Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another teenager dead right now - how do we get a grip on gangs?

256 replies

NorthNineteen · 08/06/2021 17:56

Name changed. A teenager was killed (shooting) close to where I live. It happened about an hour ago, there are loads of police, an air ambulance came. It's so awful, I don't know many details but what can be done to protect children? Clearly the current system is broken. It's so heartbreaking to think someone has lost their child today.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Djdjjfnfndkamamx · 08/04/2022 15:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

awaketoosoon · 12/06/2021 09:42

Because people are blaming gang culture on poverty. There was far more poverty in the 60s, many people lived in squalor.

Overall the population was probably much poorer though & people were probably kept more active by more jobs & more physical jobs even though these jobs didn't particularly pay much. The problem we have now is much greater inequality & a far more materialistic society.

stopgap · 10/06/2021 20:32

@JaniieJones

'But you can't compare it to the 60s - what relevance does an era'

Because people are blaming gang culture on poverty. There was far more poverty in the 60s, many people lived in squalor.

So yes we have to accept there is a massive problem nowadays with daily tragic stabbings but you can't lay all the blame with the government or 'poverty'.

More police is needed, but more community and family responsibility too.

In the 60s, people had guaranteed jobs, usually in manufacturing, to enter after they finished school. Those days are long gone, sadly. I think that’s one of the key differences.
GuildfordGal · 10/06/2021 20:24

What are Labour promising - I've not heard this mentioned particularly

I've no idea, but not voting Tory is still a starting point. A decade of Tory cuts to services and support for young people and families have scorched their way to a bleak landscape for so many.

And of course, there's little hope of improvement with the hideous, heartless government that we currently have. So yep. It's a starting point.

Tossblanket · 10/06/2021 19:27

The deterrent will be putting those carrying knives in prison.

Stop and search will find those people.

Stoolpigeon21 · 10/06/2021 18:41

Want knives off the streets? Increase stop search and make it a mandatory 3 years in prison if one is found.

Stop and search has limited impact as a deterrent, They found that after a 10% increase in stop and search during a given month, recorded drug offences would be 1.85% lower during the next month, while non-domestic violent crime was 0.01% lower.

It has slightly more impact as an investigative power. Across England and Wales in 2017/18 around 30% of stops and searches led to what’s called a “positive outcome.” This refers to cases where action is taken against people who were stopped and searched. This includes arrest cases but also covers other resolutions like warnings and Penalty Notices.

fullfact.org/crime/does-stop-search-work/

Tossblanket · 10/06/2021 06:55

It's pointless having more police if their hand are tied behind their back.

That dickhead mayor in London has plenty to answer for.

Want knives off the streets? Increase stop search and make it a mandatory 3 years in prison if one is found.

Criminals have such an advantage in the UK it's laughable.

TheoMeo · 10/06/2021 06:05

It's been said upthread, but not voting Tory would be a good start.
What are Labour promising - I've not heard this mentioned particularly.

vegas888 · 09/06/2021 23:41

Exactly that @dayswithaY

GuildfordGal · 09/06/2021 23:40

Someone needs to do something but frankly, no one knows what

It's been said upthread, but not voting Tory would be a good start.

dayswithaY · 09/06/2021 23:13

It's an exciting lifestyle plus the promise of easy money. Would you rather work 9 to 5 in a boring job for min wage or be a drug dealer and gang member with a tons of cash and living like you're in Grand Theft Auto.

Obviously, most of us don't want that as we understand that it's a horrible life but if all your influences- the music you listen to, your friends, the artists you admire - all support this way of life and you're a 14 year old with not much else going on, of course you're going to head that way.

Someone needs to do something but frankly, no one knows what.

CorianderBee · 09/06/2021 20:46

@sandgrown

Might seem a stupid question but where are all the guns coming from ? Where do these people buy bullets . Surely police can target these supply lines . My original thought is that guns came in with immigrants from war torn countries where life is cheap . The same with knives . I am in my 60s and had to get authorisation to buy a kitchen knife in a well known store . Do the parents of the younger gang members never question where their kids are at night? If they are doing county lines surely they are away all night ?
The black market. They sometimes slip through in the post as border force isn't infallible. Private planes. Shipping cargo gets through. Also modified BB guns and air rifles. Plus, many of the guns in the U.K. have been here decades. They're used, sold, hidden, used again when they're not hot and on and on until seized. Plus, there are thousands of legal guns in the U.K. that can be stolen.
Blackberrycream · 09/06/2021 20:11

It’s a really complex issue.
One thing that needs to be said though is that children growing up in inner city areas will know a wide range of people from school. It’s not ok to assume that victims are involved in gang activity. It can be mistaken identity, wrong place wrong time or just being in the park with a group you knew from primary and something kicks off.
Also the use of the word gang can be problematic. There is a current issue in Manchester with sentences handed to black youths who were deemed to be in a gang ( AI - it has been widely publicised). Young men were given sentences of up to 17 years for the murder of the brother of the Manchester arena bomber. Most of them were not there at the time of the murder. Contrast that with the treatment of the Manchester Grammar boy who actually stabbed a boy to death.
Growing up in inner cities is a minefield for teenagers.

dorangme · 09/06/2021 19:52

No but they give a shit about the amount of stabbings.

Society doesn't care, so many stabbing barely make the news. I know some people don't like it on their doorstep in case it impacts house prices but that's not quite the same.

SueSaid · 09/06/2021 19:41

'Ah thanks JaniieJones for helping discredit someone else's lived experience and dismissing it because you alone know the motivations for why people join gangs'

Anytime. I don't accept blaming others and excuses. I 'alone' don't know everyone's motivations but the pp did in fact list theirs..

'Well that's the question isn't it? Because society doesn't really give a shit about the young people who end up in gangs.'

No but they give a shit about the amount of stabbings.

dorangme · 09/06/2021 19:08

There needs to be some kind of activist movement to really inspire people to do better. Why are young lives so dispensable?!

Well that's the question isn't it? Because society doesn't really give a shit about the young people who end up in gangs.

DirectionsForUse · 09/06/2021 18:47

Saying it's all down to the music is like saying DV exists because of Tom Jones songs.

Gangs recruit because they offer "security" and belonging that some families don't. Children don't do it for the "blingy gear" or the drugs they do it to meet basic human needs, which they mistakenly believe will be met by those things.You do realise these are human beings you're talking about Jones? Human beings who in their young lives have had to deal with things you can only imagine.

Ginuwine · 09/06/2021 18:18

Ah thanks @JaniieJones for helping discredit someone else's lived experience and dismissing it because you alone know the motivations for why people join gangs.

Without you I'd have mistaken @GiveIrelandBackToTheIrish post as some sort of universal statement on gang life Hmm

SueSaid · 09/06/2021 14:58

@Ginuwine

People need to stop spouting stuff they've read from Mail articles or online blogs / videos, sit down, and read *@GiveIrelandBackToTheIrish* post WORD FOR WORD

this is the voice of experience. Anything else is a fair viewpoint but not a lived one.

I did.

'When you walk down the street and people cross to the other side because they know who you are - that's why. '

🙄

Kids get into gangs because they want the drugs, the violence and the blingy designer gear. Many people grow up on benefits but don't aspire to have people cross the road to avoid them and be chuffed of this 'status'.

Grime and rap celebs need to stop glamourising the culture, there needs to be better parenting, community leadership, more policing and tougher sentences.

Nicolastuffedone · 09/06/2021 14:40

I didn’t go to a school resembling Eton in way, shape or form but I’ve managed to get without murdering anyone

Ginuwine · 09/06/2021 14:40

People need to stop spouting stuff they've read from Mail articles or online blogs / videos, sit down, and read @GiveIrelandBackToTheIrish post WORD FOR WORD

this is the voice of experience. Anything else is a fair viewpoint but not a lived one.

SueSaid · 09/06/2021 14:02

'I did it because my mam chose an abusive man over me, so to have respect from others was a feeling like no other. When you walk down the street and people cross to the other side because they know who you are - that's why. Also of course the obvious when you grow up in a shitty estate on the breadline surrounded by this you become desensitised to it. Also what someone mentioned upthread when you're let down by the state so many times I had no faith in them'

You did it because of your dm, your shitty estate and being let down by the state?!

How about taking some responsibility. You did it because you wanted the financial gains and weren't scared how you got it.

There needs to be some kind of activist movement to really inspire people to do better. Why are young lives so dispensable?!

NOTANUM · 09/06/2021 12:50

Brilliant contribution @GiveIrelandBackToTheIrish

Cam2020 · 09/06/2021 12:22

Legalise drugs. Tax them. Spend the tax revenues on education, youth and health services.

This will just cause a surge in new, synthetic drugs IMO. People are always looking for something new and I think a fair proportion of drug users enjoy being outside of the law and engaging in something 'risky' - especially middle class users where the real risks to their lives is relatively low.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 09/06/2021 11:55

GiveIrelandBackToTheIrish

True words