Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not able to figure out OpenUni assignment

40 replies

ouproblems · 04/06/2021 21:07

Writing for traffic.
I thought I was fairly smart person, but clearly that's not the case. I am struggling with OU 1st assignment. Course is fairly technical. I am from different background. For1st assignment, there is a lot of reading and then I need to critically appraise a complex science paper using a framework in another scientific field.
Is it normal for all OU master's level modules. This is my 1st ever module and within a month, without any guidance and help, how do I assess validity of a research paper authored by an expert when I am complete beginner in field.

I am ok to fail this but dont want to fail without attempting. I have read papers, searched internet for more info but I am still pretty lost.

Can anyone with OU experience give some tips? Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shortbread49 · 07/05/2022 00:33

Do you have to appraise a clinical trial using a reporting guideline? There are lots of different guidelines depending on the scientific study design, they are all summarised in the Equator statement, the one for trials is CONSORT www.equator-network.org/. There are accompanying papers which explain them, but you go through each question and assess if it has been covered by the trial or not. E.g. randomisation, does it say it was randomised and report the method it used? The journal it is published in is not relevant as there will have been some peer review of it for it to have been published in the first place (you would hope). The book mentioned by Trisha Greenhalgh is a good introduction to study design, good luck

Hawkins001 · 06/05/2022 22:57

ouproblems · 17/06/2021 07:05

Thank you all, it's submitted now :)

How did it go , op ?

Historytoo · 17/06/2021 20:10

Well done OP. I still remember the joy of getting OU work submitted. I used to have a weekend off and then move onto the next one. Hope you have a nice weekend.

wwgg · 17/06/2021 17:13

I'm from the computer science field. Never be hesitant to clarify assignments with tutors. Also, if you could network with some colleagues on the course you'd be able to gather their perspectives too. I've never done OU, so not sure if that is possible?

78percentLindt · 17/06/2021 08:57

If it a pharm trial, you also need to be wary about quoted previous studies or trial methodology. Sometimes they say, "using the yyyyy methodology" when yyyyy has been used in 1 study by the same team published in an obscure publication.

ouproblems · 17/06/2021 07:05

Thank you all, it's submitted now :)

OP posts:
Slumcat · 07/06/2021 07:27

I’m doing very similar critiquing several RCT I’m using CASP tool to do so - PRISMA also helpful, don’t look to criticise the study but look for potential bias, study group size , researchers background, were aims and objectives clear etc
Starting is the hardest bit - good luck

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 07/06/2021 07:23

I’m doing my nursing through the open uni so I am an undergraduate but am finding my tutor a great source of help. Do you have forums and other students you can ask how they are going about it? We have a WhatsApp group and we really help each other and the forum, which is specific to our tutor group, has been helpful for asking the tutor for help and examples

sashh · 07/06/2021 07:06

Contact your tutor, as one of mine said, "That's what I'm paid for"

Glad you got an extension, use it wisely.

ouproblems · 07/06/2021 07:01

Thank you everyone. I have asked for extension.

OP posts:
lanthanum · 05/06/2021 17:55

The tutor would probably much rather you contacted them and asked for advice and another week's extension, than submit something you're not happy with and then say you need help. Although they mark your assignments, their primary role is tutor, not examiner.

NeverEnoughCake2 · 05/06/2021 17:06

I think you can use "cohort" in that way, but that's certainly not a common use and it's potentially confusing for OP, who needs to start with the most commonly used epidemiological definitions for the different study types.

The question of whether RCT participants are representative of the population they're supposed to come from is a different question to rigour of the study design in terms of identifying if Studied Thing influences the outcome. It's more about the generalisability of the findings whereas study design affects the probability that the observed relationship between Studied Thing and outcome is causal

CMOTDibbler · 05/06/2021 07:51

It is a case control study if you are doing a retrospective, but certainly I'd use cohort to also describe a patient group randomised to an arm. It can be important in an RCT as outcomes in the control group will be better normally than in the general population due to the nature of hospitals participating in RCTs. For instance in the US, women of colour are very underrepresented in oncology studies, and household income and highest education much higher than in the general population (I'll have to dig out the citation on this)

NeverEnoughCake2 · 04/06/2021 23:18

CMOTDibbler, I think what you''re describing as a cohort study is a case-control study

A cohort study is when you take a group of people/things, some of whom have been exposed to the thing you want to study and some of whom haven't. You then follow them up over time and see whether those who were exposed to Studied Thing are more likely to end up with a certain type of outcome (e.g. greater height, being diagnosed with a disease, having a higher IQ) than the people who weren't exposed to Studied Thing.

You may need to adjust your statistical analysis for factors such as age, other diseases, income, that could also be possible explanations for the relationship between Studied Thing and the outcome, but you don't have to start with matched participants.

OP A cohort study is different to a RCT because the manner in which people end up exposed to the Studied Thing isn't determined by the researcher using randomisation, but by some other factor.

CMOTDibbler · 04/06/2021 23:02

So apart from contacting your tutor, I'd say for this one you are on the right track of starting with the journal. Look on their website and see what the submission criteria/ process is.
On the study - who were the samples taken from: were all patients with symptom /condition X asked to consent to the blood via a defined pathway or was there potential for bias in who was asked. Then were there enough of them for it to be statistically significant, was the study endpoint well defined, were the right questions asked (what did they say they were going to do, what did they do, did the results reported actually tally with what they said they were going to do).

A blinded study is one where neither the patient or the person treating them knows which treatment they are getting. In the old days you'd have a stack of sealed envelopes with numbers on that the trial designer had made up and randomly draw one out of the box. That number would then be linked to (say) a bottle of tablets which have just the trial number on. This way I don't tell you 'ooh, thats great, you've got the shiny new treatment' and you feel better through the very real power of placebo
An RCT is a randomised, controlled trial. So you and I might know what you are getting, but the sealed envelope (or of course now the online randomiser) sends you to one arm of the trial - the investigation (shiny new) or control (best practice). We can then compare whether giving you the new drug is better or not. But there is potential for placebo/nocebo effects
The cohort is the characteristics of the patients - they must be matched - age. sex, ethnicity, disease stage, other diseases, smoking status, and various things can lead to them becoming misaligned. A common ones is people getting randomised to control and then dropping out when they find out that they aren't getting the new drug. Patient populations joining trials can be skewed as well as people may encourage younger or better performing patients to enroll.
Hope that helps a little

slashlover · 04/06/2021 22:45

@ouproblems

Thank you all. I was too embarrassed to tell tutor I was struggling. I will ask for support after this assignment.
Ask for another extension.

I'm in fourth year and have learned that you can't be embarrassed, your tutor wants you to succeed. If it's any help, this year was a good year because I only cried at one of the four TMAs. Have a remote exam next week so fully expecting to have a cry at some point over the three days.

FB groups have been super helpful to discuss tips and swap ideas. I would also see if there are and youtube channels which cover what you are learning, sometimes someone explaining something in the simplest way possible is helpful. (Bloody statistics!!!)

Here's one "How to appraise a clinical trial" I haven't watched it but the comments are positive.

MoreHairyThanScary · 04/06/2021 22:42

Do you have any masters level writing videos with your uni or writing cafes?

All I have gather so far is to continually ask myself ...so what? What does that mean and why? And could things be done differently and be better.

if you've been asked to look at studies- what have they fudged, don't assume they are the expert they are someone who is published, your plan is to pick apart what has been overlooked.

BillyIsMyBunny · 04/06/2021 22:40

How long until the submission date? It might not be too close to ask for some guidance if you’re really struggling, the worst that will happen is you won’t get a response in time but it might be your tutor is able to help clarify things or you may even be able to get a longer extension of you explain how much you are struggling. If you really don’t understand how to approach this then unless you only have a few days left to write the assignment it seems like it could only be beneficial to reach out to help compared to devoting a lot of time to completing an assignment you don’t understand with the attitude that you’re just getting something in to fail.

superduster · 04/06/2021 22:36

OU seem happy to take on people at Masters level with no relevant previous study, which probably explains the huge drop out rate from some of their courses. I would agree ask your tutor and double check there is no extra help on the forums.

ouproblems · 04/06/2021 22:32

@slashlover, I already asked for a week long extension as I relocated few fews ago.

OP posts:
ouproblems · 04/06/2021 22:30

Thank you all. I was too embarrassed to tell tutor I was struggling. I will ask for support after this assignment.

OP posts:
slashlover · 04/06/2021 22:30

I should've asked tutor for guidance but now I am too close to submission date.

Can you ask for an extension? At postgraduate they're automatically agreeing to them (up to three weeks) due to covid. I've used it twice this year.

ouproblems · 04/06/2021 22:27

Thanks everyone.

So framework is from clinical trial but I need to use it to appraise microscopic study of a natural resource. Tutor has specifically asked to not give superficial analysis or description. It has to show deep understanding. In one assignment there are several questions of different type.

@CMOTDibbler There are no participants, or results based on survey. I am new to understanding concept of trials. Samples collected were blinded, taken to lab and studied. (I am new to these terms blinded study, cohort and RCT, control etc and still don't understand well how one is better than another).

It's an open access journal and I need to figure out if it is predatory. I have searched internet to find clues to figure out but I couldn't.

Also I need to tell what publication details tell. And I can't figure out what exactly they what me to evaluate here.

Yes, it is Masters level course. My undergrad is in business related field from another country, and I didn't do this kind of analysis before.

I think I am more of a high level, kind of person who has a lot of superficial knowledge and that has helped me in past. I still want to try my best to learn.

I should've asked tutor for guidance but now I am too close to submission date.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 04/06/2021 22:19

All the best op

Swipe left for the next trending thread