Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation in partner’s family

95 replies

Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 17:24

Hi,

First time poster, longtime lurker.

As the title suggests, I have a question about organ donation in my partner’s family.

My partner’s brother needs a kidney and has done so for a while. Some family members have been tested to no avail and now it’s widely considered to be my partner’s “turn” to do so. The issue is that they are not close and whilst my partner is concerned (naturally, as a fairly decent human being) about their sibling, it’s a big thing to do for someone you don’t care for/aren’t in touch with and are unsure if you want to take such a risk for.

Sadly, the sibling really does need the kidney and has two young kids. Their partner is not a match. Not relevant, but financially they are ok. My partner is not ok financially and is a job hopper with no real security (same for me).

I’m concerned that my partner would give the organ and if something went wrong be screwed, financially and health wise. We have no support of any sort from family and are private renters. For full disclosure we don’t have kids as it didn’t happen for us so we don’t have young people to let down, but I also feel this is why we are feeling pressured for my other half to test and donate.

Thanks for reading!

Yanbu- it’s a risk with no guarantees for all involved
Yabu- don’t be selfish- it’s just a kidney; your partner will recover, should be able to mange with just one and must help!

OP posts:
HavelockVetinari · 04/06/2021 19:30

Honestly, the transplant team will likely conclude he's not a suitable match - not because of his blood & tissue types but because he's unsure about it. Potential donors have to get assessed by a psychologist and if they're not sure they can go through with it the potential recipient will be told he's not a match.

Might be the least awful option.

Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 19:25

Thanks, @FortniteBoysMum, I hear you but also need to tell you that some family members are shit. I don’t have a single person I can rely on and have been let down. Same for my other half. Neither of us owe anything to anyone or even each other, sorry. I am n/c with one parent and l/c with another. Lovely if you care about each other but some families don’t and will only get in touch when they want something.

OP posts:
FreezeMotherHubbard · 04/06/2021 19:23

@FortniteBoysMum

I'm not close with my brother in that we rarely talk and live long distance but if he needed a kidney or a piece of my liver I would be first in line to be checked as family is family. Might not even be a match. The best thing is get tested without telling the brother. Tell doctors not to say if dp is a match until decides if wants to go through with donating. If not a match your worrying over nothing and if they are counciling will advice on options.
And what if your DC needed something in later life that as a result you could no longer provide? Also, "family is family" is a bit of a sweeping one. 87 year old uncle?
saraclara · 04/06/2021 19:22

@TheRebelle

As a pp said you can go along to be screened and tell them you’re under pressure from family and they will tell him you’re not a match whether you are or not, it might be the easiest way out of a difficult situation.
This is definitely the case, and probably the most sensible course of action for your partner. It will avoid family bad feeling, and no-one will be told the reason for him being rejected as a donor.
FortniteBoysMum · 04/06/2021 19:19

I'm not close with my brother in that we rarely talk and live long distance but if he needed a kidney or a piece of my liver I would be first in line to be checked as family is family. Might not even be a match. The best thing is get tested without telling the brother. Tell doctors not to say if dp is a match until decides if wants to go through with donating. If not a match your worrying over nothing and if they are counciling will advice on options.

Kidneybeans · 04/06/2021 19:11

Hi @Flawedperfection

I have some experience of this
If he has people willing to be live donors but who are not a match then the paired/pooled scheme would still apply

www.hta.gov.uk/faq/what-paired-pooled-donation

No one should be guilted into donating (and in fact their are rigorous processes to prevent this)

Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 19:06

Thanks for all the replies which are for the most part, extremely helpful and non judgmental.

The horrible thought is that if his brother dies due to no organ, my partner will be devastated. But there’s no guarantee it’d work or even that it’d last that long. Some kidneys transplanted can last up to 20 years, but some don’t.

But yes, back to if his brother dies: the question is could we go to the funeral and then continue our lives without overwhelming feelings of regret or guilt? I don’t know, but I do know that it’s shit all round really, isn’t it?

I agree with a past poster that if he got tested and was an outright “no”, that’d show he’d tried etc, but how awful if we felt a sort of relief at that outcome?! Just awful and of course I feel for his brother.

OP posts:
Freddiefox · 04/06/2021 18:58

What does your partner think?

Bubbles1st · 04/06/2021 18:55

Has he considered getting tested to see if a match and how that then makes him feel.

He may not be a match and then all of your worry and concern is for nothing.

If he is a match then his sibling instincts may become stronger and he may feel he wants to. Or that the prospect is so real that he cannot afford himself to put himself through the survey and recovery for the sake of his own health, wealth and family.

You may get the outcome you want without having to outright refuse...

PotteringAlong · 04/06/2021 18:55

@osbertthesyrianhamster when I was looking at being tested as a match for a family member I was told that they would tell them I wasn’t a match rather than I didn’t want to do it if it was needed.

BlueSurfer · 04/06/2021 18:54

I think this is something that your partner should have specific counselling for. It’s a big decision either way because there are the repercussions of the long term guilt if they say no and their brother dies as well as the potential to go wrong for saying yes. Whatever the decision, it’s not as straightforward as saying yes or no. However, either decision is completely reasonable to make and understandable.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 04/06/2021 18:50

@Flawedperfection

It sounds like partner is worried about himself (and he is, as am I) but he’d also hate for it to go wrong and be a waste of everybody’s time. What if the organ failed after a short time?

I know we sound like negative catastrophists (is that a word) but we are naturally quite pessimistic people and have heard so many horror stories for both sides!

You and he do not have to justify your reasons. ALL of them are valid. Honestly, find a way to get out of it.
Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 18:46

It sounds like partner is worried about himself (and he is, as am I) but he’d also hate for it to go wrong and be a waste of everybody’s time. What if the organ failed after a short time?

I know we sound like negative catastrophists (is that a word) but we are naturally quite pessimistic people and have heard so many horror stories for both sides!

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 04/06/2021 18:38

I think if I was feeling assertive then before going through the motions of being tested, I'd ask the relevant family members why they expect him to undergo a general anaesthetic and surgery for a brother with whom he's not close and also how far they've progressed in matched donation.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 04/06/2021 18:36

YANBU. No way should your DP do this unless he 100 % wants to. Your DP should either tell his brother no and why or of he really doesn't want to do that he could see if he's a match and then 1. He isnt so it isn't important 2. He is and can say he doesn't want to so he's rules out, but tell his family that hes been ruled out but not why (so he isn't lying, but doesn't say why). I think he should just not offer to get tested and then if asked say no, but obviously it's easy to say that as it's not me and you don't say if your DP has actually been asked or if you just feel like everyone is waiting for him to offer, but if they are waiting for him to offer then I wouldn't talk about it with them until they ask.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 04/06/2021 18:33

@TheRebelle

As a pp said you can go along to be screened and tell them you’re under pressure from family and they will tell him you’re not a match whether you are or not, it might be the easiest way out of a difficult situation.
If that's true I'd go with this.
CynsterBitch · 04/06/2021 18:32

I voted YANBU, your concerns are valid and the only thing that matters is how your DP feels about it, there is no right or wrong in this situation.
If he does get tested and is a match is this automatically disclosed? Not sure how it works in the UK.
If not then maybe he could get tested and take it from there, if he’s not a match then tell everyone that, if he is a match but doesn’t want to do it then tell everyone he wasn’t a match, or if he decides he does want to do it tell them the truth.

For what it’s worth I would give my brothers anything they needed, but we’ve always been close even living in different countries. I also had a cousin a few years back who needed a kidney transplant and got tested for her, not surprisingly I wasn’t a match, so not sure how I would have reacted if I had been in a position to donate, but I would have always wondered if I hadn’t got tested. Luckily she did get a new kidney in the end.

TheRebelle · 04/06/2021 18:31

As a pp said you can go along to be screened and tell them you’re under pressure from family and they will tell him you’re not a match whether you are or not, it might be the easiest way out of a difficult situation.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 04/06/2021 18:24

@Flawedperfection

Such a hard decision- what if the kidney my partner is left with goes wrong (although we realise they only take one if you’re considered healthy enough. But we have (maybe stupidly) read some case studies where it was like “on yer way now” once they got what they wanted from the donor. Obviously it is all about the recipient really, and I’m terrified about the aftermath and aftercare (or lack of) for my partner.

To the posters who mentioned finance; I meant that the brother has a house and finances if he needs to take time off work. My partner has v little due to private renting and securing a decent job/career with his specialized qualifications. He has no debts but no savings or job security. Also, our families can’t/won’t help us financially (not saying they should though).

It's a non-starter, your partner can't do this. HIs family are gits for expecting this from him and especially if not going to help him. I'd honestly say no but say I have diabetes or something.
PotteringAlong · 04/06/2021 18:24

For what it’s worth, my mum was a live kidney donor and is absolutely fine. However, there were hoops to jump through and unless you are 100% committed to it then you won’t get through the psych evaluations anyway.

TheDinosaurTrain · 04/06/2021 18:23

I have a condition that means I may well need a transplant at some stage. My sister said when I was diagnosed that she’d happily donate part of her liver if I needed it. My response was one of absolute horror. My children need her as a fit and well Aunty and she has her own life to live. I could never take that from someone living. Post death, absolutely, but living donation is a huge deal.

If your partner is at all uncertain then that’s fine and he should never be made to feel guilty about that

IHaveBrilloHair · 04/06/2021 18:22

YANBU.
His body, his choice.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 04/06/2021 18:22

I would make up a health reason to say no. But there's zero way he should do this. If it goes wrong he'll be thrown under a bus.

gabsdot45 · 04/06/2021 18:21

My husband was recently tested to be a kidney donor for his best friend. he wasn't a suitable match in the end but the process is very thorough and if there is any hint of coercion then they won't go ahead. The donor and recipient teams are totally separate and if your partner is a match but decides not to go ahead then the recipient team will be told there was no match.
It's a huge deal, serious surgery and not something to be taken lightly. My dh hadn't considered half of the implications before being tested.
Don't be forced into it. Dhs friend is having dialysis now and is on the donor list. It's not the end of the world if a match isn't found.

Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 18:21

Such a hard decision- what if the kidney my partner is left with goes wrong (although we realise they only take one if you’re considered healthy enough. But we have (maybe stupidly) read some case studies where it was like “on yer way now” once they got what they wanted from the donor. Obviously it is all about the recipient really, and I’m terrified about the aftermath and aftercare (or lack of) for my partner.

To the posters who mentioned finance; I meant that the brother has a house and finances if he needs to take time off work. My partner has v little due to private renting and securing a decent job/career with his specialized qualifications. He has no debts but no savings or job security. Also, our families can’t/won’t help us financially (not saying they should though).

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread