Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I might have lipedema? Anyone know anything about it?

110 replies

GentleGiantOctopus · 14/06/2021 18:48

I’ve read around 10% women have lipedema, many of whom go undiagnosed.

Ever since puberty, I’ve always had very flabby upper thighs and large buttocks compared with the rest of my body. I’m skinny on the top half of my body, but my bottom half is really wobbly. My muscles aren’t strong but if I bulked them up, the fat would still be there - I know this because I have been a stone underweight in the past when I compulsively exercised and ate barely anything (unfortunately I was anorexic as a teen, but thankfully have been well for around 20 years now). Even then, I could grab a whole handfuls of it, which is part of what kept me in the grip of anorexia until I realised it was too miserable living life like that and started

My thighs currently look very similar to the attached image (insta pic of a young woman who has lipedema). I also have an awful lot of cellulite - the kind that practically throws shadows in places!

Exercise-wise now, I walk a lot, but don’t run (bad knees) or go to the gym. In the week I don’t tend to walk over 8,000 steps a day, but on weekends it can easily be above 20,000 each day. I walk swiftly every day so as to get my heart rate up and always run up the stairs at home.

My ankle on one side has a swelling that my GP previously said was a lipoma, but now I’m wondering if this is part of a bigger issue. I also have optic nerve drusen (fat deposits on the optic nerve) and a cholesterol that is on the higher side of normal, despite a healthy diet.

My BMI is around 19.5 (so I am still on the slim side) and my upper half looks skinny which I don’t like, but I never gain weight there. I also have slight bat wings under my arms.

I had liposuction around age 20 to remove my saddlebags on my outer thighs (plus a revision surgery). They are still there a bit, but considerably less noticeable than they were. They were very prominent prior to surgery and looked rather odd compared with my bony top half - they looked very like this: www.instagram.com/p/CEHrDM2gt1N/

As I get older, I have stopped wearing normal socks as I get a huge sock line at the ankle that lasts for hours. I wear trainer socks now. My legs get slightly bigger by the end of the day, but probably only I would notice. When it’s really hot or I have eaten something really salty, they swell as well (especially with the latter).

My query is, could it be lipedema if I have no pain? The ‘lipoma’ on my leg aches a bit sometimes, but nothing major. The rest of the flab is not painful.

Or am I just ‘skinny fat’? I am conscious that if it is lipedema there are things I need to be doing to prevent its progression. Problem is, I have a feeling it would be very hard to get a diagnosis because right now I don’t look particularly out of proportion - a passer-by might only look twice if they saw me in a swimming costume (which will be NEVER, haha) and I have read that most GPs don’t know much about to the condition.

Thanks and sorry for the long post.

OP posts:
Zerogravity · 19/07/2021 18:23

My legs look very similar to yours and I am beginning to suspect the same. I have always felt "little balls" under the skin on my thighs and it can be quite painful. What really made me think though is this summer, I can see I have got fat around my knees - they look like my grandmother's knees! She had quite limited mobility due to her big legs despite being generally not overweight.

GentleGiantOctopus · 19/07/2021 18:23

@NeverDropYourMooncup I haven’t, no. As with lipedema, I haven’t (yet) suffered any major issues that made me feel I could justify seeing a GP. I do have a lot of the symptoms of EDS though - hyper mobility, constantly clicking joints, soft skin, easy bruising, etc.

What makes me think it’s lipedema (though doesn’t discount EDS) is how scrawny my top half is in comparison. There is almost no fat on my upper half, apart from my upper arms and a small amount around my belly. So it’s strange that my body is beginning to lay down fat around my ankles, when the upper half needs it more! It’s crap because there are summer dresses I’d like to wear but I just look rubbish in ones that expose my back, shoulders and arms.

To think I might have lipedema? Anyone know anything about it?
OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 19/07/2021 18:15

@GentleGiantOctopus God you look amazing!! Yes, I would agree on stage 1. The curve on your thighs is indicative and I can't see your cuffs but then I'm used to my 22 ins calves Sad but its not unusual to have different sized legs. My left is bigger than my right and my ankle cuffs are actually 2/3 the way down my calves! At your stage in the game, I would recommend seeing a guy called Dr Gupta at the Hunar Clinic. He could probably sort that in a one-er for you Wink x

GentleGiantOctopus · 19/07/2021 18:02

@TheSnootiestFox Ah, sod it, as you say I’ve already bared my cellulite, so you might as well see the rest.

Excuse the filthy old dusty mirror and the stubble, ladies Grin

I would guess that if I have lipedema, I am in stage 1, but I am noticing a build up round my lower legs these last couple of years (diet has not changed and has in fact been a bit more restricted). The only thing that makes me question lipedema is that I am not completely symmetrical - the ankle cuff forming on my left leg is far more advanced than on my right. Plus I have that delightful little roll of fat under my right butt cheek, but not on the other side.

To think I might have lipedema? Anyone know anything about it?
To think I might have lipedema? Anyone know anything about it?
OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/07/2021 17:37

My first thought is to ask whether you've been seen by a rheumatologist due to the possibility of EDS, as you could easily have very loose skin that you are mistaking for something else.

GentleGiantOctopus · 19/07/2021 17:31

@ghislaine I also desperately hope the technique makes it across the Atlantic. I found it very interesting, especially when they showed how it spared the blood vessels. Those who use the technique argue it’s no harsher than a deep tissue massage. Maybe in a few years.

I have also been reading about the keto diet being beneficial for lipedema sufferers. I have to admit that I tend to eat a very carb-heavy diet. I also ate a very sugar-heavy throughout my youth (think endless fruit, cereals and low fat yoghurts laden with sugar) - this was back when fat was thought to be the bad guy!

OP posts:
TheSnootiestFox · 19/07/2021 17:18

@ghislaine oooh, interesting. I wonder if she's up and coming in the lipoedema world? And that's interesting about Anne Dancey. I'm sure that she would change her mind if she was the one having to find 10k an op to only have 5 or 6 litres removed at stage 3 or 4!!

ghislaine · 19/07/2021 16:45

Catherine Milroy works with Peter Mortimer and Kristiana Gordon at St George's so I think that's why. But I agree, I never heard her mentioned as a Lipedema surgeon. She seems to do a lot of top surgery. I was googling her before my consultation and ended up deep in FTM trans forums!

Interestingly, Dr Gordon said she would not recommend Anne Dancey as her approach was too aggressive.

TheSnootiestFox · 19/07/2021 16:34

@Willyoujustbequiet -

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/07/2021 16:07

Following with interest as I believe this may run in my family.

Having said that those pics look like normal cellulite to me ... asked my girlfriends and 6 of us all had it in our WhatsApp group Confused

TheSnootiestFox · 19/07/2021 15:51

@GentleGiantOctopus - I'm afraid to say that those nodules look all too familiar. If you're happy to post a pic of your legs I can give you an indication as to what stage I think you are- I'm no Dr but I'm rarely wrong now Smile I would post my stage 3 beauties but as they've been all over the press theyre instantly recognisable to anyone who live locally to me Grin

@ghislaine - I've got a pretty good handle on the options for surgery in the UK and I've never heard Catherine Milroy mentioned. Quite why you'd be referred to her by Kristina Gordon who should know this stuff. It seems to be a split amongst the surgeons as to compression to life, Mr Munnoch told me yes, Dr Klasmeyer and Mr Karri both said no. They can only go on their experience I suppose.....

ghislaine · 19/07/2021 15:13

That is really interesting, @GentleGiantOctopus. I was intending to ask how liposuction deals with fibrotic fat as I had exactly that thought about the cannula. I went straight to the videos - amazing how much extra fat was extracted that way. Made me feel very hopeful. I wonder if/when this technique will make it across the Atlantic.

I think Catherine Milroy is an outlier. I definitely think she was trying to discourage me and/or was talking from a lymphodema standpoint. If the fat is removed, then the lymph system can surely function normally and there would be no need for compression.

GentleGiantOctopus · 19/07/2021 10:07

*nodules!

OP posts:
GentleGiantOctopus · 19/07/2021 10:07

@ghislaine 40k!!! Shock How very depressing.

I’ve been reading about manual lipedema nodule extraction. Oh my god, for those who enjoy Dr Pimple Popper’s videos, this is on another level! I can totally see why standard liposuction only partially helps, since all the modules can’t go up the cannula and just get left behind.

OP posts:
GentleGiantOctopus · 19/07/2021 10:03

Thanks so much @TheSnootiestFox. My turn to apologise for a late reply!

I have done some more self-examination by pinching the skin and am pretty convinced this is lipedema fat on my thighs. What do you reckon? I can see very obvious nodules! (By comparison my stomach fat is completely smooth when pinched).

Maybe it is normal cellulite, though.

I am also considering approaching Kristina Gordon for a diagnosis.

OP posts:
ghislaine · 10/07/2021 20:59

Has anyone seen Dr Wolf on Harley St? I was looking into the German clinics but I think that’s off the table for some time. I did see Kristina Gordon who diagnosed me and then sent me to Catherine Milroy to discuss liposuction. She was very discouraging, saying I would need daily compression garments for life plus it would cost £20k per full leg ie £40 for my lower half!

TheSnootiestFox · 09/07/2021 11:15

I've just come across this - sorry it's a few days old now. Chances are you probably do have lipoedema I'm afraid. Your description of porridge thighs and being hyper mobile clinched it for me Grin most GPs have no clue about it hence its woefully underdiagnosed. Surgery is the only real treatment but its nigh on impossible to get NHS funding, I have stage 3 disease and I'm on my second go. Feel free to ask me anything you need to know ahead of going to see your Dr. There is one NHS specialist in the UK, he is Mr Munnoch in Dundee. I live in Yorkshire and travelled up to see him last week after a 2 year wait. I've also seen Mr Karri privately. Good luck with it, its a vile disease and I wouldn't wish it on anyone x

GentleGiantOctopus · 25/06/2021 22:22

Thank you all for the useful replies and sorry I didn’t reply before now.

Foobydoo, I did that test (answering as conservatively as possibly) and scored 58%. Anywhere between 30-69% is listed as a possibility of lipedema (with 69% and up being highly likely)

Kurt, the fat feels relatively normal to me but ‘loose’ if that makes sense. Just like in the picture I posted. The only place it does feel a bit like peas/lentils is my inner thighs and I thought that was normal, maybe due to glands underneath?

It may or may not be relevant, but I am likely hyper mobile and my skin is extremely soft and velvety to the touch - my outer thighs look like porridge. I don’t think my cellulite is normal for my weight - by age 17 it was very pronounced and has slightly worsened over the years (but not much because I control my eating to avoid weight gain). I remember the articles showing Mishca Barton’s cellulite in 2008 and being grateful seeing a celeb with thighs similar to mine, but was gutted that the press was so horrible about it - suggesting her smoking was to blame - leading her to claim the image was doctored (could have been).

So lipedema does look like a possibility. Working myself up to seeing a GP about it.

OP posts:
Singlenotsingle · 16/06/2021 16:48

Thank you yesmate. So sweet.

Yesmate · 15/06/2021 11:02

Please go and see a GP or a specialist. Please don’t get your info from people on the internet or, even worse, Red Quest like the ill informed and offensive @Singlenotsingle seems to 🙄

Foobydoo · 15/06/2021 10:46

lipedemaproject.org/do-you-have-lipedema-quiz/

Lots of info on the site above.
Lipedema is not the same as obesity the fat is different and dieting will not reduce it. Women of all weights can have it you can be slim and have it or have obesity along side it. If you are obese diet will help with the regular fat but not the Lipedema fat, although some find the keto way of eating helps with the pain and inflammation that it cause. It is thought to be linked to hormones which is why it predominantly affects females. And doctors in the UK know very little about it.
There are some good groups on Facebook with advice on how to slow its progression.

KurtWilde · 15/06/2021 10:29

Actually bridge doctors don't know about lipodema. It's very difficult to get any of them to listen or indeed look into it.

bridgetreilly · 15/06/2021 10:25

Doctors. Doctors know about lipoedema. Not randoms on the internet.

KurtWilde · 15/06/2021 10:00

Lipodema fat kind of pools in little pockets and feels very different to regular fat. It'll feel cold and spongy to the touch. You'll have some dimpling like cellulite but whereas cellulite tends to feel like orange peel, with lipodema it's more like marshmallow.

My ex-sister in law waited a long time to see a doctor who would actually diagnose her lipodema.

Hope that helps a bit.

cheezy · 15/06/2021 09:18

I’m a bit like you OP, body wise. Skinny fat, pear shaped etc. Not sure that what you describe is lipodema, isn’t a criteria that the fat is painful or heavy? And surely it’s normal to get some water retention or swelling in the legs? I don’t have this myself but I do get a slight mark from socks. I understand your concern as I think it’s hard to diagnose but once diagnosed is treatable.