Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?

462 replies

ilkleymoorbartat · 09/06/2021 21:49

With the mass exodus from London at the moment, aibu to ask whether there is some promised land that people go when they have kids (whatever the location).

Ie, are those of us in London missing out on a life that is lovely and idyllic which if you're in the London bubble it's impossible to imagine?

Do we have Stockholm syndrome basically?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Divebar2021 · 14/06/2021 16:07

Apparently Manchester speaks the most languages of any city in Western Europe and still can’t manage “ welcome”.

ChunkyKitKat123 · 14/06/2021 13:41

@Bythemillpond Cool, but the OP asked about places outside of London.

denverRegina · 14/06/2021 13:27

Everything. Haven't you heard it's "London 2.0?"

You can buy a scratty damp terrace for £300k or get a McMansion for a little bit more.

It'll suit you if you drive a Chelsea tractor and have some hunter wellies. If you could loudly tell others in the playground you're doing them a favour then you'll have nailed it. Apparently.

x2boys · 14/06/2021 12:59

What's so great about Altrincham,? I'm the other side of Greater Manchester ,I don't think Altrincham is all that tbh!

MargaretFraggle · 14/06/2021 12:49

I had no idea until yesterday that Altrincham was the promised land!

denverRegina · 14/06/2021 11:12

McMansion 🤣 the OP is clearly 2 nuggets short of a happy meal

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 14/06/2021 11:01

@denverRegina

I've heard Altrincham is nice Wink
Yes quite as apparently “naice” even. Don’t go especially if you are a monied London property owner sporting Hunter boots driving a Chelsea tractor with children requiring normal decent grammar level education etc as pitchforks and extinctions rebellion cult religion communists riots may camp on your upgraded McMansion. Not sure what the urban street English variant dictionary would describe McMansion as I am assuming it is a Desperate Housewifes footballers gated townhouse with express ultra processed junk food delivery on tap?
denverRegina · 14/06/2021 10:35

I've heard Altrincham is nice Wink

firsttimeoptimist · 14/06/2021 10:22

We were in London and still love to visit (still commutable) but we benefit from tiny village schools and space to grow our own vegetables, chickens and several of our neighbours have a few sheep etc. I couldn't bring my small children up in London even though there are definitely more clubs/opportunities. We visit regularly and I am a little sad when I do that I suddenly don't need to change their river/mud/tree soaked/stained clothes every day! - Oh but there is definitely more washing! I would check your areas though. We are in a village but there is a real community with lots going on, especially in the winter which I can imagine could otherwise be quite lonely! There has been a small exodus this way as house prices have risen 20% in the last 3 months!

Bythemillpond · 14/06/2021 01:10

And our mortgage is less

Bythemillpond · 14/06/2021 01:10

Scotland. Hands down the best choice I ever made was to move here (not from London though). My mortgage is £520 and out of my window I can see fields, trees, open sky, deer, birds etc

Zone 6 and we have all that

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 14/06/2021 00:20

@ RickiTarr
@ Macncheeseballs

Regarding the AIBU “To be irritated by the Londoner exodus to my town?”

Wow that what a fast moving pile of ill thought out misunderstood ignorance (nearly exclusively from the original poster). Gosh this other current Manchester London thread must be the most illogical “hidden” agenda divisive toxic mother of all “battlegrounds!?” Are there many more open hard line communist to avoid on MumsNet? And I thought this is a civilised first world advance capitalist nation to politely discuss, debate, support and share a diversity of viewpoints?! Respectfully and agreeing to disagree if necessary than open offensive abuse of misunderstood concepts. Therapy for such anger management issues would help. Sadden by these troubling issues as it must be stressful in addition to the dangers from localised Indian Covid Delta infiltration. And I am not a landed gentry lord of the manor by any stretch of the imagination just a fellow mum who recognises the evolving market dynamics and potential challenges ahead for future generations with regards to trending housing and lifestyle matters.

RickiTarr · 13/06/2021 19:53

@Macncheeseballs

Just don't move to greater Manchester, according to another thread, they hate londoners up there
I know. Can you believe that thread?!
Macncheeseballs · 13/06/2021 19:47

Just don't move to greater Manchester, according to another thread, they hate londoners up there

ChunkyKitKat123 · 13/06/2021 19:31

Scotland. Hands down the best choice I ever made was to move here (not from London though). My mortgage is £520 and out of my window I can see fields, trees, open sky, deer, birds etc. I can be in Edinburgh or Glasgow in an hour and a few of the smaller regional towns within 15 minutes. Beaches and mountains are also within short driving distance. Local schools are good and lots to do for kids. The people are friendly and I've found a good group of friends. Weather is nowhere near as bad as people make out.
Of course there are problems here too but on the whole I can't imagine living elsewhere in the Uk now.

awaketoosoon · 13/06/2021 17:32

I bought with help with parents but I have friends/colleagues in their 40s/50s in very normal jobs who can buy 1m houses simply because the have a ton of equity. And then you have others who are completely priced out

We looked at a house a few yrs ago that needed a ton of work but had huge potential. It was on for 800k but overpriced. We could have just about afforded it by stretching ourselves completely but I was pregnant & it was completely out of catchment for any school etc. We didn't go for it & a developer got it for 720k. Not even 3 yrs later the prices & area went crazy. It appeared on the market again with the kitchen extension, loft done etc & sold for just under 1.7m. Crazy

awaketoosoon · 13/06/2021 17:24

I defo got the nightbus in the 90s but I grew up in a then bit dodgy part of z2 so wouldn't be walking through certain areas in the early hours.

Tealightsandd · 13/06/2021 17:19

What’s scary is how small differences a generation or two ago have been hugely magnified by housing luck. I feel like I’m roughly in the median spot of it all, age wise, class wise, salary wise, just observing the variations.

It is scary isn't it. Such a huge (and damaging) change in so short period of time.

Tony Blair wanted to make London into a playground for the young, healthy, and rich. His successors continued down the same path.

It pisses me off hugely that oligarchs and bankers were prioritised to such an extent and that massive swathes of London have been left without hope. It’s not a real, functioning city any more because of the economics of it all. I can’t think about it too long because it makes me angry.

I agree. It's wrong on so many levels. And all the people who resent London's 'investment' don't realise this is the unenviable reality of it.

Disabled Londoners have been particularly hard hit. Shut out of stable housing in London but, unlike their peers, less easily able to leave for pastures new.

I feel sorry for the young too.

I have a feeling the planned 'levelling up' particularly the so called Northern Powerhouse will simply bring the same problems and misery to other parts of the country. It's already started happening with house prices around Manchester.

I think you're right about the night buses. Perhaps they're more dangerous nowadays? It was always a really friendly vibe back in the day. Never felt unsafe. I think things might've changed. What a shame.

Bythemillpond · 13/06/2021 16:55

awaketoosoon

We always use sites like Just Park etc
We parked in a fancy hotels underground car park for 4 days recently for £10.50 per day
We added up for 4 of us to get the tube even for the shortish journey there and back each day would have cost quite a bit more and we had the convenience of the car after 12 hours at work.

RickiTarr · 13/06/2021 16:52

Oh and I can confirm we did the Nightbus thing from central home to zones 4&5 in the mid nineties @Tealightsandd although we did have one for end who wasn’t “allowed” to use them officially so she did but she stayed over with one of us and details were blurred I think. Maybe the idea that they were incredibly dangerous grew? In fact, maybe they did genuinely get more dangerous? They used to be so good humoured when we used them (the only London transport people would sometimes chat on, slightly sozzled) but later I remember some reported muggings and so on being reported on them.

RickiTarr · 13/06/2021 16:43

@Tealightsandd

Yes, I really feel for the younger generations of displaced Londoners. New Labour were just as much to blame for not balancing policy as Conservative governments were and it has horrible consequences for some.

The major issue (as it's being going on for several decades) is it's not just young Londoners.

It's affected huge numbers of lower income including many disabled older Londoners - people in their 40s, 50s, and beyond. And they are the very worst off. Partly because, unlike the young, they don't have time on their side - to hope for a change in policy and/or their personal circumstances/health.

But also because they are so often invisible. It's mainly the young affected in other parts of the country and people assume it's the same in London. If people aren't aware of their situation, of their (miserable) existence, then definitely nothing will ever be done to improve things. For example earlier taxpayer funded inflate the bubble schemes like Help to Buy give tax money to developers to put up shoddily constructed overpriced new builds were restricted to under 40s. Understandable to an extent because it's easier to get a mortgage under 40 (although the retirement age has risen) but no alternative help was given to the unfortunate homeless or insecurely/poorly housed over 40s.

the young native Londoner renters moving out to rent or buy somewhere affordable have very little and they still get the same resentment aimed at them that the ex-Londoners with £££££s get.

Adding insult to injury is that many of the 'Londoners' with £££££ are not Londoners, but people from across the UK who moved to London to take advantage of it before moving on elsewhere when they've had their fill.

Worst off than young London born Londoners are the older ones. It's easier to adapt to change in your youth, and often easier to fit in - meeting new people through work, university, new partners.

It's a time of life before you settle - when it's not uncommon to move around to new places.

Pity the older and disabled Londoners. They're they ones who have really suffered from governments since Blair 'investing' in London.

Yes I know @Tealightsandd I was trying to address just the one aspect because I think my older children and slightly older (nineties babies, in their twenties now) are being quicker to cotton on and just leave and settle elsewhere than the people of my age who struggled to buy for a long while (those of us without gifted deposits), with mixed success.

You’re right, though. There are of course multiple demographic angles to it.

I’m speaking as a Londoner who bought late myself and very nearly not at all. One set of my grandparents were solidly manual working class and it boggles my brains how anyone in their jobs or circumstances would survive in London now. In fact that whole side of the family did well, and all were owner occupiers in London sooner or later, despite always being in skilled manual trades. I know some of my second cousins are having a rough time.

The other side of the family were more middle class and slightly ahead the curve.

What’s scary is how small differences a generation or two ago have been hugely magnified by housing luck. I feel like I’m roughly in the median spot of it all, age wise, class wise, salary wise, just observing the variations.

It pisses me off hugely that oligarchs and bankers were prioritised to such an extent and that massive swathes of London have been left without hope. It’s not a real, functioning city any more because of the economics of it all. I can’t think about it too long because it makes me angry.

Tealightsandd · 13/06/2021 15:15

Tealightsandd I'm sure they did but every weekend? What I found then with night buses is there wasn't always one for the majority of the route & I didn't feel comfortable walking home so late. We generally slept over at a friends & yes the all-nighters were easier!

Tbf a lot stuck to all night clubs or went on to all night cafes like the Italian one in Soho or semi/not legal all night bars to wait for the first tube. Sometimes just hanging out together outside stations until they opened in the early morning.

But yes several friends did regularly get night buses home from central to zones 5 and 6. I think they had the attitude of the invincibility of youth, partly fuelled by alcohol. It was very mixed. People regularly stayed over with each other or shared cabs home (each dropped off in turn) so it probably wasn't often that any went all the way home to the outer zones on their own.

This was the 80s and 90s though. Things might have changed/people got more cautious nowadays. Although I thought uber made things easier now anyway. It used to be more difficult to find a cab sometimes, especially one willing to go further out, and more expensive.

Tealightsandd · 13/06/2021 15:04

Yes, I really feel for the younger generations of displaced Londoners. New Labour were just as much to blame for not balancing policy as Conservative governments were and it has horrible consequences for some.

The major issue (as it's being going on for several decades) is it's not just young Londoners.

It's affected huge numbers of lower income including many disabled older Londoners - people in their 40s, 50s, and beyond. And they are the very worst off. Partly because, unlike the young, they don't have time on their side - to hope for a change in policy and/or their personal circumstances/health.

But also because they are so often invisible. It's mainly the young affected in other parts of the country and people assume it's the same in London. If people aren't aware of their situation, of their (miserable) existence, then definitely nothing will ever be done to improve things. For example earlier taxpayer funded inflate the bubble schemes like Help to Buy give tax money to developers to put up shoddily constructed overpriced new builds were restricted to under 40s. Understandable to an extent because it's easier to get a mortgage under 40 (although the retirement age has risen) but no alternative help was given to the unfortunate homeless or insecurely/poorly housed over 40s.

the young native Londoner renters moving out to rent or buy somewhere affordable have very little and they still get the same resentment aimed at them that the ex-Londoners with £££££s get.

Adding insult to injury is that many of the 'Londoners' with £££££ are not Londoners, but people from across the UK who moved to London to take advantage of it before moving on elsewhere when they've had their fill.

Worst off than young London born Londoners are the older ones. It's easier to adapt to change in your youth, and often easier to fit in - meeting new people through work, university, new partners.

It's a time of life before you settle - when it's not uncommon to move around to new places.

Pity the older and disabled Londoners. They're they ones who have really suffered from governments since Blair 'investing' in London.

RickiTarr · 13/06/2021 13:27

@MargaretFraggle

Interesting post Resl re. the global market pricing Londoners out of London.

I guess I did know that really, but I hadn't really thought of it that way.

Yes, I really feel for the younger generations of displaced Londoners. New Labour were just as much to blame for not balancing policy as Conservative governments were and it has horrible consequences for some.

A lot of people seem to assume that all Londoners have fat wedges of easily acquired housing equity, but the young native Londoner renters moving out to rent or buy somewhere affordable have very little and they still get the same resentment aimed at them that the ex-Londoners with £££££s get.

MargaretFraggle · 13/06/2021 13:05

Interesting post Resl re. the global market pricing Londoners out of London.

I guess I did know that really, but I hadn't really thought of it that way.