Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling jealous and generally grumpy when i hear or see how much help other parents get

132 replies

LiJo2015 · 15/06/2021 16:31

I need grounding and perspective and i know mn wont fail me!

I am estranged from my family and cannot rely on my husbands family for help with childcare.

Met up with another mama today who explained how she had childcare provided from her and her partners side and i cant deny i felt jealous. This issue of course far exceeds the childcare aspect and i generally just miss having any form of parental support myself.

So aibu? Am i being a whinging minnie or is it understandable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Drainedagain2 · 16/07/2021 12:51

I know this is an oldish thread but I understand where a lot of pp come from. I'm so sorry op , it sounds very tough, everything you have been through.
I have lots of family and they never help, no matter what. I would never expect childcare to work but we've moved houses while having toddlers and pregnant, no help offered at all, I've had, thankfully, minor illnesses and again absolutely no help but things like having dry socket and having to look after v small kids, it was hell. They all knew about it but didn't help. I totally helped my siblings with kids pre-kids loads as I sort -of thought that was normal...especially if they were ill or exhausted. My parents are mid 70's now anyway so wouldn't have energy at all but they have never, ever even gone for a walk around the block or to the playground even once with me and my dcs... my eldest is 10!! And I guess it will never happen. I asked my sister once if she would mind them while they were in bed so we could go out for a meal for our 10 year anniversary and there was a huge fuss and back and forth and then ultimately a no. I am surrounded by ppl with endless support and close family ties. My dh family are totally handsoff and also impractical and would never help.
My dh and me are v 50/50 as we have to be so we take weekends away ourselves and give each other time off. I think some ppl take the absolute piss too however, I meet a very elderly lady in the local playground with a 2 year old who she can't control at all and despite talking everyday she couldn't remember who i was this morning.....imagine she's with a highly mobile 2 year old ..he nearly bolted in front of a car, crazy..
Despite this I get lovely messages, requests for photos etc but at the end of the day we are on our own. I know ppl have it so much worse but it can be hard to realise also that we are fckt if things go wrong and it's a v v sharp contrast to what I see around me.

mindutopia · 17/06/2021 11:16

I think your situation is probably as much the norm as the other though. We don't have any help and nor really do a lot of mums I know. Dh's family lives far away (they would be only minimal help anyway, maybe the occasional evening of babysitting, maybe, but MIL has health issues which mean we can't leave her unsupervised with dc, so another family member has to travel from even further away to babysit MIL if she were to babysit dc). My family lives even further away (overseas) but I am NC with them. When we need help, we have to pay for it.

But I also think there is something about standing on your own two feet and doing everything yourself. I wouldn't want help. I want to rely on myself and dh. My mum, when we were still in contact, used to occasionally give us some money for nursery. I was doing a post grad degree and dh was still early in his career. For Christmases and birthdays, I asked that instead of buying us presents (we don't need presents) if she could contribute to nursery costs that month instead because that is something we'd really appreciate and value. She did, but then would often point out how she needed to help us financially and we weren't independent. She clearly forgets that my grandparents provided full-time 8am-6pm care for me from 3 months until I started school and then did the school runs for her and fed me dinner every weeknight. They also had me full days every school holiday, sick day and sometimes on the weekends too if she wanted a break. Realistically, I spent more time with them than with her (or my dad, who was largely absent). That isn't a criticism of her, it was lovely to be with my grandparents (until they died when I was around 11). But I think she forgets how easy she had it never having to worry about sorting out a single day's worth of childcare until I was in secondary school. They did everything for her. Personally, I wouldn't want that, but I don't begrudge people who do.

KnobblyWand · 17/06/2021 11:14

I only really get bothered by it when friends, who have round-the-clock family support/babysitters, complain about how hard they have it.

Someone I know often complains that she's tired, fed up with the kids arguing and has just had enough of how RELENTLESS it all is.

Her parents:
Take all three of her children every other weekend.
Have them some weeknights if she and her husband fancy watching a film/going to a party.
If she gets a cold they take them until she's better.
Take the kids for Christmas, Easter and half term trips away.
Sometimes she'll just ask them to babysit so she can get extra sleep in the morning.

I have to really bite my tongue because of course, it's all relative, and it's not up to me to decide whether she's worthy of complaining. But nobody's babysat my kids in 10 years, it's all been us, no date nights, nothing.

It was a fucking miracle we managed to arrange someone to stay with my eldest as I gave birth to my second. I ended up arranging a homebirth for my third so my parents wouldn't have to be 'inconvenienced', bless them.

LiJo2015 · 17/06/2021 11:01

@stealthninjamum

I am so sorry to read this was triggering for you. At the same time - i get it. Its also something i feel isnt discussed enough. The world we have now is so different to what our parents had - or at least it feels this way? Families are so dispersed now and fanily dynamics are so much more varied. Everything you say about the roles that our extended families have and can give our children is absolutely true and something that friends cant do. Its that sense of kinship, identity and investment that blood relatives have. Yes friends can do this but when the chips are down, blood family 'should' come through.

I am estranged from all of my family, i have no comtact with any of mu bio fanily. I am an orphan in a sense. Estrangement i find also comes with a judgement, people just dont get it - that something must be wrong with me? This last point is something i internalze.

OP posts:
stealthninjamum · 17/06/2021 09:19

@LiJo2015 I am only up to your post at the bottom of page 3 but it’s made me so emotional. I’m so sorry to hear about your dmum.

As you say it isn’t about the babysitting, I can afford one, but just about the emotional connection and my children having adults in their lives to bond with and learn from. In my family the adults had roles - very traditional because it was the 1970s but my grandad had his shed and allotment, my grandma did baking, knitting and played board games with me, I’d enjoy visiting great aunts and uncles and having orange squash which I wasn’t allowed at home. Because they were retired they had more time to hang out with me. I feel that my dc are lacking the interactions with other adults i had. It doesn’t help that one has ASD and so I have to explain how conversations work when she should be surrounded by adults having conversations with her and learning naturally.

Incidentally my exmil offered to look after the older child so I could have a ‘break’. How would the other child feel knowing she isn’t wanted by grandma?

LiJo2015 · 16/06/2021 00:51

@Grapewrath

🌷

OP posts:
LiJo2015 · 16/06/2021 00:51

@ShallWeStartTheMeeting

God this sounds so hard - im so sorry 🌷

OP posts:
LiJo2015 · 16/06/2021 00:49

@RoseMartha

🌷

OP posts:
Grapewrath · 16/06/2021 00:02

Yanbu OP
It’s normal to feel envious and sad knowing others have what you don’t when it comes to parenting. My parents don’t give a shit about me or my kid- have never offered any emotional, practical or financial support and couldn’t be less interested if they’d tried. They’ve never baby sat dc even once. Yes I have many blessings but it’s still hurtful to see other people who are loved and supported

ShallWeStartTheMeeting · 15/06/2021 22:40

What can be worse is not lack of help, it's pretend help.
The rare times my mother came to 'help' I nearly murdered her.
Once DH had to go to Singapore for 10 days so she came over.
Spent the whole time on her phone- actively told her 2 NT grandkids that she couldn't play with them because she was busy. Didn't take them anywhere, talk to them, ask about school etc.
I had to sort out all things kid- related while caring for disabled DC and when the kids were all in bed she would then expect dinner and chat.
At that point I would be so knackered all I wanted to do was watch mindless TV and not have to look at another person.
She left all proud of herself and my dad told everyone how helpful she had been.

ILs came to 'help' after 3rd child was born. I ended up cooking meals, was breastfeeding on demand so they would eat without me and leave me to clear up after them.
But for me the worst is ongoing lack of interest in disabled DC. My ILs act as if he doesn't even exist. Sad

RoseMartha · 15/06/2021 22:36

You are not unreasonable.

I have a sibling who has several children. My children sit age wise in the middle of hers.

My sibling and her dh have professional jobs, my parents looked after my siblings older children, but could not look after mine. (I ended up looking after her younger children as my parents were past it by then).

I had no one to help look after mine. Because of my line of work it was not possible to work and afford childcare and I struggled for years to earn a bit here in low paid casual jobs and to fit around nursery and school times.

My now exh refused to do any childcare from day one. And he forbade me to apply for certain normal jobs but wanted me to work. 🤷‍♀️

His family lived mostly too far away. The ones that didnt never agreed to help babysit when asked. Probably because one of my dc has SN.

So totally understand where you are coming from.

saraclara · 15/06/2021 22:33

@sweeneytoddsrazor

Be careful what you wish for. I know someone whose mother provides all their childcare and saves them £££££. She even moved house to do it. It’s abundantly obvious to everyone but them that she’s setting herself up nicely to ensure she’s looked after in a couple of decades time.

And there we go. Couldn't just be doing it because they are loving parents and grandparents.

Most elderly people don't want their children to care for them. They don't like the indignity of being washed, dressed fed or whatever by their kids. What most of them want is to be cared about not for. But apparently for an awful lot of people on here normally that seems to be an alien concept. Parents are not welcome unless they are providing free childcare at the same level as very expensive nurseries, following exacting demands. Any deviation results in nc/lc. Outside of free childcare, they are only allowed to visit or receive a visit at the convenience of their offspring, never their own. They must never make any suggestions regarding their DGC because of course that is interfering. And they must never buy any thing, for DGC without express permission and it must not be made of plastic, too big too small or be 50p less than anything any other sets of DGC get.

applauds

I was quite confident about being a GM, but MN has put the fear of God into me. I now constantly overthink my role and worry about doing/saying the wrong thing. I'm forever checking with my daughter that she's okay with what I'm doing/how much I'm doing/how I'm doing it and most of the time she looks at me as though I'm mad to even ask. Fortunately, she's really easygoing and wouldn't fit in on MN at all

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 15/06/2021 22:27

Sorry OP, hadn't rtft and missed that your mum died so young. I definitely think theres a huge amount here that is about grieving for a much bigger loss than childcare. Flowers take it easy.

LiJo2015 · 15/06/2021 22:21

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

I know you make a valid point. But god i wish i had these dilemmas versus a dead mum and a dad that couldnt give a shit.

OP posts:
LiJo2015 · 15/06/2021 22:18

@GivenchyDahhling

Youve hit the nail on the head with this one. Ive seen it often (like today) where people have been able to continue careers owing to free childcare. I know this formed part of the reason medicine became so difficult because something had to give - and in my situation it was medicine. I know its completely umfair to be angry with other people who i see have been able to go back to work witgout the emotional or financial strain of putting their kids in a nursery, but i just find it so unfair. Life is horrible like that - or as gump
Would say life is like a box of chocolates - you never know what youre goimg to get. My daughter is 10 months old, and with lockdown, its been hard, really hard. Then throw in all the other emotional baggage, past and present, today just really got to me. I came home and just sobbed. I domt know the lady who prompted this post and she's probably really nice and of course undoubtedly has her own issues, but seeing her there, just having the option, i felt angry at her - this of course is completely ridiculous because whne my daughter is her age i would hope i would do exactly the same.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 15/06/2021 22:17

Couldn't just be doing it because they are loving parents and grandparents

In this case, no.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 15/06/2021 22:15

Also my parents worked hard for years and years and raised my siblings and I. To provide meaningful childcare for me would mean committing a week day every single week, 46 weeks a year, it would be hugely restricting for them and honestly, I don't really want to have to ask that of them, especially as I dont desperately need them to, financially.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 15/06/2021 22:12

Yanbu but try to think of it from another angle.

I dont get any regular childcare help from family. But actually for everyone I know who does, it's something that is actually frought with issues and is something they only accept because they financially gave no choice. "Free" childcare often has many strings attached and can lead to a lot of rows, grandparents who prove unreliable and expect to jet off for regular holidays leaving working parents high and dry, disagreements over what children are fed, whether routines are adhered to, children left to cry, impractical situations where parents drive an hour each way at unsociable hours to drop off & collect children from family etc.

GivenchyDahhling · 15/06/2021 22:06

I understand completely. I spend £1200 a month on full time nursery for my one year old. I’m in a senior leadership role but effectively earn less than the people in my department I line manage who have grandparent support on both sides. Sadly, my parents are abroad and DMiL has health issues that mean it’s just not possible for them. I totally understand why women don’t go back to work/move to part time hours because it’s just prohibitively expensive, without family support you really have to be a high earner to make work “worth it”. It’s really hard not to be resentful even though it’s nobody’s fault (except perhaps the government for not doing more to subsidise childcare).

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/06/2021 21:45

Be careful what you wish for. I know someone whose mother provides all their childcare and saves them £££££. She even moved house to do it. It’s abundantly obvious to everyone but them that she’s setting herself up nicely to ensure she’s looked after in a couple of decades time.

And there we go. Couldn't just be doing it because they are loving parents and grandparents.

Most elderly people don't want their children to care for them. They don't like the indignity of being washed, dressed fed or whatever by their kids. What most of them want is to be cared about not for. But apparently for an awful lot of people on here normally that seems to be an alien concept. Parents are not welcome unless they are providing free childcare at the same level as very expensive nurseries, following exacting demands. Any deviation results in nc/lc. Outside of free childcare, they are only allowed to visit or receive a visit at the convenience of their offspring, never their own. They must never make any suggestions regarding their DGC because of course that is interfering. And they must never buy any thing, for DGC without express permission and it must not be made of plastic, too big too small or be 50p less than anything any other sets of DGC get.

vampirethriller · 15/06/2021 20:52

@RealisticSketch thank you, that's very kind of you to sayGrin

RealisticSketch · 15/06/2021 20:50

@vampirethriller

It's understandable. I get the same sometimes. My daughter's father left when I was pregnant, he's never seen her (we were together years and daughter was planned, until he changed his mind) and my family are in another country. So it's just me and until she was 2 I had 45 minutes to myself for a haircut once! Now she's in nursery a few hours a week it's better but I still get fed up at times.
Omg! You're coping with that! Hats off to you, through the kids if your relationship as well 🥺😯 your daughter is one lucky lady to have you! I hope things continue to improve for you both. Flowers
Fizbosshoes · 15/06/2021 20:49

My DM died when my DC were very little and for a long time my heart ached when I saw a child run up to their grandma and give them a hug, or see a young mum out for coffee, or shopping with her mum....because I wanted that too.

I know a lot on MN would tell me to get a grip or just get on with it but I feel sad for my DC that they wont have that relationship (my Ddad slightly lost interest after DM died) and IL told me the novelty had worn off because they'd got lots of other GC

When my DM or IL showed pride in their GC I feel that's sort of affirmation I'm doing ok as a parent. Its really silly and as I've got older and I've had longer without my DM (Ddad and MIL have also died) I do have more confidence in myself but I still miss it.

RealisticSketch · 15/06/2021 20:47

Terrible auto corrects sorry

vampirethriller · 15/06/2021 20:46

It's understandable. I get the same sometimes. My daughter's father left when I was pregnant, he's never seen her (we were together years and daughter was planned, until he changed his mind) and my family are in another country. So it's just me and until she was 2 I had 45 minutes to myself for a haircut once! Now she's in nursery a few hours a week it's better but I still get fed up at times.