Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Teaching Assistants are vastly underpaid for their role?

319 replies

altoran · 15/06/2021 14:03

When the role of Teaching Assistant was created, the idea was that they would help with basic tasks like photocopying, wall displays, etc. It was a very basic role with no real responsibility.
Now Teaching Assistants have a lot of responsibility and are very involved in children's education, although under the supervision of a teacher. But they receive very little over minimim wage for this.
AIBU to think they are vastly underpaid?

OP posts:
cocoloco987 · 19/06/2021 08:55

For us though the job has a pay scale which you work through by time in the job. It's not a very big one. Qualifications are irrelevant. I could go on to take several degrees and it would not affect my progression through the scale nor could I exceed the top end. My contract is for 25 hours a week and the dc I support needs 1:1 for those hours despite them not being allocated to him by the LA. If I wanted a different pay scale I'd have to apply for a different job that offered one.

Howshouldibehave · 19/06/2021 08:27

New EHC plans rarely state hours these days, it’s usually amount/banding of funding, so that makes sense with what the pp was saying-if the support staff wages rise, the funding will cover them for fewer hours. It’s rubbish really as it might encourage some heads to have the cheapest possible member of support staff in order to cover the most hours for the child.

cocoloco987 · 19/06/2021 07:39

I'm sure it works differently everywhere but we have 3 dc that qualify for the allocated 25 hours support then the rest needs to come out the general budget (we do get more than other schools due to the area) we are currently going in to the new term in August with 21 dc needing full time 1:1 support plus others that need regular support (due to conditions such as diabetes) the staffing has been allocated and there are no general classroom TA's after this has been covered

Sirzy · 19/06/2021 07:26

The local authority do allocate a certain amount of funding to the school based on what’s in the EHCP. The setting then uses this (on top of the nominalbudget for SEN) to cover what’s in section F of the plan

cocoloco987 · 19/06/2021 07:25

Yes the only dc at are school that have allocated hours have downs or other major medical need. Many more need 1:1 support but don't have the allocations. What it means is there are no general support TA's after the budget has been used up covering the 1:1 support and the 1:1s are stretched doing the job of 2 or more people because those classroom jobs still need done and there are plenty other kids that still need additional support outside of those allocated the 1:1 - which is exhausting and also doesn't do justice to the child

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 19/06/2021 07:24

[quote cocoloco987]@RockingMyFiftiesNot that's an unusual way for it to work. For us dropping hours wouldn't be possible as the dc needs support for the full amount of hours (and for the dc that have support allocated, it's hours that are allocated regardless of where the person is on the pay scale). A new qualification would not normally make a difference within the same job. You'd need to apply for a different job role on a different pay scale to see any difference in your wage.[/quote]
Maybe my friend has misunderstood what the head told her, that the LA had awarded x amount for support for the child she works with so they couldn't increase her pay, and would reduce her hours instead.

Sirzy · 19/06/2021 07:20

Sadly many EHCPs aren’t specific though so don’t state the number of hours support which is actually needed. I had to battle to get Ds a plan which was specific and ensured the level of support he needs.

cocoloco987 · 19/06/2021 07:17

@RockingMyFiftiesNot that's an unusual way for it to work. For us dropping hours wouldn't be possible as the dc needs support for the full amount of hours (and for the dc that have support allocated, it's hours that are allocated regardless of where the person is on the pay scale). A new qualification would not normally make a difference within the same job. You'd need to apply for a different job role on a different pay scale to see any difference in your wage.

Cheesypea · 19/06/2021 07:13

Lsa

Cheesypea · 19/06/2021 07:12

When I left my role as an la I got a support job with adults. The pay was double.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 19/06/2021 07:08

One of my TA friends is working towards her level 3 qualification, which will lead to an increased hourly rate. But she's a one-on-one support and the funding for the child is fixed. So when she gets her qualification, she won't get more money but a reduction in hours for the same money. Not many jobs where that would happen.

mag2305 · 18/06/2021 22:12

@Onlinedilema you're right it is a highly female dominated job, particularly in primary. Purely anecdotal, but my husband is a TA. He's works in a secondary PRU which is a tough environment and being a man possibly helps in some ways.

For us, my dh being a TA does fit in with children and holidays. I'm a teacher so it means we get the same holidays together which is nice. I'm currently pregnant but one day we'd like to share the childcare and work. Even if I only teach one or two days a week.

And yes, TAs can be over qualified. When I did the job before teaching, I was hired at a school with 6 other ladies. 4 of us had degrees. Doesn't mean much in the role though unfortunately. My dh is also a qualified counsellor but chooses to do TA work for the regular, consistent income, as well as the holidays even if the pay if rubbish.

Onlinedilema · 18/06/2021 21:08

The reason that lots of women , and it is women not men, apply to be TAs is simply down to this. It is virtually THE only job a mother can do which guarantees she can spend time with her children when they are not at school. The reason I didn't apply to work as a bin was was simple. Who will look after my children from 7.30am?
It's that simple.
That is why it is low paid because it is predominantly 'women's work'. Where I live there is never, ever a shortage of bin men. I happen to know someone who managed to get her son a full time job as a bin man. It was only through personal contacts that she managed it.
Every single TA I know, and I know plenty are very intelligent, well educated women who left much better paid well respected jobs. Again the reason was that they became mothers and did not have child care so needed a job to fit in with their children. If you could take unpaid leave in other jobs or work more flexible hours or had a husband who had the guts/employer who would support flexible working then things would be different.
As for it not being a dirty job are you joking?
You think cleaning vomit, shit and piss up is not dirty?
You think being told to fuck off and screamed at or hit is not poor working conditions. The trouble with working in schools is that you are increasingly doing the job of the failing parent. A young relative of mine is a TA she was bitten by a child.
I doubt most people would have to go back into work and work with the same person who had bitten them, all for around £11500 a year.

BoredWML · 18/06/2021 18:34

I am not a TA and I think they are massively underpaid. In most cases they are looking after couple of 'special' children in the class. I was very surprised when I found out how much they are earning.

BackforGood · 18/06/2021 18:16

TAs do get different pay, different T&Cs and have different responsibilities, it is true, but overwhelmingly they are vastly underpaid (as are Nursery staff in daycare).

I can't understand that 16% have said YABU - I suspect they don't realise what the role actually entails for so many.

ObviousNameChage · 18/06/2021 17:56

I need a job at some of these schools!

After NI and pension I still don't take home 1k(after many years at the same school and excellent performance reviews). I'm in 8 am until 3 pm and have a long list of jobs and responsibilities, on top of actual class work and admin/displays stuff. I've also ended up teaching more than once, including on my own, especially in lockdown.

18k is far ,far away.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 18/06/2021 17:54

I think this thread is too focused on TAs

The thread is about TAs!

Howshouldibehave · 18/06/2021 17:14

Don't be under any illusion that LSA or nursery nurse work in the lower year groups isn't physical and very unpleasant at times

I have taught YR for over 20 years, I know exactly what it’s like. I think teachers and support staff are fantastic. The point I was making was that even now with the pay being crap, people are still queuing up to do it because they like the working hours.

ReceptionTA · 18/06/2021 17:11

It can be very dirty work - I often go home and jump in the shower as I feel so dirty from all the contact I've had with poo Grin But for that part of the job I think the pay is about right- apart from being a nice person, it's not particularly skilled.

There are other aspects of the job such as teaching phonics and ensuring all children are reaching their reading potential pass the phonics screaning test, Ensuring EAL children who have zero English can access the curriculum, and the behaviour management etc are skills that not anyone who wants a term time only job can do before they've been trained. The training these days is as an apprentice on an apprenticeship wage.

We're going to be recruiting a 1:1 to work with a child with SEN. It's not going to be easy to find the right person. Although we'll only be looking for someone with level three qualifications, they'll need specific skills, and in return for those skills they will be paid less than £10ph. It's not a job I could do.

If my colleague who spent this afternoon having her face licked by a child is reading this- you're definitely not paid enough Grin

mag2305 · 18/06/2021 13:45

@Howshouldibehave

Bin men get paid more.

Those queues of people applying for TA jobs could apply to be refuse collectors, but they don’t. Presumably because it’s dirty, physical work and doesn’t fit round the school day/holidays.

Whilst people are desperate to work school hours, the pay will continue to be crap. They could go and and earn more in Tesco but most don’t, because of the hours.

Don't be under any illusion that LSA or nursery nurse work in the lower year groups isn't physical and very unpleasant at times.

All LSAs deserve a lot of appreciation for what they do but in my experience, support staff in nursery, reception, year 1, maybe year 2 as well, are total heroes. Unless you've worked in one of those year groups, I don't think you realise how grim it can be. I've been a reception and year 1 teacher for 10 years now. I could write a book about the poos, wees, sick, blood, snot, lick, dog/fox poo!! Most of these don't even make it to the toilets. Unfortunately support staff often take the brunt of this. For example, I've had the winter vomiting bug in a class of 30 reception children who don't tell you when they're about to be sick and then just do it all over the classroom so everyone can touch it and step in it... Sometimes my LSA and I didn't know whether to laugh or cry.

I taught a child for 2 years who had psychological issues around doing a poo so would have multiple, daily accidents. Both my wonderful LSAs dealt with it amazingly. True heroes! The parents didn't even show much appreciation for the level of personal care given to the child which was a bit sad, but their work was very much appreciated by myself and the school.
It's lovely to see parents commenting on this thread who have really appreciated their child's LSA, especially the 1:1s. Because it really can be a tough, underpaid job.

Sweak · 18/06/2021 13:29

The bin man comment reminded me of a student in my NQT year who rejoiced in telling me a bin man would earn more than me.

I think it is another example of supply and demand right? I'm assuming bin men need to be fairly well paid to make the job attractive. Whereas as plenty have pointed out the school hours make being a TA attractive so people will accept the job even although the wage isn't high

cocoloco987 · 18/06/2021 13:14

I think that salary is probably maintained schools with BM who do a bumped up bursar role. In most academies business managers are paid at least the say as the deputy head and are SLT.

I'm in Scotland we don't have academies etc so it's a totally different structure altogether.

Is that full time wage about right? Yeah probably, for a job that doesn't require a degree or have any supervisory/managerial/strategic etc responsibilities.

The 17k here is the full time wage. What i actually earn for working 25h pw is around 9k

mrsorms · 18/06/2021 12:57

I do apologise, I have not read the entire thread. However, my eldest son has SEN and when he was at school, his TA was vital to his ability to participate in any activity and to learn.

The TA broke down questions for him, carried out interventions, such as prompting him to find a quiet place, built up a rapport and a relationship with him.

He had a number of complex needs and developed significant mental health issues. The TA's job was difficult and demanding, often dealing with issues of self harming and terrific meltdowns.

I respect teachers and TAs, but the job his TAs did held huge responsibility and was incredibly difficult. It was not teaching, but it required a skills set that was worth far more than the TAs were paid.

SunshineSum · 18/06/2021 12:19

That is, £21.5k - £24k. Looking at other jobs with that wage it's about right.

Ofc as I said earlier, pretty much all workers at that pay level are underpaid at present when you look at inflation vs pay and compare the two over time.

But that issue is not unique to TAs.

SunshineSum · 18/06/2021 11:11

@LynetteScavo but contractual hours are relevant. At 65% of full time hours it is a very part time job so the pay is pro rata. Add another third onto the wage and that's what it would pay if TA was a full time job.

Is that full time wage about right? Yeah probably, for a job that doesn't require a degree or have any supervisory/managerial/strategic etc responsibilities.