Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Teaching Assistants are vastly underpaid for their role?

319 replies

altoran · 15/06/2021 14:03

When the role of Teaching Assistant was created, the idea was that they would help with basic tasks like photocopying, wall displays, etc. It was a very basic role with no real responsibility.
Now Teaching Assistants have a lot of responsibility and are very involved in children's education, although under the supervision of a teacher. But they receive very little over minimim wage for this.
AIBU to think they are vastly underpaid?

OP posts:
Fitforforty · 15/06/2021 20:13

@shivawn

What qualifications are they required to have?
The same as a teacher there is no minimum standard.
lazee · 15/06/2021 20:12

Also the teachers were often summoned to meetings etc where us TA's were the ones waiting way over our hours to wait for parents of a poor anxious distressed child who was having a meltdown and refused to access their transport.
Transport never waits....

Imapotato · 15/06/2021 20:12

The pay is low for what they do, but then that could be said for most support roles in the public sector. 🤷‍♀️

lazee · 15/06/2021 20:09

@0None0

TAs often earn more per hour than teachers. They do less than half the hours and take home more than half the pay. I’ve been both. TAs are better paid
Well you must have worked at some dodgy school!
lazee · 15/06/2021 20:08

@Scr1bblyGum

“TAs aren’t qualified to teach and they shouldn’t be - it’s bad for kids.“

Well isn’t that the most ridiculous thing I’ve ever heard. TAS are teaching some of the most hard to teach kids most of the time. The ignorance re what the job entails is quite telling. It’s important that staff delivering interventions and all the many other jobs TAs do are well qualified and well trained.

I think a lot of people think we just wash paint pots all day. I wash paint pots about once a year. That is it. The rest of the time I don’t stop and draw hugely on my teaching skills, qualification and experience daily.

This
Zofloramummy · 15/06/2021 19:59

The pay is poor, the job is so rewarding. I love my home life balance now. I wanted to teach as a second career, 2 years as a TA has made me re evaluate that!

Pixxie7 · 15/06/2021 19:51

I think the same about health care assistant that are taking on more and more responsibility for very little reward.

Onewayoranother88 · 15/06/2021 19:48

Agree with that, there were 7 of us at my TA interview.

0None0 · 15/06/2021 19:46

Also you need to factor in that TA jobs are much sought after, whereas there is a critical shortage of teachers. Many TAs are ex teachers who do not want to teach. There is huge competition for TA jobs

0None0 · 15/06/2021 19:41

TAs often earn more per hour than teachers. They do less than half the hours and take home more than half the pay. I’ve been both. TAs are better paid

JustLyra · 15/06/2021 19:38

@sophi1995

My school used a TA for solo teaching work for over a month when the teacher was poorly.

That is crazy. Didn't parents complain that a TA was teaching their kids for an entire month? Why couldn't they get a substitute teacher?

Either there wasn’t the budget for it, or there may not have been any available.

It’s not uncommon for that to happen.

I worked in a school once where a really unlucky turn saw four teachers off long-term sick at the same time (not stress or anything to do with the school - just fluke timing) as well as three of maternity leave and the school simply didn’t have the budget to have four more long term supply teachers.

Also it can also depend if it’s known how long the teacher will be off for right away. If it’s thought they’ll only be off for a few days or a week then they muddle through, but then it’s another week, then another week.

Dustyhedge · 15/06/2021 19:31

At my daughter’s school it was the TAs that did all the key worker school. While I’m sure the teachers did a fair amount of planning on top, it seems like the TA was basically supervising and caring for 15 reception kids while the actual teachers made about 30 mins of content and did a zoom call twice a week.

Suzi888 · 15/06/2021 19:31

[quote altoran]@shivawn there are TA qualifications.
But TAs could get as much or more serving in a pub or a cafe without any qualifications. The only reason they get applicants is because of the school hours for mums.[/quote]
^ this
It’s a difficult job, a colleague of mine (who is tiny in stature) was placed with a college boy, SEN and he had violent outbursts. She didn’t want to tell anyone, but she was scared stiff. She couldn’t walk next to him, or sit by him in class or he would turn.

Scr1bblyGum · 15/06/2021 19:30

Howshouldibehave

It’s not mandatory but common. At my school several of the general TAs are quite experienced ex teachers. Others have degrees in other areas or previous professional jobs. We may all love it but we are all still all underpaid.

sophi1995 · 15/06/2021 19:30

My school used a TA for solo teaching work for over a month when the teacher was poorly.

That is crazy. Didn't parents complain that a TA was teaching their kids for an entire month? Why couldn't they get a substitute teacher?

Absy · 15/06/2021 19:26

YANBU
My DM is a TA. She’s a qualified teacher but despite 30+ years experience her qualifications weren’t recognised in the U.K., and she didn’t want all the extra responsibility. She loves her job (most of the time), particularly helping children who struggle with reading because of learning issues or because they barely speak English. She does a lot of unpaid work, like running clubs, supervising lunch breaks etc.

I also totally agree with the PP about early years educators. I don’t know how the manage with a room full of 2 and 3 year olds (it’s tiring enough living with one). My DD absolutely adores her teachers, and they come up with so many creative ways to keep them entertained and educated. During the first lockdown they put together activity packs for all the children and ran zoom classes. As a parent, it is tough paying so much (FT nurse places in central London can be £2,000 a month). The government could really step in and help as these EY workers do so much.

Howshouldibehave · 15/06/2021 19:25

@cannotchange

Unlike teachers TAs don't get paid during the school holidays and don't get the same pension. But do have a lot of responsibility with regards to childrens' education and attainment.

Absolutely ridiculous that you have to be degree education to get a HLTA qualification, yet with this you earn about 50p more an hour !!

Our TAs get paid monthly with salary broken into 12, throughout the year-just like the teachers.

I have also never worked with an HLTA who has a degree-that has certainly never been mandatory.

Thisisus909 · 15/06/2021 19:22

YANBU but it’s unlikely to improve anytime soon, sadly.
It’s also a job where the vast difference in skills is rarely recognised, unlike in other organisations. A skilled TA is as good as a good teacher (I say this as a teacher), a poor TA can be a pain for the teacher and make school horrible for children.
Schools often seem to have a mix of fantastic TAs who are drastically underpaid for their skill level and terrible ones who really should be fired.

ButterflyBitch · 15/06/2021 19:18

I also take small groups who need more targeted support and occasionally I will take the whole class if the teacher is out for some reason. I’m not paid for that ‘teaching’ time. Yes I don’t have to plan the lessons but if I’m delivering a lesson I don’t think I do that bad a job Grin

ReceptionTA · 15/06/2021 19:15

Most TAs I know hold qualifications far beyond the basic requirements. Half of us have degrees and one is a qualified teacher. Some are hoping were thinking of but have changed their minds to go in to teaching in the future. None of the TAs at the school I work in do it because of the hours. (Although initially I was looking for term time work when I applied as I had a DC who wouldn't have coped with holiday care).

I could earn more elsewhere, but I do love the job, even though it's the most stressful and exhausting job I've ever had. Grin The only reason I can afford to do the job at all is because DH earns considerably more than me. One TA who was a single parent received quite a lot in benefits. It not a job which always pays enough to be able to support yourself.

I'm very lucky that I'm paid from 8:30am - 4pm, with an unpaid lunch hour that I always work at least half of. I know most schools don't pay for such a long day. On an average day I will work an hour for free, but that's because I want everything to be lovely and organised, so I spend a lot of time sorting out things the class teacher should do but doesn't (not all teachers are like that!!!) and creating resources.

I don't think most parents really understand the role of. TA. They see us on the door in the morning, and letting out at the end of the day, and won't see the behaviour management, the many interventions, the first aid, the vomit,making sure children take medication at the right time, put their eye patch on, keep their eye patch on, the planning for when teachers will be out of the classroom, the cleaning up of pooped pants, coaxing a child out of a toilet cubicle, coaxing a child off the roof, the teaching of phonics, speaking with S&L therapists on how best to deliver interventions....we are accountable for children in our intervention groups making progress, but ultimately if they don't it's on the class teachers head. I'm certainly not expected to sharpen pencils these days. As a reception TA I'm also constantly facilitating children's play and making observations on the children.

I have no idea if TAs are underpaid. I think I do a damn fine job, I know I could earn more elsewhere, I know my teenage DS earns more than me at his part time job in McDonalds.

Maybe I should go and work in McDonalds...nah, I'd be bored pretty quickly! Grin

longsigh · 15/06/2021 19:15

The argument is that they could earn more at Tesco- but they would be doing nights weekends bank holiday etc- it's a pretty good wage for a job with lots of time off and easy hours!

ButterflyBitch · 15/06/2021 19:15

I’m a TA and I love that I don’t have to work outside of school hours. I can go in and do my job and come home. I also get all of the holidays free. But it can be tough. I help with the behaviour management of the whole class, I’m on the playground for break and lunch times and deal with any injuries. I help with lunch itself and serving puddings and drinks and clearing away. I do speech and language interventions and other SEN interventions and keep all the records updated. I also hear from the kids about all the things that happen in their little lives and I think that’s the toughest part sometimes. I don’t think I’m underpaid as such but if I didn’t have a dh I wouldn’t be able to survive on my wage I don’t think. I do feel that TAs often know the children a lot better than the teachers do.

lazee · 15/06/2021 19:13

Brainer 😬

DontDrinkDontSmokeWhatDoIDo · 15/06/2021 19:12

As a previous poster said - its supply and demand.

My friend was a highly qualified NHS director, she took early retirement and became a TA at her youngest son's school.

Massively qualified, hugely practical, resourceful, reliable, been there 4 years now,

Almost every TA there is a person from a prior career, happy to earn a low salary and do school hours.

Economically - why would you pay more unnecessarily if you had a very tight budget?

lazee · 15/06/2021 19:12

I used to work a 39 hour week in a SEN secondary ( very challenging students)
Earned 18k as level 4 qualified.
I now work as a PA for young adults with SEN.
Work 25 hours and earn 19k.
No brainier