Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Miriam Margoles would make a perfect Nanny Ogg?

234 replies

Needhelp101 · 15/06/2021 00:17

Started re-reading the Discworld series (really need something to cheer me up atm) and it just struck me.

Granny Weatherwax - Maggie Smith maybe?

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 19/06/2021 17:16

Richard E Grant could be Mr Slant and not just because it rhymes.

Possibly Robbie Coltrane as the Dean

CaptainCallisto · 19/06/2021 17:14

I too picture Reg as taller, but I couldn't really think if anyone tall that said Reg to me... I think Rowan Atkinson would probably do it well, but he's still not quite right for me either.

I thought Going Postal was wonderful. Brilliantly cast all round. Hogfather was also very good. I hated David Jason as Rincewind (though loved him as Albert) so Colour of Magic was a miss for me.

ItIsAShameAboutRay · 19/06/2021 17:04

Somehow I always picture Reg as slightly taller and thinner than Toby Jones, but TJ would do earnest very well though!

Idris is too big to be Vimes, I see him as shorter, tough and wiry.

Basically Stephen Briggs need to be everyone because his voices are so perfect in the audio books Grin I love Carrot being Welsh, it's just wonderful.

I've never watched any of the TV adaptions, are they worth seeing or best avoided?

CaptainCallisto · 19/06/2021 13:38

What do we think to Toby Jones for Reg Shoe? I think he'd do earnest zombie rather well.

MilesJuppIsMyBitch · 19/06/2021 12:54

GW would have been a brilliant MNer, though. In the custardo-on-teen-behaviour-threads vein.

GlendaSugarbeanIsJudgingYou · 19/06/2021 11:44

@GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal

I do love a Pratchett thread, they're just so nice. So much of Mumsnet just seems so toxic and angry atm, whereas a Pratchett appreciation thread is like the internet version of a lovely hot cup of tea and a biscuit.
I agree. Smile

Brew Biscuit (friendly biscuit)

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 19/06/2021 11:38

Idris Elba for Vimes.

Weepingwillows12 · 19/06/2021 09:57

Daved Tennant as Carcer is a great shout. I love these threads too but I never actually like any Pratchett tv shows as they never quite get the humour across properly. I think it could work for a Guards series.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 19/06/2021 09:27

I do love a Pratchett thread, they're just so nice. So much of Mumsnet just seems so toxic and angry atm, whereas a Pratchett appreciation thread is like the internet version of a lovely hot cup of tea and a biscuit.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 19/06/2021 09:23

Much as I would love to take the credit, that idea came from @Redskyatnightsailorsdelight Smile

Dontgonearthecastle · 19/06/2021 09:11

Jim Carter (Carson, Downton Abbey) for Death - great voice!

Ralph Fiennes is my Vetinari I'm afraid.

And David Tennant as Carcer is inspired @GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal

C8H10N4O2 · 19/06/2021 09:08

James Earl Jones. [as DEATH]

But can you hear James Earl Jones murdering a curry? Morgan Freeman on the other hand.

I also struggle to see GW as anyone other than the Granny in my head but Adjoa Andoh could have a good stab

Also like Dev Patel as Mort upthread.

The late Bob Peck or a modern Idris Elba as Vimes

Joanna Lumley as Mrs Cake.

I used to love a good discworld casting thread - don't often see them these days Grin

CaptainCallisto · 19/06/2021 08:34

I always thought Christopher Lee should have played Mr Slant

SirSamuelVimes · 19/06/2021 08:31

Ooh good call, yes he'd be brilliant at that.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 19/06/2021 08:16

I think David Tennant as Carcer is inspired. I can really see him doing that sudden switch from "who, me guv? I'm just a bit of a cheeky chappie, heart of gold, no harm done" to absolute fucking psycho really well.

SirSamuelVimes · 19/06/2021 08:06

David Tennant would make a good assassin but I don't think he'd have enough to do in any of the assassins roles? He'd make a cracking Oh God though, I think he'd do a good Billius.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 19/06/2021 00:15

@WalkingOnTheCracks

Sorry. He is much missed.

(And that should read “Hamish and Dougal”)

I’m all for David Tennant in anything but after his performance as Crowley, I rather imagined him as someone from the Assassins Guild…

WeatherwaxOn · 18/06/2021 22:34

Only read p1 as my computer is on a go-slow but I have often thought Sheila Hancock would be good as Granny Weatherwax.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 18/06/2021 22:31

So who could play DEATH?

WalkingOnTheCracks · 18/06/2021 22:30

@BrightYellowDaffodil

Charles Dance was amazing as Vetinari, I couldn't cast anyone else.

I always imagined Vetinari as the late, great Jeremy Hardy (playing a similar role as he did in Hamish & Douglas as The Laird).

And absolutely yes to Eileen Atkins as Granny Weatherwax (GW being my all-time hero)!

...you just reminded me that Jeremy Hardy died. That's punctured my evening a bit....
Weepingwillows12 · 18/06/2021 22:19

I always picture a younger Martin Sheen as Moist.

I think Colon is really hard. Nick Frost could work but it's not perfect....i feel like theres someone better out there.

Totally agree on MM as nanny Ogg.

SionnachRua · 18/06/2021 22:18

@Needhelp101

Need to get The Rock in there somehow 😁 Chryosphase? Detritus?
Honestly if the Rock were a Nordic looking sort he'd be the perfect Carrot Grin
sauceyorange · 18/06/2021 22:10

@MilesJuppIsMyBitch

Alan Davies could do the voice of Gaspode
👏👏👏
sauceyorange · 18/06/2021 22:09

Alistair cook for carrot? Except he's not ginj

MilesJuppIsMyBitch · 18/06/2021 22:07

Alan Davies could do the voice of Gaspode