Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Teaching Assistants are vastly underpaid for their role?

319 replies

altoran · 15/06/2021 14:03

When the role of Teaching Assistant was created, the idea was that they would help with basic tasks like photocopying, wall displays, etc. It was a very basic role with no real responsibility.
Now Teaching Assistants have a lot of responsibility and are very involved in children's education, although under the supervision of a teacher. But they receive very little over minimim wage for this.
AIBU to think they are vastly underpaid?

OP posts:
mag2305 · 16/06/2021 08:01

@Sweak I think it depends on the school to be honest. Many will do whatever to cut costs. In my last school, there were several LSAs that did cover and were then asked to become the class 'teacher'. Parents were known the wiser to this, not sure if they would have cared anyway. I know their salaries would have been capped at the unqualified pay, and the individuals I'm thinking of are excellent in their roles. However, having been through a degree and teacher training myself, with the costs involved, I feel like that QTS should mean something. But at my last school it felt like saving money meant more than having the right qualification for the role. Seemed unfair in many ways.
So if you want an unqualified teaching role, I think it might be more about getting known and in a school that does that first.

Tangled22 · 16/06/2021 07:53

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

But supply and demand means there are still long queues of people who will do it at that pay so it never improves.

This!! The only way pay improves in a market economy is if people refuse to do the job at the wage offered.

TAs will complain about the pay, but horses apply for these jobs every year. Because actually there are hardly any jobs that fit around school hours if you are determined that little Jimmy never set foot in wraparound care. So there is clearly a substantial value to the working pattern available to TAs and that is a factor in the low pay accepted by staff in these roles.

Just to say - some TAs still have to use wraparound care. My other half is a TA and finishes at 4.30pm (only half an hour before me in a normal 9-5 job). Primary school kicks out at 3.10pm.
singsingbluesilver · 16/06/2021 07:47

I am surprised that a non teaching pastoral lead is managing teachers. Why are the teachers in your school not line managed by their head of department/ head of faculty? How do you support their line management in their subject areas?

Witchcraftandhokum · 16/06/2021 07:31

notanothertakeaway

I'm not a TA, I'm a Pastoral Lead, middle-management in a school.

3totheright4totheleft · 16/06/2021 07:24

What @NoIDontWatchLoveIsland said. Yes, the pay is awful but with no childcare costs you are saving a lot, not just financially but the stress involved in trying to get cover for all the holidays. Not to mention that often people are local to the school they're based at, so travel costs are low. The trouble is that it's seen as a fallback job for mums rather than a proper career that people aspire to. There are just no other jobs out there that give you so much time off - even a part-time role elsewhere will require you to work holidays, and the AL is pro-rata'd so you'd almost be worse off.

Sweak · 16/06/2021 07:23

@Fitforforty yes but the majority of schools want QTS. I was recently job hunting and all the state schools wanted QTS. It was actually only the private ones that were advertising for unqualified, oh and one state primary school that wanted PPA cover. I'm sure some are asking for unqualified due to cost but it's few and far between

The words 'no minimum standard' implies anyone can get a teaching job, when in reality without QTS you would struggle to find roles.

Fitforforty · 16/06/2021 07:17

@cardibach

The same as a teacher there is no minimum standard Rubbish *@Fitforforty* . Teachers in the state sector have to have a degree and postgrad teaching qualification.
No Micheal Gove got rid of this requirement. As a teacher I was rather annoyed by this.
CarrieBlue · 15/06/2021 23:29

@altoran

The average secondary school teacher earns £39,000 a year.
And?
mag2305 · 15/06/2021 23:25

A few people have mentioned male LSAs which is really interesting. My husband is an LSA and is applying for other LSA roles at the moment. He seems to get interviews really easily and I said to him, it's possibly because he's a man. Especially popular in primary. And to be fair, I think having a man in a support or nurture role is really good for the children to see.

mag2305 · 15/06/2021 23:18

I can see this from two sides as I was an LSA before becoming a teacher. My husband is also an LSA. Yes, LSAs are underpaid. My husband works in an alternative provision centre for excluded children and is on £14,000 take home. This is a place where drugs and knives are brought in, fights break out and staff have frequent verbal abuse. Nature of the job but so underpaid for the type of work and environment.

For me, I was happy with my LSA pay initially as it was my first proper job out of uni and it was the most I'd ever earnt. However, I soon realised it wasn't great.

What I would say though, a starting salary for a teacher (in my opinion) is worse. For many teachers they will have paid out a lot of money to train. Then there's the ultimate class responsibility, the hours, the pressure, the workload, the grilling on progress, the accountability. LSAs don't have those things although I know their performance is more scrutinised now than ever before.

In my first and second years of teaching, I had a nursery nurse as my LSA because it was reception. She was earning a lot more than me both those years because of the grade she was on even though I was doing more work. She was excellent at her job so deserved her money but my point is, NQT wage is shit basically!

One big bonus to being an LSA is leaving school work at school, despite the crap salary. With teaching, your evenings and weekends are not your own. There's always work to catch up on. I'm on mat leave at the moment but I'm seriously considering going back into an LSA role. Big salary drop, especially from m6, but you get more of a life.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 15/06/2021 23:12

hordes not horses....

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 15/06/2021 23:12

But supply and demand means there are still long queues of people who will do it at that pay so it never improves.

This!! The only way pay improves in a market economy is if people refuse to do the job at the wage offered.

TAs will complain about the pay, but horses apply for these jobs every year. Because actually there are hardly any jobs that fit around school hours if you are determined that little Jimmy never set foot in wraparound care. So there is clearly a substantial value to the working pattern available to TAs and that is a factor in the low pay accepted by staff in these roles.

Howshouldibehave · 15/06/2021 22:36

@Stompythedinosaur

I very much agree they are underpaid. I think their pay is an insult tbh.
But supply and demand means there are still long queues of people who will do it at that pay so it never improves.
Stompythedinosaur · 15/06/2021 22:34

I very much agree they are underpaid. I think their pay is an insult tbh.

Dizzybintess · 15/06/2021 22:31

I had a degree allready when I signed up to be a TA
I still had to do level 2 and level 3 LSA qualifications I also work with SEN so there is a lot more training there, Considering how strenuous/and demanding a role it is .... its very much underpaid.

SuperMonkeys · 15/06/2021 22:29

Oh, prior to this I was a 1-1 ta with a child with significant SEN. This was at the lower rate of £9 something.

ShaneTheThird · 15/06/2021 22:28

Agreed op totally. I was a ta for 3 years and the pay was bullshit for what i was doing. Literally i was teaching whole classes from time to time whilst the teacher did other things. I would have to mark work books, teach phonics and spelling, numeracy, science and art. I would have to talk to parents about things, do lunch time duties and deal with substitute teachers regularly. Yet the pay was so poor and you get zero respect because you're not a real teacher.

SunshineSum · 15/06/2021 22:28

Most wages below around £27k are low for the work put in though. This is the level that wage stagnation has hit hardest. So yes of course £9.57 is low in terms of aptitude required but then £9.57 is also low for eg hospitality staff required to work long hours and changing shifts and have endless amounts of people skills. TAs are paid ok I think looking at other jobs that pay the same which yes may not have the same amount of responsibility but which are much worse in terms of working patterns and autonomy over task flow etc.

If wages for the lowest paid deciles had kept up with inflation then TAs would be paid more. But then so would lots of people. But that hasn't happened so here we are.

SuperMonkeys · 15/06/2021 22:27

Yes and no. I'm a qualified teacher but working as a TA and HLTA.

As a TA I get paid £9 something an hour, and assist in class, plan and run intervention groups and help the teacher. I feel this is quite fair.

As an HLTA I cover classes for absent teachers, often with no planning provided. Deal with discipline issues, speak with parents etc etc. Normally don't have a TA in because, they're short staffed. I do this role 1 whole day per week during which time I don't get a break as there is no-one to cover me (as in, I eat in the classroom with the kids and then go out to supervise then while they play). The other days I am hlta for mornings.

HLTA garners approx £11 per hour. This I feel is too low.

Thecazelets · 15/06/2021 22:22

@NameyNameyNameChangey

Yes. Same with nursery workers and care assistants. But, to be fair, teachers and nurses are underpaid too. The support staff are more underpaid. Everybody should get a rise, IMO.
All very female dominated jobs, as a pp has pointed out. Part of the systemic undervaluing of this kind of work, which is done mainly by women.
dootball · 15/06/2021 22:17

There are some some amazing TAs for sure who are worth far more. However in my years teaching in secondary there are also a large number number of terrible ones who certainly are not worth more.

twinklemum87 · 15/06/2021 22:11

I have voted not unreasonable! I know some amazing teaching assistants and feel they are underpaid for sure

cardibach · 15/06/2021 22:09

Obvs or a degree which rolled in the qualified teacher status like a BEd, but those aren’t so common now.

cardibach · 15/06/2021 22:08

The same as a teacher there is no minimum standard
Rubbish @Fitforforty . Teachers in the state sector have to have a degree and postgrad teaching qualification.

soooooooG · 15/06/2021 21:43

Our school has amazing TAs, they're definitely worth their weight in gold, my eldest does targeted 1-2-1 work for his SEN with his.