Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paper straws in drinks cartons FFS!

138 replies

QueenOfMe · 16/06/2021 09:51

So DC came home for the 2nd time in a row yesterday with half a carton of Innocent smoothie all over his shirt and the rest of it leaked in his lunchbox. Had the same with his lunchbox drink, Capri Sun, so I had to stop using them.

Why, oh why would they put papers straws for drinks cartons which need to be pierced!? They are almost impossible to open. When I tried one myself I got juice all over the table after 10 minutes of trying to open it.

I’m all for saving the environment but not when it’s not workable!

Similarly Tesco have paper bags now for loose fruit and veg. The damn things rip as soon as you put more than one thing in them. If you’re picking up jacket potatoes for eg. you can only put one in a bag. Same with apples and bunches of bananas! I’ve complained many times but have been told they won’t be changed back to plastic!

It’s bloody ridiculous or AIBU?

OP posts:
PattyPan · 16/06/2021 12:56

@HollysBush

Surprised people saying jacket spuds don’t need a bag, what if you buy 8? They’ll be all over the place! I have reusable veg bags. And op, I’m afraid a refillable bottle is the way to go.
I don’t really find it a problem for big things like apples and baking potatoes. How is it any different to having 8 tins of beans? They’re a similar size.
SecretKeeper1 · 16/06/2021 12:56

Another one with a Capri sun incident... all over my sons school shirt just after I’d done a white wash as well. A tear off corner would be a better solution.

PattyPan · 16/06/2021 12:53

I have to say I get the rage when I see innocent’s tv ad about the environment, from a brand owned by Coca Cola that sells all its products in plastic bottles and difficult-to-recycle tetra paks... greenwashing pure and simple

Lorw · 16/06/2021 12:53

Very small inconveniences to your life in the grand scheme of things, doing away with plastic bags and straws is saving lives and helping the planet 😁

Send your son his drink in a reusable drinks bottle that he can open easily and you can get reusable bags for fruit and veg to take shopping with you, simple solutions 😁

JeanClaudeVanDammit · 16/06/2021 12:52

I can’t stand paper straws. There must be a better alternative! They disintegrate before you’ve finished the drink and the feel of them in my mouth makes me shudder. I avoid anything that might need a straw now.

TheGumption · 16/06/2021 12:51

Just don't buy them.. or buy bigger bottles and decant into a reusable cup?
I'm surprised your school allows sugary drinks though. Water only at ours.

spanielstail · 16/06/2021 12:50

Juice cartoons are bad for him and bad for the environment. Buy a reusable drinks bottle rather than disposable cartons every day. Ideally with water in but if he's not used to that then put a splash of squash in.

Librariesmakeshhhhappen · 16/06/2021 12:49

You dont need bags for fruit and veg. Just put it in the trolley.

Buy reusable straws.

Sorry OP, but you are being really stupid. We need to cut out the plastic and the are 2 issues where it makes absolutely no difference to your life. It isnt difficult to make these changes.

Iloveitall · 16/06/2021 12:47

The paper straws are rubbish, I agree. A mesh bag is great for the supermarket. Trouble is the planet is in big trouble so we need to adapt or the consequences aren’t going to be good.

PattyPan · 16/06/2021 12:46

Decant some juice/smoothie from a larger into a small water bottle instead of getting the small cartons? I’ve got a small (330ml ish?) Klean Kanteen which fits in the dishwasher so that sort of thing would be ideal. The Capri sun packets were terrible even with plastic straws, used to just punch straight through to the other side.
I just put the veg loose in the basket/trolley except for small things like mushrooms which I take a reusable bag for.

Shakirasma · 16/06/2021 12:44

YABU. Sorry for your inconvenience, but fucking up the environment even more than it is cannot be an option. Single use plastic must be phased out completely. There are lots of reusable options available to you.

FudgeSundae · 16/06/2021 12:42

Stab the seal with a pencil. Job done.

Patapouf · 16/06/2021 12:41

Make a smoothie and put it in a bottle for fucks sake.

The environment is more important than your need for convenient pre packaged plastic shit.

Miiaaoow · 16/06/2021 12:40

YABVVU

Every single bit of plastic ever invented, every single bit of plastic you've ever touched and seen in your life is still lingering on earth. Plastic doesn't ever disappear or dissolve, it simply breaks down into microplastics which animals and guess what?! HUMANS consume. Its in our food, it's in our organs, it's found in human placentas!!
www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/aug/17/microplastic-particles-discovered-in-human-organs
www.eco-business.com/news/great-concern-as-new-study-finds-microplastics-in-human-placentas/

You don't like paper straws? Buy a foldable metal one. You don't like paper bags for veg? Do your bloody part and carry a fabric reusable one.

Open your fucking eyes.

Bibidy · 16/06/2021 12:40

@Lou573

And this is why we’re all screwed, because people’s desire for a smoothie is more important than the environment. They’re awful things but I don’t actually care what people feed their kids, I do care that they’re trashing the environment for mine though. Buy a bloody reusable bottle and stop whining!
Yes I agree.

Unless there is a sensory/SN reason why a child needs these specific drinks, surely if they're not working in a packed lunch then they just get replaced with something that does work?

justanotherneighinparadise · 16/06/2021 12:35

There’s going to be a process of reinventing the wheel when it comes to plastic. The reason we LOVED it is because it worked. Now we need to go backwards again until we find something that’s works but also degrades.

Personally I’d either have an alternative plan for a straw or I’d decant the drink into a sealable cup. I have a load of plastic straws I’ve had for years, so I used to bring a couple when we went to McDonald’s. You also now have stainless steel straws and of course a better quality of paper straw you could buy separately and stick in the lunch box. Silicone straws aren’t going to pierce the film on a carton, so recommending those is pointless.

As an aside what I really want doesn’t seem to be available unless I pay an absolute fortune. I want a stainless steel sippy cup for my kids lunch. I also want it to be something I can sling in the dishwasher. Plus I want it to be less than a tenner. I wasted hours of my life last week searching for those and coming up with nothing 🤬

SoupDragon · 16/06/2021 12:34

@RancidOldHag

Get a reusable, washable silicone straw for use with cartons.

Take your own reusable bag/s for loose fruit and veg

This.
Notebooksarefabulous · 16/06/2021 12:33

YABU to buy sugary drinks made from concentrate and goodness knows what else.
Id send him with a bottle of water - which is all my two are allowed for school drinks.

Bibidy · 16/06/2021 12:32

Sorry OP, I think you're being unreasonable.

There are loads of alternatives to what you're doing - give him a normal reusable bottle with a drink in, or just get him a reusable straw he can take in and bring home with him?

I do think it's stupid though that companies are using paper straws for unsuitable products, and should adapt their cartons to maybe include a corner you can drink out of or something?

As for fruit and veg, depends where you're getting it I guess by in my Tesco you weigh it in the fruit aisle and get a sticker with the price...that's all you need to put it through the till. Just put them in a normal bag once you've weighed them if that's an option?

M4J4 · 16/06/2021 12:22

YABU. Have you see pictures of what plastic straws do to animals, especially in the sea?

Don't be so bloody selfish!

He doesn't need a bloody Innocent smoothie, send him with something else.

And use metal or silicon or bamboo straws at home.

SirenSays · 16/06/2021 12:08

I'm dyspraxic and could never open capri sun's with the plastic straws. Couldn't he have asked the kitchen staff to quickly snip off a corner and tip it into a normal cup.

PixieDust28 · 16/06/2021 12:03

What?! You bag loose bananas and loose potato's? I don't think you're one for saving the environment. What a waste. Bring your own or just put them in the trolley. It'll be washed when you get back anyway.

As for the carton. Just put it in your own bottle in the morning. Job done.

MistyFrequencies · 16/06/2021 12:00

@ButIWantedToBeYourValentine It's a balance isn't it. I try to be conscious of my impact on the environment but my son would end up with scurvy if I couldn't buy plastic straws for his innocent smoothies.. .. literally no other fruit gets past his lips. The days between innocent switching to paper straws and me finding alternative plastic ones were hell, half hour meltdowns every morning where he would keep looking for a smoothie then losing it once he saw the straw, inconsolable.

Lou573 · 16/06/2021 11:57

And this is why we’re all screwed, because people’s desire for a smoothie is more important than the environment. They’re awful things but I don’t actually care what people feed their kids, I do care that they’re trashing the environment for mine though. Buy a bloody reusable bottle and stop whining!