Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?

462 replies

ilkleymoorbartat · 09/06/2021 21:49

With the mass exodus from London at the moment, aibu to ask whether there is some promised land that people go when they have kids (whatever the location).

Ie, are those of us in London missing out on a life that is lovely and idyllic which if you're in the London bubble it's impossible to imagine?

Do we have Stockholm syndrome basically?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bythemillpond · 11/06/2021 20:38

We couldn't afford the size of house we want in this area, and decided that if we were going to move to zone 6 we might as well move to the coast

Why not move to zone 6 and still have virtually everything you have now?

Cherries590 · 11/06/2021 20:37

I’m a London girl and moved to leafy Surrey many many moons ago. I have an enormous garden with deer, pheasants, the lot, running around. I’m 3 miles from the station which is 40 mins into London. It is without question utterly beautiful, but it is so so so dull. There is NOTHING to do and I’ve calcified. I’m selling up and am off to Brighton (pure skank I know, but at least there’s the thrum of LIFE). And honestly the drugs problem with teens that a lot of you are trying to avoid is rife everywhere. I live amongst high 6 figure earners, pure privilege. You’re all kidding yourselves if you think you’ll save your teens from the perils.

babbaloushka · 11/06/2021 20:35

[quote LateAtTate]@WelcometoJam ‘people like us couldn’t live anywhere else’ ? How small minded... I say this as a brown person who came here for uni.
Somewhat counterintuitively a place being cultural melting pot doesn’t mean anything. When I went to uni in London loads of people got away with clumping with their own nationality. In fact when I graduated and started work there was still a large number of people who only knew people of other nationalities through work. Outside of work they only spent time with people from their own country.
Meanwhile in my Northern city there isn’t this cliquishness. And my boyfriend’s family (all from a rural village) have been extremely welcoming. I’ve never felt out of place.
Not living in a cosmopolitan city doesn’t make people close minded. And as an aside so much contempt from foreigners for places that have ‘too many British families’...why come to the U.K in the first place if you have no care for its people or culture at all?!?[/quote]
I have found this too, and a much greater 'otherness' in London than smaller, more rural places. Leeds was my absolute favourite, so vibrant but less affluence and snobbery, a more communal feel. I think often white people see non-white folk and think fantastic, here's our diversity, but it's how we, as non-white people, feel best integrated- and for me it definitely wasn't in London.

Puffykins · 11/06/2021 20:29

I love London with all my heart. We're in Notting Hill, my school run is walking along the canal to Little Venice, I love the galleries, the theatre, the aliveness and bustle. I swim in the Serpentine in Hyde Park all year round, I walk to work across the park, we have a huge communal garden, and if it was up to me we would never leave. However we are; we're moving to Hastings in 3 weeks. Because we all live in a two bedroom flat and we have run out of space and the children are only going to get bigger. We couldn't afford the size of house we want in this area, and decided that if we were going to move to zone 6 we might as well move to the coast - and to a house 10 minutes walk from the beach, contemporary art galleries, where I can still walk the children to school etc. - and walk to a station and be back in London within 75 minutes.

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 20:29

It's the breathtaking hypocrisy and complete lack of self awareness.

For decades, priced out Londoners have been told to suck it up.

Yet - here we are. A tiny little taste of the much resented London 'investment' and we get screaming tantrums.

'Locals' complaining they can't afford to buy the house they wanted, citing their want to stay close to family etc. Yet there was no sympathy for low income homeless London families and disabled individuals who were rehoused forcibly by London boroughs across the country, very far away from their families, schools, friends, and support networks.

When Gordon Brown cut housing benefit so vulnerable Londoners couldn't afford to stay near support networks, people were in favour, saying those vulnerable Londoners shouldn't expect to stay in an expensive area (expensive only because 'locals' from other places moved there). But apparently it's so terribly wrong if locals outside of London can't afford to buy in the area they're from?

It doesn't work just one way.

No one is more special than anyone else. Nobody has more right than anybody else to stay in the area they're born in.

Traffic can't be just one way.
No double standards.

CallMeCleo · 11/06/2021 20:16

I'm hoping and praying nobody recommends my town. We've been inundated with Londoners moving here and it's changing the town.

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 20:14

David Cameron, for example.
Moved from London to Oxfordshire.
He wasn't a Londoner moving there. He was actually a local returning home.

Dominic Cummings. Currently lives in London. But originally from County Durham.

The Blairs. Moved from London to Buckinghamshire. Neither are Londoners.

Jeremy Corbyn. Moved from Dorset to London (pricing out a Londoner). If he moves out, it will be a case of someone from Dorset moving somewhere else.

George Osborne, yes, he is a Londoner. But he is the exception rather than the rule.

Lancrelady80 · 11/06/2021 20:13

Norfolk. 3 terraced houses been built next to use. All sold before had even been physically built. All smaller than us, with smaller garden. Cheapest was £515k. One of the others has a stunning view of the side of our garage wall (we are raised) and our oil tank. Silly money. But because they are brick and flint in Norfolk, they've been snapped up. We can't take advantage by selling up and moving to a similar sized property with, say, an extra bedroom because ours is ex-police house so the exterior is aesthetically nowhere near as nice. Whilst it will have increased in value, not enough for us to get even something the same in our area, let alone bigger. And the amount the bank would lend is pitiful compared to what we would need.

Only way this ends well for us is if we do a proper relocation and find new jobs and new schools for the kiddies. For now, we have to just sit tight.

Locals definitely being priced out. Heard of affordable housing locally being put up for rent (part of deal of allowing them to be built) at over £1200 per month for small 2 bed semi. Then when/if they can say "but anyone's interested in renting them," they can apparently be sold off. And it won't be locals affording them!

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 20:06

@Barney60

tealightsandd Don't believe you. I bet at least half of those 'incomers' are not Londoners.

4 in last 6 months in cul- de- sac near me, we villagers think its due to HS2, all that will happen is they will get south 20 mins quicke.r

You saw their birth certificates?

I bet at least half are originally from other parts of the UK.

LateAtTate · 11/06/2021 20:05

Also the pricing out really isn’t about Londoners/non-Londoners it also involves people who weren’t British born 😂

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 20:05

Please don't come here.

Ah those lovely warm locals, with their insularity (that they want to work only one way, because of course it was ok for them to move to London).

You don't own your town or village.
People from where you live have been coming to London for years.

What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

People say they want 'levelling up' and London's 'investment', then moan when they get it Confused

Nowhere has a housing crisis worse than London (two thirds of all UK homeless families are in London). So for all the cries about house prices from the 'friendly' locals elsewhere, I suspect there's more than a slight whiff of racism behind the 'you're not welcome' posts. Bearing in mind London's diverse ethnic makeup.

Barney60 · 11/06/2021 19:59

tealightsandd
Don't believe you.
I bet at least half of those 'incomers' are not Londoners.

4 in last 6 months in cul- de- sac near me, we villagers think its due to HS2, all that will happen is they will get south 20 mins quicke.r

angela99999 · 11/06/2021 19:54

@Welcometojam
We left London some years ago when our children were ready to leave home, so that we could help them with places to live. We went to a city which we loved but found that we missed our children and missed London. We've now downsized back to Greater London living in a lovely spot, and I'm guessing that lots of other people will come back when they're older - living in the city is great for those of us who are retired and have more time to enjoy it.
We were not originally Londoners but had been here for over 40 years before we left and have realised that we really don't want to be anywhere else.

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 19:51

There are lots of 20 somethings and 30 somethings struggling.

Whereas in London, the crisis is even more serious. It's not just 20s and 30s in London.
People way older are struggling.

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 19:47

@Barney60

loads of Londoners moving into villages near me. Personally lived in a city when younger (late teens) hated it, far too noisy, i love peace and quiet.
Don't believe you. I bet at least half of those 'incomers' are not Londoners.

Londoners pricing out the rest of England.
Wrong way round. The rest of England (and the UK - including Wales) has been pricing out Londoners. Which you yourself are part of.

You say you're Welsh - yet you're someone who’s sitting on a fat profit from a London house aka someone from Wales who priced out a Londoner.

People can try to claim otherwise all they like (out of spite, ignorance, or both) but the facts speak for themselves....It's London that is the capital of homelessness.

SherbrookeFosterer · 11/06/2021 19:47

I still love London.

When I retire I'm moving to Soho!

angela99999 · 11/06/2021 19:45

My DS and DIL are moving to Surrey from London primarily for the outstanding schools. Also they can get much more space in a better house. I'm sad they're going and think that a lot of people who are moving may regret it in future.
WFH may not continue at its current rate and commuting is getting more and more expensive.

MustardRose · 11/06/2021 19:45

It used to be a promised land round here in this part of our county. Lovely villages, countryside, picturesque small towns. Good roads, rail links and other infrastructure.

Such a shame the whole area is being carved up by developers building huge new estates with tens of thousands of properties to house all the people who want to come and live here. And even more of a shame that the young people who already live and work here can't afford to get on the property ladder because everything is way out of their range.

Please don't come here.

DaddyCool60 · 11/06/2021 19:32

I’m having a poke. Don’t take it to heart. Call it schadenfreude.

Barney60 · 11/06/2021 19:31

loads of Londoners moving into villages near me. Personally lived in a city when younger (late teens) hated it, far too noisy, i love peace and quiet.

DaddyCool60 · 11/06/2021 19:29

@lazylinguist

Sorry but sympathy thin on the ground here for all ll those complaining you’re priced out of your own towns and villages, especially in England, I doubt you or your parents shead any years when it was happening in Welsh villages back in the seventies and eighties.

Unless you think that the people currently unhappy about being priced out are the same people who came and snapped up properties in Welsh villages in the 70s and 80s, or you have evidence that they knew about Welsh people being priced out and were unsympathetic, I don't understand how this is relevant or particularly fair. Confused

Well obviously not the same people. That would be rediculous but the sentiment is plain. English pricing out the Welsh. Londoners pricing out the rest of England. Can’t bring myself, as a Welsh person, who witnessed the lack of concern from the rest of the UK back then, to feel any real sympathy for the complaint. Get over it and all that. And I speak as someone who’s sitting on a fat profit from a London house who could choose to buy the almost any of the most expensive houses back where I came from, and would without guilt. But then I probably won’t as after more than 40 years in London I’d no doubt get withdrawal symptoms.
blueleonburger · 11/06/2021 19:28

Born and bred Londoner. Moved to Manchester in my 20s never looked back. Still got the city vibe with good access to peaks and countryside if you want. Now I've been to the Cotswold this month and dreaming of the countryside life!

RickiTarr · 11/06/2021 19:27

@DaddyCool60

Sorry but sympathy thin on the ground here for all ll those complaining you’re priced out of your own towns and villages, especially in England, I doubt you or your parents shead any years when it was happening in Welsh villages back in the seventies and eighties. What hours around comes around is the phrase that springs to min Wink.
That doesn’t make much sense. Why did people have to cry before they were alive - or even conceived - about phenomenon X, in order to get your permission to be upset about the same phenomenon later? That’s nonsensical. Parents and children being responsible for each other’s thoughts is an even weirder notion.

There are lots of 20 somethings and 30 somethings struggling. It’s not tribal. What’s the creepy winking about?

RickiTarr · 11/06/2021 19:20

The whole issue of "pricing out" is a systemic issue with our housing market, and nothing to do with Londoners or non-Londoners, English or Welsh.

Confused

It’s to do with all those groups and more.

Multiple generations and areas have been impacted by the same pattern repeated, precisely because it’s a systemic issue.

Central government continue to make bad economic and housing policy.

Tealightsandd · 11/06/2021 19:15

Yes Rishi Sunak did a lot to exacerbate the problem.

As an aside. I bet if Rishi Sunak moved to a village in Cornwall or Suffolk or Lincolnshire, it would be framed as 'a Londoner pricing out the locals'....Rishi isn't a Londoner. He's from Hampshire.

Swipe left for the next trending thread