Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paper straws in drinks cartons FFS!

138 replies

QueenOfMe · 16/06/2021 09:51

So DC came home for the 2nd time in a row yesterday with half a carton of Innocent smoothie all over his shirt and the rest of it leaked in his lunchbox. Had the same with his lunchbox drink, Capri Sun, so I had to stop using them.

Why, oh why would they put papers straws for drinks cartons which need to be pierced!? They are almost impossible to open. When I tried one myself I got juice all over the table after 10 minutes of trying to open it.

I’m all for saving the environment but not when it’s not workable!

Similarly Tesco have paper bags now for loose fruit and veg. The damn things rip as soon as you put more than one thing in them. If you’re picking up jacket potatoes for eg. you can only put one in a bag. Same with apples and bunches of bananas! I’ve complained many times but have been told they won’t be changed back to plastic!

It’s bloody ridiculous or AIBU?

OP posts:
CrazyCatsAndKittens · 16/06/2021 14:14

@Booksandtea84

Has anyone seen what's in an innocent smoothie? Literally just fruit. Nothing bad. Unless we now classify fruit as bad cos of sugar content. It's cheaper making your own smoothie but no need to shame op or anyone else for buying ready mades for saying they are bad.
Smoothies aren’t great because you lose the fiber and you are concentrating the juice down so you get this sugar hit (albeit natural sugar). Innocent smoothies have around 4 teaspoons of sugar in them. They also lose their natural vitamins pretty quickly, so are supplemented with vitamins. It’s much much healthier to give whole fruit to kids and have them drink water, but apparently it’s massively unreasonable to say this. Basically, the fewer processed foods you can eat, the better.
PattyPan · 16/06/2021 14:12

@Booksandtea84 the sugar in a smoothie is much more available than in a whole fruit because of the blending process. And in a juice even more so because it doesn’t have any of the fibre. This is why smoothies and juice only count as a maximum of one of your five a day.
www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/smoothies

TinyTear · 16/06/2021 14:10

Some people probably don't have children who won't eat if some foods are from a certain brand or shop or a very specific flavour or won't use wooden cutlery and would rather go hungry and thirsty until they are home for their familiar things...

As i don't particularly want my daughter to not eat/drink while at school and on days out I compromise...

And I won't feel guilty over my plastic straws as 5 smoothies a week aren't the issue - as a family of 4 we recycle and compost so much we put out less than one small bin bag or rubbish a week...

I am here to say I stand with @QueenOfMe because these newfangled straws are not fit for purpose

ConstanceGracy · 16/06/2021 14:09

@RancidOldHag

Get a reusable, washable silicone straw for use with cartons.

Take your own reusable bag/s for loose fruit and veg

Silicone straws are bendy and won’t pierce a carton!
Bibidy · 16/06/2021 14:08

@Booksandtea84

Has anyone seen what's in an innocent smoothie? Literally just fruit. Nothing bad. Unless we now classify fruit as bad cos of sugar content. It's cheaper making your own smoothie but no need to shame op or anyone else for buying ready mades for saying they are bad.
I think Innocent Smoothies are totally fine to give, but just that if they no longer work in a packed lunch then just put something else in instead and save them for home?
Booksandtea84 · 16/06/2021 13:55

Has anyone seen what's in an innocent smoothie? Literally just fruit. Nothing bad. Unless we now classify fruit as bad cos of sugar content. It's cheaper making your own smoothie but no need to shame op or anyone else for buying ready mades for saying they are bad.

M4J4 · 16/06/2021 13:53

@TinyTear aw diddums, the 1 million seabirds that die every year due to ingesting plastic straws would be devestated that your dd can't have her Innocent smoothie Hmm

Better to be holier than thou than completely self-centred and lacking an awareness of the world around you.

lurker69 · 16/06/2021 13:50

paper straws are shit they really don't fulfil the job of a straw, reusable ones are probably to big for smoothies and capri sun the silicone ones are probably to flimsy as well, personally i would probably just send a reusable bottle of juice of squash from now on to be honest

TinyTear · 16/06/2021 13:47

Here come the holier than thou crew with 'why give juice?'

@QueenOfMe I wholeheartedly agree...

My 6yo takes an innocent smoothie on her packed lunch and now really struggles with the paper straw, and she won't drink it when it's decanted

we stopped buying the cawstons juices because of the paper straw

I do have metal foldable straws and reusable plastic cutlery but i carry those with me for outings when there are paper straws and wooden cutlery as other wise the kids wouldn't eat...

i don't want to send an expensive metal straw with a y1 child to get lost though

FuckyouCovid21 · 16/06/2021 13:43

@HollysBush

Surprised people saying jacket spuds don’t need a bag, what if you buy 8? They’ll be all over the place! I have reusable veg bags. And op, I’m afraid a refillable bottle is the way to go.
All over the place where? They aren't that small that you'd have trouble locating them, if they roll about just put other stuff around them Hmm
PattyPan · 16/06/2021 13:33

My local five guys and burger king both still have plastic straws

Hopefully they’re just using up what they already had. I saw this article the other day which is awful: www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/jun/10/takeaway-food-and-drink-litter-dominates-ocean-plastic-study-shows

HitsAndMrs · 16/06/2021 13:32

Who do some people think they are, honestly. The OP didn't ask if it was healthy, get off your high horse and go back to your water. Hmm

cocoloco987 · 16/06/2021 13:32

A stainless steel straw thin enough to fit in a Capri sun would be a lethal weapon in school. Plus very dangerous to drink from for younger kids

justanotherneighinparadise · 16/06/2021 13:21

@Rubyupbeat

Mesh bags and stainless steel straws, easy.
I would want to supervise kids with a stainless steel straw after that terrible story of the woman who fell on one and died. But squash in a bottle seems the obvious solution.
JeanClaudeVanDammit · 16/06/2021 13:20

Also the paper straws on drinks cartons are all sealed in a little plastic bag anyway. Obviously it’s been better to move away from single use cartons altogether but it does seem a bit of a nonsense sometimes.

DdraigGoch · 16/06/2021 13:20

Similarly Tesco have paper bags now for loose fruit and veg. The damn things rip as soon as you put more than one thing in them. If you’re picking up jacket potatoes for eg. you can only put one in a bag. Same with apples and bunches of bananas! I’ve complained many times but have been told they won’t be changed back to plastic!
I use cotton drawstring bags for loose stuff and wouldn't even bother individually bagging a bunch of bananas - they conveniently stay together, after all.

PickAChew · 16/06/2021 13:17

I agree on the straws - and they're a littkw redundant when they come with a whole single use drink carton.

My only issue with paper bags is that they allow stuff to dry out in the fridge. I like the compost able ones that waitrose do, though I made the mistake of putting one down on a freshly wiped surface, once. That was messy.

Rubyupbeat · 16/06/2021 13:14

Mesh bags and stainless steel straws, easy.

VapeVamp12 · 16/06/2021 13:13

Paper straws are so awful! I read somewhere that a lot of them aren't actually recyclable either because of the film on them.

I didnt actually know it was a government ban until a PP said. My local five guys and burger king both still have plastic straws.

Whyhello · 16/06/2021 13:05

Get a decent water bottle (my DC have Klean kanteen) and fill it up with squash. I don’t know why anyone still buys disposable cartons.

justanotherneighinparadise · 16/06/2021 13:02

[quote Cadent]@justanotherneighinparadise

This one's on offer for £11 . Seems to be steriliser safe.

]][/quote]
Bless you. Thank you for looking. I did grab at the term ‘sippy cup’ knowing it didn’t quite describe what I meant. I was being lazy. I mean some sort of top that flips up with a spout so small children wouldn’t throw the contents all down themselves.

My kids are terrible for losing their stuff or damaging them, so I don’t want to spend too much. Equally much of what I’ve found at the price point is either too small and in covid times the teachers don’t want to refill so ask for big bottles of water. Or else the reviews are terrible.

1940s · 16/06/2021 13:01

I'm cringing that you've complained many times to large supermarkets that you can't fit bananas and large jacket potatoes into paper bags. We've got no hope

Riapia · 16/06/2021 13:01

This is AIBU the views posted on here are not necessarily those of the person posting them.

cocoloco987 · 16/06/2021 13:01

I agree with the Capri suns - there isn't an alternative solution to the sharp hard plastic. I support an autistic boy who won't drink anything else and we've had some epic meltdowns since they introduced the paper straws as he gets upset when it spills. The manufacturer really does need to think of another solution and change the whole packaging if necessary

OhYouBadBadKitten · 16/06/2021 12:59

I cannot cope with paper straws at all. Their texture is utterly utterly horrible, (shudder)