Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Teaching Assistants are vastly underpaid for their role?

319 replies

altoran · 15/06/2021 14:03

When the role of Teaching Assistant was created, the idea was that they would help with basic tasks like photocopying, wall displays, etc. It was a very basic role with no real responsibility.
Now Teaching Assistants have a lot of responsibility and are very involved in children's education, although under the supervision of a teacher. But they receive very little over minimim wage for this.
AIBU to think they are vastly underpaid?

OP posts:
Skyla2005 · 15/06/2021 16:09

T a s carry the teachers most of the time they end up doing much more than they are supposed to

Bargebill19 · 15/06/2021 16:08

Yanbu. I earn more as a cleaner and don’t have to work outside my paid hours. I really can’t see why anyone would do it other than for the ‘love of the job’.

MrsBungle · 15/06/2021 16:05

I agree TA’s are ‘worth’ more. In my trust they’re paid between £18k-£27k (full time equivalent) depending on grade. I have to say though we never have any trouble recruiting to the roles.

altoran · 15/06/2021 15:59

The average secondary school teacher earns £39,000 a year.

OP posts:
OttilieKnackered · 15/06/2021 15:58

I stand corrected!

InpatientGardener · 15/06/2021 15:56

I started out as a TA ten years ago, I loved it but my take home pay was about 900 a month on full time term time hours. I couldn't afford to pay into the LGPS even (generous local government pension scheme). I also used to get used as cover when teachers were off or out of the room..this was a generic SEN school with 10-12 per class but some very challenging behaviour from usually at least half the pupils. Its something I would like to go back to but I expect the pay would prevent this for me. Can't live off that in the South East!

Tangled22 · 15/06/2021 15:49

Agreed. Echo what PP have said about TAs often having to teach the whole class for half days or even whole days, teaching subjects they may know nothing about, and running their own after school clubs. The level of responsibility is not reflected in what they are paid. TAs should be paid more and teachers should be paid more too.

Nursery workers should also be paid more.

ItsSnowJokes · 15/06/2021 15:44

Locally TAs earn between 11.5-13.5 for an 8.30-3.30 day. Yes they have the school holidays off but they only get paid for the 28 days (or more if the school over it) statutory holiday pay (this is included in the figure above).

TAs and EYF workers are not paid nearly enough for the amazing work they do, but as others have said they get so many applicants for TA jobs (EYFS are struggling to recruit in a lot of areas) due to hours for mums and dad's that they have no incentive to pay them anymore.

billyt · 15/06/2021 15:44

Please excuse my fat fingers....

Many a time,

(who is actually HLTA level...

billyt · 15/06/2021 15:42

@singsingbluesilver,

I know that using TAs as 'cheap labour' is a ploy by headteachers.

But to say 'nor do they just 'bugger off' for the fun of it.' isn't correct either.

May I time teachers that I know of will direct their TA/LSA (who Sia actually HLTA with a degree) to run the class while the teacher takes kids out to do things the TA should be doing as it's deemed the easier option.

So like you say about TAs, some teachers can also be downright lazy, with zero empathy. And treat their TAs like some sort of lower class person.

(And no. I'm not a TA.)

altoran · 15/06/2021 15:41

@OttilieKnackered no it is not, or at least not for those over 23 years of age. You don't get 16 and 17 year old TAs usually. Normal working week minimum wage is about £17,300. So £18,000 is just over minimum wage.

OP posts:
Morgoth · 15/06/2021 15:36

They are underpaid but paid the right amount comparatively to teachers. Meaning both roles are vastly underpaid.

OttilieKnackered · 15/06/2021 15:32

[quote altoran]@OttilieKnackered I am not comparing their pay to teachers, but to pay in other roles. And the level of pay is terrible.[/quote]
Well, £18k isn’t just over minimum wage is it? Minimum wage is about £13k I think. Granted it’s low, but I think it’s a bit disingenuous to imply they make basically minimum wage.

altoran · 15/06/2021 14:43

@OttilieKnackered I am not comparing their pay to teachers, but to pay in other roles. And the level of pay is terrible.

OP posts:
cannotchange · 15/06/2021 14:43

Unlike teachers TAs don't get paid during the school holidays and don't get the same pension. But do have a lot of responsibility with regards to childrens' education and attainment.

Absolutely ridiculous that you have to be degree education to get a HLTA qualification, yet with this you earn about 50p more an hour !!

singsingbluesilver · 15/06/2021 14:39

Can people stop blaming teachers for TAs being far too much responsibility for the pay scale they are on? Teachers do not direct TAs to work as underpaid supply teachers, nor do they just 'bugger off' for the fun of it. Teachers also do not decide on the working hours of TAs. It's not their fault when TAs are exploited and are directed by the head to work unpaid hours.

Headteachers are the ones who take the decision to save on staffing costs by using TAs where they should be using a qualified teacher. Blame them. Or better still, blame the government who changed the rules about need QTS in order to be a teacher. Teaching unions tried to raise concerns at the time, but no one listened.

I am sure that many parents would be shocked at just how many TAs are being used in place of teachers.

I have worked with some amazing TAs - worth their weight in gold who deserved double what they were earning. I also also worked with some who were lazy, had terrible literacy skills, and had no empathy for those in their charge. So, from amazing to downright useless - just like people in all places of work I should think.

OttilieKnackered · 15/06/2021 14:37

It looks like about an £18k FTE salary (though most earn a lot less as the hours are quite short. Not great, but there’s no point comparing the pay to a qualified teacher as the roles are totally different with massively differing levels of responsibility. TAs shouldn’t be taking any work home or having to use any of their holidays to do work. If they are, the problem is the management’s expectations of them.

I imagine for many the hours are highly attractive as then fit in so well with their own kids’ hours and zero childcare.

Sirzy · 15/06/2021 14:36

Ds is in year 6 and has had 1-1 since year 2, full time since year 4. They have made it so education is accessible to him. His teachers have been amazing but his 1-1 even more so.

He is now preparing to move to a mainstream secondary (with 1-1) which would not have been possible without him having had that support.

For him the TAs have been invaluable

Fairyliz · 15/06/2021 14:35

@arethereanyleftatall

Well of course they are, but like any job, it's supply and demand. So so many people want to work those hours once they have children that they will pay as little as they can. Even if they were volunteer roles, they'd be half full!
This. I used to work in a school office and every time we advertised a TA role we would get about 50 applications (Midlands), several of which would be from qualified teachers. Schools don’t need to pay more to get good candidates.
ChangePart1 · 15/06/2021 14:34

As part of the Early Years workforce (I’m a childminder), thank you for recognising that we are underpaid for the level of responsibility we have. In the past I’ve had parents moaning About how much they are paying me, while they are taking home £40k + each year. I can only dream of a salary like that.

The phrase 'pay peanuts, get monkeys' springs to mind... not that nursery workers are monkeys, they're incredible. But why do we value a role so little when we are putting the most precious thing in our life, the lives of our child, in their hands? Why is that not valued more? Like you say, it can be hard to attract and retain staff with that salary. Not many people can afford to live on it!

It's just wrong, but I'm not sure what the solution is. I know some people struggle to afford childcare as it is, but others could easily pay more for it.

Greenmarmalade · 15/06/2021 14:32

I agree completely. It can be a really satisfying role but the pay is far too low for the level of responsibility and workload

Maryann1975 · 15/06/2021 14:31

@ChangePart1

YANBU.

I'm appalled by the salary earned by nursery workers too. They have so much responsibility and work so hard, and the ones I've come across are excellent at what they do, really good at building rapport with kids quickly and relationships with the children in their care. I'm in awe of them.

We take in chocolates regularly and send cards in to specific workers who've been great with our helped our DC but I would really be happy for our nursery to charge more so they could be paid more personally. Maybe a means tested charging scale so parents earning more pay more and those on less pay less. I just don't think it's acceptable they get paid so little for such a difficult, skilled job.

As part of the Early Years workforce (I’m a childminder), thank you for recognising that we are underpaid for the level of responsibility we have. In the past I’ve had parents moaning About how much they are paying me, while they are taking home £40k + each year. I can only dream of a salary like that.
One of my best friends is a TA and we are on similar hourly rates, although I work more hours, so my annual pay is more than hers. Part of her problem is that although she is full time, that’s only 30 hours a week, 38 weeks a year (And although she needs the money, she can’t see why she should have to work in the holidays to boost her income, which I disagree with but hey ho). Whereas most jobs, full time is 36 hours a week all year round. But I completely agree that the pay should be far higher for Caring jobs like Teaching assistants, early years staff and care home staff. There is little progression in any of those sectors and I know in one of our local nurseries, the difference in pay between the nursery nurses and the room supervisor is so little, they struggled to promote anyone as it wasn’t financially worth the stress. Unfortunately, I can’t see it changing any time soon.
JarJarQ · 15/06/2021 14:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

arethereanyleftatall · 15/06/2021 14:28

Well of course they are, but like any job, it's supply and demand. So so many people want to work those hours once they have children that they will pay as little as they can. Even if they were volunteer roles, they'd be half full!

LadyCatStark · 15/06/2021 14:23

In a previous school, TAs were expected to stay until 4 despite being paid til 3. I couldn’t as I couldn’t afford to pay for a late finish at nursery to work for free so my contact wasn’t extended. A few years after I’d left, the TAs got together to say that they should all be allowed to finish at 3. The teachers were dismayed as that’s when they needed the TAs to do the basic admin tasks (as they were now so busy during the day running groups etc). The TAs then came back and said could they then finish at lunch time on a Friday to gain back some of the time spent working for free (baring in mind they also worked for free for at least 20 mins every morning)… nope that was rejected. Guess who all started leaving bang on 3pm!

In the school I went to, I was practically usher out the door at my finish time and if I ever stayed late, I was told that I must take the time off an afternoon. The head teacher noticed that teachers liked TAs to be in at 8:45 so decided to pay everyone for this time. I stayed there for 5 years!