Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Miriam Margoles would make a perfect Nanny Ogg?

234 replies

Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 00:17

Started re-reading the Discworld series (really need something to cheer me up atm) and it just struck me.

Granny Weatherwax - Maggie Smith maybe?

OP posts:
MummBraTheEverLeaking · 16/06/2021 02:39

IMO they got the castings very well done for the adaptations they did on Sky. Although I preferred David Jason as Albert over Rincewind.

Richard Coyle and Claire Foy as Moist and Adora were great, as was Michelle Dockery as Susan. And as mentioned by many, Charles Dance as Vetenari was bloody excellent.

Whatup · 16/06/2021 02:31

I think the live action movies had perfect casting wouldn't change a thing. The animated series were also good and Tony Robinson in the audio tapes nailed it also. This city watch thing looked massively suspect who in omms name thought they knew better about characters and development than sir Terry pratchett? If you really want a good Terry pratchett experience go to one of his adapted for stage plays. He wrote in a way where it was mainly the character and their actions that explained their outward appearance. And if anyone is a massive discworld fan Josh kirby has produced some face masks. Now I'm off to sing a song about hedgehogs and have my dried frog pills!!!!!

Needhelp101 · 16/06/2021 02:14

Oh, and yes to Nick Frost for Colon!

OP posts:
Needhelp101 · 16/06/2021 02:14

@TheTruthAndNothingButTheTruth

Agree Paddy Considine would be great for Vimes and I do think Miranda Hart would make a good Sybil. Andrew Scott for Moist James Norton for Carrot. She's too young now but in 20 yrs - Daisy May Cooper for Nanny Ogg Tony Robinson would have been a good Nobby a few years ago. I can't pin point Colon or Granny W.
Agree with almost all of these. Miranda as Sybil, definitely. She's got that kind of clanging upperclass confidence together with kind of shy, rather beautiful vulnerability.

I also thought of Tony Robinson as Nobby, he's basically a slightly more intelligent Baldrick Smile

God I need to go to bed 😊

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 16/06/2021 01:33

Toby Jones for Nobby or is he too old (and clearly human)?

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/06/2021 01:32

I will allow Luke Evans or Sam Heughan as Carrot. I'm generous like that Grin

The problem with Granny is that she so clear in my head that no one is her. They need some unknown character actor who is her. And has never been anything else.

TheTruthAndNothingButTheTruth · 16/06/2021 00:56

Agree Paddy Considine would be great for Vimes and I do think Miranda Hart would make a good Sybil.
Andrew Scott for Moist
James Norton for Carrot.
She's too young now but in 20 yrs - Daisy May Cooper for Nanny Ogg
Tony Robinson would have been a good Nobby a few years ago.
I can't pin point Colon or Granny W.

SirSamuelVimes · 16/06/2021 00:28

Gwendoline Christie for Angua?

KirstyHasLeft · 15/06/2021 22:57

I love you all for this thread :)

Sunbird24 · 15/06/2021 22:52

Maybe Sheila Hancock as Granny W…

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 15/06/2021 22:49

@MrsTerryPratchett

Sam Heughan as Carrot anyone?
YES!

...Ahem.

Furiousfive · 15/06/2021 22:46

Yes! I've always thought MM for Nanny Ogg! I used to think Maggie Smith for Granny but I like the suggestion of Fiona Shaw...

crumpet · 15/06/2021 22:33

Sam Heughan as Carrot? He’s suitably huge and beefy

Sunbird24 · 15/06/2021 22:32

Maybe Luke Evans could dye his hair?

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/06/2021 22:26

I assume the actor can learn an accent, to be fair

True but this has to be perfect.

Hot, tall, ginger welshmen anyone?

CaptainThe95thRifles · 15/06/2021 22:23

@JohnLapsleyParlabane

Sean Bean as Vimes
I could get on board with that.

Lee Mack isn't an obvious choice for Rincewind, but I strangely think it could work. And MM is a perfect Nanny Ogg.

Gazelda · 15/06/2021 22:15

Oh gosh, I though NannyOgg was a MN character 😳. I had no idea she is a real life book character! And I consider myself pretty literate too. Yikes.

Shoppingwithmother · 15/06/2021 22:14

I’ve never consciously realised this before until reading this thread, but I imagine two of the characters as Simpsons characters (although all the rest as real people)!
I for some reason imagine Sam Vimes as Chief Wiggum and Vetinari as Mr Burns!

Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 22:14

Definitely Emma Chambers for Magrat 😢

OP posts:
Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 22:12

@Sunbird24

MM would do an excellent hedgehog song…
She would, too 😂. Wonder if we'd ever hear the 14th verse about goats? (Think it's the 14th verse. Must re-read!)
OP posts:
Lockheart · 15/06/2021 22:10

@Amrapaali

And Ridcully in my mind is a striking double of Merlin in the Sword in the Stone.
Personality wise yes but Merlin from Sword in the Stone is far too skinny for the Ridcully in my head. He's more like Brian Blessed (but not so much that I think Brian Blessed should play him). He's got presence.
Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 22:09

@MrsTerryPratchett

Chris Pratt as Captain Carrot.

Carrot's not American. Welsh for preference but Scottish will do!

Physically as Carrot he'd be perfect but yes, he'd have to pull off the accent.

Kristen ST as Margolletta, perfect.

OP posts:
Lockheart · 15/06/2021 22:08

@MrsTerryPratchett

Chris Pratt as Captain Carrot.

Carrot's not American. Welsh for preference but Scottish will do!

I assume the actor can learn an accent, to be fair Wink
Stakhanovite · 15/06/2021 22:07

@MedusasBadHairDay

I'm rewatching the early Call The Midwife series, and reckon Pam Ferris would make an excellent Granny Weatherwax
I'm rewatching it too, and wondering about Miranda Hart for Sybil?
Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 22:07

I do hope some casting agents and directors are reading this Smile.

OP posts: