Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?

462 replies

ilkleymoorbartat · 09/06/2021 21:49

With the mass exodus from London at the moment, aibu to ask whether there is some promised land that people go when they have kids (whatever the location).

Ie, are those of us in London missing out on a life that is lovely and idyllic which if you're in the London bubble it's impossible to imagine?

Do we have Stockholm syndrome basically?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Warmduscher · 10/06/2021 10:20

[quote userxx]@Warmduscher what a beautiful garden, My eye is drawn to the shrub at the end........ strange shape 😏[/quote]
Blush
It’s actually a shrub and a vine and I hadn’t noticed the shape before.

SunglassesSeventy · 10/06/2021 10:16

We moved away from Stoke Newington when our first DS was a toddler, around 16 years ago.

We moved to a large town in Berkshire that has plenty of eating out options and shops. It's a bit poor on indie shops and culture, but incredible for schools, cinemas, leisure, etc. Things like climbing walls and skate rinks are available. A short drive gets us to countryside for walks and when the kids were younger there were plenty of rural activities you could take them to, farm days etc, as well as enjoying everything the town had to offer as well.

We met people easily here, it's very diverse, we live in an area of the town where the locals vote green. There are some nice arts organisations and activities (arts trails where you can buy local artists work). We have the river for cycling beside, and paddleboarding on.

It's not a perfect town, there are still pockets that have that grotty city feel with the fried chicken shops and litter on the ground.

But overall we're happy here and only a 25 min train ride from London if we need to go (we rarely do).

dreamingbohemian · 10/06/2021 10:15

@HowToBringABlushToTheSnow

How fucking rude. As if that's all Brixton is, a rubbish filled street. It's one of the most fun and diverse and community-minded neighbourhoods in the UK, with one of the best parks too, all 10 minutes from the centre of London.

These threads always go this way though. How can anyone possibly live in London when it's so dirty and crime ridden and grim, and yet 9 million of us do, go figure.

Maverick197 · 10/06/2021 10:10

@HowToBringABlushToTheSnow

I moved from Notting Hill to the Surrey countryside, absolutely love it here! I have the best of both worlds as I’m still close enough to London to work there three days a week but I wake to bird song and peace instead of sirens and traffic noise. Every weekend is like a weekend away. One of the best decisions I have ever made.
Ditto! We moved from Streatham to Surrey and love it here. Close enough to have access to all that London has to offer yet far enough to be surrounded by beautiful nature and a slower pace of life. House prices are pretty much the same as in London, but most houses have bigger gardens and space for off street parking.
Muminabun · 10/06/2021 10:08

We moved to sussex. Beautiful village school for the children, 15 minutes into Brighton, downs, sea, fresh air, community and a house we could only have dreamed of in London. The crime is incomparable to London and my guard came down as soon as we left. London is fantastic to visit though but the stuff I saw there I don’t want my kids to see.

Starlight39 · 10/06/2021 10:05

I think it depends on how much you love London and what you're looking for in terms of lifestyle. People I know who have moved from London have gone to:
Village in Derbyshire - much cheaper property so they have a huge house but schools aren't great
Haddenham - 40 mins to Marylebone on the train but still quite expensive for property. They have made lots of good friends as lots of similar types to them.
Oxfordshire villages - around Bicester, property not too pricey and can get to Marylebone fairly quickly (around an hour I think).

The people who live in the above places live fairly rural lifestyles now though and would be a big lifestyle change. They tended to move early to mid thirties with babies or tiny kids. If you love city life, I'd think about moving to a different city like York, Leeds, Sheffield or Manchester.

x2boys · 10/06/2021 10:00

@Brainwave89

I moved to rural Norfolk just over ten years ago now out of London. I am very happy here, but you must consider all of the pros and cons before you move. It does depend on your personal preferences and what you see as a good lifestyle. For me I value a slightly slower pace of life, clean air, the countryside, good local food and the coast. My kids had access to good schools and were not exposed to some of the worst parts of living in London. Equally I would consider things like transport- my village literally has one bus a day! If you cannot drive it will not work. The best restaurants, bars, theatres and galleries will be a decent train ride away- you cannot just decide to pop to one in an evening. Another note from experience is to think really carefully around where you are moving to. In any rural area some villages are more welcoming than others, often in the same area. As when you move anywhere spend some time in the location assessing the area before you consider moving. Check local newspapers, google, local websites. Minutes of local parish councils etc. This will give you a real feel for what the area will feel like to live in. I would particularly check the local pub as a barometer of how open to new people the area will be. Even then remember that the countryside is a living place. At certain times of year it will smell (muck spreading), it can be noisy, and farm vehicles have rights of way. Shops for some items may be a reasonable distance hence so you need to plan.
Proving my point ,it is not London ,and everywhere outside of London is a vast wilderness,There are many other parts of the UK that have towns and cities ,that have good transport systems ,where you can get any takeaways of your choice at any time etc ,there is compromise ,it's not either London ,or very rural and that's it .
BarbarianMum · 10/06/2021 09:56

Dh and I left years ago. I miss it to the extent that we try and visit for a long weekend once or twice a year and do stuff (museums, galleries, exhibitions, shows). The rest of the year we have a good standard of living that we could never have achieved in the SE.

HowToBringABlushToTheSnow · 10/06/2021 09:56

@WalkingOnTheCracks

And now they’re teenagers, they feel that way too. They’d much rather live in Brixton or Tooting than leafy, dull Surrey

Well I can totally see why Grin

Leaving London - is there a promised land?
Leaving London - is there a promised land?
Brainwave89 · 10/06/2021 09:50

I moved to rural Norfolk just over ten years ago now out of London. I am very happy here, but you must consider all of the pros and cons before you move. It does depend on your personal preferences and what you see as a good lifestyle. For me I value a slightly slower pace of life, clean air, the countryside, good local food and the coast. My kids had access to good schools and were not exposed to some of the worst parts of living in London. Equally I would consider things like transport- my village literally has one bus a day! If you cannot drive it will not work. The best restaurants, bars, theatres and galleries will be a decent train ride away- you cannot just decide to pop to one in an evening. Another note from experience is to think really carefully around where you are moving to. In any rural area some villages are more welcoming than others, often in the same area. As when you move anywhere spend some time in the location assessing the area before you consider moving. Check local newspapers, google, local websites. Minutes of local parish councils etc. This will give you a real feel for what the area will feel like to live in. I would particularly check the local pub as a barometer of how open to new people the area will be. Even then remember that the countryside is a living place. At certain times of year it will smell (muck spreading), it can be noisy, and farm vehicles have rights of way. Shops for some items may be a reasonable distance hence so you need to plan.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/06/2021 09:50

@LoudestCat14

I feel really sorry for people that live there and don't realise how much better it would/could be, somewhere else.

How patronising. You have no idea what our lives are like, you just assume they're shit. I live in a three-bed house with a big garden five minutes walk from a Tube station and from amazing restaurants, bars and cinemas. Central London and all that has to offer is a 20 min Tube ride away. My DD goes to one of the best state schools in London. I don't need anyone's faux pity, thanks very much.

Well that's fair enough that you can afford to live in a 'three-bed house with a big garden five minutes walk from a tube station' but the point is that almost no-one can afford this, which is why one option could be to move to another city where they can afford a suitably sized property and still have access to city amenities.
RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 10/06/2021 09:49

I lived in London when I was much younger (20 years ago), but had grown up in a village and found a huge city quite hard work. I love visiting though. Then I moved to a small city, then another small city, then another small city... then a village. It's the right thing for my child (quiet, safer streets - traffic not people I mean, school has amazing outdoor facilities), but it's boring for me. My partner loves it, but he's not a gym go-er or a swimming pool user, or a shopper or coffee shopper. He likes watching sport, cooking - in a bigger kitchen - and growing food on an allotment.

When we moved to a village I had to change jobs to make sure that I come in to a city every day, I also had to spend lots of money on a country-club type gym on the way to work just to get a swimming pool. As soon as child is a teenager, I'll be wanting to move somewhere more 'something'.

Vivana · 10/06/2021 09:48

I moved to the south west from London 15 years ago. I will never go back to London. Even when I visit there to see family I want to go home asap

supermoonrising · 10/06/2021 09:46

@irmafaylear

True enough. But if you want excitement and the international experience in your 20s, without the crippling costs of London, perhaps case your net even wider. Shanghai, Beijing, Berlin... more fun for less money.

CounsellorTroi · 10/06/2021 09:44

Cardiff is a great city. Lots of people come here to university and never leave!

blarbed2 · 10/06/2021 09:42

Loads of people from London living here in the villages in South Warwickshire around Warwick, Stratford and Leamington, buying up the expensive houses... good schools.

mynameisbrian · 10/06/2021 09:41

I moved to London many years ago and still love it. I have many friends who have moved away now, some to quite villages around Oxford, others closer to somerset, outskirts of bristol. Lovely to visit, large houses, bigger gardens etc etc. Some have regretted it and moved back. I am fortunate to live in a lovely area of London, fantastic local parks, great local restaurants, pubs etc with great local schools but still able to get into the city in 15mins. So I have zero intetrest in moving out.

MintyCedric · 10/06/2021 09:39

Is there a promised land?

Yep...London Grin.

My parents moved out when I was 3...I'm 45 now and have never entirely forgiven them.

579qkghs · 10/06/2021 09:37

A lot of people move to London in their 20s/uni and never intend to stay. So effectively they just go back home when they have kids to things they are more familiar with from their childhood. Others cant afford to stay - you're unlikely to be able to afford a family home in a nice area if you work in the public/civil service etc. My impression is that a lot of people are moving further afield this year such as Bristol, Manchester, Edinburgh - lets see whether WFH continues.

I love mountains so fo me Edinburgh would be the promised land if I had to stay in the UK. But globally - I would pick Geneva over anywhere else you get city, water and mountains in one place.

sadperson16 · 10/06/2021 09:26

I think Urmston is the promised land.

HowToBringABlushToTheSnow · 10/06/2021 09:22

@Bythemillpond

We moved out for 12 years and lived in a thatched cottage in a village that had pubs, shops and a church. It was the most miserable time of my life. I don’t think I spoke to anyone apart from my friends who lived in London and Dh.

If you don’t drink, are not Christian and don’t have children there is nothing to do and no one to connect with.
Alcohol seemed to play a huge part in village life, probably because whilst the scenery was beautiful, once children had left home there wasn’t anything to do apart from drink.

We only moved because of dh’s work. I am never moving outside the M25 again. Dh and the family know this although they try to show me what I could afford if I moved out.

That is the total opposite of our experience. Alcohol barely registers in our lives now we don't live in London, there is so much more to do here , we are always out and about making the most of the countryside. We have also made some wonderful friends, everyone is calmer and warmer, we have made loads of connections.. oh and we are definitely not Christian either!

Life for us in London was all about bars, restaurants and pubs!

IrmaFayLear · 10/06/2021 09:16

@supermoonrising

I know a fair few people who spurned the London experience and nice and sensibly bought property when they were in their 20s and didn't throw their money away on rent. They were able to trade up and now are in, in some cases, £1m houses.

Am I envious? In most cases, hell no. Middle age lasts a long time. No need to be embracing it at age 24.

LoudestCat14 · 10/06/2021 09:15

I feel really sorry for people that live there and don't realise how much better it would/could be, somewhere else.

How patronising. You have no idea what our lives are like, you just assume they're shit. I live in a three-bed house with a big garden five minutes walk from a Tube station and from amazing restaurants, bars and cinemas. Central London and all that has to offer is a 20 min Tube ride away. My DD goes to one of the best state schools in London. I don't need anyone's faux pity, thanks very much.

Xenia · 10/06/2021 09:15

In 1984 we could not afford inner London so moved out here (zone 5 outer Londno) and I am still here. I think it's a reasonable compromise - detached house, private road, horses go by, woods and golf club opposite yet not too far from tube stations and good private schools. It is not a promised land - nowhere is but it is good enough for me. My older son about 2 years ago moved to Oxfordshire and that is lovely too (and closer to his work)

Lissy23 · 10/06/2021 09:14

Hebden Bridge

Swipe left for the next trending thread