Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?

462 replies

ilkleymoorbartat · 09/06/2021 21:49

With the mass exodus from London at the moment, aibu to ask whether there is some promised land that people go when they have kids (whatever the location).

Ie, are those of us in London missing out on a life that is lovely and idyllic which if you're in the London bubble it's impossible to imagine?

Do we have Stockholm syndrome basically?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MrsPetty · 11/06/2021 17:26

After ten years in NYC, I returned to London and spent eight years there. Left in 2016 and have been living on an island with my 2 DDs ever since. We walk on the beach after school (it has sixteen kids), they go to the shop on their own. We go back to London for the Summers and some holiday as DH still lives and works there. We’ve found our promised land. It’s safe, clean, peaceful and there’s a real sense of community ❤️

treetimes · 11/06/2021 14:07

@Liverbird77 A lot of people do live in Trafford for the grammar schools. I know a couple of people with teenagers at Parrs Wood, they seem happy, I need to ask them more about their experiences.

I also love how friendly it is here.

@treetimes

I can see why you wouldn't move. Friends who have moved didn't want to, they couldn't get a bigger house and garden in the same area within their budget. You get more space out into Chesire. I don't have the budget for a bigger house here unfortunately, a bigger garden would mean a smaller house.

I imagine the equivalent area in London would be incredibly expensive?

LoudestCat14 · 11/06/2021 13:43

[quote WalkingOnTheCracks]London is crowded, noisy, busy, ancient, difficult to get into, difficult to get out of, huge and sprawling, mostly unplanned, expensive, dangerous, unpredictable, aggressive, dirty and as diverse as Babel.

Having said that, I feel I ought to balance the list by giving some sort of downside - but there isn't one.

Here's an unabashed celebration of my hometown...

vimeo.com/255057733[/quote]
Love the video so much!

sqirrelfriends · 11/06/2021 13:29

Cotswolds, the fens, Cornwall are where everyone I know seems to be moving to.

I think it's the promise of less people, more open space etc.

Personally, I'm staying put as I don't think WFH will last forever and I'm happy in my little suburb.

LateAtTate · 11/06/2021 13:24

@WelcometoJam ‘people like us couldn’t live anywhere else’ ? How small minded... I say this as a brown person who came here for uni.
Somewhat counterintuitively a place being cultural melting pot doesn’t mean anything. When I went to uni in London loads of people got away with clumping with their own nationality. In fact when I graduated and started work there was still a large number of people who only knew people of other nationalities through work. Outside of work they only spent time with people from their own country.
Meanwhile in my Northern city there isn’t this cliquishness. And my boyfriend’s family (all from a rural village) have been extremely welcoming. I’ve never felt out of place.
Not living in a cosmopolitan city doesn’t make people close minded. And as an aside so much contempt from foreigners for places that have ‘too many British families’...why come to the U.K in the first place if you have no care for its people or culture at all?!?

zafferana · 11/06/2021 12:37

I haven't RTWT (cardinal sin, I know), but everyone's 'promised land' will be different. I used to live in London in my 20s - had a ball and loved it and couldn't imagine living anywhere else - but now, in my 40s, I'm very happy that we moved to Herts. It was DH's idea actually, but we have the best of all worlds where we live. Our small city has good amenities, other ones nearby have things our home city doesn't, and we're a short train ride from London. When we first moved out I missed London a lot, but I can honestly say that, 10 years on, I don't miss it at all. I haven't been into central London in over a year and it doesn't bother me a bit. We're not near our families here - we're commuting distance to DH's job - but our quality if life is good and our house and garden are around twice the size the same money could buy in London.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 11/06/2021 12:36

London is crowded, noisy, busy, ancient, difficult to get into, difficult to get out of, huge and sprawling, mostly unplanned, expensive, dangerous, unpredictable, aggressive, dirty and as diverse as Babel.

Having said that, I feel I ought to balance the list by giving some sort of downside - but there isn't one.

Here's an unabashed celebration of my hometown...

vimeo.com/255057733

RickiTarr · 11/06/2021 12:16

@WelcometoJam

Of note….all four houses that went up for sale on our road in last 12 mths sold in less than a fortnight. All bought by Londoners moving from flats to houses with under 5’s. Like we did 10 years ago. So no change there then. Everyone I know that has left in my experience are not Londoners - went back home. Of the four new families that have arrived on our road only one couple are English. The other three: Italian/Canadian/Hong kong Chinese - This is why we and people like us couldn’t live anywhere else.
Of course you could live somewhere else. You could live plenty of places if needs be, as I’m sure your new HK expatriate neighbours will be able to elucidate for you, if you ask.

It really does make London and real Londoners look ridiculous when this chirruping about not being able to survive elsewhere gets bandied about.

Millions of people nationally, cannot afford to buy houses or flats anywhere near their home towns and that includes very many Londoners, of all ethnicities.

dreamingbohemian · 11/06/2021 12:16

I think Londoners also have lower demands when it comes to 'appropriate homes'.

We live in a small 2BR flat with no garden on a council estate, I'm sure a lot of MNers would turn their noses up at it (no bath! no garden! no storage!) but for us it's completely fine. It's cozy and has a lot of character, and the neighbourhood is amazing.

Like a lot of city people (I'm originally from NYC) I would rather have a smaller home in a great area than a big home somewhere boring (to me) where I'd have to drive everywhere.

PotassiumChloride · 11/06/2021 11:52

I think it depends on what you’re looking for lifestyle wise and your stage of life. We live in a large city and took the decision to buy “the worst house on the best street” - we compromised on space because we loved the (very expensive) area and the amenities it had. We’ve now had a baby and our priorities have changed - the house is too small and unsuitable for a child. This might lead us to move, but the local schools are excellent so we might just have to suck it up.

MargaretFraggle · 11/06/2021 09:29

I can totally understand not being able to afford to live in London how you want to - it's one reason I never moved there. I would visit friends and spend a tenner just walking down the street! I do know Londoners with enough money for a nice lifestyle who wanted a larger garden etc, who have moved here and been a bit shocked at the mundanity though. No cafe culture, lack of a lovely high street to wander to (unless you are in an expensive market town). Expensive, not brilliant museums. Rural living can be boring and heavily car based, but village life is what a lot seem to wish for. Well, according to MN Smile

4PawsGood · 11/06/2021 09:13

@MargaretFraggle

I live in a leafy county. Lovely, but a bit boring. I don't completely understand why Londoners with enough money to enjoy it would leave, especially if they have a garden. Pluses for me would be subsidised public transport, huge parks, theatres and free museums. Where I live it can cost £5 to travel a few miles on a bus, which will be late, not turn up, or drive past you!
Because they can afford to have a home that’s an appropriate size for their family and a garden. And live somewhere that it’s safer for their children to walk around.

I do love London but can’t afford to live there at a way I’d want to.

MargaretFraggle · 11/06/2021 09:01

I live in a leafy county. Lovely, but a bit boring. I don't completely understand why Londoners with enough money to enjoy it would leave, especially if they have a garden. Pluses for me would be subsidised public transport, huge parks, theatres and free museums. Where I live it can cost £5 to travel a few miles on a bus, which will be late, not turn up, or drive past you!

Xenia · 11/06/2021 08:42

The 2 houses close to me where a very old person has chosen to move out in the last few years including I think one next month have both not surprisingly as they are detached family houses been sold by those old people to a young family with children. The working from home of the covid legislation plus stmap duty holiday has just speeded things up a bit for some people.

Divebar2021 · 11/06/2021 08:07

It’s not as if London is ever going to be empty. For every family moving out to a smaller city or town or village there are people from those very same “idyllic” locations heading to the big smoke for a career opportunity or some excitement. Nothing needs to be forever. I like my current location on the Surrey /London borders. Quiet enough with access to lots of green spaces but close enough to be in Central London in 40 minutes. I’m sure it wouldn’t suit lots of people but that’s fine... it doesn’t need to.

WelcometoJam · 10/06/2021 23:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WelcometoJam · 10/06/2021 22:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Tealightsandd · 10/06/2021 22:38

@DonGray

It's easy to get caught up in thinking that... particularly reading the papers. But actually it's still a small minority.

An acceleration mostly of those who were always going to leave/return home, but still just a minority.

Tealightsandd · 10/06/2021 22:33

@Xenia

Very interesting to hear from people about all this. There is never a right answer. My parents bought a house not to far from Newcastle centre which was good for work etc. I lived in Manchester and Chester (university and law school) and 3 of my children have been to Bristol U and others other towns. There are lots of towns in the UK and it ie certainly not London or rural Northumberland (my spiritual home).

For me outer London has been the right compromise. It is a minority white borough and has good private schools, several tube lines and yet our house when covid walkers are not tramping up and down our private road it is peaceful and quasi rural, horses go by etc (one man was in my garden this morning briefly with his 2 dogs which strayed in - may be I need to get my hose pipe out to fight invaders off)

I like Newcastle a lot.

I agree that outer London can be a good compromise. I have friends who are very happy in zone 5 and 6 boroughs. Both north and south London ones actually.

Personal preferences vary.

DonGray · 10/06/2021 22:30

@Tealightsandd it feels like an exodus compared to normal years
Possibly because noone left in the last 18mths & they are all leaving now

Tealightsandd · 10/06/2021 22:24

@bookworm14

I don’t think people hate London at all and “everything it stands for” (whatever that means!). They just don’t want to live there, same as some people don’t want to live anywhere else.

A lot of people absolutely do hate it and have made it very clear on the thread. One poster said she was ‘sorry for anyone who lives here’. I don’t care what anyone thinks of London personally but I am sick of the constant sweeping generalisations on MN about what London life is like, and the failure to grasp that not everyone wants to live exactly the same lifestyle.

The generalisations are not just on MN. Politicians and the media do it too.
Sanguinesuzy · 10/06/2021 22:08

And fwiw I come from one of those places on your list, would love to move back but no b**y chance as I'm priced out !

Sanguinesuzy · 10/06/2021 22:06

@SingingInTheShithouse lol of course they are. Nicest most desirable parts of the country. Not exactly flocking to bolton, barnsley or oldham (and I live in one of those places before anyone moans)

Tealightsandd · 10/06/2021 21:31

10% of families at our primary are leaving London - all year groups

So 90% - a whopping majority - are staying.
Hardly an exodus.

I'd say most of those leaving are either the priced out, or people not originally from London moving to be nearer their families or where they're from.

I wonder if some who have left are already regretting it and keen to encourage the narrative of the 'exodus' - to feel they're not the only ones leaving?

I can’t imagine being in central London with small children.

Central London is a fantastic place for children. Lots of lovely (and large) parks, every facility you could possibly want for adult or child, museums, London Zoo, excellent public transport (which gives children a lot of freedom to travel around), and some good schools. If you can afford it or, like some friends of mine, have social housing there, central London is great for families. But obviously each to their own. It's all down to individual family preferences and priorities.

Poorlykitten · 10/06/2021 21:22

It’s second homes that are the problem, bloody loads of them around here and people air B and B ing them for thousands a week because they can get more that way than renting out to tenants. Several friends been evicted recently so their landlords can ‘remarket’ the property.