must be a certain length or they are not complying with uniform regulations. Same as length of boys hair and so on. Saying they make male teachers/boys uncomfortable is an unwise red herring.

Tickledtrout · 17/06/2021 18:07

Oh and 100 denier tights all year round. No pair of trousers has ever passed the school uniform test - too tight, too cropped- because shops just don't sell them for that age group.

OzziePopPop · 17/06/2021 18:06

The simple answer at my daughters school is trousers only, male and female. No skirts. They still have a trouser policy but it’s just ‘black, not skin tight or leggings’. Simple!

Unsure33 · 17/06/2021 18:05

@StoneofDestiny

Oh yes the pleated skirts forgot about those if you rolled them up they stuck out like a lamp shade .

Of course we had the risk of the cane or a blackboard rubber being thrown at us as well but we all had to adhere to the length of skirt rules r there would be consequences .

Therefore we did all fit in 🙂

DysmalRadius · 17/06/2021 18:05

Surely, if the problem is so endemic, the solution is to change the uniform. Is there not an option to phase out skirts altogether?

NautaOcts · 17/06/2021 18:04

@LittleGwyneth

They should be telling girls that skirts are a uniform length, and if they're not wearing them at the correct length, they're not wearing the uniform. Just the same as not being allowed to make your tie shorter.

They should not be telling girls that their uniform has anything to do with whether they are attacked or not, or that they are 'distracting' to anyone else. If their teachers aren't able to teach without looking at pupil's legs, I suggest they are in the wrong career.

I agree with this

It also annoys me that since they had to go to school in PE kit the uniform skorts are extremely short - crotch length - so I think it’s really inconsistent to say this is ok but other skirts are too short.
My dd doesn’t go by public transport but I wouldn’t feel comfortable with her travelling in her skort as I know she feels self conscious in it but it’s too warm for the tracksuit bottoms alternative

Tickledtrout · 17/06/2021 18:02

We've had this. School regulation kilts that only come in one length, bought from one provider. Girls made to stand in class for everyone to inspect the length of their skirts. Crap about men being uncomfortable. I thought it was just our school - rural backwater, rugby heavy school run by ageing PE teachers and resting on its decade old "outstanding" laurels.
Boys get away with an awful lot. Lip service given to mental well-being.
They always get the female teachers to phone home and run the assemblies too. Handmaidens to the patriarchy.
I've got a bank of emails OP.

AriadnetheSpider · 17/06/2021 18:02

Will get flamed for this but I agree that the uniform policy should be enforced. For the record I absolutely do NOT condone the victim-blaming mentality of why very short skirts in schools are inappropriate, but here goes:
A) Schools have a right to enforce their uniform policy - just that.
B) Teeny skirts aren’t practical for walking, going up and down flights of stairs, floor-work, bending ect.
C) School in many ways is a precursor to the world of work and the general expectations of society as a whole. It’s important to learn to dress smartly and appropriately to respect the sensibilities of everyone. Very short skirts are simply not appropriate in a lot of situations, which is beside the point of men and boys ability to “control” themselves.

I just want to make it clear that I live right next to a secondary school. We are not talking about “short” skirts - in some cases they actually expose the lower part of the buttocks. Genuinely microscopic.

Branleuse · 17/06/2021 17:59

[quote ProfPickles]@Branleuse of course it's a battle that can be won, there'll be plenty of backlash from the girls but that doesn't mean we give up on them and allow them to continue flashing their bums and underwear in public. We have a responsibility as adults to do what is best for children, women and girls have always been on a back foot to men and this is just one small part of it we have the power to change [/quote]
OK good luck with that.

FudgeSundae · 17/06/2021 17:58

I don’t know. I don’t like saying things are modest or immodest either because it’s not to do with decency so much as appropriateness. Like, I don’t want my boss to come to work in a mankini. It’s not because I would find it distracting (as a heterosexual woman) or immodest (if it’s a weird word to use for a man it’s not the right word to use for a schoolgirl), it’s because it’s not appropriate. That’s all they need to say.

StoneofDestiny · 17/06/2021 17:54

@unsure33

Not all are - some are bought already micro mini length. You can see them walking down the road when the school shirt is tied up! There are tiny skirts being worn and tiny skirts being created.

I rolled my skirt up at school, but it pre dated the stretchy Lycra era, and was pleated so there was a limited to how much could actually roll without looking like you were wearing a life belt 😂

Mymapuddlington · 17/06/2021 17:47

if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching

Nobody is uncomfortable seeing a girl in a short skirt, knees aren’t the sexiest of things. However a student flashing their knickers or bum cheeks while you’re trying to teach is distracting.

dudsville · 17/06/2021 17:45

Whilst it is of course every male's responsibility to see to their own behaviour, I also agree with posters above stating it would be inappropriate for me to dress in short skirts at work, those children's teachers can't wear equally short skirts. Why are we not instead asking for girls uniforms to be equally as professional as boys' uniforms?

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 17/06/2021 17:44

if male teachers are uncomfortable in seeing a 13 year old with a short skirt, should they really be teaching

It's better they're uncomfortable than having teachers who actively enjoy the sight teaching them, isn't it?

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/06/2021 17:43

uniform should be policed by parents before they get to school

I pick my battles due to my level of health and very low energy levels. I prefer to be available to help my dd learn. I’m disabled and chronically ill…. So spoons. Dd rolls her skirt up and asks me if it’s too short. It is short. But not bum cheek showing short like some girls. Luckily she’s a bit of a prude. And she has Nike Pro shorts to wear underneath if she wants…

DancesWithDaffodils · 17/06/2021 17:43

The reason is not acceptable BUT there are indecently short skirts at the school I go into, and if my arse was hanging out of my clothes I'd expect to be called out on it by colleagues.

Grellbunt · 17/06/2021 17:43

[quote ProfPickles]@Branleuse of course it's a battle that can be won, there'll be plenty of backlash from the girls but that doesn't mean we give up on them and allow them to continue flashing their bums and underwear in public. We have a responsibility as adults to do what is best for children, women and girls have always been on a back foot to men and this is just one small part of it we have the power to change [/quote]
I think it is a great idea you have

ProfPickles · 17/06/2021 17:39

@Branleuse of course it's a battle that can be won, there'll be plenty of backlash from the girls but that doesn't mean we give up on them and allow them to continue flashing their bums and underwear in public. We have a responsibility as adults to do what is best for children, women and girls have always been on a back foot to men and this is just one small part of it we have the power to change

Pieceofpurplesky · 17/06/2021 17:39

I have a male colleague who was called a paedo for years because he called a girl out on her skirt and said that he didn't want to see her knickers. As a woman of a certain age I can say it with no retorts. Younger female teacher and male teachers get called many things when asking girls to unroll their skirts

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/06/2021 17:38

@Ozanj

The girls who shorten their skirts do it to get male attention at all or any cost. It is most definitely for the boys so I would punish her by making her wear the trouser option.
My 12 yo definitely does it for male attention. NOT. Ffs. Have you listened to yourself? The girls do it to fit in. To rebel against what they consider to be a shitty uniform and because they want to all be the same.
Branleuse · 17/06/2021 17:36

This is not a battle anyone is going to win. Its been happening forever.
Short skirts are more fashionable and look less formal which I think is why they do it. Not for male attention.