Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Miriam Margoles would make a perfect Nanny Ogg?

234 replies

Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 00:17

Started re-reading the Discworld series (really need something to cheer me up atm) and it just struck me.

Granny Weatherwax - Maggie Smith maybe?

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 18/06/2021 14:00

Slightly off the wall suggestion
Ray Winstone as Willikins. Willikins was a street fighter / gang member (think peaky blinders) in his youth who has risen to the rank of butler.
You need someone who is believable as a scullery boy made good.

pointythings · 18/06/2021 13:55

Ian Richardson did Death in Hogfather, I believe - and he was perfect. Sadly he is no longer around.

MilesJuppIsMyBitch · 18/06/2021 13:13

I'm sure a place could be found for Brian Blessed in Dunmanifestin

Sunbird24 · 18/06/2021 12:32

Any way we can find someone for Brian Blessed to play please?

Needhelp101 · 18/06/2021 11:19

@MilesJuppIsMyBitch

I'd come back to suggest Roger Allam for Vimes, but I see I've been beaten to it.

I still think Chris Pratt for Carrot. He's brilliant at accents: ever see the clip of him on Graham Norton doing his TOWIE bit? Amazing.

Aiden Turner as human Greebo. Yeowww.

Aiden Turner would be the perfect human Greebo fans self.

And Chris Pratt really can do accents (that Graham Norton clip is hilarious).

Very good point made by a PP about Death being animated but would need a good voice. Alan Rickman would have been good, maybe?

OP posts:
GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/06/2021 11:05

"Aiden Turner as human Greebo. Yeowww."

Oooooooooh yes!!

BrightYellowDaffodil · 18/06/2021 10:58

Roger Allam can be subtle, of course, but I reckon he's got the pipes to also pull off the Ridcully Boom.

Absolutely, just think of the "I'm a nurse killer, a banker and now I'm raising FUCKING TAXES?" line from Thick of It as Peter Manyon.

Nanny0gg · 18/06/2021 10:30

@M0rT

I always thought Brenda Fricker would make a great Granny Weatherwax. Miriam Margoles definitely has the Nanny Ogg spirit, I see her as a wiry woman though.
No! Definitely not.

Granny is the wiry one

MilesJuppIsMyBitch · 18/06/2021 10:19

I'd come back to suggest Roger Allam for Vimes, but I see I've been beaten to it.

I still think Chris Pratt for Carrot. He's brilliant at accents: ever see the clip of him on Graham Norton doing his TOWIE bit? Amazing.

Aiden Turner as human Greebo. Yeowww.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/06/2021 10:06

Oh god you said Carrot - definitely not DD!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/06/2021 10:06

I would say Danny Dyer is more Nobby than Vimes!

Yes I can see Whoopi Goldberg as NO, but also MM.

Maggie Smith would give good Granny Weatherwax I think.

Someone like Damien Lewis would be Carrot in my eyes- he’s meant to be very attractive.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/06/2021 09:55

I always wondered why he didn’t do Sir Friendzone (forgotten real name of GOT character) Scottish as I think of Bear island as in Scotland!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/06/2021 09:54

Whoever said Ian Glen as Vimes is genius. I wouldn’t have thought of him, but perfect.

Vimes has a Scottish accent in my head, although I’m pretty sure Terry Pratchett did not intend that!

TheTruthAndNothingButTheTruth · 18/06/2021 09:43

Oh I have a soft spot Ridcully and more importantly, so does Granny W Grin I mean obviously he is absolutely awful but hilarious and deceptively clever and every now and then rises above the foolishness of the wizards so I'm sticking with my anti-Clarkson stance.

Blimey, I never thought I'd ever get heated on a TP thread, Discworld is my happy place Smile

HelloPudding · 18/06/2021 09:33

I think that Shirley from EastEnders has a very Granny W look to her. The glare, the cheekbones, the hardened-by-life set of the mouth.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/06/2021 09:15

Roger Allam can be subtle, of course, but I reckon he's got the pipes to also pull off the Ridcully Boom.

YesThisIsMe · 18/06/2021 09:12

Roger Allam is subtle. Ridcully is anything but. I agree that the late great Robert Hardy would have been brilliant.

Sam Vimes of Cable Street is actually canonically the original mentor of Roger Allam’s cynical old copper in Endeavour.

TheTruthAndNothingButTheTruth · 18/06/2021 09:07

Oh no, no to Clarkson. He’s a misogynist pig and violent to boot. There’s no place for him in TP ranks of heroes (and Ridcully is awesome!)

SoupDragon · 18/06/2021 08:18

Sam Heughan is, unfortunately, far too old to be Carrot

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/06/2021 07:50

Oooh, and Anthony Stuart Head as Vetinari! If you remember him as Giles, he can definitely bring the "edge" the character requires at times.

OccultGnuAsWell · 18/06/2021 07:46

Rather old school but does anyone remember Melvyn Hayes from "It Ain't Half Hot Mum"? played Gloria.

He's always been my Nobby.

(Did NOT think I'd type a sentence like that before 8am on a Friday)

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 18/06/2021 07:41

Sadly Robert Hardy is dead - he was 91 when he died in 2017

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/06/2021 07:37

I always though Jane Horrocks, in her younger days, would be a great Magrat.

I quite fancy Rupert Graves generally for Vimes, he did world-weary-but-dogged-and-determined police officer so well in Sherlock.

Ewan McGregor has the charm for Moist , I think.

John Finnemore for Rincewind, maybe? I definitely want to get him in there somewhere! Oh, and while I'm Cabin Pressure casting, Roger Allam as Ridcully?

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/06/2021 07:27

Ah, apologies Crumpet, I read on and realised you'd already been telt. Grin

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 18/06/2021 07:26

@crumpet

Nanny Ogg is skinny and wiry isn’t she? I always imagine Granny W as plump
No! Granny Weatherwax is described as on the thin side but remarkably strong. Nanny Ogg is short and fat. Tbf, she's also had loads of children and is very well fed by her many DILs.

Sheila Hancock as Granny Weatherwax for me.