Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?

462 replies

ilkleymoorbartat · 09/06/2021 21:49

With the mass exodus from London at the moment, aibu to ask whether there is some promised land that people go when they have kids (whatever the location).

Ie, are those of us in London missing out on a life that is lovely and idyllic which if you're in the London bubble it's impossible to imagine?

Do we have Stockholm syndrome basically?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ChrisQuean · 10/06/2021 08:24

We left London after 20 years. It was decided pre-Covid and lockdown, but we left mid last year. We lived right in the centre of London, hipster area, and both of us walked to work and to school. It was - and is - a brilliant city and I do miss it and we had loads of local friends. Very vibrant, mixed community. Tiny house and yard, so it was a squash and a squeeze.

But we had three boys and there were issues with violence and open drug dealing on our street. Secondary school options for boys round us were either single sex (the TOP public schools, brutal exam regimes and £££) or pretty terrifying comps with metal detectors, and no sibling policy anywhere. Three kids at three schools was the norm round us. We were both working silly hours too.

Last straw was coming home to find a police woman pulling a roll of Police incident tape round our railings. A 14 yo boy had been stabbed and collapsed bleeding on our doorstep (he was ok). We didn’t want to do a commute after such convenience and we had no links to the Home Counties, so it was stay or do the whole hog move. New jobs, new schools, new house etc. We decided to go nearer family and find a vibrant town we could walk to school and work again. Didn’t want to be rural and car dependent. Don’t regret it, and DH and the boys LOVE their new school and job and lifestyle. I’ll be honest and say I’ll am not quite settled. Don’t feel I have my network yet. It’s a beautiful city, no school worries, we have a bigger house and lovely garden.

SapphosRock · 10/06/2021 08:21

Brighton or Hove. The work life balance is so much better than London. Evenings and weekends can be spend swimming, paddle boarding, walking in the Downs.

We have a beach hut which is perfect for hanging out on summer days / evenings. We use it for entertaining friends, picnics, evening drinks.

So much for kids. Lots of seafront cafes, two seafront playgrounds with paddling pools. Lovely parks. Beach volleyball.

Loads for adults too. Great restaurants, theatre, comedy, quirky pubs, the lanes for shopping.

You can be in London in an hour.

There are downsides. Namely problems with homelessness and drugs, but nowhere is perfect.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/06/2021 08:21

Nothing new in this. My children were born in the early 90s. My husband and I had taken it for granted that once we had children we would move out of inner London to the outskirts of London or somewhere in the Home Counties in commuting range, or possibly somewhere else in the UK altogether. Our reasons were schools, crime, pollution, wanting somewhere more leafy.

However, once we started thinking about it, we realised there was a huge amount we'd miss if we left London. We also found out that our kneejerk assumption that inner London schools were poor was wrong. Provision was patchy but there were some terrific schools there (and my impression is there are far more now than back then). As we explored our local area at the weekends, we realised it was actually very green - lots of parks and open spaces. Also, we recoiled from the idea of spending a lot of time and money on commuting and living in a dull suburb like the ones where we'd both grown up. We wanted our children to grow up somewhere more diverse. We also didn't want to end up reliant on a car to get around.

In the end we moved to a nicer house nearer the park and in the catchment of a good primary school. My husband could be at work in 25 minutes door to door and that made a huge difference to how much time he could spend with the children (and me - I was a SAHM back then). Still in that house, children now late 20s, still living in this area, no regrets from any of us.

Mummadeze · 10/06/2021 08:15

Nothing I have read on here has convinced me I would prefer to live outside London. I can’t imagine I would ever feel at home anywhere else. Sometimes the rife crime aspect spooks me, but in general, day to day, I feel part of a lovely community and enjoy the diversity and endless entertainment. I also think schools are good.

Bythemillpond · 10/06/2021 08:15

awaketoosoon

I think what people find hard to get their head round is if you move out and are near a mainline train station then it is so much quicker coming into London than to get from one bit of London to another.
Watford to Euston is 21 minutes even Rochester to Stratford is only 29 minutes
St Albans to Kings Cross is 22 minutes

It all depends on where you need to get to and where you live.
Dh could get into his job door to door quicker than some who were coming from one London Postcode to another

x2boys · 10/06/2021 08:11

These threads always make me 🙄everytime ,there is one ,posters will pop up saying they moved out of London , into the middle of no where ,and now can't wait to go back to London for the vibrant life ,as though the UK consists of London and anywhere outside of London is just a vast waste land,and then accuse non Londoners of being parochial.

MsTSwift · 10/06/2021 08:08

Bath. Most of my friendship group here moved from London. Pattern is move to London in your twenties work hard play hard find someone to marry move out when first kid a baby or alternatively stay in London for good. Pros and cons to both.

sbhydrogen · 10/06/2021 08:01

I left. I'm a born and bred Londoner, and was dead set on staying put (all my family and friends are here) as I'm a very proud Londoner. After we had our first DD, we realised how unaffordable it would be to live anywhere near our preferred areas, so I begrudgingly agreed to look at houses in Essex (my family come here a lot).

Although it's a different life style, I now love it. We have bought a house with many bedrooms and a massive garden that costs 2/3 of our tiny dark London flat's rent, and childcare is about half the price. It's perfect for bringing up small kids.

name8793 · 10/06/2021 07:58

We lived in London for a few years, moved out for work reasons, I'd love to go back for a few more years eventually. I love London, love the vibe, the transport, everything going on, but as public sector workers the cost just isn't worth it. We live in the midlands now in a 1600sqft detached house with garden and country views and we paid £350k for it, excellent schools. I just couldn't downgrade our house for a "vibe" because our jobs pay about the same wherever we are.

DH and I plan to rent out our home and maybe rent in London for a few years post kids (as they should be out our house by our mid 40s....) because I haven't got it out my system yet.

awaketoosoon · 10/06/2021 07:56

I’m in zone 6 and have loads of amenities plus fresh air and a house and a garden and a few tube stations and rail lines to get into central London within 30 minutes for anything else.

Where are you? I'm in 2/3 & my door to door journey often takes around 30 mins.

RosesAndHellebores · 10/06/2021 07:54

OP my DC were in primary, in London, in the noughties. In DS's year by Y6 there were 4 of the original intake left. In DD's 5. DC either transferred to the independent sector from about 7 and or parents moved out if that wasn't an option.

Motleyvegetables · 10/06/2021 07:51

I live in suburban south east London. No one I know is leaving. However, most people who live here were born in London / Kent borders so this is likely impacted by closeness to families etc. Suburban life may be perceived as dull but we have a nice terraced home and large garden, the kids school is around the corner and we have easy access into central London for events / activities. That said, I often ponder moving somewhere else but always talk myself out of it!

Bythemillpond · 10/06/2021 07:49

I’m in zone 6 and have loads of amenities plus fresh air and a house and a garden and a few tube stations and rail lines to get into central London within 30 minutes for anything else.

I always find people think that the Home Counties/commuter belt is made up of boring housing estates. Whilst there are a few there are also loads of places that look like villages and hamlets and are the exact opposite of a boring housing estate.

awaketoosoon · 10/06/2021 07:49

Isn’t that because they still need to get into London for work? Less so at the moment, obv.

Not sure I have friends in outer zones who have awful journeys. Some of the people I know who have gone to cities still have London jobs. Some relocated job wise but are actually better off.

Decorhate · 10/06/2021 07:48

I adore where we live. Can be in central London in 25 minutes from our local station. 10 minute walk into our town centre. Loads of bars, restaurants etc. Woods & green spaces minutes walk away. Proper countryside 10 minutes drive away.

Would not live in an outer London suburb instead of here. No comparison

Poorlykitten · 10/06/2021 07:46

We moved from London, went to a kind of ‘halfway house’ (smaller city) first, now in the middle of nowhere in the Lakes. Love it. Brilliant outdoorsy life for kids, they just run around climbing trees and wild swimming. No noise, just the birds. Rural cinema comes to us at the village hall! Great sense of community. No crime. Seriously friendly. Only downside if we can see ourselves driving kids everywhere when older.

Cheeseplantandpickle · 10/06/2021 07:45

A few have left my part of London recently and gone to Devon, Brighton, Surrey, but they were always going to leave I think, they just had the push.

BarkingUpTheWrongRoseBush · 10/06/2021 07:42

Husband moved out of London with his young kids and then wife 15 years ago. Back to an island where we met. He still goes on about how much he doesn’t miss his awful commute on the train and tube into London.

We are a 10 minute walk to work. 10 minute walk to decent cinema and theatre. 10 minute walk to good restaurants. We can be on the beach8n minutes in the car or in the countryside. It’s beautiful. Pre covid we went away to the big city once a month or so.

He does wonder about his kids as they would have had more or different opportunities if they’d stayed in London. But they’ve all been to university and where we live has low unemployment and some really quite different job opportunities. And a healthy mix of locals and blow ins.

RaspberryCoulis · 10/06/2021 07:41

No. There is no life outside the M25, it's a barren wasteland. And as for "the North" - shudder.

Hmm
Liverbird77 · 10/06/2021 07:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

4PawsGood · 10/06/2021 07:41

@awaketoosoon

Baffles me that these questions are always framed as London, the dull suburbs in the outer zones or the Home Counties or 'the countryside' as if that's the only choice.

Yes! If we did move it would definitely be to another city. For me lots of Zone 5/6 are not particularly great amenities wise. I like stuff on my doorstep.

Isn’t that because they still need to get into London for work? Less so at the moment, obv.
reluctantbrit · 10/06/2021 07:41

I think it all depends on where in London. We live in an outer borough, Kent is just around the corner and I do have most stuff on my doorstep without setting a foot into Central London.

Yes, it's not a ruaral town but I wouldn't want that as I prefer not to have to use the car to get a pint of milk. I also like that DD can walk to secondary school and cycle to most of her activities and I don't have to play taxi driver all the time.

We toyed with the idea of moving into Kent when DD was a preschooler and we looked for primary schools but my commute would double in time if I don't get a fast train and triple in costs. Not worth it.

Topia · 10/06/2021 07:40

I live in Surrey & I think my two little ones (one primary, one just about to start nursery) have a lovely life. Plenty of green space, not too crowded, quieter, good access to London if I need to go there (45 mins or less on the train,) & excellent restaurants, local amenities.

I have a garden too which is a lifesaver.

UpSlyDown · 10/06/2021 07:39

@Liverbird77 yes! Our exact spot 😘

Liverbird77 · 10/06/2021 07:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request