Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Teaching Assistants are vastly underpaid for their role?

319 replies

altoran · 15/06/2021 14:03

When the role of Teaching Assistant was created, the idea was that they would help with basic tasks like photocopying, wall displays, etc. It was a very basic role with no real responsibility.
Now Teaching Assistants have a lot of responsibility and are very involved in children's education, although under the supervision of a teacher. But they receive very little over minimim wage for this.
AIBU to think they are vastly underpaid?

OP posts:
HappydaysArehere · 16/06/2021 10:18

@Gatehouse77

I work as a TA and whilst, as you say, it's much more involved in the children's learning than originally thought I don't know that I'd agree with you about being underpaid.

I don't have overall responsibility, no reports, progress meetings, parents' evenings, emails from parents, no lesson planning, no thinking of differentiation within the class for each subject taught, etc.

When I leave I don't think about any of it whereas a teacher (hopefully!) will.

Exactly this. I have been retired for quite awhile but what you have said seems very clear sighted. However, would add that a good TA is worth her weight in gold.
Sweak · 16/06/2021 10:12

@mag2305 thank you ☺️

@Witchcraftandhokum I think you and @singsingbluesilver have differing ideas on what constitutes managing staff? Are you involved in setting and reviewing performance management targets? You can manage an area of work which will involve leading staff but that doesn't make you their manager, if that makes sense?

I think non teaching pastoral leads can work really well in schools as you can deal with things quickly as you aren't constrained to a timetable

Whyhello · 16/06/2021 10:10

Definitely. I feel sorry for some of the TA’s at my DC’s school, they have to take over from the teacher if they’re in a meeting or even absent sometimes. In fact, my DS’s teacher doesn’t work Friday’s so the TA teaches them every Friday. I’d hope they got paid more for picking up the slack but I doubt it, shameful.

singsingbluesilver · 16/06/2021 10:05

Witchcraft - well the important thing is that it works. I was just responding to your comment that you don't get the perks of being a teacher yet you have more responsibilities and less pay than those teachers not in middle mangement.

Witchcraftandhokum · 16/06/2021 10:00

Sorry posted too soon

Every school is different and our teaching staff report it works well.

Witchcraftandhokum · 16/06/2021 09:59

singsingbluesilver
Every school is different and the major

singsingbluesilver · 16/06/2021 09:56

Witchcraft it must be difficult to compartmentalize those aspects of the role. Behaviour management is one of the top priorities for teachers and this is very often linked with pastoral issues beyond the classroom.

In my experience anyone who managed me was also involved in my performance management targets and reviews - someone senior to me on payscale and on the mangement structure. Of course I know that not all school s are the same. In my school the pastoral support team managed within their team - none of them managed teaching staff. In the same way teaching staff did not manage the pastoral team.

WeWantAMackerelNotASprat · 16/06/2021 09:53

Should add I still think they are underpaid but you can't compare! That's why so many TAs don't train as teachers, they don't want the responsibility or extra hours

WeWantAMackerelNotASprat · 16/06/2021 09:51

@Flawedperfection

Haven’t read entire thread yet, but previously TAs did half the work of teachers for half the pay which was fair enough (I’d rather have done the TA job out of the two if I’m honest); now TAs do the work of a teacher (more or less) for the same TA pat, whilst the teacher will basically now do the work of two teachers. Crazy...
I find it odd people say they do the job of the teacher- In my school they finish at 3.30, come in with the children and have no work to do at home, how can that be compared to teacher hours?????
Witchcraftandhokum · 16/06/2021 09:50

singsingbluesilver yes I'm on less pay than the teachers I manage. My salary sometimes may look similar but then I'm pro-rata'd to term time only but they aren't.

In answer to your question about split management it works well. I have the experience and knowledge to train and support them in Pastoral issues where subject heads don't.

singsingbluesilver · 16/06/2021 09:44

Witchcraft so you are in middle management but on less pay than those teachers who are not ? I do wonder how having multiple managers works out for the teaching staff.

mag2305 · 16/06/2021 09:41

@Sweak oh sorry, I got the wrong end of the stick there. Oops. Good luck for your new position in September, hope it goes well. Smile

Witchcraftandhokum · 16/06/2021 09:40

Not exactly but similar.

Sweak · 16/06/2021 09:36

@witchcraftandhokum are you a non teaching head of year?

Witchcraftandhokum · 16/06/2021 09:33

Singsingbluesilver The management of our teachers is split. The subject head manages them in all aspects of teaching and learning. I manage them in the Pastoral part of their role, safeguarding etc.

Sweak · 16/06/2021 09:22

Oh @mag2305 I'm not unqualified. I have QTS too. I've just got a new teaching job starting in September.

And yes in secondary schools, the very rare posts for unqualified were for graduates. Like I say I saw that for private schools though. I'm sure it's happening in secondary academies too but it's very rare to see a post advertised that doesn't require QTS

mag2305 · 16/06/2021 09:09

@Sweak yes, I am primary so that might make a difference. Although I think academies can arrange things to suit themselves sometimes too, financially that is. I was in an academy school.

With unqualified teachers in secondary, I do know of this happening. However, from what I know, it tends to be people with a relevant degree and expertise but no qts. Although schools do offer training on the job in some cases. In secondary, it always used to be maths teachers that were so desperately wanted and were given the 'golden handshake'.

Definitely consider getting into a school first, show them what you can do then you're in a good position to ask for more responsibility. Have you got a subject preference?

JustLyra · 16/06/2021 09:01

TAs I know find other work to top up their earnings, earning more per hour in retail/bar work than in a school.

One of the sneakier/unseen elements of the spreading of pay over 12 months is that people don’t qualify for benefits (or as much too up benefit) during the summer when often they’d be entitled to.

There was a push in one council in Scotland a while back that Classroom assistants (different role, but similar in terms of paid for term time only and speed over 12 months) should be allowed to choose between term time wages and equal spread because of that issue.

Sweak · 16/06/2021 08:55

@singsingbluesilver agree with your points entirely.

I'm sure some secondary schools are using TAs like this. I just think it's more common place in primaries...particularly using the TA as a full time teacher long term as pp described

The poster who was talking about managing staff but she's not a teacher. I got the impression she has a leadership role but isn't necessarily a line manager? If that makes sense. Like isn't in charge of performance management. Poster please correct me if I'm wrong

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 16/06/2021 08:37

@MojoMoon

Starting salary for a teacher is 25k - and that is for considerably more hours, stress and responsibility than a TA and after completing a degree and post grad qualification.

So relative to a teacher, I am not sure I would say they are vastly underpaid.

But relative to their merits in society, I would say both were underpaid.

Most TAs only get paid for the hours they work though, not for all the holidays, so they don't earn anywhere near the published salary. - I believe most earn about £11k a year.. TAs I know find other work to top up their earnings, earning more per hour in retail/bar work than in a school.
singsingbluesilver · 16/06/2021 08:29

I have seen HLTAs cover classes, in secondary schools and also be timetabled for classes in order to fill gaps in the tt. It 100% should not be happen but it does. It really is down to poor management, lack of funding and parents either not being aware or not caring enough to raise concerns.

Schools have (or at least to my knowledge should have) insurance which covers them for the costs of supply for long term absence so HTLAs should only be used for day to day cover when teachers are off sick for a couple of days. But, again, I have seen HTLAs/ cover supervisors used to cover long term.

To the poster who claimed that teachers need no qualifications - I have never seen an advert for a teacher without QTS (in secondary school that requires a 3 year degree and one year post grad course, plus one year NQT). There may be academies that appoint non qualified teachers but I have no experience of them.

I don't know why this thread seems to have developed into a teachers v LSA debate. They are different jobs, different qualifications and different pay scales. Many LSAs deserve to be paid more than they are - what teachers earn is not relevant. If LSAs and HTLAs are being asked to do more that the role requires then they are being exploited.

If someone without QTS is managing teachers who are paid more than them then that is a very odd management structure. I am still struggling to see how someone can be in middle management and yet be less qualified and be paid less than the people they manage.

JustLyra · 16/06/2021 08:20

Just to say - some TAs still have to use wraparound care. My other half is a TA and finishes at 4.30pm (only half an hour before me in a normal 9-5 job). Primary school kicks out at 3.10pm.

This.

Plus even if you finish bang on the school bell time that only works if you work in your child’s school.

When I worked in schools people always commented how “lucky” I was that I didn’t need childcare when I still did as even if I finished in school A at 3.15 I couldn’t be at my child’s school at 3.15.

Sweak · 16/06/2021 08:19

Maybe you are right it's about getting established first...I do wonder if it's more common in primaries though.

Sweak · 16/06/2021 08:17

@mag2305 are you primary or secondary? I've actually not seen a TA do cover or teach lessons in the secondary schools I've taught at. I think it's more common in primary schools? We have cover supervisors to cover classes. Lessons pre planned by the teacher.

Could partly be down to needing the specific knowledge to deliver content at GCSE and A level perhaps. Or at primary sometimes I'm assuming it's better to have a great TA who knows the kids covering than external supply who has no relationship..probably true of special needs schools too. That's not to say that's fair on those TAs though. Especially if it's a long term thing where they need to plan rather than just deliver pre prepared lessons.

I totally agree QTS should mean something. But like I say I rarely see external roles advertised for unqualified.

mag2305 · 16/06/2021 08:01

Edit *none the wiser