Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?

462 replies

ilkleymoorbartat · 09/06/2021 21:49

With the mass exodus from London at the moment, aibu to ask whether there is some promised land that people go when they have kids (whatever the location).

Ie, are those of us in London missing out on a life that is lovely and idyllic which if you're in the London bubble it's impossible to imagine?

Do we have Stockholm syndrome basically?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
579qkghs · 10/06/2021 12:27

I guess it depends on what people want at the end of the day. The reality is that if you aspire to a four-bed detached house then yes, you will have to be very very rich to get that in London (unless you bought years ago and are now very very rich indeed). If you want to have rolling fields then London is not for you. If you are happy to live in a busy city in what Brits consider to be cramped accommodation (i.e. not three/four bed semis/detached) - or are very rich then London is fine. I love it but it's not for everyone especially once you have kids

TicketyTickTock · 10/06/2021 12:23

We live in one of the Home Counties. The local estate agent said the market in any given year is 30% a Londoners moving out but for the last 18 months it's been over 70%.

bookworm14 · 10/06/2021 12:16

I don’t think people hate London at all and “everything it stands for” (whatever that means!). They just don’t want to live there, same as some people don’t want to live anywhere else.

A lot of people absolutely do hate it and have made it very clear on the thread. One poster said she was ‘sorry for anyone who lives here’. I don’t care what anyone thinks of London personally but I am sick of the constant sweeping generalisations on MN about what London life is like, and the failure to grasp that not everyone wants to live exactly the same lifestyle.

Warmduscher · 10/06/2021 12:13

Yes to all this. I am sick of the attitude to London on here. We get it - you hate it and everything it stands for - but can’t you muster up the imagination to realise a lot of people actually love living here?

Not sure who the “you” is in this but lots of us who lived in London for years but have now moved have said to the OP that if she loves it, she should stay.

I don’t think people hate London at all and “everything it stands for” (whatever that means!). They just don’t want to live there, same as some people don’t want to live anywhere else.

CounsellorTroi · 10/06/2021 12:11

In an ideal world a second more substantial family home in the countryside together with a central London base is the best of both worlds. That way you have all the unique attractions and benefits of cosmopolitan busy global London with express touch screen doorstep delivery and proper strength WiFi and then when work is done a relaxed weekend home retreat in a tranquil rural or coastal environment to digitally detox with fresh air and friendly locals that say good morning and have time to be civilised. Manners long lost in London. Poole or New Forest sounds tempting.

That is way out of reach of most people though.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 10/06/2021 12:07

Regarding Brixton - not been near for years. It’s been in the news for wrong reasons too many times for comfort over these pandemic times. I understand it’s changed a bit but still a world away from Clapham Common. The local Afro Caribbean food markets were eye opening but put off by the drugs scene and many friends who commented on (sexually implied infringement) behaviour of a few passing locals when lunching in the sun al fresco there. Based on geographic location there is much investment potential if it becomes a gentrified bohemian hipster spot. What happened to that Brixton Pound thing?

Don’t want to make this into an unhelpful and unnecessary where is worst or better in London as each to their own as all of us would be from a diversity of backgrounds and so some will fit into certain established communities better. What makes London unique and interesting is the ethnic make up as you don’t need a passport to explore globally within London with so many BAME majority areas. You don’t get this melting pot outside of London and New York City. It’s a positive thing and should be celebrated as it reflects the historical development of UK over decades and centuries.

In an ideal world a second more substantial family home in the countryside together with a central London base is the best of both worlds. That way you have all the unique attractions and benefits of cosmopolitan busy global London with express touch screen doorstep delivery and proper strength WiFi and then when work is done a relaxed weekend home retreat in a tranquil rural or coastal environment to digitally detox with fresh air and friendly locals that say good morning and have time to be civilised. Manners long lost in London. Poole or New Forest sounds tempting.

bookworm14 · 10/06/2021 12:07

Argh - formatting messed up there. The first two paragraphs are a quote!

bookworm14 · 10/06/2021 12:06

*It's depressing that people think you can't raise a family in London, like we're all neglectful parents for daring to live here with kids or something!

My son is in an Outstanding primary (10 minute walk), we are surrounded by parks and green space, loads of local activities, plus all that London has to offer. He'll be fine : )*

Yes to all this. I am sick of the attitude to London on here. We get it - you hate it and everything it stands for - but can’t you muster up the imagination to realise a lot of people actually love living here? If we stop loving it, we’ll move. I live in zone 2 in a three bedroom maisonette minutes’ walk from some of the best parks in the country. My daughter attends a lovely school where she mixes with people from a vast range of backgrounds. I have access to restaurants of any cuisine I want, excellent transport links, culture, shopping, and a wide range of children’s entertainment. I get on with my neighbours. What’s not to like?

dreamingbohemian · 10/06/2021 12:02

@bookworm14

Yes. Life is way better after you leave. London is fun for drinking in your twenties but when you’re ready for family life, air that doesn’t make your skin grubby, a decent sized house, schools the kids can walk to, parks where they can leave their scooter and still find it there hours later, and neighbours who chat to you, leave.

I live in London and I have all this stuff.

Me too. Zone 3. And no, we are not wealthy.

It's depressing that people think you can't raise a family in London, like we're all neglectful parents for daring to live here with kids or something!

My son is in an Outstanding primary (10 minute walk), we are surrounded by parks and green space, loads of local activities, plus all that London has to offer. He'll be fine : )

bookworm14 · 10/06/2021 11:52

Yes. Life is way better after you leave. London is fun for drinking in your twenties but when you’re ready for family life, air that doesn’t make your skin grubby, a decent sized house, schools the kids can walk to, parks where they can leave their scooter and still find it there hours later, and neighbours who chat to you, leave.

I live in London and I have all this stuff.

Xenia · 10/06/2021 11:50

Very interesting to hear from people about all this. There is never a right answer. My parents bought a house not to far from Newcastle centre which was good for work etc. I lived in Manchester and Chester (university and law school) and 3 of my children have been to Bristol U and others other towns. There are lots of towns in the UK and it ie certainly not London or rural Northumberland (my spiritual home).

For me outer London has been the right compromise. It is a minority white borough and has good private schools, several tube lines and yet our house when covid walkers are not tramping up and down our private road it is peaceful and quasi rural, horses go by etc (one man was in my garden this morning briefly with his 2 dogs which strayed in - may be I need to get my hose pipe out to fight invaders off)

Skysblue · 10/06/2021 11:46

Ps I grew up in London and worked there for many years and I say with confidence that life is MUCH better elsewhere.

Skysblue · 10/06/2021 11:45

Yes. Life is way better after you leave. London is fun for drinking in your twenties but when you’re ready for family life, air that doesn’t make your skin grubby, a decent sized house, schools the kids can walk to, parks where they can leave their scooter and still find it there hours later, and neighbours who chat to you, leave.

Basically look at a map of train stations, search those areas on rightmove and work out where you can afford to be.

Married to a banker? Move to Surrey. Popular places include Guildford Woking etc.

Doing well financially but not married to a banker? Try St Albans or Sevenoaks.
Only need to work in London occasionally? Have a look at Cambridge, Tunbridge Wells and Folkestone.
Into alternative culture? Forest Row or Brighton.
Tight for cash? Look at East of London - Gillingham Rochester etc.
Able to work from home forever? Go to Cornwall / Edinburgh (unless you have school age children; English accents get bullied in Scotland).

mynameisbrian · 10/06/2021 11:43

BarbarianMum phew....i had to go over what I had written previously to ensure I hadnt offended!

Divebar2021 · 10/06/2021 11:42

Brixton wouldn’t be my first choice of places to live but it definitely has a lot of cool stuff going on...unless you’re into horses or country pursuits ( cottage core??) I can see many teenagers / people in their 20s preferring to be there rather than the Surrey Hills. ( unless you want to pop around the antique shops of Dorking... or maybe the quilting shop)

BarbarianMum · 10/06/2021 11:41

@mynameisbrian apologies I got you mixed up with another poster Blush

mynameisbrian · 10/06/2021 11:34

BarbarianMum no idea what your going on about. I havent disrespected anyones choices about where to live. I was responding to someone who showed a horrendous photo of Brixton

BarbarianMum · 10/06/2021 11:30

@mynameisbrian interesting how you have to piss on where other people live to big it up in that case.

albero · 10/06/2021 11:29

I grew up in London zone 1 and my sisters and parents still live here. Most of my older friends from school have left over the years, so the exodus isn't new, although those who stayed in zone 1 are mostly those who managed to get a council flat here, or keyworker housing. The families I know who are leaving now are those who grew up elsewhere, and have never really seen London as their home, but just a place to stay in their 20s and get their career started.

I've lived in other UK cities and have been on city breaks (and rural holidays) all over the UK. I think they have a lot to offer but for me, nothing comes close to the diversity, breadth of culture and convenience of being in London. For me the pace of city life is what makes it exciting, and I'm not too bothered about the crime as it's mostly localised and I've never been affected by it (apart from pickpocketing years ago but I'm more streetwise to it now). We have a toddler and will likely move further out to zone 2/3 when she starts school - we plan to go private and the better schools are further out (or the other side of town from DH's office). Currently we live in a 2 bed flat with a shared garden and fortunately we can afford a house with garden, so we see no need to move out of the city. If it weren't for the schools issue, we would stay living centrally. I love having everything on my doorstep and several tube/rail/overground stations within walking distance.

mynameisbrian · 10/06/2021 11:22

HowToBringABlushToTheSnow so you found the worst photo you could find of brixton to prove your point? I have added some just to add some balance.

Brixton has a great vibe. My DS lives in a flat there atm and i lived there when i first moved to london.

Leaving London - is there a promised land?
Leaving London - is there a promised land?
Leaving London - is there a promised land?
Bythemillpond · 10/06/2021 11:03

LoudestCat14

I feel really sorry for people that live there and don't realise how much better it would/could be, somewhere else

I have lived somewhere else. I have been in the unique position through Dh's job to have lived in many towns and cities across England and Wales and I still prefer London

I am on the outskirts although would much prefer to be further in.

We are selling our house and it is at the point that we need to start looking for a new place as the move is imminent.
After searching on Rightmove and Zoopla and getting it down to 3 places we set off for a viewing to a house further out than where we are. 4 bed detached that ticked all the boxes.
I ended up being physically sick on the way as I had a panic attack at being so far out and ended up cancelling the other 2 viewings.
We then viewed a large 3 bed flat in a grotty area of London and whilst the flat just wasn’t suitable (we need 4 bedrooms) I felt much calmer and I know I need to adjust my search options.
No more within 30 miles of London.

Faultymain5 · 10/06/2021 10:25

I'll never leave London. I would spend my summer holidays in Suffolk, Yorkshire or Nottingham edepending on which family member woiuld have us. Suffolk was the only place I really felt at home and it was because everyone was so nice. But even there I couldn't live. It's too slow, and although it has theatres and venues, theres not a variety of good restaurants and everyone seems to live so far away from actual hospitals.

London is buzzing for every age group, if that's what you want. More family are here. But living in inner London is not for me. So the compromise is living just within the M25, with trees and farms nearby but only 30-45 minutes into the centre of town with frequent transport links. This is about as close to village life as I need.

Roselilly36 · 10/06/2021 10:23

We have recently relocated from a small seaside town on the SE coast to Norwich, best move ever, small safe city, lots to do, wonderful sandy beaches about 30min drive away, facilities on your doorstep, great value property, cost of living miles cheaper, many ex-Londoners here too.

MrsKoala · 10/06/2021 10:22

I was born and raised in London. I lived there (apart from uni days) till I was 34. I think it totally depends where you live. I grew up, went to school, college and worked in Hammersmith/Chiswick/Kew/Richmond/Brentford areas which is lovely. Then wanted to buy so bought in South Norwood/Norwood Junction/Selhurst as it was all I could afford and it was utterly shit. Really rough and nasty. I worked in a local school which put me off having kids there and I couldn't afford anywhere else in London so I moved out.

I moved to Sevenoaks/Tonbridge/T.Wells areas and it's lovely here. Nothing like the feeling of constant 'mild peril' and general dirty dinginess I had in SE London (I have many unsavoury anecdotes about there) and only 45 mins into London on the train. But had I stayed in Chiswick I'd think living in London was the best and nothing could beat it.

Folklore9074 · 10/06/2021 10:22

Yep - if I could afford to upsize (without pushing ourselves too hard on mortgage repayments) I don't think we'd consider moving. I love London, although now that our first is on its way we aren't really making the most of everything it can offer. Yes it can be hectic but the diversity, tolerance, the scope for opportunities that exist here are a huge benefit for children. I grew up in a small seemingly idyllic location and it wasn't the 'promised land' by any stretch of the imagination. There was a lot of ignorance, intolerance, and a general lack of ambition because you just didn't see examples of what was possible in front of you. Its all a balance I guess but I feel as though talk of a mass exodus is over rated and that its very possible that a lot of people that leave for a different type of lifestyle might find that the grass isn't always greener.