Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paper straws in drinks cartons FFS!

138 replies

QueenOfMe · 16/06/2021 09:51

So DC came home for the 2nd time in a row yesterday with half a carton of Innocent smoothie all over his shirt and the rest of it leaked in his lunchbox. Had the same with his lunchbox drink, Capri Sun, so I had to stop using them.

Why, oh why would they put papers straws for drinks cartons which need to be pierced!? They are almost impossible to open. When I tried one myself I got juice all over the table after 10 minutes of trying to open it.

I’m all for saving the environment but not when it’s not workable!

Similarly Tesco have paper bags now for loose fruit and veg. The damn things rip as soon as you put more than one thing in them. If you’re picking up jacket potatoes for eg. you can only put one in a bag. Same with apples and bunches of bananas! I’ve complained many times but have been told they won’t be changed back to plastic!

It’s bloody ridiculous or AIBU?

OP posts:
Laiste · 16/06/2021 11:53

A couple of weeks ago I dropped a large baked potato straight through the paper bag and onto the floor of tesco. That was Blush enough, but then it rolled for what felt about a bloody mile with me running hunched over grabbing at it Hmm I swear this thing was propelling itself!

Yes to the mesh bag for heavy veggies. I have one now.

ButIWantedToBeYourValentine · 16/06/2021 11:49

@MistyFrequencies I could have written your post. The paper straws in smoothies and juice cartons have caused no end of meltdowns here with ASD DS. I have used metal straws and silicone straws but they weren't the same, so I ended up buying a bulk pack of normal bendy plastic straws from eBay and trimming them down to make them shorter. I do try and reuse them as many times as I can before they get binned though.

Laiste · 16/06/2021 11:47

Reusable straws would be great, and we have them at home, but it’s yet another thing that will never make its way home from school.

What about decanting the smoothie into a tupperware cup with a lid, or an empty water bottle with screw top - little Evian bottle? Or a small reusable drinks bottle with the straw inside?

RainingZen · 16/06/2021 11:46

People like you moaning on and being obstructive is why the environment has got so wrecked in the first place. Just grow up and adapt.

DarlingWithoutYou · 16/06/2021 11:45

I am 100% with you OP. DS got soaked trying to open his smoothie yesterday. I'm so annoyed, they're literally impossible to open with the paper straws which then go soggy too.

Rosa · 16/06/2021 11:40

Place a bic biro without the middle pen bit in said lunchbox and job done , and it can be reused again and again. Or use a metal straw and put it in lunchbox to bring home.
Does Tescos not have those vege bags that you can purchase and reuse ? I am in Italy and our vege bags are biogradeable but we get charged for them as well. We can use the reuseable bags if we want to .

DappledThings · 16/06/2021 11:37

YANBU about the paper straws. The time it takes mine to get through a carton means the straw is a soggy bit of limp paper by the end and totally unusable.

YABU about the fruit and veg. I haven't put any, except mushroom, into any bag, plastic or paper for years. Loose in the trolley then into the big shopping bag.

Exhausted4ever · 16/06/2021 11:36

Yanbu about how frustrating paper straws are. They are stupidly useless.

haba · 16/06/2021 11:36

@Trisolaris

You only want to save the environment when it’s convenient? 🤦🏻‍♀️
To be fair, this is how most people feel...hence the state the world is in.
Jennyfromtheculdesac · 16/06/2021 11:24

Capri sun should be an occasional thing, presumably you can pierce the hole with something else at home (a corkscrew) or have a reusable straw.

Yeah, then it will definitely be fine in the lunch box Hmm

Nothing wrong with sending an occasional juice or smoothie. DC1 too struggles with the paper straws. Reusable straws would be great, and we have them at home, but it’s yet another thing that will never make its way home from school.

ChessieFL · 16/06/2021 11:23

I’m with you OP, paper straws on that type of packaging are annoying. And yes I do use a reusable bottle most of the time but sometimes you can just forget to take it or just want to give your child the occasional treat of a smoothie.

GlutenFreeGingerCake · 16/06/2021 11:21

Yes it seems stupid when the actual Capri Sun pouch is still plastic. My dd likes a Capri Sun occasionally if she is out but switched to a different drink because of the paper straw.

InTheDrunkTank · 16/06/2021 11:19

Like a pp said I'm sure you can invent a solution! I'm the least practical person in the world and have found work arounds. (Reusable straw and my own Tupperware).

motogogo · 16/06/2021 11:18

Reusable straws or better still buy a bottle for his packed lunch and refill (like we did when we were young. We had kids flasks in our lunch boxes)

Capri sun is just squash, think of the savings!

BlibBlabBlob · 16/06/2021 11:17

You've scared me now... pretty much the only fruit my daughter ever gets is from a certain flavour of the Innocent smoothies. Has a carton in her lunch box every day. And no, she won't accept a home-made version or quite frankly any other version. Given that she won't take vitamins either, those smoothies were the one thing saving her from scurvy.

She also hates paper straws, they're a sensory nightmare within a minute or two as they become soggy and it sounds like the Innocent ones don't work to pierce the seal anyway? I think we must be on our last one or two of an old batch if they've recently been changed - now worried that tonight's shopping delivery will contain 20 undrinkable smoothies... Sad

Ozanj · 16/06/2021 11:15

You can still buy recyclable plastic straws. Just get a huge box of them and make sure he returns it so you can recycle it

Notimeforaname · 16/06/2021 11:13

Yeah just came on to say get your own reusable straws to keep in lunchbox. And your own reusable bags for fruit ..its really not difficult to adapt.

Shamoo · 16/06/2021 11:08

Because the government introduced a ban on the supply of plastic straws and a plastic tax, which made it inevitable that manufacturers would need to find alternative solutions.

It’s not all about the amount of plastic in a straw, but that they end up in water supplies and kill animals in the ocean.

HollysBush · 16/06/2021 11:07

Surprised people saying jacket spuds don’t need a bag, what if you buy 8? They’ll be all over the place! I have reusable veg bags. And op, I’m afraid a refillable bottle is the way to go.

MistyFrequencies · 16/06/2021 11:02

I have a kid with autism whose only fruit intake was innocent smoothies. Fucking paper straws ended that. I've managed to purchase a box of similar straws off Amazon they seem to be ok for his sensory oddities but only god knows what we are going to do once they're gone. I've tried silicone, bamboo, stainless steel straws, nothing works.

Heneage · 16/06/2021 11:02

Bananas need to go in a bag?? Wtf? Why? They have their own wrapper. As do potatoes.

Carlottagiudicelli · 16/06/2021 10:58

Sucking on a paper straw is just gross, quite apart from the mess. And in supermarkets that don't have small bags, slightly leaky bags of flour, sugar etc. are disposed of rather than just popped in a bag - is that any better for the environment?

GenevieveLenard · 16/06/2021 10:53

YANBU
We switched to big bottles of smoothies and a plastic Tupperware-type cup because of this (is also much better value!). DD won’t drink it now that she can see what it looks like though, so she’s taking fruit juice instead.
Actually PMSL at the posters who want you to pierce the carton with a silicon straw, or pierce it with a corkscrew before leaving home! I’m sure that wouldn’t be at all messy Hmm

PercyPiginaWig · 16/06/2021 10:35

I got reusable mesh bags for fruit and veg for 30p each. I have also used one as my toiletry bag when travelling as I can see everything.

Just because paper bags are available doesn't mean they should be the default option, they should be used if you really need them, people need to get into the mindset of reusable.

Capri sun should be an occasional thing, presumably you can pierce the hole with something else at home (a corkscrew) or have a reusable straw.

We all need to be aiming to reduce our consumption of single use plastics consistently and consciously.

Pedalpushers · 16/06/2021 10:34

Paper is very high in carbon emissions compared to plastic - not as good for the environment as everyone seems to believe. The problem with plastic is that it isn't correctly disposed of - if it was, the fact that it never rots would actually be very good for the planet as it is essentially sequestered carbon. A lot of these plastic reductions and replacements have knock on effects that are worse for the environment while also having a negligible effect on overall ocean plastic as things like straws are such a tiny percentage of it.